19951229 TZHC Dar es Salaam

·THE UI\'J.~D n-:-'FUBLIC or TAtlZAlt!A ..,.,_.,_.....................:. ~--·+.........,.._::... ....... ~ .. IN ':'Ii:~ :-IIGH COURT or '.rANZ~ DAR ES s_:\r.,;:,AM DISTR::: C;I' RE4X$'l'R'f. . MA.RY SANTAMBA , • • • • • q • • • • • • MlllDO-"N W''-' 1¥..J..Ji. ,.r.1. OF KI"· l'l!frft'>crrr ,_,nvn \,. • '"',,,..,,.._,JI ,:.L, ·1... O,>j.LJ\.. 4,n PL · -,,;, c· ') "IT'ltf .J••:.· ; ••• • • • t • • 'l'UMELIKE mrtIPO MOOBS )' ·..,__ ' ----- ~hia .u a fttpon-:l •~Pl)~ .,,ill, froat ~h• ~d.sl,..- et I C ~ ' ~ Co~t ..it\' Probe.~~.-~ f.~dtij-lftrE, . :ion H,US& i!t.1J ,!,f, 1!21J. : .,pnn~ng t~e ,;,te:te ~1: ~h•: t,..,, Pn'!ll. ·1 )IOS~S MW~fAt Ith() .... .i'.-~.~t& em~time. in .1979.•. Th, ~ t - , '._ tt~ aurv:t~d b:,'h:i!l wit•:~ 'l'UMAL'J¼E MOSES PHitir-o, and t~• grai,.d(. · ildren, ume1,,1 ~ Mt<SAE?, ; : , , .- . I MARIA MI CHAE?, ~« MOSlS MICHA!J. being t · ·~- children· ot 1'ia einly <ttd.ld, llr. CHARI.ES ML!ro O ANDEMmfUYE Vho_ hf< ,l'ft.detee;se~·1'i.m. It ap:t,t,_ Wat the tleeeMed •s \, '=' ", one 'l'UWJ'.J.;(~: M_•ts FitittlO, iid not be~ 4. ...,. c;hild •,ritl\ the dec,.:aset. At th~ Hme .:)f hie deatlt tlte late PrrILDD MllSES HWAMAN?ETA left t• ·o hew!ei!!t all 1'uilt 1n ~ •• Salaue one of · ,.,hieh i~ lf!a· ,~j· on Iilot No,;;t~/!4B.. s_it ,:.tt• at ••ma:.4 1ula. area, .• vithi!I the eity 'of ~ es Sal~.m. It ts su,:':: hc,u.11e tthieh ie the sub5ilft f this ptoteedinge. .. It is clear froi1,-the ~aeor• c,I t!te q-~&l •fd" 'tha.t upon the ' pa~ at the ·s~id PHILIPO lfOOES ?,n1AH.Ul!ZfA1 "11 t•ttft~atton n9te ' '•• •t•d g/1L19.~ ~Ex!! •.r) vas wt'th!l 'JI ~h• ETevK~ ·lffrttar:, of · , . .t--- .. 1 ?uf:llyo Ward ;,1:'.'" ·5.~ ~~t ea4 aet ~ Couri Mngistrnt._ 'l'-j,a'o. •~• in turn, on the S("'alM dt,.tfJ 9 ~ • Ill te~•ftft•, (Exh. G) 1 ,; •••. /2•. ' / introducing qne ~OBE::-:':1 M'· 1AHANYETl., ~·oung .hrot!i.,~r of· the lo.ta PHILIPO .MOSES MWAMANYE?A, to · ·hoe·;,-:::- \ins c:onc,:c-:1ed, .:th~t the scScl ROB:SRT• th~.t he ,.,rus the Administrci.tor· of tk, es'::n.te of 1;:·.e :l,o.te P'dil.J:ro MOSES i-~JiJ-1AMETA• ,, It is fi'.rther to be nc .;,~ l frOl'.l :.the re~d of the t?-io.l court that fellowing such c;..;o.tb of the E: .id :FRll,U~·JAQ.~tS i!lilliMAN!l'E'rA., Probtlte Moel 1 Administro.tion Cc.use £<?..•..2~-:-?..:f..3..22.t., ~ c ~ ~ • • ·a~ Kin&ndoni Pi-f.mary ~'.p,t• Conseo,uentrial tf~ereto, cash• ?!,;'1.4,§.0 N r,e,~•ed from the NIJC ~7' Kino!idoni Prim.a..ry Court o..e de~)OSit in t'ell:Pett •t sueh Probate o.nd Admini• stration Cause ~~ .•<1...1~• v:t.«,, E~~ ,ff,!! ;-/677669-ef U?/81 1 !at•r, tauyni 'by letter do.bd 12LU.'.1.9~ (:.TI:m.!l\J ''~· P r ~ Cou1"t Magiatttat~· the Manager Jf N.H.t:. "'0.S ·1nr~d thn.t.