19900223 TZCA Dar es Salaam10

" [, .. - (-:;c~-~-.l=g :;:J;_:,,;·;:;:·cL". 2 J o:.~ 2 R,:1.::..·__ ;y.:_:..;_:r, J,L, Imel ~::-LLIL:i. 2 J.L.) Ch:C:IL.r;.1 .~PVi:::.1 1:-c. 64 07 1989 . pe-1 ( ••P _. d, - - co··.1·,r1· c·:,J·.o·,-_ o,.._... +.1-~.e fron1-. ..u:.~C V u •' u ~ in Cri::linal Sessio:rn Ca,:-3e •. o. 34 of 12_88 . . C:.e2.tti passed on -;;:1e ap:1:)ellarit by the E:igh Com·t (T::iaina 1 J .,) citting a·i; LbcU. J:.fost of tl1e fac·~s were not ir1 dispute.. ~:>.e appellant e..::.1c,l t~1e c.lecea:::ecl 'Th.e appella;rc J.12.d been .:-•:-;..1· r:.:cinlcing f.rm abov:i; 12 a.r:1. till about 5 p~Dd he was said to "be very c'cnml:. a kl:.ife 1 whereupon t:ie 0.eceasecl i,1terve11ed. ancl asked. hi:w not ·co cc.use c1-isttu·bance., In reoponse to that tl~e appelJ.an"i:i ·0-0..rnecl to the clece,'.'-sed a:1cl stab1Jetl him with the L:nife in the l1eacl. i1l:e cJ.ec0<.-:.sed. fell clown. appellant ran away bv..t shortly re-cv.rned to :~lie sce:-:.e wi tl1 a panc;a~ Ire inflicted panga cu:i;c on the deceasecl 1 s head 2,f·.ccr ·,·r1:dc~1 lie ran away leaving the dece2,r_;ec~. 0;1 -;;:ie gT01.111cl f2.tn.l13, 1raw.1.cledG Deceased. c1.ioc.: o;:ly oelf-clefonce Emel iirco:.:ic~:'.;io,1 i."'.,;;; his defoncec. The trial court, b.owe-ier~ reject-eel both c~cfencos. 0 •••• /2 .- .j •r .. ' . , .... in J, 0GGO:,:co I 1020~100 of b-(;o::ica-cion o.~1d rojoc·~oc_ oviclcmco :i.1ot mough :JOl'oly to si1ow t:.1e,t -~.ie j_:iri □ onel' was ve1·-y d.r-~u'Jlq tho ca..1rt l1as to co fu1,,.,.;her and 7Jo sa·cisfiocl -chat· the prisoner 1-12,~: so c~rt).i1.k tho.·G llo wc.s i:,.1capa-blo of :f O11:1i11g the i:c,·i;o;.rc to kill I for:1in3 ·i;J:10 i.r~ent ·co }.::ill o;r Ca.1.IB0 griovouo hc.r;:i, btr~ -c11c cour-0 h ..... r to clociclc J••• (..111.:.i o;, tlmt issue witl:. l'o:f orej::.co to the e-v . , on c e L: -~llG case· as a w~1ole .. 1.CL In ·;;ho . .., e C ,:.S -'-'10 1,l -·-~·.-.1 u.!. l.c:, ·•·d"" J~l ...,c''-,o,.. t:>e u. cC.c.!. S.JOd ~-l.J •,·,..,.. S cl·" - ·'o C .,v.!.12. m·,.o~~,1·0,1 .., .L1, "-~ _ ~ • S:.te loa.r:rnd j1..~c1ge fo-~mcl ·clu:it, the nppollant gave a clear ffi1c1. d.e-~r,iloc.l accoimt of w~1c1t l10 clicl befol'e, during and. after t110 l;:illing.,· After s·cab~:iii1f,' tho C:.eco2,cod I · wore not co;1siston:i; witl.1 a person who wcs so c7..nml:: 2,;; to be i11cz~pnble of for:::1L:ig t~1e intent to kill· or cauao g:riovoEs l~,rn., We a:cc m:.ablo -~o fmut tl12;i; ren.soninge In co;:1ing fo tht;c conclusion -~l1e lcc:.n1od fa,i2,l judge 2,l so tool: into accom1t th2,t. while ·chc appellant "t·TC.,8 rctu.rni:1g to ·i;hq scene wi tl:. ·c::10 pa~1ga ho i:lOt PoW.2 to wllo:".1 lie declared hiG intention to f'illish off J~,, 1,1.v c1.ccensod11 ~ But what is cv011 ;.1O.:ro importa;rc is t!J.isg The a ppel la1ct i;.1 l:.i s evic:.cnco at the triru ro:_Joatodly plen,,locl tllc c:.o:fo:.100 of i::.1to:-;;:icr,cio11 -;:210 appoll2,nt j aac1- inC:ccc"':. on ·0110 cvidorice -thoro could. bo :.10110. 23rd clay of Febr11ary, R. IT. IC( S.:TC1~ 4 I certify -cha·;; t>.io is e true copy o-? t::,o origin2,L, ( ' SEFI OR DEPUTY REGI S'.1.Tu'.R. \..