fadhil mohamed vs shabani unami 1994 tzhc 415 4 february 1994

PC, CIVIL J-.P. 33/19G0 lYJDZILI MOIIAIEIDI*. . . . . .IPPSEJUOT? YjiESUG f?-Tff;'3TT TETiKI............ » . 333SP01HELW J S D G 1 U 3 IT T This appeal ro tten to a piooe of lan d whioh. has "been a mtb-jeot «e -two c i v i l oases tf-daL deoided \rj tho ICEtoi'a PriHiary Court in Kr-lom'bero D is tr io t. Blxe one i s C iv il Cose Ha. 77 of 1901 -which i s re fe rre d to in p assin g "by the learn ed a p p e lla te M a g istrate, end th e o tl.er i s Q iv il oaso 33o* 14 of 1986 yhxaih i s the su b je ct of th in appeal* Ehrecits uiaoih. le d to t h is appeal ocn o n ly 1)0 put in to olocr forous ttfter fondiJag out what was adjudioated •upon In ' . the e a r li e r s u it* In tho Xfckura C iv il Case W0. 77 of W Aflh& Logchalijm sued liohaiaed s a id K ilcopckiirili on tho seotmd th a t th e defendant had onnhoachod on tho p la i n t if f s p iece of len d . She sued *0 reoovor th a t lan d and fo r w npensation fo r inro oooonut tr e e s which wero f o ile d h y the defendant. Her aotion suooooded in a tmanimous judoQcmt of tho t r i a l prim ary Court. I’J hilo considering the appeal in rospeot y£ the Ifalcara Prim ary Court Ci-yll oaso ITo. 14 of I 98S tho loam od D istrio t M agistrate ohsorvod th a t tho p l a i n t i f f tho ro ?tlio la t e Asha, Xdsohaliniaj was ShcJboni Unoinxs p a te rn a l aun t. Shahcni U nm i i s tho respondent in t h is ap p eal. I t was algo in ovidenoo th a t tho defendant In c i v i l oaso lTo» 77 of 1981 "was in no way ro la to d to the l i t i g a n t s in th e prosont appoal. 2 On tho pilior Iona, there m e ovidenoo th at too 3aid mrf* Shaiiba w * tho property i f ono t e i mmotrnu the i„i sa id leftn o issue WTVlTtaG h i* , t a t Doforo fe, died Anzi bequeathed tho s u it p lo t to Asha U s o h a lim lAo « * M s s t o m a l ra n t. I t ^ « 0 court, ^ c a lle d KO„ svidenoo ” l a *” e t0 * ° ' ? » oolosio=-l enflw of tho l i t i ^ i t a , tlrn-t tlT.0 respondent fa th e r oad A n si's fa th e r „oro brothers, I t is now 0U ° f 1 te ‘ * “ 000,0 °f aotion * » <w*«fa«a «& * 10 teNA on the re la tio n sh ip lw h w a, tho respondent and tho la t e t o r t „ho tho l i t e r ' s p atern al Imolo. looked a t fron m other anslo, tho th ru st * * * aPP0Di Sof° - * • “ - w Court W . power to devise tho s u it land to is!,-,, h is m t a a a l aunt. She appellant i s iish a lig o h o lim u ’ s grabdson* I t i s VQ0 .^euod M o r e tho lo a n o d ap p ellate D istrio t M agistrate " 00#ort“ 6 *> « » Atogoxo t e t l a l o w * * , , * , rfiicb tho lit ig a n t s ^oolong, a maternal n ep lw has no r i cht to in h e rit r e a l property t«m C r T V ""* ^ * “* • i s l a t . tho a p p e llan t's mother Erie *****49 « • * « t e t o r t had bequeathed of the Local O u s t e d I™ B u lo 'jq Eulo X On’■ 4 3 ' °f 1?63 dSfeata t :‘0 “W y a n t 's olalm. 49 provadoss— Tho sa id "IkiTra. h a t e , baba au shar,jOTi v a r i e d ndugix vengtae wa fcuKmoni*Tl E T C octually t h i s Eulo k i l l s a woman's - i r h t to bominH- i ttT -i-? i -» t , " ^ ooquGcviJn re a l px^oportv imxola bole age to lior to IiGr cwn W m n- +n o-l to caiy* otner person s ^ ig o r d e r s worthy « W iif a g hor e s ta te , * CKst TZZTTT S o c i e t a l needs i t i s intended -ondor l t o ’ • °J * “ ** t0da;’ ilGaoteiaatoE' against anyone m p o lio - t r ^ l 0 t ° 01,4 * <®a3nait to ^ p o lic y . I t i s puhli o 1 Pa0pl° “ • OWWl »X»t<eo the lair ,* ia h , fa ^ ^ ^ aHo „ ta . T a o. u T s ta , ^ " to ^ G C t ah w - 0110,3 to ^ « , t s u s e l e s s and ^ t , thor.Toro, ho d ia o a ^ d . Blo i t o ^ Sh ifth " T ^ th° 't° 'b°TOat:i I,or to whoever she cihose G ^°^ofbro pcssod good -fcitlo to ^n-dlinli M 7 ^ # -ho hoquoathod tho s u it porool « 1 ^ to h i l T ^ " ^ * . ^i st troioot V<fc«t C M sot T asides 1 10 the ^ ° "dudgnent roi- B“ of^ the t r i a l~ w h ™ , - alh o lt upon d i f f e r ^ oonslderatlons, i s resto red m ^ S h a ll ho read to the p a r tie s hy tho a ^ J o oa 4 f c * * ■ " “ * jkt-JS maCAWJA / •Vs JUDGE L / It f c S ^ y f e o ^ r * 0-* ® -fcpouajrt. in ji^ iU p p G lla ir t f g Eoprosojxtn-feirol 4- 2- 1994-