19940318 TZCA Tanga

• • i • • ••• 411D Tfj'J llEI'UllI,IO. . .. • • • • .• l~ • • . • • • • .BmPONDDl:Jll. · (Appeal from the -oonviot:L~ SJ.,d aent<moe ot tlle lli.Bh Oourt r£ · Ta;aza:ui a. at 'l!a.na'a,) ......,!..-.____...:.t......: ., •. . . (i:~'ff~ f,) . ' .,.,,, . d.b.te4 '\~ 26tll dW ~ .M..11 1$~l ' •··· .• .:.;·f --~, ~1.~~~-'~-~ed, .lariam ~ • d;oq.~8'.t,Bp~ ;~~~~~~ ii' lt!· .... • .... ' .. ~ ,►. 4 ,;. O. O i · .. ,. ; . • •. , · -~~f3rd-:-~,::·19$0e T'.1e ~9~~,:.~rt~'°iPt;,:l;Q (~•:?.4),,,~ t·~:-~.~r~ml . . lfgeJmra (Pl-r.11) ca~. oe.1.1¥,0_.of dea.tJ;i. ~-~~. ' :.- ~oak.~ to loss of a lot of blood. beoo.use of inoomploto • • • I • • f&:ia~lla.nt, them, tms 11ot a.t ~ooo, :T'~ a:.)YIOlla.nt. r.Q~.C..,.:. i:_v- . • . ~"~,_a.bo)lt 4 p.m.. a.ad, a.ftar 'boing .told of tlla ~~?~~~~ ·:-- _..,., '_qd,· ~'lit.P+lP,od:!lor. ':&Q;~tJll'Q.;..a;iC'!.i ~49, oxj;qn~.~~ - ;:".· __ , . ilij4 "~-~-·•... ·~ -- ::: ~- .. - - - · - • .::: ~-- ·¥\,i'.r.__-~:_:, ~~'~ wao 0,11'1. still io 0:,.1 iaauo. · · · '· · · ~ ' ... • ... 2 IT01trovo;, i 11 11:i M1i a.an.ti tl:l.apdtoti -bLa·b o.t a.bout 61115 ll•lllti ifuo. apl)Olla.l1t took iuo clocoa.ood in o. taxi to C.I.C. IIoal,1ita.1.t ~t. ta.xi wa.o hJXJl.tc$lt, wt t:.,o iD.ot:ruotion of t.:lo a:ppollrl.llt, by .Ali To..dua. (P!f.4), a. tocia:1t _of tb.o aJ_:ll'JOlla:rl;. .:.-!; that timo tllo doooa.aod wc1.r :b a bad ::rtla.to rn1d lu:.d to bo aoniotod into tho oa.b a.ad a.lso o: .t of' it ul1on t:1~- o.r.rivod at tb.o !.ospital. T'.alOl.'O, tho OGdioal of::iooi- 011 duty~ Timba Kajombo (Pt·r. 7), o. Modioal 1.soiata.nt, ua.a told b;r tb.o D-p1xilla.nt tll.C.t tho dooocood !lad a.n o.bortiOJ.1, 1.:11 ond o:f his tot~or, o.dv'ioocl tho appollo.nt to ~ tho doooaood to :Bombo Tioo:pita.l. Bi.:i.t iuotoad of doin::; that tho a;nxilla.rlt loft the -~oco~~d_.~]:d :rotirod to hia ·ho:m u;.:.ol'b ho .-ro.s mot by wo olclo:i:- aiotoro of tho dOopa.soda llQ4olilµ, (Plt,.1) a.ml ~liU, (~t.a). llllD.1 ,ro,r.i said ·boti-roort tho o.p1,qUe,iW and. ·Lho ·lt\tu aii.rbQrP ia moot poi;1t but it is u,:disi:,utod tl.ul.t tb.o a.1:,i:>ollant o.;.ld. Rf.1 took e. i··, ~ to tho C.I.O. IIoapital from uhoro t::oy i;xa;:1Sforrod tho t~?:~\ -: n}. ·- L~---- doooatJod t o ~ I!ospital and ovo11tun.J.ly to nombo Zospita.l. F:oom tb.o hotUJo of tho o.::;i110lla..