19940121 TZHC Dar es Salaam

Di TI.IE r.:rcr.: CCTffi}i! 0]" T.Al'ir·JJUA ....... ·-- 1-.::..1 :0;.;.1 ES SALAAM Cb.UGL.~.'1.1 JOlUSOIC-'I'ION CRilWi'AL m;;:;r;rG,:TS CASE NQ. 2,5 01:1 l$i'.JD REFUBLIC VOJ:'Sl.ts SiuJ1EE J1JMA. 1 I .._ ·ll.e accuaoc.l s".;o.1"ld!; 0~5Qd. = AU in:te,:mA"JLPn c.:t .aur£1G.~~.:izi to ;,-.::ICO'~i-011 196 o:Z t· .o Pcital Coda, and he ~ul,a plc~CL 1u,·~ c;-t?iU,,:r :fie..::;;~ ~ff~ ~o :loll0i·l'11'i.g· a'.Ce the ~,1a·~·~c~::; uo·l; in diapu-'liQ. ill -'iJ.s ~ ~ Geo:a13a Thomas is (°Lo~ ~ ITis c.7.aa:~h m.1s 110·~ c. na:)1.1.l'uJ. on0c It ll'cl4 cllJ.C 'tQ. ~td.u..in~ ~ 'J!J.o o:; ouood la1m, •lf ~a u.ocoa.so~ ~ 1.L!to docoasocl diocl on 27/12/Sfi _ ~ 'l'.o oontonts of ·r,.o o:;:o·t~1 plan pi:oparecl ~ 23/12/05 by ~-ii~vo SQJ1C'Oa.u.t MJ.1a~ur,~ \ 6e i:i!.10 oontc:i.'lts of •i;.::.a pos·:; m~iiam :rcpor·~ ~er,~,ed ~r ~ ~ o ~-~Ol' a::runininc; ·i;.\c t7.oo'oazod ta body~ T;.i.o oviclciwc ndclr:.oocl tl.::wtc :D:or!l -'~ro p:i:00001~0ll ~r.i.:~ssos ano. ·:;JJ.o ll.00t"U:1ccl ~av-a a sworn ::f.;.:i;~oi'.1C11"b in his dofc11cet E~~ Myanililm Ptll as.id "lfaa·:; oil 'Zf/12/SG l10 1::.oa"JJd noise a:l; aroru:d 4c: ~O ~me Re uai.1-b ~o li.1czc ·il.\c uoiso was ooai11c; 1:rom and found Gooxc;o ~Jcil1g beaten '.l=e7 t.:l.o ' ' . ru:>Cl.:~0t: 11:io;-;1 ho immr :.iy "l>:'.!c :;iruiio of .MA.13.eJTGTI. ~~ uas on ·i;ho 13Tot:.:.ld- ~1d -~7.Lc aocL1acd 1-1as boa:~i::.1c· liim with e. stick o..::;ou:~ 4 :n on long,.,.;;;. a,.'1<1 fl' t-1 Jii.1tl.0::.1essc llic atJCL\.OC•.l oven usod a. fold.il1{; <>--'•t:fr ·~c. beat ".;ho doooo.:::od tt;t J1.f10 :.~o..1d1 . oar and uo;.d;.\~ M waa unable to o·~op -~JJ.o bcati.i.1c; as tho · \ · aoor.acd uas qui -~o violo..r'i; D.11.C.l was Jlil.'.l.rca:~ohillG PlTJ:,' 'J!.~Cl:oto:t"o PHI ac:r~ fox PtT2 l'i.a#JladJiam. Por-L, l'tJ2 oc..u1a- -'~o -'li..li.C ~c•tc o;,16. otiex pcgple a,:-.ma -'Gho:ro a;.:·:.o:r Pi-1'2 had o;;;~i·. cd.c Tho accu.sod. "ml-S -~:.to,.1 ex::01:r~ocL and ta::on -'Go -:;::;,,e OCH office o.ncl. .::.0~100:::'o:ctll -'i;o ·tho Polioo ~-~c;~ic..7c Aoo~:1.G to Ptfl t1.:.c oocuscd oppc~o~l ~o. :1~va tw..cn ecr.ma liqt.1~ PUI know f.