19941201 TZHC Dar es Salaam

I ------. ... TEE Dllt:'..J@ Il.If:¼13LIC OF TAN'Zlil!+A nr cir~ lTIGII COT.TRT OF TANZWA ------- AT DAR ES stu.Ju\M • • • • • -- • • • • ¥ • • • • • • PL,O.DJTlF.D" versus R U T:, I N a In this oasc -:::.,o k'.7to!'nay Genc:ra.1 b.2.s been served w:i.th a. Third:, P~tr lfotioo ac a r:-:rtt lic:blo to i11denmL-Py tho 2nd Def~ndant1 the Bat:lonal Dank of C!c,:.;·.,:::roc, for oL::.L':l.cd d~os DJld o.Qsts in a suit :Lnstitu:hGd agah:s.t :.-t joi:1t:.:.y -:-iitl~ Ta.11zD.nia Sisal Au.tllo:t:ity, the 1st l)efond.rol·i;, £or failv.xo to c,1:ant vnoo.nt posacssioi1 to ·t.10 Plaintiff' of. --~ I.and- puro:1asod fi'om ·tho 2nd Defcnd.ent, on oocount of allogod -wrongful; .r.evooat:i.on 0£ a RigM; of Oocupa.noy by the Prcsid01t"'41 of the United llA)pub~o of Tanzania, in rcspoot of suoh land, lt.l.ioh ha.d been laro:~ 'fm~d by tho 2nd Defendant to the Plaintiff, E1£Unji L ~ Limited, upon SUQh salo .. In hie Written st~tooont of DcfGnoc, tho A.t~rnoy Gcmar:al hae- n.istd a prclimina:ry point 1ilicll Mr• Malaba1 loaT1tcd State Attorney, en 'bcll.a1f of the Atto:rnay Gcnoral1 has ~guod boto:r:o tllis oourt. In the :f:i:ret plaoc, it :1as been oonte.nted t!la~ tho Third Pa.l!'l;y Notioc acrvc<l upon t:J.G A:tio:cllOy Gener.al has no"i; oompUad with the . p,:ovisions of 0,1 R._1,i"..t~ of the c.P.ct, ~iah :rt~os ~t tho Noti,Go a.1ould state .219£!.1:l t:io nc.~c of the plaintiff' a oaac ~ainst the Dotc;ul..:l'-t(s), it 1)Ci11.[;· n:r.:;uccl ".;l-:r;~ thG Notice ccl'V-cd upon tho A.G;. . . '..... . doos not S?._onoisc\y o:r ::£."'.22..i.sc1y a·~;~d;c the pl~1.ii:2:t' ::i oasc ~ainrl tho Dot.c1ula11ts, and, ::.11 j_)1:.:r·~io:.1ltcc the 2r}.d DGfcndan·~, suf"2ioicntcy to G%l,a.blo ·foe A. a. l.'Gply -~o ~1::.0:1 lfoticc. _ &0011.d.J.y, it l:as boon oontGnc1.ccl by Ml:, I:Ie.lcba t:·,;:i.t uhilo it is tho ;r.c<J.'l,1-irc.mcnt undor 9~.ifa.~ 12,W o:f tho 'C.P.C. ·:.:1a·~ t:'.10 third pnrty lfoti.Oc should state also -~ho Dcfcmdat1t' s a~'\im ~?t\inst ·i;J.10 'lhird Ptll.'ty1 that hM not boon done in -'.;ha ineta1.1t oaso. • - 2 - . . lfotiQo in c:J.so supposod ·\Jo adnhlish tho conneotion bo-bweon tho Pl.a.in.tiff's Q.J.$ ~ainst suoh Dci'1mdro1t ancl ·the 2nd &f'ond.o~xt• s o1a.i.Dl against t.."rio · ~- ~il:d fozty vzhich to ::~1, lin.cl not been mnd.o out Ol(i~ 1n thG ~ d P~ty lfo•:;ioo eorvcd upon ,.,~-~G A.G. 011 tho point ~io · GQUt't ha.a bocn J:afo:;red to tho 0?460 o:£ Sl.v~e.op,g·:~~2t1w Co.,_ (Rood. S.04"rl.ooo) t'Od.. Vs Afl'iosi ii£~P-~. A«9nt;l (j~). Ji.t~ ,W62) !,At, ,19q~ It hns th.on been l:'ij;'030d by Mr. li.'