-,t, tho other aic:tor, w.2, lront I ... ba.ok to i.'tt'om thoir r.1othor., ili.lda (PW.5), uho a.loo wont to Dombo IIoa:pita.J. to ha.vo u lo.pt a].im]?So of her doar do.uditor. Tho doooa.Bod l)<U3aod awo,y ohorlly a.ftor hor rJot:1.0r o.rrivod. It is olao comon crou;.1d that t!.lo O.l);?Ollaat r.1ado hiraaol:L' ooa:roo imuod.ia.toly a.:rtor ho dalivo:r:od tho docoaoocl o.t iJombo IIoopital• T'.i10 d.oooo.sod. ua.s buriod at Huhoza oa 5t:i. Juno, 1990 but only to bo- o:x:humod-'t1ro'ii;t;1y-nil1.o da.yo la tor amt bo r.iubjootod. to c.u.tOJ;>GJ" b;y Sylvootor Ebook +k'l.o.n:,,'!i (~+ 1lh m.:1 At1Wl.i:i'ttl.i1'11 lbd.it#\1 Ottioo~ !l who :prod.u.cod hio ro'.P()r'li (nlm. P5) t'.Jn.t tho abortion ucs plzy-aico.lly illd.ucod ru1cl. tlu.t tho uterus tro.s !)Orforotod. ••••• /3 . ,· 3 'l'llo loa.:imod trial j ~lso I I$)tmr, J.' oo~rvictad t!:io C.l)}')Ollant or OUJJd.w:. ~<?__!>E_liovod Pila. 1 and--2- that tho a;.7.:_,ol+ant--Canfoosad to thoo 'to llavr po»:f'orrood 'b1Q ubortion On tho doooOJJod. $ld. tho ~ ~ juda'() found tlv1iJ t'.\Vtdi:1110i) ·bi) )lb rJUl:ti:ibrilotl l.\y ~- tho p~tJnorlGtl wporl (2hrJ.J.. 1'5). In additio:1, t!:io ocmduot ot ~ a.:.ppolla..c·: l):t'Widod t:io oou1_) do gre.oo. Tho loarnod jl.lda:) oaid.a "•• • tho acoU1Jod act_ oi? to.kine; tho doooe.sod froo hio houso to th-, afm.--0:..oontionod. ho3J?ito.lo a.."ld i:ny for tro11S}?Ol't alio.re,'OG clo ·.rly dononatmtoa hio i11volvono11t L-i tho aa.id abol:'tio11ll. That ju.d6uont io t'..lo suhjoot of tl1io appotl. It baa boon (r;}S bittorq o.ttaoll:od b-J Dr. lc.mmi.i, loo.rnod a.dvooato for tb.o a.:pJ.Jollo.nt, but dutif\tl.ly dof'o;1.dod by Jir• lfu;:m, loar.nod. Sta.to .l.ttol"l1cy, for tho rospondont/Ropublio, 'ftro groundo of aJ?lX)tl !l.:wo boon o.d~1cod, Tho fin.it gr<>Ui.ld .--·-·--·· hao a nur,1bor of fronto. li'or t:lo pu:r;po::ioo of olari ty wo nllll.U d.o~ ttith-o:l'.W,.-y .aopoot oi' botlJ. c,'ti:'.a.iludtl t:LfJ m\Jtad. 1f :bi•• Lw11tn.J., --•--•-- rot:ipondod to by Mr. lfu.ao. w.1cl t!lo roplioo of' tl1.0 Colll10ol for tllo In tho f'irot {;t'OUJ.1d t~ c;,,:•.x>llo.at tWOl.'13 t:ia t tho i:,rooooutio:.1 (_~ did not dioch.:.J.