¥ ROBE_Rr MW~'l'A was the en• 11,. who had be~r, .aPP,P).lited the aue~~-~l.s ~J:JJ:,, tn I¼-ot,at• and AaWatr•"'P Cause ,:~._3-L:_. of ~¥1~ •t t•• eourt~ '.~1:1 ·;$.~o.t· ~t'tle deed in respeet ft house ~:~!a._.l}.C?,t. ~-~·~?4!• ~~P\Yt.n{··?· ·-f~O. !!~:.~1:.ld ho.ve ~• ~•. et , - ~tl3-Aolder <:h~_ge(;_ to -;.1T.,:1J\. lftCHf\;l_t.,. ·W!, :.:c. !.UC!:''·.GL and -MOSES MX~L; \eing th~ ~ ' d ol:'dl~:ru:.~ .•t :th, 4~f.~!f.,.::., the said FHILIPO MOIIIS llWAMAN!E'l'A. On the o:her.- h~.11d, by a tri,.~~~t •e_4 t*il- 4t-11,,-n &1'14 ·••ute~ ~ ;$J.12/_91 be.tween one T~li•!l!.L!KE ICOSES f:'.\\9.t..t,,ife -~~ _y;e late MLXP.9 Mcim HIAAMANYETA and KANIS.". L\ HOR.tVi!fJf.•1,~•P.,t fA!fflAM?A,, USH!Rm WA t C I ~ the subject h•use '-:M 1aoJ..d :;,.n~ :. ~:PJl' .t• the said. ICAMISA lA_ 'MOllAvtANt · .. frOJI! _the _pre:t"isus ;title hold.er,. .. :· .... -'~~~Urt.te•41.Jlf t_f'· eueh d.e•C. tt ~ ene TtMAL~ ~{OSE~ .mw:ro, .t,!;.e ·... . ~il, ;·••4'M t•· ~obo.te , . , A&au. Cause 1!0,31! *of J9?~· o~·.;F;i.~«~:J ·i.J...., 4:.n• au,ls ·t\euee ho.d.'1,een ct•q and rut •l"de:t made "to ho.ve the uaae .ot~ .,_ ,_..., 'title· h:ttldeJ;" ell~.nged end bear• iete_ad~ •fie'M.ttJ~s 1 ,.-ef l'lJKl Mlc:HAWt,, ~i4.JCSCH$.J·ait4 MOSES MICHAELt the crMd.~ildren of tli~ st\if Mif:PO '"°'ti· n , ~ A ~ . Ae.eordi~g ~- tlte ™•2• e~e RAMADHAN I.SSA"MZ8.- ,,-_ JV.2, ... ~---~E-mul the lW.3 1 one MA-~AN t<.IB0NA, it ~:']:)-3MP.S t.\a:t .•uch tsa,l;t l ' U , ' ~ •.--ithout e'Ven the know:l1t."-ge of both the ten-ceU. l.ttl'.ld~•-• the •~• ,gnnd ~•hi1=~en mid MY ethel' •eliltive. ,\nd :the ·:tiU• ;~,~~~ •ttll! t:-1,se• •tJ11· the deeeasf:d, -one ML!m }!OOES Ml•f;it,t\NYE~':~. :it ta -.iem-~· ~11eN(f.v~, thnt ·at the time •t au~h sale the said ·:I.1UiL\L!h.~ lMOSES 'PHILrPO .--:~tt• .,., the said mILiro MOSES MWAMANYETA, i4.i"': mis-rept't:13ent ~h• :19.et• ;t~t sJle ~.U. the one 1-•ith titl& t• . she ·110:d by then auch house t so t::.::.t . ,110 ,oi,,er.. . ,U~se . u: af such house by sale os she did. For. i-t ,_fa ~tuallf .,J;ear th~t. ·tie~ftding to the order •f' Kino:ddo_ni Primr.ry Court :in f'rot;~~e , . , ~lmint.tn:~ion. Cause F'lo• 34 ot 1 , the ti:til•' "t~. it-~· ··-su:~;j&ct hqu's'.'! w•· i.'.1t,\t tr~e!'e·cl to -the joint n,runes D TUMA·f1ICHABL,. ~!,:t{M\·.·,~;tGit\Et.,; •~rd ·JtclllJI .MJjHAEr,•-' ·thJ•·:p~llehildren ef the eaid 1mirro MOSDS ffl-,~it~i. '. S1'.e ••"•t1 ~ \ ifl. 1'a:et,, . ~ . ,th,e.. lt~ltficiary . . ,. ... ' ~ of such ' ~- - 3 .i, . It ,,,r..a then upon r~.-c ~iving c. notice tc quit do.ted §L?/12,~ served upon hnants 9 of "'hom .,,as t!1e o.ppellMt one MARY . S t,~ tho.t concern woe aroused o.bout sueh dispooition. Conaeqµently the Adminil!tro.tor in_P.r-ob~te and Admin. Co.use No.34 ,f 1979 of F'.i".o~dol)t · , . . ~ e ~ ·filed the eutt the eubject of this appeo.1 .;hallenginpr, F;v1,ch so.le .'