~c deacaaod Ooo:reo to be ot~:~'~i~ trout Jl.0%nia- ,i:.lAl ~.Jl!Q,,f,,.!J~ra. ~ l e ci·;;:.:Cl" to xv~1 or dofcnd hiracoLJq Pi-T2 Ramadha.ni P~i oo.n:~irmod t:ia.-~ ~ J'Qi.Ulc,,1i:i;.1 iT.i.s sent to 1Ji:.:.1 'by P.·rI lll.ld ·~..ds :rou·th -'liolcl :um tha;~ ~lche was fiG'-:.•::inl ltith GQa.t'B'Ot 1n,on ll.o rscro to -~ accno., PU2 totmA Sol.cll.D s~"l.lld.:i.lli,1 ,~·:.:.>. :~i.e. ,l"ii5.•lc i,i\ .:U.a 2- h(U.!dsi: Sal.oho told PU2 1 ~i.c -'i;;_1ici' is hexes n poi11.-:;i:1G t1:t Geo:ce,-c -Oll -'i..ilo .~otu-ul~ Plf2 I,1w.12{.·oc".. -~a r,:ttab SaJ.cl10 hom b~ucl a:ud, wim -~ !l..cil.;.:- . o:: -;r:.c l)Coplo aroundt fJ!l..lo2.10 was tioc1- up am:. ,,1ili·~fo..,1<L1 sont loJ;, rt.lo . tu cle1once -'(1c o.ooi.::..:i<1d ~ Jt1u1a. saic..l Oll. oe·:;:.~. ·tia~ on 2T/s2ivo ho v::i,c 0,1 :.us 1fcli;, -~o a nt·o:,ia dn4coc :Bu·t clt1.c -'.;o -~:.w ,,10:,f:.i liquox 1r.':.i.0:.1. ~.lo ;.i.w:.l -~D,'..;:011, l:to ltii,~ LLou;.1 ~lCl slcp-i; S()I.Ultlly :?o~ m.i~-0 4,. .b.04.trac lr-.aa .":o ~ l.1.1.) a.·~ a:,: ou.nd 4· p~ _;~ >.o :Zouncl his sb.oc,;1, m1:~c~~ arnl ~600}. 1.ti.r.::-1il1.£;" · -i,.,, • • r.,,. . . ,..-4..,,., • ' , • • d ., . ;i..i,:Q;,l .:.-~ ~60Ik l!l<lll1 e.a .. :,c UO-S g .........,e uac.u: .,_;.or.ie,. .:.J.Q -~~ 'w.!.e, ~ f:tf 1>-iflia:.:',. :lill.iof~ tt r:o oauld esoo people oomi..1c or-.-~ o:Z -~:::..oix h ~ ~-~oo:.:.:i.113 Goor:10 nJ.:.o wac .-t:-1.0 -~hiofc· Tie sc..11-, -~:-~c o:- oo::i 1r;.ti.cb. Goorc,-o , ~ ~~~;>c Zi.o:r lookod 11:..:0 ·~hose of -'cl.lo accL\cci:.l i(,.ic:, :1a;:l ~i~~ mt. :bJ.lq.rod uptc, u4oxc (l)oxG"Q hru:t :z:u.n wailc bcillc; -e:.i~od by tll.'l lilo~ IIe t01.u.1c.l Oooxeo on t:10 [;TOi.Uld.t: Gcoxe;o hod bocl'l -;Jo"':~on 'bJ' the JnC'q.. y.litA · ~ :..~.1.'--0'iil ;r:Li~~ i:clw aoo;.:soc1 oould soa -~Jw:~ -;;:~a ::i;woa and -'cii1c tt,:1;~e:1 u.u.o:, Goore;-o had on Li:.i 11cx o o:Z tb.o M-<Htsock ~ l . · ~ ~ . , . ~l,;l.i.ncd. ·to -~.,.c uo1J• t.::ia.t Gooxe;·o .".:.aiL<.J.is pxoport~; -aml J~.c ~Ta11·~~cl. ·i;o tet.k,e ·l;;..,~i,1 :Z':rom ~c;oc 'E.i.a·t is uJ.1011 ·;;.