-[;'O ito bm'Cl.011. of proof aad t~t t:i.o oirot.U:ltlt.?.:.1000 roliod upon uoro oa.po.blo o:r i:10:t'O t:io.:.1 0:10 illto:......:,):..'Ot~tia.1. 1-.a hio fira t poi.1t :i;1 tha. t e,-roi.t:d 1 Dr. L.:,.,:nra.i o:uu.10,:.~'0d tb.o pootl,.mortom report (n:t:i.. ?5). ITo pobtod out t:.iat P'J. 13 did 11ot diodlooo his aCD.domio quo.lifica.tio,10 but r:toroly OC'.i:l th..1.t ho ,ra.a an Aooiota11t Uodioo.l Oi'.i:"ioor n. Dr. I.o.r.nmi ]?Oilltod out t:ia-:b ~Y partioulnr n.utopsy1 ii.1vol•..ri:13 a::uw.1ation o1 a. boC::,7 buried t(ronty.-ui.."'lo-db,-;•fl"·p1-oviouoly 1 otllod for a. oot,:1d b:.01,lodOJ of to:ro:.:.sio rnodi~~b wll.ioh Pl-f. 13 d:ld. )1ot oVo::1 tllo.it1 to _i:u:,ouo::Jn, .l..o ov;\.i'l.ri11e10 ot tho l!i.ok of l)l'O--roqttlu:tfo o=::11oriiao, 7.)r. Lo.i:nro.i olo.ili10c11 Pt-T.13 ,··· . X'Oliod on t:10 ialora:.tio:.1 1;:~:i.cb. uas ou:,::_)liocl to llii:.1 by tho :rolativ~o of_:t.:io dooo110od tb.at it .uo,;:; a. c;:-.ao of o.bortioa. .. ' . . lll:>...7.l't froo tl.JD.t, •••••• /4 4 tho :1.oa.mod Cou.113ol. poi:.1tod. out, P'.I• 13 dicl :10-t diopln.y tho ~o.lHZ ot i:'..l OX:f)QJ.Yti i;.o t:.::-.t :i.o did :iO'li ::;ivo tho d.w,-,oiCllO ot tho po:t'forotian of tho v.toruo., Dr, Ior:nm.i ur 0'0d U3 to l.Ql.0l'O Jj)Oot.:,i:iol'ton b ll.ddition t.o :tio t~tlili~ a.CJ .".,µoitJtL1,llt t ~ -------· 0t.t'iOaf• · I::. a.iv oaoo, i'lr~ fat:10. 1:Li'lHml.1 OY011 :i:r ·bl.1CL t 11i0Qti UC ClV'!i.d.ot'lOO io <liooa.rdod tho:..•o in otill t:10 tootir.10:cy of 7d'•11 rotd t!i~ doatb. cortifica:tlo (Eicll. :i?4) tllat :::oao ro:-.in.i."tJ.o of footua. ~ ooon. llouovor, tbnt l)Oint tin::: _alroa.d,y co,rorod bJ• Dr. Ia.tnro.i u.b.o adoittod o.bortiqi but roitorotod tbat tho 'i.or.::.:,o ,ms ~r.10 ~ d i ~ Dr. Iel:nrai aaicl. tlla, t a. l ct of orodi t mw J.)Ut on tho tuo siotorot P\fs. f and 2, but ho O.l'(,'1od tb;;,.t tho:r clicl not doa.orvc. it ao o~ch llD.d J.'C)cordod -mro otatoront.o at tllo. l'olico Station :in a llJ;)a.n ~ a yoa:r. ITo said. thn.t th.::.t should not b.2.vo boon nocoooa:cy- llo.d. thoy boon foi-thcolling. I:fr., Iiu.n conoodod thn.t. there n.ro OOnl d100:ro1:nnoioo in tllo tuo ato.toao;.1to of bot:i ;:;iotoro but dicnioood tlloa a.o immtorial. lll.roccly projudicad. o..gni.;:1::rh t:.:io a.P1_X>lla.nt no 11 c1.."