19901220 TZHC Dar es Salaam
,·"+•~ , i t~ IIT TIIB IIIGE COITTlT OF T:LIZDJIA 11;1: DLR ES S;~LJ,JJi., CIVIL Cf.SE EOo 261 OTI' 1903 IIATIBU IflJSSfilF •• o • • • • • • • • o o • • • • " • o • , • PLI.IETI:J'F versus I .. .,.-,V'A'Y,,..,m '1ICIT'T'L i,; 1:..i..G,:.i1 1' .1.1..i.1., i:101...1; GI) c--c~- 7 - ~~.•--D ., T 2,. TJJTBSCO L'l'D ) •...
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- 19901220 TZHC Dar es Salaam
- Court
- TZHC
- Jurisdiction
- Tanzania
- Judgment Date
- 20 December 1990
- Source Language
- en
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
No structured case brief is available yet for this judgment.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
1 paragraphs
,·"+•~ , i t~ IIT TIIB IIIGE COITTlT OF T:LIZDJIA 11;1: DLR ES S;~LJ,JJi., CIVIL Cf.SE EOo 261 OTI' 1903 IIATIBU IflJSSfilF •• o • • • • • • • • o o • • • • " • o • , • PLI.IETI:J'F versus I .. .,.-,V'A'Y,,..,m '1ICIT'T'L i,; 1:..i..G,:.i1 1' .1.1..i.1., i:101...1; GI) c--c~- 7 - ~~.•--D ., T 2,. TJJTBSCO L'l'D ) • • • • • • • 0 • 0 " -0-= .,;;l. 1u 1 This is 1)roua1t the rlcin'Ci?f uho is ti.10 fo..thor of 2. cloco2.,sou boy u:1-0 C:.ioLl throuc:h oloctrooution a.t tho first clcfoncl,:-,..nt I s -electric st:ruc·curei> Tho· Plaintiff is clm,.rin.~; aco..inst th-<:: mmer of this electric structure, Ev-'uJ'.'ist Ihch2,el Hs~ci 9 ru1c1- Tc.,nr.c.nio.. Electric Su~1ply Cor.1p,11y LL:1itoc:. ullicb. ·is the sU~)i)lior of. oloctrici ty in tho oity4 Tho oviLlonoe c;i von l)y -i;ho plc'..intiff is tl12.,t he h2,;.l a. 9 yoo:r olLl lJoy uho cliocl on 10/10/82 at n. structure for n,:1..vortisin..::.; o.. bClJ." of the firr:rt clef o;,11-c:nt. Tho a.clvortisincs structure of w2,tor nc2J'.' those polos c.,s it 11<.;.ll •rained on tha.t c:by. The o..ro~., noo:r tho poles uo..s oloct1-ifiot.l o.ml the pla.intiff rs son clio-1.. by eloctrocution11 Tho polos uoro si tm~.to~l o..t 2, foot po.th which U['.,S us_oJ. :Jy nnny pooi1lo. Tho plo..intiff uont -co J~10 scene ·o..ncl so.,~i tho rn1.vortis0i:1ont structure there., But next r..1..o:y i ·i; u0s no 1011.::;-er there us it 1 11C,s, ror.10Vc\.l C'l1Ll "ro-oioc-Ccc.: closer tc tho 1st clcfo11~1.CJ.1t I s ICi11,...lo Guo st IIousc o.nc1- Bex~ Tho i.lccec',so:1- iT0s tho firs~ born of tho i,lc:intiff in a f2:I.1ily of 4 cllil--1..ron~ The L1ocon,sor..1. u2.,s hoa,l tly .:1.ml bric;ht ;:::.nc.1.. vory helpful to Jliho . plo..intiff. 