\c people around ·boo).:: ·i;:.io Mu:ood to t1lc OOH ~Zio~ ancl ·l;.'.,e11 -~o -~ho Police S·~.:i:ao11c ll1 c.::coss-:-a=::runimi:~io;1 t;J.o nocuscd cloniou. t1:33QJ.ll•;;~1g ~e d.Qae~~- I!o acJ..i.cl -~ha:~ both wi "i.'.acc:3cs ·vrere J.Jring tll!:a.i11a,-~ ; 1.i,wi: rte ~uld n<rl rel:1o;;1~JO'.i.:, _:10 ·said, 1-uoJ.;.•.:.or ho Sall PW2 Ni.1.orn Le :.:.1Ci-r; o:,.1cl 1,rlJ.c·l;hex .:.c : :as:1. a :;rao~.:, 1Jt1,.·;; tl1a;;; H 1-m.s -~:.\o ,i101J wllic.:.1 ·boc:i:b -;;12.c clcooaaodo ot -;;:.:o :1l'Of:lOOU·~io;.1 as -~o \T. \~1\i -~ook plncc 011 -~_::.~~. ~ de.\/~ Uta.I SLtii1::tl:1c: llp to -~b.c -u;:;scsao:ts, all o:: ·;;."\0'-'1 ad:visccl ·that t>.c aoc,:ocd. '1-ras not e,i.1.il -~~/, 1Jcon.t1.nc '..10 did no·~ asm1:..'.l·0 -~:ic deceased at nlle Z.1c:~ Ci.id no-'li D.Qcoi,·~ ·:.110 1 -•vic.lcmcc o:c Pt'TI u\o v~ -~:.:?.c only oYe 'Wi"'lillcs:::; .,i.o •:..::1.c O:dJ"il~ '2'.is co.se s·cancl::i <>=C" lD..lls. on ·mo oviJ..cnco of Pr[l Ezcld.01 H~~lrac I hav~ :,en.I'd aud- aacu :)o•:;_·_1 -~~1a wi"l;J:iossos .!ulcl ·~:tc ~cn~ecl &;ivo <rviclci~ I ;.,ave 11.0 do1.1.1yl; t:~a-~ PiTI ia -'lil.'tr;.J.11·u.k ff~:i;.h. :re.a,;,._:,~-~ -~o ·'1.1.0 am.::om:.o~~, I do n~.; cll,'".l:Oc ·tha·c PHI vz.s l}il1c; j_n a1w w~' as : :o : '.acl no oa.1.1.So to (lo w-,Q I1 •:;he clocca.ood had been 1Joa·Go!l by a mob it uo~,J.c.l :,i,;ve ~ oaai4J: ~-or· ptT.[ -;a g~r ~ Indco,l -~·:~c ;,1as.sa£,·o 1-iui.o.b. Pl72 :i:eoeivocl from the :to·,•:~:,. 410.,."1-',; to :.:.ii:.1 by· PllI was -~:.-..n;l; -~ ..:.o £1Ccusod and -"i;;10 doccc,aocl -nie~o in ~1Jatc. 1::iit2 doso.:;~~t he. ~T 0:.1 ~:di , I ~ a.t th.o $0(l,ll0> ;_to;J.CJ.