..l-:t.:-,ri V.:1().yofahaaika oa.."1.l. oa.ua. ba].)a, ojini ktia OhU(;Uul:!i za lru.toa. u:i.r.iba. 11 • 1.n ou.oh1 Dr. kl.r.nro.i contondod1 ma. 1 ru~ 2 pro-jud;ud t:J.o appolla.,t o,;1d fr/..f, f,1 _".l tllon olaimd that tho a.l)".:_)Qllo,;.1t h,.1.cl co;li'idod to t:ion about tho I.;--',~./ 1?\: t·,.·: •, o.bo:rtioil. Hl'. llu.10. rof\ttod tli..--.t a..1d otuck to hie r,U10 tlul.t R1'G. ~ ••,o\<" +-:.., 1 a11d 2 uoro told ao lT.r t!io aj_J::_X>lla.;1t a::Jtl. t:.ic.t fooy :roportod tb.Ua 1~-.: .. to tb.oir notb.or Fif•5 lt'.co um1u.ccooof'ully rooiatod tho burin.l c.o tho el.oo.t;i tr.:,.:J a. l'olioo 00.00, Dr. IJJ.tnm,i atta.c'.::oc1 t:..,o vomoi ty o:r t::o tire r.ii:::toro ovon f'ul.-tllo?" aad la.bollocl t:.2oa lic.oro. ::-,o citocl t:.:oj.r ov'.i.clonoo tb.'.:.t tho triio of. :Lo a~XJl¥-.1t (:m.12) co.no --ou:t of tho ho\.Ulo .and ... :t'ObWtad tho o.p::_X)llr:.nt :?01• :,:tr] :.1.C.bi t of l)Ol'forn:1.u,'.,' a.bo1•-t,ion,; I ... . ~~~~-k~-?iz~~:~_ 5 do:.l.'.!.Dd by :?.·T+ 12 horooit a.::lCl. cloo b? R-T.4 1tllo 1r,:,.n thoro ct tllo . ' r:i.:.torio.l tino. Ii:t-. liu;u,, oc.icl t!lc.t t!.:.n.t ilf'.O c quootiOl'l of crocli b:UJ t,y lil.ioll tmo J?l'Ol'lOrly dooidod on by tho loro-nod triz.l jlldtN it.ur-.c n firnt c.!)rocl t::.io Oo~trt oc:.u.d otill ;·.Je!:o ito O'!m findinl; of orodib~.1ity. tl\Q r,1'.llX>llo.:1t tr1.l0ll n,bortio:.1 hv.d r-.lroa-o/ booi1 :?o~.L'orr.lOcl 011 bp:r --··-· QJ.r.1onhoro n.:1d 1)-,✓ m1utho1· 1x.H'f'.I ctt•i• Ho mlvr: inod ·b~ii/:1 11r.n11ciqj;j;~1 ovidoneo tllct t:.io docon::;ocl. md uot boon foolbc troll tlmt oo~rl.!1ci <'.lld CV'Oll· boforo i 1;. Thio H~.o or.id by t::i.o nothor (RI.,5) t1.11d fuo ·foo ·oiotor::i (Pffo. 1 2.;.1d 2h T'.10 doco.:.ood, Dr. loam.i rooj_.1dod. uo, oiocod o. cley d oohobl a:.1d ~1..."'.d. to fabrioa.to c. hoopi t.."..l chit to 0Xl)lo.i:1 ~1or tru.."..~ioy. T'.1m1 t1.lo..t fci.toful ,1:1ornil1c;; tho doooo.nod Ut'..:J olUGGio:.i in roovo:1C:bs to tl!oir not:.ior•o :roquo::it 1o hor for a. ou.ri of tea. Imloocl, no~,1 c.:?toi• o~o :i.c.d J?l'OiJc"..l.'Od cmo, c.ml tlt'.O rillo..rod b,Y tho □othor to roou:JO ;.:.or Ploo;.:>, o::io did oo b tho corridor re. tllor thc..1 i.1 .!l0:i;- bod. Dvo:;.1 t:.10 yl.'Ocoodi:ig ni[)lt ~10 docoaood .. ha.d iw1 boo:1 quj;\lq ll.o:crJoJ.f, D.r• I.oil'.llrr.:I. UQm'\o4'Qd ,;tto"1ior ~ho ciooon11Qct lmcl :1 Cl1/ f!n?l.l r.:b :I.t ·bhr,t or.:r.l:i, 1.J. tonm1i:i.