•C t~e_ subject house on the gi'OUnd thnt it ho.d. been done fro.udule1ttly-,• u tto .ttation hnd been mo.d~ in Probo.te :ind Admit?-, Cctuse !Ss--.34· of ~22• "'~lick ·\-;na t~ken to have been the b ..~l.S ~· f or th8 0.C t;l.0!;. '.:-~.,.7.S,l'.!. · 1 •,)? t's1<3 · sr '.'..u . .',.,.. ,u\A·· TI'-"'·-'-' Pn-,.L-.1.· ._. ·•r~·•y-.:.i.·~;..~,.. !U. PO t 0 ..... sueh <;)'II' 11· house. The s ~id '.':u'NALil'..E i r::: a:.so sa:i. ·:. ·'., < -~•. d~Q4. Ace ordingly- · the o.ppe llant • ee MARY s:.1@IBE. on behO.:.f of one r -~- ··:\': MW&!A~;'.;".ETA sought to be appointed. the _Administra.tor of the r 1:<;o.te of tl'-. lt-.:·.e ffiILIPO MOSES :M\'l!J•1ANYETA, ~ w-epect of the s·1bjeqt h0·1,-o, It t-·-,s., lioi ::Ver. ~oe eontention, for the ~ ..___ t t h e so.ic,. Cua.1:1er · . T"A').t°M-A "f"T),v-~· ;.:.,.-u~.,_.,,_!' .•_.:. ·, ·.:-;..._,_;:,.._ .!,... .•->- ~• . 1· I ••tr;!r•·,· lfiil m••·z. ff.:.•~··r, , ~, tTs•M'-rlIKf , n.u, t.lA KINO~""""',. i ~v ·,,uvn4 t • tho.t such hou.::;~ hd( ·l,a~1 5:~_-.,fuJ.1:• r,.,:-c ~.;:3i,•~. \.- ':i:'h121_ tri0:l ~~_lfi:t ; ~ • -r_... • gnve judgmct ~ ..1· .. ~ .. j.11 to.Tour of the .b.preilc.n~, ·~c!a.r~.j(::> hn~t:&~ 'B~-.le -~~fond void, M4 a~inted the :).P~llAnt ·o.§' the Aiimiru.~t.:-:.ilt·'u~~;,fli1'~·~ho.t the snle had. been CO?'ried out ,,,lfon- ':irtc'·~le 6:n~ ~lin:lut.t'tc·ot:i~ pi,_1,edinge had not bean -,:,ened ruid de term.ihed'. 'hi resp..)o\ e;f the '.':'.1.ibj;1c\ hou!:e. That a.ggrieved t'he Respondent, ruid led them to appe.•.1 ",~ th•. l~··•• tlfpe11...t• eourt~ The l~er ·appell~te c--..urt found for the. :fte~--nt._ tp ~ troua4. thnt there ,,'Nf p-ob,.te . d Adrninist~o.tion ~us~ !tort.I+ ~~;191! et Kinond.oni Prim~ Court._ Sn respect of tha some house the n,,S~•J; c -r thi~ pr-oe&~d.!nga, ruid th•Nt~• the tl'i~l court O\olght- not M'Ve al~l. th~ -~J'ell~t . . . •• . : . ~n na,.• pi-obflte ~ . tnd ndminietr..,tion pt"0O~j?din~ tll s,.t\,1.~~ .. ~4 /.dMt~ ~ e N~•:--11 o/, ~ffl, e t~e J?!i1!Sl?l:.._~.£!!.ltid1e.o_,tQ.. Tho.t tQ-;, ~ehd, the ni,»ellant~ hence her appeD.l to th~ court. The judgment of th~ ~o-,,.t, EL]Jllle_1:,late . : ~ ,-. lee~ impugned princ1~ an t•-•o grounds,_ thnt ~ t11 d1: (a) that the l.~» c-ourt ei·red. Sal'. nilC t'l\et ~n t'lndihg that ~obate ond Adrain. P,;1al!•...1:·~'.211 Wrecl ,m ,he '.* prinoipla of zr,es-judieatn oli lhe ··16.st, if l\-o'bate ·Md Aclm1n. c. lfo. J!t-fZ9 whi~h hc.d beerl CM\duned secretly ~ind fraudulently by the . lct·o fllMiC:i:tct MOSES iPAnIPO, Pi';ho'.lt ,1w )lfto"l6dge of ·,tie!' re:i.,rti~e'S.