\l.aba ~.ia.t -'lili<:: ~lit'd fczty Not~G shoul.d be dismiseed wi:fo Qosts. Iil hi.8 rep~, l<~~ ~olo, loat"nod counsel £or. ~o 2nd. Dotondant hM t.WG'U,Od. tha.t tho objoQtions raised by tho A,G. -~ yonooived and t4orcZoro oon~lu. IIa h~G oontond.Gd that all -w.i~t is :i:oqtliJ:Gd ~ the O"i°tCld ord.Gr: o:t tho C,.P.c. is for tho 'Ih~d-l'~"q lTotioo to eta.to tho natttto of tho olo.ima by tho pa:r.tioo in t.'lc mu.t_ ai1d tho r.eliofe tlh~ o~ on~ cl.ai.mt3 1 ~ l i i t.1ta.t tho m=ds ~oo1sol3' or "oonoieo~ u.~d by t:10 loarn~d st~.;o At·~o:r:ncy woro not applioablo to S•1..&1'ii bGOe.t.tat t;J.<; ~~ ~'tr Uotigo doQs not have to ~cpi:odt.100 l-41a.t is ~ the p1l1.i,i\11 neither· ie :I/ii ,:<oqi.,til'Qd. to rox:q:od~o li1a·~ is in the ~ttGn Sto.tc:m1ont of Dotc1100 1 it being tho dtt'liy of t;.io 'l!lud. fartv" 1o look tor and obtain oopics o:? plaint O,t'ld 'tft!itton &t;n:lioaont of Doto%10o ~ order to have l)l'coien fnots to enable him to _tile o.-1 ~o:ttt'i• det.c1100, Ji?,:·• l~ol.o hn,e it-c:·~hcr nxgncd tho.;c J29::t:'.Liu .Cf! tho ~ird P~ty Rot~G l~iofa t11;0 Plaint~"'Zi :3 ol~im against th<J ])c:tondant{e) join~ 81\d the roliei'e claimed by the PJ.aintif:f'1 the-roby a..'\t.~ tho ~-Gqw.tG!lan.t,i unilc:x: ~ (~'J.5. ,W of the C.,P.a,. Likov.i.so, ho has. olao aontondcd that - ~ of tho •~il.'d Pc:o:v Notioo <EtI>l.aille tho ~ l\<it~nd.P,nt 1 e olai.m 8€$8"..__-~:i.o A.G. 1 1iuDh 1s imemni.,iW and. that tho A, a:. 1 a aote tdiioh giJn oaus ~ ~tion to tho . . 2nd Defendant- have:; boon. iltd:i.oatcd thoroin, thGX'cb:r s.X-dqfying the J<G(l'liroaonts 'J! £J-Liilbl of tho c.P.c. Ao ~g~ .the ..GhiJ:d PO-int of tho objGotion, 5.t ~M boen oonton.4ed by tho ~oDnG<l oounsol for -~he ~ Defcndent 1 th~·& in ~L(g), of th.a Tlu.:i:d Fc4W Notioc, JlillCi :ccliofe oL.'"limod by tho ~l't l)ot4214a.nt against th.o A. G♦- h4!1G beon s-tntGd1 bointr ind.<imhity by tho A.G. to tho 2nd. llofcndi.\nt of tho a~t• alaiL1 ~ainst tb.e 2nd. Dcfondant ~d. ooats ot; i, 'tho suit, so that the, 1'0(!l1.U'Cr:tOnt of 0,.1 R.1i:,W oz t11.o c.• P.o .. ha-vu also beon ful.17 aompliod uH:i. At! ~cgnrda tho atrii~.lo~i·~y of tho Ugonclan oaac of ·ovarsoae T;=inG Co, (no·nc1 (&nio.os) M;cl.. o.itcd by the lo~ned S·~t\"~c Attorney, it 19' tho &WJniissi.on by ooui1sol tor the 2nd DcfGnd.ont ~1ct tho oasc hae no %.t!l(;Vo.nc)O. to the frotr.i oi' -~1is on.so, in that Jlihc ism.'l.o thGl'c was ltlot11~ '. , .11111111 ·- 3 a.t the olosure of the Plailr'viff'' s oase the evidenoe 0~1 .recOTd was suoh that -'~e iilii:rd p ~ had any oase to ~ewer.. I-'.; _l1as ftll'ther boon a.t'~d ·on this point tlta.t if ·l.!.10 A. a. had found the tota.li·!;y of the claim and . ~-elief'_s stated in the i:B.1:ird Party Notice to be inadequate rmich ho1~sr, is OQnsid.Grcd by the le_a=cnad counsel to be not. tllo oaso, then he should hc:Wo a,pplied. for ~tl~.c:r- and bet-'.;or· particulars of ,.,lilie claim. ~.,~ 11aa been finally sub.1115:ttod for the 2nd Dofcnd.c.