-roly, Dr, I.c.nll!'.i quoatioaocl t'..~o 1.U1C;ciootta1tod for t).J.roo hou;ro of tll..."..t fctoM di;;·. ·,Tho lonrnod o.dvoo6.to rovis:ttod tho ovido:100 Of :'ff, 1 u:.i.o loft ho::10 trith tllo dooo2,0od··c!..1d rc,rtod 11t'v"O c.t ~hou.t··10.oo o.,n. Tllo dooo<1.Soa.' un.a t'.'.oil' i?z,ooood.1.,g to . ...... /6 .; ~ houm- le.tor t:·,. clocoo.ood. ooor:;od at tho !loUDo of t!lo a.P.POl,lo.n~ wa.l.k:ing uith uor.10 difficulty. T:io.t was a.bout 1 p.m. Dr. ~ tho going b--' JeDO ~5.:i:.."ul, tho pro!:'o::::oio:cl aooistc..:100 Of tho n.ppellant 11 ·.o aouoit. Ur. )1u.na o.gnin cl.iouiacsd. t::.o t:1X00 l:.ouro ao icoa.tor:l.al. liha:t is crJ.Cially ic.port..".,1t to hie ii:: t!:.o fact that tho . doooaood U'Qnt into tho hoWJo of t!10 a.J:):._)Ollnnt u."'laidod, Dlboi t with BOQ) difficulty, 1:>ut co.no ~ut of it o~otely hcl:plcns. Mr. Mwa also quosti011Jd the dill~d.;.1~ of t!l.o n.:,::o+lo.nt for :::orno tno end a Ql,l.ll.rtor-hours--aftor his :roturn··heoo.- I:.:. t>.o condition of tho cl,QQf!El,DOd ha4 d.raa'l;iQall~r WOl.'QQi-iQd a. t tho hQUfJO oi' t:.li;I APl.~llal1t, -·-·-· )t;r.,. !fun.a chilJ.lo11god., ulli}' diilnt·b a. UocUoc'.l Jw:l:~i111lcµt'11 M "l>lm a1:,polla.nt, roalioo t:lo sorio1.1.Bnooo of t:.:.o oi tu.::.tion and rush tb.e d.oooasod to the ho:J!)itru.. Hr. !Iuna suboittoc.l. t!lc.t tho clooea.sed had not eono th.ore :for lJ:t'Of0saional ac.:si::ita:.100 but for an abor.t1011 a.nd that .-ro.o u:;y t:.i.o a.p;_:.olle,,t took t~t long bo:foro ho resorted to tho hOSl)itoJ.o. Tho scco;.1d grouri.d of n.:1.)C.'.'.J. ic tl:d t:io lcaruod. judgo a.p1X)llant did ucs to t~ t0 l:ol:1 t~:c docoor;ocl c.:::.tl 11ot to Q.Otua reus a..11cl hcmco t4o:.-o cod·l not )?O,oibJ..:· bo oons:-roa,-,--of-a.ey ooi-t.- .1~. liwa.ltJ ro::_1ly 1,:•.i:1 c;Lii.~lo, oinoo ·U:.o rl,:!):i;,pllM'fl J?Orto:mod tho abo1'tion t:ion !lO kl:ou t:ln t ewe. t!1 ooµld pQ80iW;r roaul t a."ld ..r~on it did, tl,ou oons roa 1 ~ ·rorJ ouch thcro. 