- ,,-ihieh then I • ... --~-,~r1end the so.le trD.Udiiltiltj (b) thot the lwer co~t et-red in ~~• t\n~ t'ii4t t6if finding • .. . <.. ·, . in favour of ·th& ~apottdant • ,,the i.t6\sis c,t ,Na judicntei, ~••hen the ·S"'id TtlMA!m MOSES Jldttro ~Ottdueted ~obate Md Adnd.n~ C•:,tme ,tfo. ~ ;,,hen •lie h~.d .. ,,:1t been dttiy oppoint'ed as the Adr.:i~i~trator by 't.he ·e1t.m mem- -)rs, :;>, :. '~i1itt_;_,,G this ,.rme-:-l th ft,; cot:rt sougr.t tn c ,"c1s:i.c ,r- ,.,:,.r,.-·i,,e... · .. not ; thorf, v:'.!s prnio'.lsly n 1,_,_,.,ft-,l ndmin:i-tr-·tion of 1.:,::c;~o.sPd's er:-+:--<--- ~-~ . ".'-nbo.te and Aci.11:i.:.1, .;, .rne No.,,2:_£:~._.-:191,9 of K~.-::condoni Prim~.ry Court in rr~<:~~cr:t cf the houi:;E: -~he subject of i,c!~·.inistrc.t:L:.1 ':c.use !-;;.-,. 13 of 19?3 1 nf Kinc::idoni ... ---- ------ Primc-1::-~ Cou •.-t. An inst:ruction · ~.-, ·: bm given to O".ll for· Kinondoni Primtl.ry Court i-i.ctd.i:..istr-".1.tion '.:,nuse No. 3L: ,Jf 1979. 1 Unf.ortun~t-<'ly, -the R.M~ inchn.rge Kinondoni District Court, by hi::: le~ter Ret. ~o. tN/C.30/2/111/80 of 17/10/95 h11s inf·,:·.•1,.ed this court th~.t such F":'.non::l.oni Primnry Court Probo.te ruid l\drnin, -Co.use: _N?..:,31+~_?L.1912, cannot be t,·'l.eed. " Counsel -r ,.--:· the Rt;sp~-g-ent l& ch~llenged this appe"l 9 mc.J..ntf.l.J.m.ng tho.t K~.-i:rn::idoni ~-~i;:nnry Cc_urt Probate and Administr!'l.tion Cause Noa 34 of 1979, had ·. _ > -~ (luly 11 .tde,1 ~~:.- comp1,~tilig ·•ith nll 1:e5'°1 requirements~ including :· ~ • .., .$ ...... • "':U' ' ' . cite:~:' , , ri.dding ~ha~ ~t --c.s i,,h&t1 the tin:e given for· objection had elc:psed .•... ; .... ,... - thn.t 'i:;he vife cf tbG ic.~ ~l~ro 1-(0SEp n ··-~~-nis~e:. . r1,~ the estate of her lo.te husbnnd i~ t:V:::J ~ci.~'t','3; \ / · '•-:·· -.• , l1;_:~,/;' • tt~ s!~ . . i( . th . t ::.·:.-,~ ·::,.~ t'l-:te Respondent Mr. ' M,-ff.Jmsungulo. -le!'tr11e~ qo;_~~:~el for tlie.;pi:.~JX·: ·'..c,::.t :.--.:.fl :Y:rnn honest ho;.,ever, ' --~• ~ ' to o.drr,:i.n:1.str ,te tl1~~ :~.•.•~ ~.id not. .., --~t-1:g .. . - .. t·) fully ·h,~tber. there was cito.ticm.,... . 1·1 0 in resp&c~ ,f i:,:rob.te ;_!').:'. A~i1'-:Letir,.t';i ~- ~.-.use No. 34 of 1979; coupsel ~OJI .. · . : ·i .. ----- ., •·. ,,...., ""rr-1 r"t 1i the Respc":o: .ent hes furth.::r c.rgu~li · tllot1 ,-~n if Prol-:. :.te r.:.nd /:.dnil.n. c. !!,oo 3'+~ had beeri ( e;nducted secretly ••·h!l~ a~t-'31 ough'.~ to helve elm.•.-·. , ·!l.s to chnll&nge the ·"-J'.>Iic ·ntm8nt of one TUMALIICt,· :I.S:~~e, ,\dminfat:r.~.tor in suer. Pr00r...-co Md Admin- · , .... "'"' · r,_~cl.iJ.':.g··thit it i1·ns ,,ropf·c~/·h~i- .· ·~ .~. . . t~ppellont) to open another Probo.t& . ·· :~. ~ rind. A/. :inistrnti8n fuUF.(; in respect of :.e.~ S' me est,...te. ; • • t, ~ 1· ' .. .· . · · It It hus further been ··tp~; e.ont1?11t~cn ·for the Respondent th ....t were lt -. . . . .