·v:l"', ·tha.t einoe tho 'lhi;d P~ty has not filccl a defence to the Pla.ilT~l.:l.'>fi a olaim as requhted ...... undfll'•9,.,_,1,·RelZ of tho C,P,C., then he is to be tal:c11 to have admit-'.;od the claim~ a.nd tho:refo:rc ;juc![;ncnt should be entered tor the 2nd. Dofcmdant in aaoo:rdcinoo with the provi:ti.011s of Q..,,1 R~ 19{ 1){.§2, of t:ie C,P aC •, fo1' tho :ttel.iofs pt'ai;red by the 2r:.d Dc:.?c:.:u.r,rr'G ns well as 12.to Plain·~i£f'1 and tha.t tho prolimi11ary obJoo·~io:10 by tho Third Party sh.ottld be dismissed rd.th costs. Ih l'Oply, l'fr. I::-.l2~J2. for t:.10 A.G. has maintai11od that the words unde:r -.Q.,~1.·A~l?(a~· ~~.tL1tl o1 ·~hs c.P.c. cannot 1)c c;ivc11 wy other meaniJls than. tho nature of -t:,.c· f'no·~s to 'bo stated dlould bo ·which a:t'o snough or suffioiont to on..."1.blG -'~:.,.o 1l1l1:i.rct Pa:rty to reply to tho ol.aim by eithor admi t-'li~\! or doeyil1g o:r pn.r.,i;ly a.drlli tting or pa;rtzy dc11Yingj llddil:ig that . . . liha.t. 1'1e . Thi:rd Pn:rty is m.tpposod to do aftcr· roooi'V~ . . Tb.:ir.d Party Notice is to mal~G a rapl,y to au.ch Third Por.ty NoticoJ ·!~o lias no dllty ·l;o soa1;0h fo'l: tho plaint or i'rittcm Statement of Defence, so tha,-'ii tho Third P;:,;rty lfo-'li1oo in qUGstion did no·~ moet such test. On the oa.sc oi-'iiod Mr, J:fulaba has maintained ·~ha-'i. · though learned counsel for tho 2nd Dofc11d..1n-'.; sought to distil'lguiall i t 1 -'.;he case fits exao-'.;:cy in the r:.rgwncn-'.; uo :1ad ad.Vroiocd, oontendillC' ·b!lat tho Principlo la.id by su.oh caso boillG .,li~.1n·~ for thG Third Party -'i;o bo hold liable fu.Gl!e should be ost.J.blishGd 0011ncotio11 between tho Pla:iJ1·~itf 1 s claim against . . the Do:toadant and the Dofcmdn.nt' s claim against -'lt10 Third Party; which the Th:ixd Pa:rt;y lfotioo ia quo i:rcio11 had not even a·acmp"ued · to do. It is ru::o the ['.J'.'fst'.f.lc11t of lii:r" Malabn. il1 rcpl,7 Jchn;I; while appli- cation for i'ur·~1or nncl bo·~-'.;cr pC'.J.'-'.;:Lcula:rs, ic for non-:-mibetantivc issuos, :f.ailt1l'o ·~o di:'::closo -'Ghr. nL':~·-'.l'o of t).~c claim is tonto.r,1<JJ.11t to fnilu:ro to disclose; a ODUsc of notion and fnilv.rc, to disoloac onusc of notion has a.lweys been good rcmso11 :?or dismissal of plcr.di11Gs1 F;i..'llally 011 the )?l'c\Yor for. tl1c 2nd Defond..