'I Ii r . I •...... /1 ' I I f • 7 .kJJ a.l.roa,cl;r ot.o.toc1, t::..a t:occ~od li.::.el i:1cor.11il.oto abortion, ~- al1'0D.ey oc..i, ., t1.ui.t cloci::;~.0:1 m·...a ;.>ou;.1clo{l 0:1 t:.:.o oviclo:100 of tllo !'To oo.;r no 1-roll ctn.to riJ:..t ct t:~o bo.;il~tl:~c t:.io.t ctriotly th.io ;.' .. \ r>iooo of ovic.0:100 cloor.: "!ot nd.v.:.:.100 t.'.:o oc-..Go oao U<Q' or t:io otbo.J.,• I It co:lf'i:N.10 u~t :.iao .:i.l:.'O.:::.ct· boon oottlocl; t:.J.O abortion wno imlt10ocl. ITouovor, H cloorJ :;.1ot toll tu:: u:iat.ar or not tho not detain un l011c,ur. 3u:,'.'Zico it io to oc..::, t.'10:t ,ro CG-000 uitll. 0 C.. So 1ro al."O lolt :1:m ,;;it~ tll.o ov:i.C::c:100 of' t.'.:o t.ro oiotoro a.11d tll.o oo::iduot of t:.i.o O.l)".f)oll;;,.:.:t. Uo ta.kc it c..o c. f'c..ct t!.~1.t if.,o;,1 t'..::.o tuo oiotors n.rrivod r,rivo.to ohct. ?Fro. 1 c.:.1cl 2 1ro::..'O oi.r.:?Jortoll b;;,r 711.4, a tonz;nt of' u o.p:.lOllant. T'.i.o quoot:i.o:1 :i.n ,fi..".. t ii::::: :::c.icl. T::_;.o i::: ti'.D 1ro.rcl at 8 io to vhi to. :&lt do:fi.:1....,_ to~· it i::: c.n pi:ik io to roil. T'.}.0 fir.:it -·-··-'. ~lQ hn.m i.r;ini taro. ollud:.Lu.i cc. l-4,to.~;. r.J;i.:.1bv, tul;i.onc. liiY,l•O • i, ,, ~!wnu l'.r: .ofa.1.zyn. o.-ir1bo J:ld;o,: ·~.. :kLbo :;,l\'/O t'.i.•.l~ ln1.11i i.il:l. ·ti1Jll.1i4 1w. ; i a.l<:c.oom ••, Ma.to.kn iuo oim. ~:;m:.1za, b.u!co 1'1,7UT.1b0.1:i lc110:1u iJIJioooo oto.tono.1tr; tho .:io::.rmC,'() 1ro.o co o:.::..-,ron:::. :::r. 2 rJQ..id "••. ali tua.obia 1o u~ irr>..O thio. (ho vould o::::ioct, c.o D.c-. Ul.t':1\·m.i odd, tlla.t tho tiro oiotoro uould not lmvo rtl;1ccll t:1cir src::-c.b :i.:r:1oclic.tol;r ~ ~ looo of t!loir doo.r 0;_10. L.p:u-t f'ron that t:.,o t::o :.:i::;tci"l:l old.noel i:1 t:.:.oir !!ad pori'on10d t!lo o.borticu bo:i:oro ovo;1 Lo uot~:.or ,ro!1t to Iloobo :.:Ioapi W. Ilouovor, in oroo~-.:Lr.t;;.0:1 ;)~' ::;;., !..ktu-o,. .ilfe 1 odd 11lw.1 1~19 ooul,cl.~bt tolJ. 0L1r 11,7.r,x.1¾p t:.irJ :l:w'.;:_:.;,~u.~·biu·:t or,t,l;l.Q:i,t l.1~UUQ :r-c.oxnni urtio;.1 b-J Iir. 1-iunc :i.J.o ro:..10.-.tocl: n: ,,:-,,o no co:-r..''u;::ocl tl:at I oouJ.d 11ot toll qy pcronto c.bout t:·.i::: :i.::c'.c'.o:·.t ir:::--:ot'lj.cto).;r eftor c1.ocor-..ood to RoooT I I i ! 9 ~I 11 (\. 