• . ·n , . true ·;hc\t there ,,,as frnud in th!t ~obate --..nd Admin. Ca.use No. 3-t.. of 1979, - -~- th..,.- 1i1~ul.::i ho.ve constituted a good .«rounci in seeking revie1-• by ti::.e court ,. ·~ ;"~' i. ·. ,.. of 6'..lch cc~ae on s-u.c:.1 ,:::round, 'l>'hi&h ~,,heJI f,~,:nd. to be found could lend. to . ,. . .. ,. . rcv,:c:i.tion of the o.ppobt'.'.'lent of 1:he sold ~•.mALr:i::r:.: o.a th• Administ:-~tor in P.rc,-: ,n.te uJ1d Ari'ilin. Co.,:,se ~~._:t_tl:J1... !L'h, J,c :.;r-ned counsel ho.s o.lso ::: mported ' th< .:'\•,cision of the lo;-•er npp(;-11ate1•~ 'i··. rejecting Probate o.nd 1 \nj_n. { ·ro .• 1 ?./~?2 for beiri.~ Ree Judleit.ta, tn.t'· .. (\1,f of an enrlier Prob,d·.. ruid . . ~1 . +- ; . .th· • t~ ,. L:, ..:o.t"ned couhsPl :fr,r 1:h 0 spondent ·. : -. . y, 1 ~ 1e c c ~tbe~ :4 on by tne ·, • · thnt .... ,/ : n! by the o.p~--:di!!.nt that tl:~ :' eb.l<J of the l--:.0use in .:1isp·u-':;,, , · 0 _3 frr-~,.-1-r .::.~ :- ,~·,_use ti:,e· firct Prob;ie Dnd A&nin:.str"'.!.tion C.'.'-use No. 3l1- o::: 1979 1 . . .. ' . . . . . . . . ' ~- ,;~ . . . ", ·, . :. h·1<i° ·,. c·· .:. !cL•.1,_:_ster::u fro.udul,-:ntly, ,,rus Ji"t t=ue bec~u.~',3 Guch clnim cif ±raud ~. , ,o.~ ·never mentioned in· the: -~~ect.li?\~~\,~f~r~ ~·. -:he trfo.1 court in Pr.~bot , '~ ' 0 w..-~. Adm:h:.:i.str~tio!l ·eaWJe N~. 1J::of 1,,·'·:~•,.:lt ll-·~.-=.: ther,·.fore been subm.~tted 1 ,. •. , • • , ,._,. ..._ .... -~·~ ·1 ~f- J,• 1 "'-,·•-+ · ~,- +h: ;: --~puot1l be· C:.ismissed\·oh the · · "d'~th~.t Acl.ministrrttion Cz:..use No. 13 •f ·Jadic~to.. · ·· · · · ' ,,.,· ... , J ~-~n the light of th•: :~n.cts rcffiewe2- .2tc·:e, t':is ccm:·t is s1":ttisfi43d .. .., .-·r-:,, that follo,.•ing the d~c.t;,1 of one P.:·H:IJ:-:O ::cz_,:]S : '1 \"J.'_ .::..ri;;T:., Eo:netime in 1979,, Prob:i.te nnd Administr~:tic:: ~-use ~fo •• :/ of 19':"'? , ·c.::: opened in respect of hie 6.St~te,. b~ing the house in <l:J.:-rpi1tJ~.-1..·:·-:-·~- ~--;:: clec..r. from the records of the t~ial co~t t-~nt one RC'J ~ET 1:fw/1'!-i:~N'if. :.'-.. , young brother ·cf the deceased, the.'' l~t~ HIILIPO MOSES MW:2!.'.NYETI. ·,.in.s · ·, ' 1"1n~e~ ~he, AdrinistJ'.':::.tor in such Admih.~ ,. ,. ·i<t1-.i ;.:,.·:; xf •' ~u8e. · It does o.lso 1.ppell.r. the.t up ~.;;dat~rmfnc.t:ibn 'of Probate nnd Admin. 1 :ii .• : I • • • [ ,1 JI ( (:; • o • : • • • • . '?ri,::~ry .,I Co.~.ee l!~•bn,34112, on .l;4l~,. . Ki~~~c ' . . 1' . ._C9urt· b.dv~sed the Mo.n::tg&r N.,H,C. .. ; . . 1 , .. 1 ~ . Iklr es So.µlllm, iuil!ltti.!cenl,- ·thouglf~··c4· :.. ~ ,..n.s n~.t the D,ppropric.te ~uthority,. t ~ .the ~e ~- th~:r_tU~• ho'.l~e~i- 'fbf :16u~e·- ~~.:.?D.2~ Plo~ No.1_9/24~ · · i • · Mva.Mny~~lo.,' -~en~: )4\deh is ih .d~~c.1; e~.o~ld .be C:"c'mged Md ..have. the· . ~~- of TTlM.