--.nt -'ii~.1a:'.; upon failure of tl10 !Ih~d. PoJ:"vY to file 1fdJ.;tc11 Sta.tomont of Dcfenoo, · judJLcnt should be entGl'od ':tor the 2nd Def c11du.1.1·h, is tho eubmisaim1 of· Lt, Malaba. that suoh lfr:itt·ei1. ~a.tomont of Dofo1100 hod alrGady boon filcd.t and I think he is :igh.t. . 011 iihie, ' , - . 4 llaving hoard roµro0cn 1~nti.ons c..s a.dva.nood 011 6ot.h sides, this OOttt'-tr s journo;r i11. sca.-rch of jt-i.s<::~oG mu.st, of naoosei-'liy s-'v1:1Xt 1-rith the a::mmi11a-'don of tllc l'clovant provisionu of the C.P.c. In tho first plapo ,tr:. start with tho. provisions oi' .o,,1 ~ tha relevant p~aguaph~ for 0-.. oaso,. being parns .(~)0~)_:_~~ci. Col~ Tllcsc 1 : .- I p:ttocood to qUOtc in -~cnso, thoy provide thus: ~1l_s 15 ~ l}vozy third party notioo shall stf.l,tc - - (o.) t:1.c no.tl.u'c of the plai.lr~i.ff 1 a oasc ~ - tho d.GfondantJ (1,} t::i.o no.-mo of tho d.ofcnda,rtli1 s claim _ Dgm.nst tho Third. PaTtyJ {o) _f t1).o z-c lief e claimed by . lc d.o:cclld.a.nt agailts·h tho Third Pa.1:ty1"' At t!tia junctui:o le·~· it bG pointed out th,d; o. Z1ird Pnrty lfotioc is for: all pr:aotioal pu:rposca1 a form of a. olo.im by the d.ci'ondant institutod tho snma aga:i.nst tho t::..ucl party, for tho ~oliofs _oot'!G'ht. As tho d.Gfcmd.wi;t a Qla.:w. ~ro.nsii t.lio 'ntl:rc: P~·hy lir.l@)s on. the na·h:ira oi' tho claim of -'liho plaintiff ogainst the c1ci'c:1cbnt, it is, for u fo.:i.r and just adjudie.a-'don of . . tha dispti.-'tio impc:rn.tivo ·r12.-'li ·the third paTty should ho suppliad with sufii- . o:i,ont fao-ts as to mal:o I1im ln10w adequately tho 1w:~i~o of the claim D.S -'oo bG in a position to propn'.t'q a J.):t'opor Md Gd.oqu..:d;o dcfonoo, Tho nocd for euoh sui'1ioio:it i'aPts ·fo Gnnblo -'i;ho third party idont:u."y tJ.1c 110.:tu:rc of tho alaia oamos to tho fore 'l·dlan ono roads R.ulo_u of .9.t..1. of the c.P.C, that lh.ilc p:t'ovidcs ro'ld I qL'lOtot tlffllo.:ro a t:.d.:rd pal'ty notice has been acrvad on tho third p~-'~ tho third party ahaU,· .M: ¥ wisho::, to . . . . ... . !q .,c\i~t.~.<GJlo. pj,antifft e claim l.ll;~!:.o__.~i;:~ §!eainst ~ho !1ofo.Ada:1t. 1?;£0scnting the ~hii:c\.P...~~~no•ticc or:- his own lio.l)ility to tho d.Gfond2J1t w:i.-'i;hin twenty oi'l.Q dcys of ·the sex.vice of tho 'lbi:rd Pcll'-'i;y notice ur.,on him .............. prGsont to -'i;ho ooc:r'li a. 'Writtcn \ ' Stu·iic.raG1r'i. o-Z Dcfa110c. u (Einpb.o,sie suppliGd,.) C.learly t:·it Third poxty Cc'.:."1.not :rcn.sonab].y dispu-'ljc both the pla.i.11.tifft s Claim to - '.b!ic c.1.efo.n~l.::.ri; . n.nd :1.is lio.bilit~, to tho dofcmdr-.:.rt unloss n.1.1d untill hv has bGGl1 cCYailcC:. o:: mifi'icicnt facts ·~hn:t olc:.!l'l;y' disclose tho nature ot the pla,il'itiff•: ~ olnin_ to ·t,,'..10 dGfcncl.air~ a.11cl t::i.0 basis of his licl:lility to fuc dof011.da11t c..s clainod i.'1 the Th:i.rtl Poxt:· Wotico. ~ho qua.ritum of m.1.c:1. infOl'mo.tion can also 1:io- t,'-1.l\,"'G<I from the pro~sion -Of ~Vl-&.L O::r t.:110 .c,p'~·c .