'E.10 plcintiff scic:. . further that ·i;hc o.,c1.vcrtisone:nt structure of Kimlo duost House H,'.'1,s very closd to tho path. IIo s.::,il1 in nnsuor to o.,nothor quoation th0t the clooo0sec1. wo.,s as1Jirinc to lJopono s, Lloc·~or Gnu th[l,t he l1;::ul c:;j1i bi tocl. such n,spirdion· tiTico when he 01,oro.,toc'- on o., c~1ic!rnn ancl put scr.10 t2.,blcts ' , in it .::tnLl · when ho. clir..l tho so.;-:io to n, r.rnusc. Ile c.lso smc1 tl1a·~ t~rwollin::; c.;-:ponsos for, tho funoro.l of his son c.:ix.1e to shs,. 2700/=~ IIo .'.1(:r.1itt0Cc ~12.,t tho first clo:2'011.~.:mt Llcnc1,te.:.1- shs., 2,5(()/= a.,s his assist2..11ca to tho plo..4,ntiff for !lis son I s funern.lci ,, 2 He !.1ec.2c.1. chil<.lron shoutiir tll"'t o., cl1i1Ll .rc.s c'. .:.'i.~1:_:. IIo uont to tho sOO11O ilJ.u;.1i110..tinc tho O.i.lVcr·tism.1cn-0z "KinJo Guest Irousofl, U!.1on ho trice:. to hell:. t:1c cl:i.ilc.1., ho fol-[; 2,11 electric shocl;:., IIo· a.10u·~ot'. 2-t t!.10 Kim:.o Guest HouGo om1ors to switch. o:Ef t~ie oloctrici ty. T;.1ey L:.ic7.. so M:1.. then :ic ro;·.1ovoc.l the c!lil~l fro,.1 whore ho u.:-,s li'in:::;., Tho cl1ill1. -w2,s i).11conscious41 Tho chilc.1 u2.s t22;:on to ho::ipi tc.l., In QJ.1sHor tc further qi.1os·;;ions, he s2,ic1.. tllo.,t tho dck1.t~: oocurroc1. 2-t tho ~1olos of tho i1C.1..vortisoDont stn1c·0uro. Ho c::1)1.:dnod further -e12.,t t~10 bc:.r u.:.s. o.,·0 one sic.lo 0f tho roc.,cl, c.;.1~1. tho structure 1TQ.S erected on tho ot:10:csi .'..c of tho roo.,c.1.. cutsi{':.o tl1e bou..,vi~lc.ry of I::inc.lo Guest House nnc.l no.::'.I' o., foot~x1.thco Tho Felice O2.r:10 to :1ii] thc..t ni0-1t cl.l.i.~1.. ho ucnt to slwu tho,J whore ho b.w:.l f ounL1.. the cl:iL:.. But next Qci,y tho structure w<1s no lonc;or there. In ru1sirnr to qu.os-cio;.1s i;1 cross-o:r..:clI.1in2..tio;.1 ho sd:.l that ho m:perioncocl c.n electric ~10ck when he uo~1t non.r the (:.ocoo..soc'... Tio clso sc..icl tb.c;c t!1e foot- pc.th uo.,s c.bout 5 foot frc;-.1 tho polos holc1..inc tho structure<! :Ti th rcc.,T.:cc7. to a parson usinc; t;.10 po.,th, ho sc..Ll thc1t such person 1TOL1.ld. nr;t o:;:i)Orionco n.ny shocl::. Th.a o·cl1or ui tnoss uc.,s John Ln.so uho sdc1- t:1c.