1rould bo ::io bold or oo otupid to· ;.)Orfori:1 ro1 c.bortioi.1 ou .:i. t,otc.l, stro.;.1£;".)r ui t11i:1 tuo !iom-r.: cftor tlloir vo~ fi:c'ot o.1cou.1tar. 0 Or 1.aa this o. ccno of 1'ku.okoc. jQ.J..".Zitt (r.ic.v--o tho rJi-tL,....,,tio:1} e-.Q D.t-.. Las:uroJ. puts it? :fo llotr ooao to tho oo:1C1u.ot of tho r,::_-,.l)OJ.lo.~1t. Did it w.riouo oireuootai1000 i.i.1 'bl.u:i:b lic;.it. of tioo boi'oro tnk:be; tl:o clocoo.oocl to :.:.orJ::_1i tel. ::lom tuo ucld c. qu..:.rtor ilO\.U:'O olc.pood bci'o:co tho D-l>:)Ollo.at to~l;: t.'.:.c cloooo.Dod to t!lo firot !.loopi to.l. :fo do :1ot :;:now u:.::.6:1 t~.:c blootli:.1& ot<'..rtocl. • . . .~~;~i:~~~-~-=~~-- -. ··.~·-·~~:~.~=·=~. :~'. {~-. --·----4~~-'="'.,....,.~ ... 10 t.ro...tocl11 • r iwct tll9_ ::.::_i::c'lOl~\:'.nt l:..,cl cl:..'Ot,c).:,' cpo~~~-~ l:Jt of titXJ uit;J. t h o . ~ l \_ c-.11c\ tll£,.t .-..t t!mt jtnoturo ii.or rolr,tiiroo i:O~ rJ.ror.<l,y tlloro ao tho t1,ppq1lp.:1t rotbou. llooo~ T. ,c:t to 1.1!:! -1o ll J.)lt'.ltU :l.!Jlti tilt].Ul:\l.·U\tj,gi1i 1 1 Thora t ~ c.J.oo tho icouo of tho JX'~•bc; for tho to.xis. T'.uo ,l firot trip to c.·I.C. IToo1Ji-tcl. froo tllo ~!lIJOllc.l1tlo l.louso oould no\ ~ :·1 •i hnvo boon otllor1dc:o, L.n to· t20 oocond log fl•o□ t'.lo o.pJX)lll'..i.1t•a ~ ) llouao to C.I.c. IIoopi t.?.l ia tllo cooiX'.::\Y of :m.1 tbn.t C..'1.."l. iunUo.-cl: bo ...'°J undQJ;1Gtoocl. Tao C.;.)l'lCllc.:.1t 1mo loo1'..il1~ for tl:,o l'Olctivoo of tllo ?:j clococoocl .:-...>1cl P:r, 1 OU(lclonl:r ooore;'Od n.::cl o::o oodc1 not nocooocrily Jlr.vo .. , l '-- roco---ror t:!o 0:1..,r(;'Oo, ir;, c.a D.r, lo.tt1h'.i cnicl, out of tho ordilw.ry ~~ Iootly, t:.i.cro io ·C::.0 lio u~:ic~l t:.lo e,::_J::_l0llo.:1t told tllo mdico.l of'f:'..cor of C,I.C. Iioopitc.l (?!, 7), t::.:.t t:io docoll.Ood tl'tl,ll ./J98j] 1 Q.Tio 720 r..:1C. o.1oo b [}9Cj] 2 1.11 D.R. 1008 it tro.o ooids , , • ••• /11 • ...... :·,-tl.~f~r"". .....~.-.,. .....;1 •• ..J- -~_:::'._/:'."' ··••'.~~~ • ', 7 /. .,-, I / ~--- I .,, 11 .... l ll ;J ~! ... __:......!...-.; ;! ~.j To bo c...-,,::_-,_..,,1,10 of o.nountL1,:,; to ]l;i ff ,l cc1:,.10bore,tic11 Q. lio told out of Co1.1.I1; 1 ~ '. nw::t firot cf ell bo doliboi,c.to. lt .\' ~ .\ -oco:adl;•, it r.11.UJt :rolo.to to Q, r.r,to:;.