~-- ~-l.a."4l ~u.ild -~ c:n~/3 3 O.OCl'.GQC"'.. i:rtc:,i.1Cl.il13' wi•~:-. a. ,r~io::: :i.J.'l. his >.andsc 'J!10 ovicloncc ot l'il2 e,'l.70rJ oroc;:ellCO to -~.1;:-;:; of PUI in a '.tfaJ':~' ~J.O CJ'vicl.m1c.e ~4h3ll by t::.o ., . ~ . , &Cc L:r..;o<l 1r~a oor:ci:uscc~ £1..;.i:,c oo;,u:t1.Sing, ·i;o sr.;-/ ·i;,;_,c , . - l oa::n;<: . ,-. ft""' ~r,.,.... .,. , _..,.., """~ - -~- .iv r,i'..o::r:;1ol10 by one of -~:1.0 a.orJor.r.;ors 'the nccl1.sccl. ar•ic1 -~\o;~ ;10 did noJli rcac;:;:Jc:i: :wlding a s·~ic:.:c Su:i:cly if tb.c aoct'..scc":. >nc\ ao s·tiok &1c1. :~c cli<l 11.0·;; ta:.i:c part in -:;:,_c ~Jc,·;ci:c1[.; o:2 the dcocr,occl :~o 1rop.lc1 remcr11'box -~:\n:~ .. c :w.d ;.10 :f~icl:.: Lltr·ii 1.crmorc -a.·~ -~:10 ))l'cli,,1i:nar~r)1car.·inc ·Le ace;u.aocl ia .roooxctoc.l. -~'.l :.:.>~c:: :~~ ......:·:...;·~- ·.0: :t of 1a<Y~G of ·;;. . o oc.1at:1 ws. ~a.4 o::-~, ·:~ .:. · . • r-~ io ol(?c..J;' t:rOli1 tl1c [s~Jo·-.;c ~)aoaag·e ·i;J.ia·~ tJ.w ~ct:~ccl ye.,::; a.draj;~·a ..lG to a:~ 10<1,rJ·~ a fi@l"i:i wi•;;.:,_ ·jf ;c c.lccec,ac~ Section 1~ O: •ij'.10 Eilide11cc .U:)~ O,J?J_Xl::i.ts to allow ·;;.:..:.c l,oc o:? a p:roViou.s t:r0·~~,101r~ •t~t ~ e.ccuscd ~-- •~<~b-¢r8.•:ro or 00::.1.J..rad::.oJ.; :us ·t.os"tii11on7~ 1E.:c sc~·~io~i ~cl.es M :. . ' '. '- 11J:n oxdc:i: -~o oo::.:::'o·:J<XC£::~c ·tl1c ·tes·~ililOl'l,:T .c:2 a .1:ci:iincss, . an,y· f'ormc:i: rr~;:;;:;o•. ,r.;1,t, wxi "i;·;;c,n 9r OI'al, 1i1o,clo by rucili. 1rl:tnoss reh~· i11;..,· ·:;o the sa,nc fao·, i':ltl;'.lo ci·:.-~cr a:i; or a,l)oLr~ -iih.c ac;;.10 ·i;:L:1c u;2en Ji;h-p fa.a·~ too:.: 11laoo o:r. baioro (,l.lW w.i.·:;~.,.orit• lee;'&.11~, co1"1poton·~ to i:.1vors~ic,a-,o t.ha f'a.o·t 1 ma,:·· 1JC ~1:covodc n · a.n acc;.:.pcd pc:-cson s·c~rcou ·,;~,ere ,ie acl,•,1i•~s ·~o be -~'-:C il1 a prolimi;i:i.:ir.;,~ ho, :dr1{:; 'bo::?oxc tJ1c nr/:·~c::.:o ,1o;t in c:1.ic.vL·rte axe r,L:·:: clo1ri.1 cU1d signotl :o~ In ·r:.is oasc the i;,ccn::.rcc.".. O,CLd,·~·;;cc1 fic;l1·iti.xl3' -~:io c.lo.o,casccl aJ.bci:'li 1ri·t~ ti:i::-.r~rJ· o~.l? as he uao i)~i;2c; c: :e.i,linorl on uh.at 1ro:a :10·~ in clispL1.-'i;c tl.t.r-inc; -~he pJ:'3liDi~4~~r ~.lOVXill(; ~0;.1clt:o·~~\ lii1.C1Qr ~ r 2 o;Z ·;;J.::,o 0:cimi~ml fr,aoc::~L''J:C ' iG ru.10-:.·:cr Ji~on ri::.;; I ~.av'<! ,ACOep:tcd the e~clcuoc o:t Pl1l ~ t:r.i..