·~ :20 wc.,s n,t his ho;·.10 ul1ich is noo..r ~2L1Llo B2.X & Guest Hcuso u;.10;.1 t~10 2,0cL1-ont of 10/10/82 ho,,~:ponoc.":.. !Io s.:::,u i:oo::lc rmminr; to 2, :)lc.,cc c.m'- ho f0llo,1oll t1:.ou U) tc whore thoro uc.s ~1 electric ~7.vortiscnont structure on t1·ro i"Olos uhic:i ro.'.:',,i.1.. 11IG.n:1-o Guest IIouse 11 ,. IJoc..r t:.1oso i)Olos n,1)ou·::; 2 1x1cos n,w.:1,y frcn tho :)olos iic'.,S 2, chilcl lyinc c.lmm,u IIo c.,·o-c a, vo~1iclo nnc.1.. tee:.: tho chilc1. to hos:)i t2.l ,rhe~·o l10 w.::.s pronouncec7. L1..CC'.,C.1. ,. IIc sc:.L1. further tJ:2.,t t11c; ~)oles wore outsi<.1.o ICiH(1..c Guest IIouso bounc.ln.ry o.m7.. t:1oy uoro non.r to ;:,, po..t:1~ Ti.1en 110:::t r..1.cy they uorc rc;:iovocl. Ti10 lo.,st Hi tness 1rc1s J::u:1os Ki tinyn, ul10 is e, :·.,o::1.icc.,l cloctor,1 Ho proc1-ucod t~10 j_;ost norten roc.,i stor b:,ok 1rl1iel1 lli'~1.. ~7..otdls concorninC," fin;_1.inc;s of c. )o::/c nor ton m:oninc.,ti ::--11 oi tl1e ~7.ococ..soc1. 1 s 1)c:.1...:,,·. T:10 rororJc s!.1ous thc.,t cc.,uso of c.1.oe,th wo..s electrocution"' The first c.7..cfom:.2.nt r_;c.,vo ovL1.oi1co l1ir.1solf. Ho s<'..i0.. th2.t ho rnrnec1 Kinde Bo...:r c.,nr..l Guest Ifouso. I.:c insta.llo,1. tl10 struc·~trro 0;_1 tho other sic:.o of tho ro2J..l fron IG.nc.o Dc:.r n.:;_1c1.. Guest EOL.1so. Tho structure is hole'- ~JY pipes 11l1ich c.ro e,1Jout 15 feet hic;h. Tho structure is 1i t by oloctrici t,7 u~1ic2.i cones f1°0;:1 :iis ~.:.c:X C;.11c1. c;ue::rc ~1ouso'° Before T!J:::sco 110,,.1- cn.rricc.1.. ou-t ins~-:,oc-tion o1 tho electric fi::tu:rcs 1 tho first c1.c2on.'..:urc :i2..'.. n.lrcc.,cy 3 T.::.en one ·c.12.y whc..t :dllod tllo plaintiff I fJ o1-.il,,_ 2.,Q it Wc:8 2. lc,nc tiac oinoe tl:c li:;~:t WC..G inotclloc.:. to tho cln.tc of ·[;.::o c'..OCiL1..ont., pcr:-.1iooio:1 fro,:i TlJiESCO. IIc >m·rcvc:r ocicl t:i2..t t:10 ::::truct1..1rc u2.s not Conoorninc t!io ~lc:-,_;i;h ccm10ol for the sooonc.:. c.lo2011(~m1t, the firot c:.cfcn:.:.o.1i-~ o,oi1.:. tl,nt ho c:.it::. net ho..vo c,, ~)or;:1i".; fr0::1 Tl'.lCSCO to instr:,l oloctrioit,7 i:1 ·c::c o;.lvortisor.1011·~ otruoturc. IIo .::J.no scir:1.. fao.t tl:wrc 1Ti.,o ·bp water souo 5 notros :fr0,J -:;110 otru.c,.;u.ro o.J.1Ll On 10/10/82 ho W2,G not ..::rot i:ror:d.1)(; for TLn:::sco. wi t.:'.l oon::n.t:10ro r 012.i;:1::J rn::r.10lir, c."