• -riiich provides and I qi.to·~o& , \ r_ _) - 5 - ~oadint' shall moan a. plaint or o. lll?it-'i;;m1 statement of DofG1100 5st1.0,l~ a. tfritt,<m S~n.t(lf10.n..-:;. at, D_afcmoo filod by o. 1l:,.1:i.rd Ptirty and such o-'lih<r.c subsoquont plaooings M f:k'\Y bo prosantcd i11 aoco:t'd..1.1100 with rul.Q 1'3, o. VIII, tt (F,mphasis supp;t~d), It is in euoh 001rto;.,-b of tho law that I nou p;.oooed to ~ tho oonto11t of t::ia th:i.'.t'd :p.:'.l'·~y notico, _scr.vod upon ·i.:l.g A_,G., and. -the tetu:~ · sontn.-tioits ma.do bci'o:ro_ -'c1:lis oottr-'i;; in respect oi' ·tho p:i:ol.imina;ey objaot~ons 1tc,:j.acd by the A.G. In JWea (§l), of t:.:.c ·l;~::ixd pe.l''t'IJ notico it is -'oho:rc statod a.e fo~o'tf.QC ttTako notice t:::.o:~ this action_ has 1)0011 brought by tho ' plain:ti:r-1 necinst tho def and.ante join:bly sooldng a. doolctro:Hon thnt tho rovocation o-Z tlio -plaintiff's right of oocupru;ioy by tho P.rosidGn-'i; is impropar. in law thcrcfoI'G void and tor damages and oosta .• u T'Ao qu.astion. t!~at i'oUows hero is rih.eth.ox that docs really rofle;t mte-Zioiont:l,y tho nu;ttWc oi' -'uho plaintiff's ' claim ~r.iitat t.'1-io 2nd defGl\dani• . .... ' · ~ 'Do bo o.blo to ~opa:-cly ns oc.rtain tha.t onG has. "bo ~-iwn to the plaintif:e• s plaint Md soG ·what_ is tho 0011'1.,~o of tho Platntitt 11:5' Gaao against tho 2nd . . . . .. . . . ' ~ Dofondo.ii-'~. That .is set Ot\°~ Oloa:t'l_y in WPrlal Ji¥\ 1). :hha pa,in:t EJ j,ch _state· l"l:lld. I quo;ss °1- 'Ille gcoond do:f'cud.ant has to dato nnd inspito of ro~n.-'i;ocl requests, fa.ilod to :.1a1\d ovor to tho. pln:i.11:l;iff vs.H·i,nt . . poseoseion ot .1;:10 osta.toa , a.fora-. sn.id ;:i.11.d. tho plcin~iff ola.ims f:tiara th.c socond doi'o11fu'.11-'c; s].'.)Goific p9rtormanoo o't -'!ilia saiµ. agroo-:- nont fol' snlo. 1J. Th.r::i/11 duo ·~o tlio notions ond omissions of tho 1st and. 2nc.l 2nd Dc;fondants -'GhG Plt\il:r'vii'f ha:t eu:f:f'~Gd. loes ca foll_o1-m (listed und.or SLtb. pixrs (a) to (o)).,ll • lib.~~ the plainti:tf preys for tho judgr.iont and dco~co fore- ('~) A. dcclc.:ration thnt tho rovooa.tiall. of ·l:iho pL.,,intifft s rigr.t · of OOCU'PaJlOY' HWJ- imiu'opor in lnw and in f.oot Md thorcfa:ra, ~ l and ·voici._ (b) Spooifio po:i:to~1:1nnoG of the 2nd Dofcndc.nt lee.ding to dclive;tty of vacant pass-coGion of tho Gomba Mtiw:iga. os"'iiatos a.a d.Glivery ao o.onta.inod in 1i:1a Doocl o~ TransfCl' ..u1.d. compensation by tho 1et Defcmd,.,·,n-'c; f'o:t' or,y assets romovad or ilGlllpGXod w.i. th after • the i;x['J1sfa 01' -'Gho Right of OocupallQY.