·l. :'Cf.~, t,t- _.i1ARt r>.. :uci!IAEL ~ ,.. '- .. fl • . ~MC,3ES~MI:0~~~~co~.de~. tJw-~~~~ }1.T(.~ ff_t~~ "' ... _'·-'·" t-- \ t , • -· ' •• • . "' • ~~. -~-~~ .t~,at ~~~:d\ct~~ ~~li ;~~in18~-~~fo17 :~~se __ No, ~;t~.t:"1f~ ~ - ~ck thr~e. c~:i.:l~?n, · •~o~· m-e'. .~:'.l.~ .,_ to ~e grnnci. cl:\i~~en of ,~!te y~te· • ,,, . •• .... .. • • . . • ., ! . • • •. • . • • . • • ~ • . •. . { ~ ... ~ ' ' ~ili:po Mose1ir Mw.~;anyett,.\ · ·oec~e •the b€.-::. f.ir-.· --::-::-iec o:~ sl.l~h house. TllP.t-e, i• ~l __ ,.·,-~.:.,•,_1·· ~:.~:-·: ·.... ", ;..,.l•~·- ·.. ·:. .•. ·it·. ,:..,! ,·... ", :·\,;~-. t- ..... ~°:'}iel'e· ~h~~ ;~_h"·t ~hr~~1TI~1AL~ M~::. ~~ 1. T :".'=C !".~d been 'deelar_,d ·t.~e r-1-i'i ., . .t ··•.r ··•· ~.=~ '•> . , • .. . , .• 1.· '· t\fj~ifi.ci~ ,of ,isue·h· ~~us~. Th~it•--~~-•· li~·-,e:re· ·~- -~- iencc th'lt ~~~- Adm~~~~~~~or on~· Robe~t ·M\-,ruim.nft!!tn,. .-..r..~t -,:1~,;~4'.-tllr. J .·., ~. -.,;~r. ::KE i10i:'.:.'.Er fEIL?PO ,, .~·.:<. r' -~- . • , •·.· . ~~ ~- - r,:_~i:: .· :., 1 t~' .•,. · tontiJ\'Ue. J!ti,.ying in ,tha h ...use Set lo,111 as :1he ,,,rutted to live in Dar- es S_a~. ~,~~;t..,_:;•,:•l~r•: .:· ~f" • ,·. r•· •••;, • , .~j ~:.::•.t,.,f "';.. What tro.nspired l~ter tharefore tli~t ~ncle · up into shrJ S".le c+' the :-C"", fc ;·_ .. •, · , r ~ · h· .... · _ t t • . .: ~ ; • • • : "\ ~jeet hot,se by the :,;~.id: Tm-u.J..,:U~ · i~ en; _;,h,..t '~ould. 1Jes,t be explained, ~Y: f_,•·: _.,.,. •,- ·:J·... i~-" . : · . , 1pJ ,. .... ~. •. · ··r .·...., -,!F,~;r,. herself. As. ~h~· 1s • "-l. ,. t ·, ·.. •t •· . • . • no••· d~ad, ~e ~-ot·. li..ti'·1 her· . • ' ;.. ord. . . !t htl.S yet , been contended vitli forde th!lt her act ~l aeili:"' .· the. hou'.se i:n dis-pute to the .. ... ; '· ,, ~ {t ~. ·, ·., ~ . " t . • } (. ,. :·. •• • • . : • • • ;._ ( Respon:dent "'M'· traudltle:nt. ~llt,. •cat-~ ;o the argwnt:~t of the le~d . . . ,~ ! • . . ,. :·. . . : ..,. . .: . . '~ . . ' - . . . ~1- ,," t ... .. ~ ' . . : '\"" : >. toune&l,fp:P t~e-pes,ondeat,. api,etll'~ el.earl) ~1~o trmt= the proc~edinge of . ~,\'.~. ·.~., ~ · ~~-:l ~ :: ~.~ ~ ~ ~ i ~\ '.' .; :~ ·1·. · 1 :•: -· .·. ....c· • •• ... "~ • 1 the tl'ifll eew-t·., ~•her• it· t-u elO:imed the-.t r :ell: llouee had been sold l:!Mt'~tly .... ·-i-:1.,.; :1 , .... ~ \ ·· ., ·~h\t-, .: ~,~~. · ;··-:. -~~---~.. :i:-r.i . . -·· - !- •• : · J • ·:, t ·.:'. 1'1i1theu~ the ~lec1.g~ ·of hothi tie- jea.-:ccll 1 -:lei-, the groundchil~ei?, in = ..~i,.~;:~~i tli~ eul>~t ..h~~;···~~ -~o \~ '!,',,_ '.'.' ,1 .:n;•:;, :·.1.:;.ft 1.: , ... ~l.;L:•f $);• ~h~ld ~~°:iders~ ~~· 'the { -,, .·.• ,.~;: · . : · · .. · _.., •.. ,: •. >: ~-~'~{/tt;·l~:- ~~ ?.~ l!,~,r_ r~;,,;ti.-es. · I~ .t~~ ci~•U&Uit¥c&. 7 .~ue~ _'~rile ~~ <?