!.c;.12:;oo ;_luo to olcotrioC1.l f.:u.l ts<I Tfo o:~~)lo.inoc.l the :"'rooo~,_uro to bo follmrod :Jy cw..yono HiDZ~.in,·: cloo-cricitJr tn 1Jc in:,diD.lloc.l in :1io 1)L°d.L:.1..inc uI1ic:i i1nr'.·:ivos uirin:: of t2:c ~:u.iL'.i~\-; :i~r ·t.:10 oliont i111'...:. i1101)ootion It io only If n, cona1.E1or 1T.:;nts ins:;:-iootion of olootric inot2.,llc.:1ii -:110 cf conoui:1ors :·.L:..o t,) rc-.:uooc:. r.m11po1ror. Oro::w-o:;:c:r;1inod by t!.~c plc.intiff ts 001.mocl~ ·li.;~o uitncss s2iC. t:.1.c.t it w...-,_,s ;_1o·c poo:::i blo f nr 'l:1lJT-]3CO ·;;o lmcw of ;:>J.'JY :::rtnw;~u:coo ~=--u·c up 2.Jl,_,_ oom1co·tc<1 Sue~: structures woulc1. bo illocc1..L oluL: :.w,c1. cli.oc.l-& He s.::.i.cl il":.. C'Jl1oluoion tl1,-.t if '1\',j_LGCO c.lL1. not cliooo~moot g 4 g T.:.e iGsucs in tJ.:.is o~:.Go uc1·c :-:.o follmrss- 2~ lbs t~:.c s.:-.i~l ·s·c:ructurc f2.ul-l:iy ;u.1.c'. cla..1::.;orous~ 3. If ·the snicl s-iirt.'!.c·turc Wc1s c1..of cc'-~ivc or fo,ulty 1 un,s tho sr:i(~ :L:::,ult plus c1..ofcot oric;i:1cl or of c, la:knJG nCLtu:rc 4t' Diel the c~coc~.soC.. C.io c..o 2., rcoult of ·t.1w fr:ulty structure. J, • I uill now prooocl'.. to ~1i:m-cr li:.10 1SSUCG, wc.,s · clef cc -~i vc b Hi•ri:.. roc;o..r(l to i □ GC ifo4, clicl', rLG .., :roauH of t\c f21.1l·G~r <.., ·" tho c1..cce;L:,oc·~1.. i:rc.,o folli1(~ l:-j,11c c..t J~.lc str1..,10-'liLU::c ri;.1:.,_ x1 0t·~o:-.1~;t ta rc~:ioVo ·0.1:0 clcccc1scc.1.. 1J~r P'T2 co.,uoc-"".. P:!2 fo muf er ('..11 cloctrio ~:oo:.:.. : 5 : clecensoJ. uont to the struc·cUJ.'G uhic:1 is u:::.~'.:t 1:ro~x1bly .'.10.:i:-:xme•.l, l:o uc::.o c0r-1;cinl~r a ·1:;roapp,sscr., 1E10 cv:L!.cnce -:;i.vcn cw.so oo·~c..~-lis.11oc1.. t)1a;i; it "1-Te.s quite sdo for sow.cone to ua.lk a.lone t}:c 1'02..Cl in t::i.o.;~ n.rco.. or clon:_; -'i;he As fnr o..s issue l'To,.6 is 00;1oernccl, the cViLcnco is very clcc..:r t::'..c;~ -'C:10 scoo~1c.1. c.l0fc:1c1.n:.1t ncvc:r conscf1tcc.1.. to the crcotioa of t:.10 structure ~10x ·:;o tho the fi:;.