-- ln tho altanativo awl- ,n:'.;:,,,out pr.ojudico (n) Sltlllinga 2,206 1 039.15 86.~et tho 2nd Dofc11d,-u1t, boixlg' oost of tho est ;:d;c s 1 DJ.td. ......{6. - 6 - {b) Shillings 06~532,145.00 against "lihG 1s-~ t'l1d. 2nd Daf'cndnnts, bd.ng trn.~:i.14\i aocommodation, log4 fooa ~nsos and loss of' LiOono, (as itonizod horoin)j plus inter.est and other· oosts. :t F.r;,om tho abO'Vo s-'G,;~~;:im.r~ of the cl....-u.m lJy ·f.:i.o plaintiff against tho 2nd Dof'cmd211t it is cvit:.Cl:.·~ tha.·~ wh.:..t has boc11 s-'lia"bod in n~a. (tiJ o:f the third pc.xty notice cc::vc-c"'.. 1.1po:1 ·li:10 11.G. docs no·t u-t. £1.11 properly N'ld. olooxly .reflect tho nr.i-:;,_1.ra of Jii:.,c plci11ti:ff' s ol,.ill O[tninst tho 2nd. Do:f'o11'1.·•.1x'c a.s to 0112,1J:i.a -::;:1c ·:;:.1ud pc:rty na.l:c r., ].)Topor nnd odGquatc; dGf'c1100 to Gl!Ch t::ird pn:rty :1<rcioo, FI.U'·~ormorc, 1ii:ilo ~ds 001.:i.rt wuld hc,.Vo been 1:>.repnr:od to fil'ld. tho sta;'aoo011~ in ,,2ara (ql o-Z -t:.10 t~d.l'd p8l'ty notioc -~o nclcquatGly :rcf'lcct on tho nattwo of' thG 2r.ul dci'cnicla.nt ts claim ag-ailtS"t -'lilrn t:1:i.t'd party, tho sto.tcuo11·~ ~ na:ra (pJ. of suoh third party notioc ns to tho reliefs cle.imGd. agai.11.at ·l;hc third pnrJizy- ia -'ooo goncral aa to oal:o i•t di.i.Aficult fo:r:i- tho third pt\t'ty to ma.Im out tma.·~ .roliof s · and of w.1a·'.; nnou·rua.o he would be :r:o~od to indotll"lily hi.':11 so as to cnalJlo tho J~1irc1. p ~ mclco a J.)l.'OPGl' and adoquAto dofcnco in rcrpaot of tho same,. Fox all 1-ihat has boon s-tatod · in para ( Q) of tho t:.d.rd party !lotico runs as f.ollowsi (o) The :reliefs clciL1od by the sooond dei'ond.an-'i; a€ainst you is for Ld,.cnnity 1Jy you to tho sooond d.Gfcu'ld.ont of tho plcintifft s olain e;.:cl costs of t:io OPtion." ~1n:li, in :.~' vic.;1 woi.iJ.<.l l1nvc becit aocqrha1Jlc had ·b~1cr:o boon stlf:f'ioicnt inf'or1:ic.1;~ion rolatine ·~o t:-.a nc:i.tt'.I'c 'of ~1c plain:bi:i:"1'·' s oln,it1 agronst tho 2l1d. &tcnd...1.1.l't. l:J riglr~l~l conkmlccl 1Jy the lco.t'ncd stri,fo fdtto.r11oy this collt't is net p:L'oporcd -Lo ncccp·b t:ic n;rg,.1r.1cnt by tho loro:intd oom1scrfi for:· tho 2nd. Dof.c11Ck""'llt -'li.!1r;~ it is. -'cl:c c1L!-ty of the third pa:rt: upon boin:B' served uith 1, third p~·zy notice to h1,U1t for· rul tho ro lcvnnt ij,u'ornn.tion to a....'·(H,rto.in o; dinoov~. tb.o :real 11a-'1i'JXO of tho cbim by the plnintli';f agailtst -'c~1c 2nd clof ondan.t J tl).c un;'i;v.ro o:Z ·rio cl.nim n.nd r.eliaf dla.imod by the 2nd au.O~.i.u.c.'1.11.'ti _,e,, _..,_ ' • clgn.ll1S t thC ..i.