~e.nrly . · ·.•·· ·•. :''· ,,?\.., ··. " · •. ·l ,.~ _t,;,J ..._••f,;.-f,l1 · .., ·, ... •, ~•' l·· t· .. - .i. · 1 t)ie.uduleJ\,t., lJt' -..,hon,: it "f,'-S :se- e:ngirt•••cJ that I eannot tell. 1 •~ r•, 1... ; \,._"',,•~J ~ ,.. f• • ,r • ~ -:. \ t ,. o. \ t.:.;~, •: , ? •~ 1 ~ t_. • '. I ~ •,. 1 f• • • ~ • 1r :. .. ·, i .·' ~'!of>M ·~-0 .-~4e6th:r·, ~~- .~~e· >.~e~~1~t-~-Pr~-- 'l:J':: dtl~. A~~~·= ~~~~ No.z~. ~~~t~.~<.\ Aqµ;;t.n~tr•~~10Ac;.~~- »o~'\,M9,. ~ -~.-s ..Jud~e9=t_~,· _on th&t I run '.;. ' • .. ' • • • ~ T C • • ,I,. elltirely Jn agreement ".rith tl• ~ud.i}lg of tie L"'Jr C.:!>;pella.te court •. Once • ther~· WM -~~{de!~ce ;; ·-~;~~- J; ~.:efk.J••1. ih~-· ·:~~ -~ub.jc~{ ·ho~~- .,,,l'J./3, 'ati~.y t~/~~tje~\/ ~rtt~te~ ·-;f a·;~.;i~-; ;•~;:,,~: ~~--A cur...iit~~deP- en~~~ '·1d r~spef' ·=°\; '! '-·· \~ '( .;•·!_l \::-.... :~ ,:v;1 •• .. ·· i ~,~..,./l.,\ , . · ·. . L ·:•~ • . • • o,t t_he. ~ame__decet:i,sed pe~~o~·i. ..t~~•, th~ aub=equent --r_ob.,.t':' .,nd kt:lin. c~u~e _ ,t.,. -', f • ;'( l: ..,,I: • • ''"'•,. ;•· • I...._ 4. f (".;.. '-:.,. • ' ... • , · '!fS: b~!_e·d fo~ _be:i.ng _Res Judi,ea.ta.-__ , · · • •••,''·ft ,: ,f I ·'>/l.~•Jl,; ;..,. · · . f. . .,•:;_~ ! ;, -~ . the.-.~ther .,. klM-d,: ..'~h~. •o.th~ .~ ~.t ,,1:¥ c,w1p~int 1-ras th:1t the Mle . .. ·t.:. ot,._the ,subj4'C-t hou®. ht1d ~ rlon~ f~~u•le•tlr nr- , th♦ref()re, it should be deelaJ,"ed _1?,Ull_ ~c~ v-d_c;_, ~ other. int'ere~t~~ ,r.r·· .. ".'lf!'.•: . ~ti_cularly the_ . ~di•hil~en . the '\.!.;" ot fttilipo Moses· K,-•~~ye·'!,?., ,.::~; ·a.p~nrs to have .. ••~~.,:•:-:~ •, ·1~-~e C,ll•J;.. ,,•,f'"' ; :: ..-.•·!:).,_y . :• ,.,~-~ . l bMn~ the beneficiari-es of the mihjec~ hou~e, •••erE r.:·t involnd.: /6 . , - . - ,i.,•··· .. _, •· . . - "- ~ t ,. • • • ~ t • ,., ~ 1 J I •' .( . . ,·. • 'I. .,. . ., . . -. • ·. ' ... t\t . . . ,-. ! . \ - .' ''- ' •~•• • ~;,)· "t..! \ ~,:,, ' • ~ t -1: ::~~ ' - ·:~ ' • ~ ~= 6 - . ' ' Apparently~ ,-,hereo.s t:,cre i.: ev.:-". :r:r.c!3._ th~t _the subj1::ct house wna, upon determin-'ltion .. of Wobo.te· ·tu.?,d :~c1-rr:/e.~,~tro.ti~n CO.USP. No, ;?4 ~~W.s given to the three grnnd~-children of t:·Le '.dece.,-13edf·the late FHILiro MOSES MWAMANYETA menticned ,above, no ~d-5 d~ncl hru!i';be"en produced to show th~t . . . . . consequent upon the o.dninistr.t{c-~ of th~ deceo.sed•s esto.te in Probatt= o.nd Administrnt{oi1 '.:!nuce ~~-g- z'l.Z2 ,he vendor, ~he -late TUMALIKE MOSES PHII.J::ro. wif<.: of t':::c> det5ensed, :the Stil.1d l?HILiro MOSES. 'MW1\MANYETA, "'M , i declnred the benef:ici:;.ry of t!~.~, ~ubject house~ I do! therefore, accept the a:.gument for t:;.e c.n:·....-ll~'1t t> :.t -,hon tJ::e lo.te TUMA.LIKE NOSES :mILIFO, so'ld the subject r.01.1::::e _.:c- -!:~. .; _:er;pc.".'