•o-1:; c.lofcm~nnt I s a(LVertisinc structure 1,r,o :t:-,v.ltJt o.nc.1 clnnccroL'.s, I uill scooncl tlc2011-,lrur'i; could n.luo :.,,:we boon lir.ble. I cmmo·i; see :J.m-r ~c:.1.e seco:1c.1- advertisi:1c structure wo.s not llis o.11(1.. he never co.,vc pc1•;-.1ir:J:::iio11 for i·b -to bo su:c,i)liGcl ui·i;ll clectricit;{-p Even i_f the sa.ic1.. s·~xnc-~1.;:.:rc, 11hioh 110 :.mmr froa ·1:;210 evidence to J.;.[',vo bom1 r.wvcC:. ii1to tl1c Ki;.1clo Gnas·:; :i~ou.oc i:rc,:1isos, is still bc:iinc 1.i-b Hit\ elcc-'i;rioity, we co..:u1ot infer th2.t -tho occo;.1c~ c.1-cfon:.~a.nt hwl o:;.•ic;L1clly I 00,:10 to tl1c 1st clc:~011."..2n-G o.r.;2.,i114 We :.1c.,vc Ccl1i:Morccl in issue Ho.5 t:1.n.t the d.0002.aocl was c. trcG1;a::;ocr_. We CLlso hc1vc lt.1con-~rovortec.l cvicl?:ncc t::cd; t;1e w:l.ver·;;isi:'1.:; otructure uc.s in Ji;ho 1st <.lcf ond.o.nt 1 ::; 1;lo·~. i-J11at 1-ro n.ro rocJ_tti.J.~cd. to ,lcc:i,c.lo ;.1ou is wllotJ10.r -~:1.e 1st clef onc~.:mt is lic.~)lo for tho dcatJ1 of "Ghe plaL1ti:7f ts son. · In crclor to clo so wo will :1r\:Ve to loo;;: at tho law, C:1a,rlcow.ortt & Porc~r 011 lkc;lir;oncc 7th cC.i ·ci on £,i. vos 2., c;oocl Moo~mt of tl1c co.:.r-.1O11 ln.u on aec;lic;m1ce,. trespassers. We lmow t:12..t a trospc.1,sscr is one who has no riC:1t to enter on tho lD.ni.."'t., or l1a:vint;- o;.1tcrccl ·:i!_:orc to roi:111in there, 01' 0~10· whoso pr03O;1cc on the ln:.1c7. uoulcl be LUL.moun -~o tb.c owner. positio::.1 of tho cor.rr.1O11 10.1: uitb. roc;nn1 to a troopn.osor on pq;o 453 of "ii::eir 1Joo!;: urn.lcr t).10 l1oac:.i11c, 11T:.1c co,:i:11O;.1 lo:ir prior to 1972 11 Tl10 case citccl is Ro1x~.rJ.; j\.<.lclie & Sons (Cq_l,liorios) Ltcl Va Drn17)rock (1922.l A.,c.35_3,365 in u:.1-icb. Lorcl JI::iils.'.w.a L C lcic7. clou:;_1 -(;~w f ollouinr; proi~osi -~io;.1 thaJG 0 tho t--rcspasoor co;·.1cs m1 to tho proaiscc est :1is mrn risk. An occEpicr is i;1 sucl1 a oase lic.iJlo oi.11:r 1-r~1cre tl1c injv..r:r is c.lL1.0 to some uiliul .::.ct iavolVi11:; 130;-.1c·~.'li~1G more -'i;.'.1011 -~:10 absence o::? :r-02..oonablc ca.re. Tl·•c·•c. ~·- J. ......~,J lJ •JO 0nor•c ·-1,,,...1., 1 .. ~, ..,,.._.1. ,10• 1 0 Tri"-:C'1 C.tAJ I.I \..... v •• J,..o. \ ,.jAtr 6 • ....~ .. ·t~~!.-f"!I/I~ Bu·t i:1 t':c 02-sc oi ~'.!:L1r:·~011 v.. Bri ti :i'.;. ~g__t;:;:z.o B~cJ: ( 197 2) ,'\.,. C. 877. , t:.10 11oL:oo o:Z Lorc.1s :rcfusoc.'. ·to follow RolJCrt !1.