~ I trill now· e,·o on -~o oo:isi,3..el' v1l1o·bhc:r t;ll1:/ c:lo:. c21cca ~-~ in ,ti.at . ' tl!.o ncon,•:wcl did as -~hcxc :i.o no doubt ·that ·fac aocr..scd oat1.s.o4. the don::.'.1. ot ·:;:).C docca,socl ~r ~~tl·:.:i.1~ ll.i,mq l\~ Iqirii,- lnr;;i•,~i,:t~ Z0;r! -~i.'..O aocL:.acc1. pLri; fo.rwa:rd ·i;>.c tiL'..GrJ"i;ion of a i'i('}.i-i;c }ic s~ciu. ·i;]ia-'i; "ii1.1cr<? 1ra.s .. 1idt•:: .., _ • 0e"twco11. -:::,c ·- "-~- u,,, ,·,•_r•c~: .., ,-,;_1c.l -::.1__•__,., dnccP.•,--,'c(7 . '""' v " ,,., vl .!.I: -~ .!!.l: o;·.1 • • -~·-lC • • CVJ.C!.Cl1.CO • __ r, t!M.i..:l.'..- in ooc::it i·i; oam1o·i; bo oci(. ·i;.:_wt -~here was a ii.:;":-:;; 1Jc·~1roen th.o acat:aoc1. a;1r1 ·it~o cl.00·0(1.sod.c. FlTI n~c1 ·i;lia:b it was a one 11<.:,;, · -~::a:2:::'ic in t:.:..r:i; t::.c a.oct·..00,7• 1ms boa•;;ing t:..:o cloooascd wl10111 J.10 clcsc~i~.iou. ·i;o P112 as a t:.tlei 0,11Ll u:·.0,,1 PlT2 1~1.cw -~o 1)o a. ·i;:1i c:Zc i].10 acct1.scd o;~ ·:,:--.c pxoliilti.lUU': · hoaxil1g 11011.·;; o.rJ fai: as w:l.mi·;;•;;i11c.; :Zic;.:ri;in{; a-gc:tllis.,i; ·i;.'..10 dcocaoocl ,ri·i;.11 .fi::ri:;3 o~~~ Ho l~cw i':com "'i;ho ovic~c."..oo ·r,::.~.-:; -'iiha:i; is no·~ -~;i;L·.c~ Jk....~ a-'c leas·~ •i;llo .E.CC1.wcc.l <l.(].;:li•li.s 1:>ofl,·!.:i.!1(;' ·:..-:c doccnsod~ 001--1.l.cl.. ·~ .fie.rt 1Ul.¥c ~-~ o~IJ.OJ:.o a.nil PWI 011.J.,;- 20t::1C.l ·i;hc tinal Ef~aecs ,):: ·;;:. ~c :~iG).1·~? T'.:..'.OJ:C .is no ovir":.cnoc -~J.ia;~ ·i;l10 c1.oooc\,3Ccl .J.rul o:tJ;y' 'ff'Cap-Oll.r.: Ol1 -~lie o-'.;hc:r hal.lCl, ·i,.::.o:-cc is oizi<loncc ·;;:'.le.·~ ·:t:-.c o.ccusoo. ~ bco:iii 1~~ =a:'.o. cl.004~ ~ e, s·~ic:..: wul -a- 1oJ.di11,;1 ~ o Ai?;~ 'tLis is no·~ ov:i..<'..c;_wc of ~- tij~ ~10 · o"ii:1.0.r dc1cncc llli.':; tori-ratd was dofonoo ot pxopOl'·cy~ 1fo.s ·:.Iio .aoct;p(l(l d.a:-:.cncl.inc :.·Lio J_)~Op~t,7'? Soo·~ion ~ o:Z ·::.·.w P.011.a.l ~ r,~mu.c:a - J.~-:-(l) S.ubjec-'u ·:;o •:;.\c pxovisions of ·~:.do Codo ovozy pcxson :.~n.a ·0:ic xic;M; --: (b) ·to <.lc:~cncl hi::.1 ~m pI'opa:c·~·· o~ J.