·:,::::t, tr.,.t vets done :"rcudulently, as Kinondoni Prim;,:::-:: Cot.:r: ! i:!1 • ,, -..e·:ur~; ·, o: title to subh ;:n-:-:e :.~:td not .dev~l ·re L:: ·.:.,n :"er pur:-Y:-nt to ~ny order of . . .'..c'.minir.'';r·: U.cic p1-ocoedings in Probate ond Ac1r::ir::::rt:;-.:,_·,:: ... ::1 Cb.use L~'!!. J ..2l.~_.:'?~:~. of I:i:::o.1c.cni P.dmo.ry cour-:: 9 as al~ 2[:'~~to i..:: -;:· e:::-, ~-t d.ce- c.1'.l: -:,.r to :ie t::.:-.t th0 c.:-iid TUM.ALIKE simp1y took iJ.::vc.ntc.30 , ' ::er resid· :ce :·n the !-:.01.lse ruid un the recognized land la.dy whc ~~,:;eiv::J :,.:i:t1:: fror. t ::ants -:1::'t.er the .<:.'';:c:t:1 of her husbdnd 1 • which then gave he:: 1::.·:_3 .:::·:~·:1:s n . ..,;l h ._:>:: t'· ·;; s-:-. 1 ::: ~-~eement of the subject house, 01;, she c'..ic.'.• Or.. :1t -:.cc·:···";, : ~~o r..-:t hesitate to decltu"e euch so.le of the ~'::::jc:.;t hou.se ::mll -'.'.!lc1 . ~i:'., :mo t'.·. ~,::·efore of no effect-. The subject house is t:::- revert to tl: · right~\.ll h,3:i.rs, c.s c:,rdered in i,robate end Administration Co.uoe !-fo.,,)~, ru; per letter from Kinondoni Primary Ccm:•t, Exh.Q_, namely TUHA MIC ·m1 1 !i\.;U.'.. MICHA'El. D.nd MOSES MICHAEL, ,,,ho are .said to be the gr.:tndchildren o:r th~ late ffiILiro MOSES MWA,.\IANYETA, • I tl:ere:'::re allow t~is t:tp)i5et\1 : r~t, by upholding tlle decision of the lo,,.er appellc.te court; wliic-h d~--- }.Qred probnte ond Admj.nistration Co.use No. -1_,3/92 o.s reE:i ,juJ.ic~t'a, h~t ac: ~erting the clnim by the o.ppellnnt th!l.t -the so.le of the subject house .,,o.s '"'::.cud1..~lc~,t, ond trcrefcre hereby deelru:-ed null nnd voL: i.~.::d if 1•.no effect, :i.t!-1 ::·, cr::.0i:- that such house ~"'- . should revert to +.:1e ::·i:)itful heirs, ,".s • ·•· eN ty K:i:2.::-nc('ini Pr:imo.ry 1 ::1. Court, in Probr..-!:e ond Administration ; 'i.u:- IJ.:?.::.. ·_ f, :?f_:\:~9.~ ~::nely TUMA MICHAEL, MARIA M:'.:CTiAEL and MOSES MI""'.:t~,:·r., ·•½o a.re :Tc:-.::1dchild:-,m of the lnte FHILIFO HOSES HWlJ-~TA. I make no order for co::::·'.. -::o ·• . DATED 6/i-1/95 R., A. MWAIKASU AT DAR E2 SAL."..~ JUOOE ----- ~ ~.,_.-;,,.·4 .....-:a 11:_f..,~, ';_.,_,.. f\;- Order: • r "' Thia judgement shcU:l:i \e. :-:ctifiecf and':r-eo.d to the pt\l'tiea by the D:tsJ~. ict Registr,t."".', ··Hi~h :CciA:irt, ',t>m- es So.lrulm Zone on nn e~rliect ~cnvenieb·: date. P., A, y· ....:; . _sv 3l ·.,· ·. ----··-i.- ~ .\1~ •> 29/12/95 Corrun: tJ. M3uya, AG.DR/RC .Present in person for the Ap~ellMit ·~sent 1r. person tcr. t:'.la Re6:poatrnt C• c. Kon(.;ia,,. · Ot.der: Judgment is deli ve:t-Eid. '°'· ti.~ ~ 'ith d.'- , ·. ;, December '1995 ia presence of the Api,elW~ .r$on rliii 1aa·t•• ,nae.nee or·• ~bsi&Oll4ettt b pel'saa. , · C Right ot Appeal explained.