-.:i.o.l l I i::muo. T'..:.il.'C'J.;;,·, tLo noti-ro of t~:.o lio 1 ;i nu.ct bo o. ror.liontion ot &,uil t, focr 1. \ of t~o trutl: •• • l.Xloplo oonot:Lr.100 lio, for OXC.O;_llO ia en attonpt to bolotor f''\ • l \ UJ? r, juot cc.uoo, or out of r.:~:..:,.r.10, or 01.1t of uioh to co~1coo.l n clic(;.!X',COi'ul v boh..·wiour frou t:;o i'D.Dil,y ••• II l ! T'.ioro io no doubt t!.:!.."..t ~}.l'.t ur.o c. dolibomto lio. :fo. OJ."O lJo.t...Qldl<l I .d ouro t;.1.."1.t tlu!.t lio __:role.tod to. c ir.torio.r-icni.;.:). :·:"!:...-,,t ,r.:-.c i.Lwoivta.rt ---··--·- to uo in tllc.t tho O.}?l::Ollo..::rll toolc h:l.tj n,,,t1011ii to ii/\o bQOvii~, tf~ r ,/, 1•·,:. l h(:i. ~ fQQl tlw;b ~ t 1roW.d. hcw·q hpon tUfformlii k·,;i ho Llt\id t!u-,t ho ~ p.iok.Qd __.c... ''t''· ~ f ,,. r, ,· . up t:.io docoazod fron tl:.o ot:roota. Bvo~1 ·Let lio to 'P'.1.7 io 11ot '\ oxoluoi-;oly OX'._)lc.i,mblo in torr.ui of c::_111Jl1~1t 1 ::i 1::.uilt. t,· - I \ :· r !ftor r-..ll ic: o.:'..itl .:-.:.:d. ,,0:10 1 n.:.1 c.cc~::Ji:c(; fi,1.:;uro io pointi..ie; ;!. .. ·1' ·'·' ;;,:• ·,~·. ;' :·;1:. ,, { n. t t.'.lo c::.>1:x,llc.:,t. !h:ovor1 no t'..:i::i io c. ro:x:.. tcl -:,ffonoo tl!o ovidOllQO @t !:.a.a to bo ;rc.torti.::,:.:.t,. It in poo:Jiblo ti:..··.:t t:.:o :roputa.tio..1 of t~ ll.l)J?Olln.:1t, if r.:iy, b..".o co:1tribu-tocl t:, :·.io 00:.r.-ictio:1. But 110 aro l f.-..r fron boL1c co:1vi..,.coc'c tL."..t t'.~o oviC.0:100 i::; bo:ro:1d o;;i;r rc4"'.00:mblo d::>ubt t!:......_t tb.o c.:,11011<'.;.ri; :.--01...Zor:::od. t)J.o a.b:.i•t::.::-,:!. ia 1 but tx.t i:J :10·!; o:·.ouJ.,. Sunriicion1 tJ.:.o:ro .. f· I, So ,:o cl!,_?'!r t'.lo-.:-.:9;1ecl, C;.L'.£.~J::. t:,c c·-,:;:;:;;=:ictioc1 oi i:1m•dor a.;1d i i: oot o.oido t:.io oo:1to::90 o:.2' 1.~0:-.·t:.. , 'i.1:.•0 r.,~r);>lJ..:-.:.t u:,,•1\ld bo wlm,tll,r\. . .•: 1-r: 1,~ ir-il:lq!lJ,i.vtiol,\r :I.:::' :,o io :.!,,t '.)·t:~oi;;riuo lt\lf.l.\U.lr b o:ro.orod. ouo1puy. It ia o::, . J\ ,.i I . -·- ~ ·: . • ••••• /12 .... .· ... \ • ~ . ..,'t..: . .t, ·d·" ....-.• .• -~r..,, .... ~~-~.:.~~~¢ .-~~~f:i~f~i,~ir;~~~~;!1;:~~ ·. '•\ ->_..... 12 J1ETIOD OF .:.;.:•:..:EZ.J:. ..::...;;.L. R,:Ji..".:il.::~;r _JUSTICE OF ~·..:,:-~ J :, ,. ·t_l:'.:!~~'). ;~~.'.)' -,; m:!:i:'OTY 1