<l.'.,~ 1ri;opcx-ty in >.in J.air1nl poss·e,rnio1l, Ol"..::r~oa._:· Ol' ,u'ld.cx his- o~.xc ox -~1.10 pl'opQJ:'·~y of a1.1,:: o·:;>.c:i: pcrso11. El(';ci,10~ rr,:q uult11rful aQ"~ o:Z soiz~~ OJ: do::r:;::!l'.0-~ion o:i: violoitoec I t:.11do:r-s·~Ll.i.1cJ. .,~10 aliovc oi•~od provisions ·to impl:-- ·t:'..a·:; so,;1conQ. i3 -".avi:1(;' his p:ropcxtr .u1el ·i;:. ,-:-:1 ,·; :rY~:.,.c:r person -'Ga.kea i·~ am'-<'.,·· o~ t:d.cs ·i;o dcr.r~:ro:,. i·~ or do aiwt:~dnc; -~o i•i;c ··•-'.:..c own.or of ·~he ptopc::·t·· ~o pc:-cini•~-~et.. ii:" ~ ·l;o s·:;op 't>n c·i:i al'11ti. s ., -~:1c iut:rudOJ: f:r om ·i;.:iJdnc i -~ or <-1.os~ ~yi.11G f;:; or doil~ ~-;:_r-;;:u_J:lG' violcn-t ·i;o i·li<: The facts in -1;~,ia 0.:..130 clo no·i:i -'i;all:,· uH:,. 1rl1n:~ sc0·ao11 t,8A(I)(1)): p:roviclc~ r ,wot'.ld ·t.,_c~c:Zo:ro aa:. ·liha:li -~;,..c c.1,c:;;'cnoc o1 'dc:7cnoc of p:-a:'opo:c•i.7' clocs no·i:; ~a·~· ;1.crc a,.1\J. ir.; ~10·~, av-a-ila.i)].a •:;o ·fio a.cot '..Gede 'i!:1011. ·i;hexo is -~\o c.lc:~oncc o;Z in.,i;ozl.ct1:;;io;.1c r.:a~ (Jg~ I dQ. no·~ -;;Jd:.12.: ·;;:~:.-i:~ sucll dot'CllCc ifJ a,m,ila.blo. 1,0 ·i;;.10 t10ct::..cccJ. i:;.1. view of ·i;:,.c :fr.c·~s 1 i,1 ·:;::ia oa::ic ,. and in vicu: o:Z -~;10 Penal ~ Si:.:g.o ~l.;iict:ioatio11 ua::: qcli i:lC.1t1.co~"':. soo·i:iion l4(~('l.) t.lQOs no".:; apply 9 no:c cloca sco•;;ion l4(2)C-iJ) n~1p)-:;" ~l '!Ji.crir, o::: ·i;ha fac·0;J -~:~a;~ -~:.1.c nccusocl was 110·;; -~cfo1pm:nJ:iJ.ir i1~1e nor -eru.t i-'.; bo sai<.l Ol'l. ·,;to :.:'s.c·::::: -~:,.ci:i:i ·i;hc 0001).GCC.1. c1itl ;1.o·i; :..,:i.101-T w'..10:i; :--.c "\lt,i"J doi1~ •Z,10 acct:.sod cliL'. ;10·~ claim ·i;l.1at noi' is -:.;_::c:.:o o•.ii<.lcncc 'i.o n~<Y!r ·t:1u.·tc Did -;;:•.c i:yi;~1:tion .i;l·~Q:.::2~e n•iili. tll.o tlC<luooc". 'r.. pO'lT-CJ: $o f'ol!m.· 1iio ilri;my;;io'-1 of ,-.1uxcle:r? I (LO ::.10·~ -t;J:d.;11;: so bcc~.l:.,Jc ·r'.c fo,c·;;s clo ;10·~-{t1c;c:;o:::·t _/ t:u).•:; ...,__,,.¼1'.o b·knt -~:.:c aoor:.scd. 'lia.o 60 C..:.:1'.:.L.'