<.1.·J.j._c__ J~..e,Qf1:;!. ( Colliq_rj.2._0__Uc~ y_,_ Bu_;·-1.1?1:£91:s 1-T:'.1ich w2,s consL'.. orcc"'.. fo ,bo wron::1:~ tlociC.,:..c.l.. c.J.l'..:. 2., ::mbj cc·ti vo tc st o-:;o:1- oi:: Z.,-OC'..I's 3 cim1. ~1is olclor :Jro·~:.:ors ::.c.c.l ~)ccn 000:1 :'l0~'i:ac; lc..wfull~r in c., Bco..c.l..ou u2.:ic::. ua.s dpon to t:,o 1,u~)lic, w::cn om1.C..cn·ay >.o u::.:,rc: ~liscovorotl.. :·.u.osinc~ Ho 1T<1,G :cot..:r:l'.l oo:riou3l~r 7~L'.I'nt, S:.:ortly ci'tcr1u:-.:rt1-s, l;;--:i.i.1c; n,co.innt t>.o olco-'iirifiod 1 for -t;.1~2.,·t r.r~i~cfoll of t>. c rcil~,cy, b.~: ken nc,·i;ifi0::. ·tr0 , ;:1011t):s 1-:;rcviously ·'t;:1::.;i; Lo:rc.1. Pc::-..rson COi1clwlcc. h1 :~io □)coo:: t:.1us_: cluty o:i: occupier to tronp:1oncr is plci:1lt ii.1GA.1.oquc;to fo:r ;,1odcrn conc'3."i:iicno 9 C11(: its ri,-;itl 2~1(1. 1·00-t:dctivo c:.ic.xo..cto:r :.1c.,s i.11.-,cC..cc1.. t:~c :)rOj_Jcr (1ovolop;-;ic:.-~ o:: -~--~c co,:1i.1Dn lo..u i11 On ]_x1,.::,-c 460 of J~:oir "!.)r;ol;: Lmc1.or ·;;:.:c :w.:-:-:.linc trcopr.,s0L1c; o::.U.lclro;.1 or c:,c.lnl·~s, n t2:-.c J.c['.J:'noLl.. 2.u·0.::.o:c-s '.~i.<Jcuss JlcrrLv;·bm1 1s cr..sc ~1l.1 s·cc:cc ' ' ·.;_:.c~:c ,. ' m.ncc · ·clw " c.} cc113icc. · . · 1:1 ..:.ci ri;.1r;·co11 :-- 0· ' I s o:-,sc, ~ 1 . .L. iT..:Cl t:q-0S C., SLUJC'O ,,J.. VO Gl:C'XkdiTort:1 c.; Poi~cy u:1io> ['.J:'C :JL:.:·:_:o:c-•::;c:l ~J:r Llccioicnn of -~~:..o IT0u:3c cf Lo.r-cls. 7 g In m · .1.cn:30;;.n.c., ' uc ,.1.avo .,_, ~~10 0ccn:~iors · ' · 1 1· t ~/ L"12.,)1 Act _no 54 o:f 19684 T~10 t~·:;10 ci -t.'.:.c :Lc·c rc2t.1..s c..o f ollr;us: to bo c1..ono tb.oroi:m,. 11 or coo(1.o lo..ufullz on ru1,;r l2J.1c.1.. • ~,. n It o::;;:clw:..co t:rcs:;::o..:::oors" In ::,cc-tio:1 3 tl:.c Aot p:rov.i.clcs th[\,t 2..11 oocu)icr mros tho 11 co:.1~.1oi1 -~d;~, :)f cc.re" to n.11 ~1i1J visitors., ftCo·:., •· Ll.t1·1:;•r 0.1.·" • .4·.101_, V - Cf':.I'C 11 1· i=i • - 1 0·"1" ,,..._ ·1c·.,..1 1· ·1 •J. • ! "U1:)SOC·"1" ,:;, ' U r-11 , ( 0,:;;_ ) vi □i-~or Will be rocsone:1Jly or..:fo in uain;; t~:.o I:ro::1ioco for t~~o 1,urposcs :for I ul:icl1. :,c io Lwi toc1 o:r por::u ·(;tcc~ by t?.J.o occupier ·co :)o ·cJ.1.cro~ 11 '11b.o Occupi crG I I:.o..vo J.;o lool: at t'.10 conr.10:1 lo;r o..s m:poLmc1..c£. ;;Jr C.'.1c:.:closuorth & Po:..