·V.:lll • d pa:P J.-., 11.y ot Lil00 J.n w.1.0l' o.l DJ.O, • 1:12\Y OJ• . W.10 du""""' .1.• ,UJ to su.pply such info:rmn.tion mtl'fioiont to GnablG tho t:.d.l'c1. pt:ll':ty propGJ:Jy prcpa.,:o tho dcfcnoG 'thor.oof, rosta squa.Gly u1,xm "lil:o d.G:f'o1tdant il1stituting tho tll.ir.d p~ty no t~o • h rsg~ds thG au:li:.10:d".;y ciJ~cd by tho loti.r11.Qd :r'.;nte .Attorney in suppori of his objoction, with rc2i1oot I do not think i-'t,; hns ~iy boaring on his a.t'guoc11.·~ t:12.t for t:10 ·::>.il'C.. pc::l'ty to be held _liable ·lf!.ico s.."1ould bo o.etablishcc1 cio1mcc·Hon 1Jo·~~;can the pL.c--dnti:i.-'f' El olc.im 0c:s1.tinat tho Dofendnnt · and tb.G Dd'crulc:-..n-ti s clc',it1 o.c;cinst tho third pt\!'t,~. Appa:ront~, tho dooision in thc;·.·ovc:r.soas ·I'our:i.l".(; Co, (Rand P.crviccrn) Ltd. oi·~od abovo by- :tvh!, MnJ.aba, oorri.'Jrod ~11 the is::uc 1-i:o·~>.c:i:- 1-rl:1,c:rc there nrc noxc -'li:.!.D.1-1. one dofcnd.n.nts n. f.ind.inc of no case to 2.noor in :t'cepaot of one o:Z ·tJ:c dofcnc1.'1.llts a.t the oloao - 7 - I • of tho plnintiff' e ca.so· 1tou.ld 01r'dlc tb.e dofcnd..1.nt ,rl:'G!.1 no oa.so to anm·ror to bo dieehar:g-Gd o~ dismissed fl!Om the suit. As to th.Cl pra;v-Gl': 1Jy ·i;110 looi'nad counsel f o~ ·tfio 2nd dofcndant th.1.t ju.d.u~ont. ·should bo 01~torod ~ s 1 ; the A. d. .011 fUVO\U' of tho 2nd de:011do.11-'.; n.s. pr:eyod :f'or: tho alleged fail:u.;r:o to :tile 1-T, S,D4 J ns i:.ig:htJ.y t;BUOd by 1~, Malt\ba i-'G is to bo noted. that in f~t t\ ~itum state,. mon-'o of Dofcnoo has been filed by tho A.O, mtd ill suob. tf.Ltitton. Sto.te. mont of l)ofonoo that -'i;ho ~climinory point' of obj_oo•~:i.on t'irBUGd before this Ool!rt by Mr. I>icw.1Ja, is -'oo be found ns the .fit'.'tt'J i b among. issu.ca •· ·:1 :t>c.:l.sea. M' tho above 1°oc.aoaa tl::.is oou:rt gr£1nts -'aho· ]Xt"Olil:ti.nary objoation. r!lif!Gcl by ,the A.G, n:i1d rule ·t:.;.nt t!:c thir·d po:rty no·aoo by -'liho 2nd. def'.ond.c.1J1-'G has failccL ·to d.isolosc suff'ioicmtl;y -'li.110 n..1.-'4il.WG of tho cl.aim by .tho ploJ.11.tiff necil1s"', ·tf.1c 2l'lC1. Dof anda.nt a.nd. -'liJ.lG roliof s olaioGd by tho 2l'lc1. doi'onctant r,gninst ·bhc A, G. as n. third J.Jr'X··:.Y, I· thc;r-ofor.o dism5.se the 21'.I.Cl. cl0.fend.Dnt 1·s third l)~~l;y notioo agp.insi; -~lJ.C A,G., with ooete, I cjr/µkl'J · R. I,llfA~ .. llolivcrad thio 1st c1.,,zr of December, 1994, c.t Dt'-1: os Salaam in tho p,:cso110c of' Mr. !Cal'olo fol:' the 2nd DGfcmdant, '•· .. hold.il1g b:riof. for' ~s,· l~ja.for Fl.o.il1.·~itf ""." l~. l{o.sh~.f.0% fst llei~t. JUDGE· ~-·~_......., 1/12/1994 .......,.._ Ordcr1 llcrn.r.iJlg of r1tdn m.ui adjourned...