- ·as to be illCHl.l)ll,7)1c o-Z :Z'~;:.ti_;,_(.• .,, . to aL::.:c1o:;:- as s·i;zi;~oo. in aco·~iau. 2)'.)0 of ·t.;w PciuJ. Ooclc~ I 1rou.ld so;;· lliJJ:o a.l.-3o t·~at ·i;.;.10 defence o:::' i::.r:;ozioa·cio11 is no·~ cva.ilablc ·~o ·i;ho IJ,OO~et'k L1 .,~10 cop.xsc o1'·ir..=i•~ii-ic;· t.l.us ju.dg.·,10nt I. ."·.t):'•to 1Jccl'.I. -~'..1i1'll.d.lla Q.b.oo."li e.:10-t.:tcX l)Ossiblo do:Zc,mc, 1-u;uncly tl1a,t of p:ro~.roor~•;;io:..: rin view o1 ·Lo f'aots in Jti'.ds oase to -~;10 o::-:: co.,.; t.1:w;;; -the deoeti.lscd m::,s n no·~orious ·~hio:2 i11 ·f_,c a:::oc:i.c: Tho accuscc".. llocs not :cely on •iili.io i1-c.:20110c,s undo:rs·;;__-u.1~· ~ bcoa;.1.r;o :,o was clcr1,.:.1.~.0 M:'JaL~.:t:~ :i;).io d.ocot-,:-:;cc1' Qi -;;:,_e o·i;llCJ: ,\~ ,0-.rj_c~e i3 1.:.JJJ:_:i,iJG 011 how ·i;Lo ncct·:.cccl. came ·~o bo wb.arc :.;.o vas foLu1il. 11i -~J.t -~:.1.c d00<1a.aoc1. b~,. PIJlc I·~ iToi.!,l(l ~)pear t;.ia:h ·~ho o.oo..~<l :.u:.ts-~ .b.avo ~ l -~~ dtiMn30c'\. a,::'·~oJ: Jchc la:~·~o:;;: : ·.ru:l. ~olon f:r-om hjjj1 u.::id -~: :011 ;10 bca:'u 1-lii:1 ~) w.1til :.1.0 aJ.a<,k 1I!l.io ·posi•~:i.on wo\.tlcl be, ·bl1.0,·~ -:.:,.a dao,oa,aed, stolcu. :Z:c.am ·:Uo .a,00 ..:r::ocl D.,.Ul ·hl:1.e C.OeulJcd ~ ~ i . hil'll lWl- oci.ut;l:.d; .;.p _ui·:tl.l. ;_j_Ji1 anc1 bo2,;~ ltln to da2.·;;:.i.c ~10 000L1.soc-:.. ·~r...l:.:r.:1 of fig'..'l:tinc- tl.i.c Llcae~oCi. ill ·the pxdil,ti.;.~ h.o~ au.l J1c ta,Jlm, o:Z sooi::.10; ;.us p:ro'.[)oJ'.':iiy wi·~;L ·~.\c c-10.coasod in .\i3 dofcmco in ooLU''Gc I·~ 3r.:ci:1s ·~o inc t,.w.-~ ·~lJ.o .acot'.f.lcd. ji1P.::r~ 71.aV-O -0:.:.ascd. ·~7.'..o tlJJY~G ~:~isi'y ·i;hc dc:Cini•~io;." of pxavao-a:aon in seo•~ion 202 of -~he l'c.1181 Oode<: P.i:ov-ooa•~ion io cle:2L1ccl i11 scc·t.-1.0:.1 202 o.s :?tll01rsi ..... "T'.uc ·Gcx,,1 'provoo~;~ion 1 means a;ntl i,:.1olndcs, o.,-;:cop-t a.a horcina;Z·~c:,; s·~ocl.1 ~ -w~ongl't-:.1 .c.o·:. ~ insul·~ of SllCD. n :::..1:~l'!.Xc as ·~o be likol;/, ·if.:.c:.1 done ·to M. o:i:dinal7 pc=c 0011, t~ c i: i: cc c. c i.: "c ~ c ,· ~ ·~o clep:r·:t.vc J'.i:.1 a:~ ·i.'