·cy, Ec:rri11r:t911 's. · case ci ·(;ol7- c,~JoVo cloc..rly ndcco lr..11Lllorc'.:::i lic,~)lo to JGrcoi,r-,Goor □ c..nc1 in po.:r·cicul;~.r to chilc.l:con. InC.ood the tl.ococ..sorl 1rcrc bom1c.:. to ;)c attr2,0·i;ocl :7J 1:::-~ cl.o:Z 011.:r,,nt' o st:nlCtu:ro, o..nc.1 c10corc1.i11c; to IIcrrinc;tontr; oe,sc, t~1.e firct c:.cfc:1•..--c:.ll"C ouj.1t to ':~2..vc fei100~: ·(he J o..c.:vor"Gidnc; structure.- By '.1.is '.:11;.1 2LbiGsic:1 ·1;.1:0 J.s-t l:o:;:0:1::r.nt s2.i,:.1 t:12.·t :11.0 ur2.,i,1,0C:. '1..,nx~JoC.: uiroo on tho structuro to s:.~::r:: ~:c;;; -t:.:.c s·1;r1.wturo uc,o c.1...~1c;crouo,. T..1cro our:1rt to ~l:¥vo ~}con o.. f c:aco n.rouml other oo,ses uorc c1ecic1cc.l u.':.ic.1.! f ollouc.''.. tho r:ri:,.1ci:~lo r.nc'- rol:.□ cnir1,,::; of •• : ♦• /3 D ·ci· -:coc -'' .• : ·o,.,,..r,r, ~-- c~·1,.,;1·'-,,·-, 1vc.,.,. Ul,,i...J. o·P C. ~ -,~ "'C" T;ic cr.,sc of lb.t.:.:i:icc kvior :)lf',l.0 '.'.·.c·'.S 1•· ..Jv"·Tr: 1 ... ,_ - ~,_-:,_~, :':".·•_:-_ "" - ••• ., "" c...i1J...:1.J \ ✓ ,1.J. .J. :..,..:,t.,t..J.> ·1::i• t'cl:-.L1J,i ·vs. Bio..s:1c..r:-1. T:rn~;.~?,l~~C.?.)/Gl:. en,: Grcc1_1__1,t-;;'.::.C1li.-,. Civil A;_,:-ic2.l i'To, 19 ·:if 1983 ( c;·~) is rclcvc~r:: .i.,_c::c. Dc-.;-.1.::> ;0:::; r.,wc.rc:.c,l ?rc:rc 15,090/= f n:r ·0b.c dcc.:0b. '.)f :, 13 JtOC.:l.' ol~1. c:.c. t.1.[;Ylior,. 1!~: 1 Ibji ·0.'..1:i.r-, 500,000/= a.s c;cnor:::-..1 cl~~-.1~~:cz ~.n~l H:--..t.w:icc L:.VC'.i:'. lTo~.li~JlJi ':·: 00..SC CCilCCl'~lCCL t:.:.U :::-..ooic.1..o:,_1t~ 'E1c CoLU'..,G of ::. L)C2.l in 1984 e;-rm·0ot1. fJ.~1.s.15i 000/= c.s cc~1e;;cl -~.:.ioecs. I clc not -b'..1.i"~;: t11c.;i; ·i;:.w ~ j_'OG'1,.1"C oo..sc is very L:i:::2 m:1.;:ri; fro;:i 1fol,.iD:)i rs o:::-..sc+ Tl10 sb.s.500,000/= uoulL!. ::c -~'.,.o C')I';;oct r_;_-.nm1..,.; ii: viou o-:. ,,>.c.·i; I b::vo s;::,i::. o..;:ovc" T2:_:::L1c; i;.1·i;'.) -:-co~tm-[; t~·10 L:::.:'lC'.:iiioacxy tc11C.. 011cy cf Ow' ctU':..'cncy, I 1-rnt1.lc.l r;rc.J:\.:. o..~7r.,;~:otl, t'..10y Will be ui·c:.1- i::.rkrcr/0 o..t C'll1I't 1o rr'.:0c :Zr-1~.1 jn~'-:::,:-.1c;.r;; L'.lrcil. s.:-'.-HGfc.,Ction of the: clc.o:rcc ( v.Lk Prori~1it2., v .. PctcJ: :Huso.. Ift)iyu, 1965~ " . .. / - -··· ' . / .. - ----:.? . . . ----r:· /~~~- . . ·-·- \. ' ( L.. BJL"/.i:I )-\ JlTDG:C 20/12/90