.tc po11ci of tloli~c,y:.Xol a.ncl to , indu.cc l1j_a· ·to Co.:.w1i·~ an assaLu·~ o:Z -G;1c. :..:incl w:1ioh 1-flic.h J~o po:i:00"1 o'..ictX[:;Cd eom,,ij/li·~oc\ (:poa -~:-10 ll&'SOlt by whor,1 ·Le ~-~ oo: insuH iG done ox o:2:ZCl'odt 11 I:<r.i:-c :i.:J a no·ho:ri.oL'.S ·i;:..j_c:2' 1ifo :.1.as stolen Jol-:J: bol0:cil1C·s and y·ol,_ 1:r~c Jti.m ni·:;.·~ ·i.::c;;1 a11.d 3'0L'l. G!.u.-.,co :.j_;,1 anc1 ea:tch up 1d·L ::-.:tr.1'- Xon u:i.11 · z:.t clo-.•Jy~ · bo }1eci:~od ttp ·tuld ~1ii;J.i,~ blog-a Oll. him w.l~~ got~d. loru:l. to JJ.is- de.at:~ An Oj!tli:u:w:~r man w0t'.ld p:uobal:ilJ,. do jLts·~ tha·k lT• clo n.o·~ lmov w10·;;.:_,_~ ·i;:10 dccoa.scd pU.,li u.p o.n,r ~eoio·;;.::...1ce ol·~houg.:.i in moe-~ ~~u A thief lfC)n~ Chu,:/ -~J:.c aocttsad cot'.lc1 >.n:iro sup1lliod us wi-~). -~-l.c uo·.;;,;;il::1 of wllµ,~ ;~:)mted p:dor -~o ·[lo a.:rri;-al-Q:Z F1JL Plr.t heard noiso ti::-r:r:; 1Jo2are 110 uent -~ i;:1.0 aoonoc Uc do 110·:; ::.101r 1t.w:i:i kind o:r noi sc i ·t- 'Im~ IJ.1. vicrtt oz ·~o p~-~~ o:Z ovidm:ic.c 0.3:\1, 1i:•1·,l.; ~~ ~~ J:. vill givo t;.ic be;.1.a:Zi'.',j o:Z ·i:;.ho -dou.ll·:.: ·li,o ·::.·,o a.o.cuS£t0. in ~1.u·~ :i.;l.,_is. cl.oub:iii'.i.u ~.Lil.,Cl' µ 6 - I :p:rovoo;:.:·~io:.1 wao o:r ua.u no·~ 3;_1.0: 1 • as to ma'..;:c an o;:d.:L;k...-...;.;;;r ;,1D11 a,c.·~ ·:t~o,/ 1-r-;:,~ -~:ic aPOLlsccl clic1£ I iiill -~]1cic::"oxo :1olc1. ·~_::.r1;:; -;;::c:ro 1ms 1-cgf.l.t i'in.tl t:.ic 2.oo~cc:L c.;uil·~~-- o:: .i:a.nslav.[91·~ L1.11.d0:i: sQO·:.i~1 19.,5, cl -~JJ.C i.i Pc11..:.J. <XJ.O ancl oorivic·~ ::.:Lu a.ocoxdi.1-ig}.yc ~ .._ .. o~:::rJocl~· ··- itr Loxd, !:R-'wi.I::.a:~io;.-µ over 6 2o:;: ~·~~ Mc::rJcd is a iiz.:o·~ ot.~crnle:.:,· :10 :..tas boc11 in Aocused ·;.l.l\S l'~l::lQQ.·U~ ~ .a.a. in r~iao;.-1 people arc ac~,;~ :~ l'Oim!riwtionc I a;:;:.: -~:.w coti.:-:-·t to ta:..:c ~ ilr~o oo:-:.oi<.lcxationc ~ ..7.··- Sru.1•:;onoo, . ~e .accu.aa,d ia ::-i:c ::;t of".2 c11clcr~ "l'NCJ:' ~"'Oa1'' Sc A. B.ililNl'I JUDGE n/1/94i; -I J» BATI.h'.l:I ......... _.... _....,_ .