19950727 TZHC Dar es Salaam

----- '/;l3RAZ- ---~ . .,..__ ,"' ......... IN 'llI~ TIIGII COtmT OF T.."JI&~l 1-.T Dlill . ml ~.l\.J~;:.,DivI . PC CIVIL l:.?Jl~lJ, N:~ 17 OF 1995 LSSA_ 1.r:cr••••••• 0 •••• • llITELIJiNT fi:J-iZL :.r...;.r.:JXL:r:~. o O. f • • ~aNDu'IT •\ • ·-·-~~- JUD GI,;._ .E. I-Pi I J3Ulll3]Ila_J'I Issa--l!l.1ir-5., -~>c ;:,;J:_)ollo.r.:', i::. i.:·5a cr>..so. is E-- ncphott to tho Uospondont:· . t.· ·<. Ramza. Ill..· .. . llam..'\dltt'lli. : T>.oiz, dic1,1JtO oo:-::t::: ;s ail a Dioco cf ~4~\'lk~ .which. tho :rospondont l\,;,il_ lor.it to tl'.o c.:::>ol:·.ent :'. )J.~ tQllJpor~J uae soootimos in 1990.- ... \.·..... Thon_~ 1993 the res,.l!or::lo:-:t tolrl t::.q t.r-:;_·,)llo.nt th;:,,t llo l-ronts his ehamba ·· back. . Tllo ~11.cll.::nt ~i;ell.t's w-illiI-._:: t.; hr41d ovor tho s.k.rabn b~..dc hit on·· I \y,.i p~ont of _OOIJll?allSa.tion for tho W".fl~i:01 ,wen.ts tho:..•)on• l..t tllc triru. boforo tho l'rm..:i;.. ('ou.rt :GviflCnQC aiven by tho appollant 0 ~· was that th9 r.cs-;ondont 4D.d ~oecl to c:.-,;:on the_ sllc"!µlbt,, to tl10 ·(appel~t) ., /' on tomp~ra'r'Y use. ~c a;pvollt\l'lt ,rcn-~ sey thnt has plontod. 7 ,. . or. to· he . · • -<-•:·.. 'j . . . . . -:' " · t ~ n pomo.nent crops Md if the, :r:'(;S~~<..rilont ,rnnts his ·ehoPl~- b~ ho the·· ~eepond~t shoul,l COi:ipcnento tho o.p;•~llr:-uf;. Tho r~spondont ~ ~ · ·· - . .. ,. . . . •\.. not willing to do so r;s ho !.:ru:'l no.'\ eauorionod,tlto plan-tine of ~sd · ~ . ·:· :.• pemenent orops. Tho '.i.'l'i.1:1.·r✓- Cou,,:-t oc:-~::.iclol:O<\ tho QV'id~ce -ci~ t11iow~_-~ ·.. -- -. . ,, ..- the_ Qlaim on the ~und th•.•·,;t t~ rosi:ondorrt; did not ~t03:V'ono · when. ho.·,· · - saw· the r',l)J?cJ.1::-.nt :_:,::.J:_\ti."!.~ l)Offit:l10r.t c:r0:1s. J:n otl!.Qr t-TOmB the· shmba.·- was g:tvon to tho C',J?J?Oll~t l)O:r:Qonontly, T:.:.o \~')s11o~d.011t t!:i.on ~pell-ant:.,_ -..,. ti)l)oalad to tho :Dis.trict Cout"t which ril o~:-cd. t!->..o c-,roocl. m1d rovorod . '.the· .... ··.··- ......._~. . •, "- ~~--. doc;ision of t!::.o tticl. cot\tt. Thi:; 1e:i:ig tl~ socO"tul tq)DeeJ.1 tho issue · . __. •.. before me is still tho S.Ji.10 th.ct 1s whotLxi, tho piooe ctZ sl4~b~ beloup·' . • ,. to the cppollont o:,., tho ros:>onrlont. Deforo r.te t!10 e-J)j)o;.l.:i,.t'lt o,dnitto~l. t-, .. --:vo 'boon (;,'iv-on the shamba, b7 his unolo tho l'OSJ?ondont. Ile was eJ.lo::roC <;o till 1t for $0t1Gid.mG (Jcua.zimwa). . IIowCiNor since ho has inc1.::..'!l'od s.;::10 a--.C:-)Cl13cs to alo~ the. . _, tho bush as ·w·aU ns l\l.allc.,~ pcm.;,nent ar-,1)s thereon ho :tools he should. be oomponaaiod '£00: thoeo offortn nnd ooc2onuor::. Tho ros,;ondant-- ~ the other htind. told tho Court thi.lt ho mcroly lo.·~ t~· shembe to ·bis nephow tho eppollem· -.rl.t!1. a i!1st~tions thc.\t he slio:Jld not plt1nt pcimenent . . crops. ~ow tho:f; he hq.a dono contrnl."'Y to hi~ tnatruetions he is not vtllifJg _- . ·~. . il to ottq1: oomronsl'.'..tion, , ._ · ...../~ -- 2 - I Atte~ rov1owing tho o"(tid.cno<• tendered~ tho roepondont end thd ho r.1,3r~~1y lo.nt . o~ belw, mlike "ho l'rimnrY C0ui--t I om sn.tisf:.cc. thc.t ·1.:~.c J?ioco -ot sha.mbo. sUJ.1 bolonse to ·it. out. to thQ . nroollant .. • I am . .. •, howovor, not oonvi.ncec·. tl:.C'.t thorc ·. ~c=·~o .ir.::.:tri..i.o-ticm,s thc,1 t"ho ~ollant Bhow.d not J?lnnt 1:iol.TI'.",ncnt oroj: -~ .:::2 cl:::c ~-,!Jy 0!1ouic: tho ~poll~ ~ fllOh a. 1 r ~ , I t::..:..::: ·tho ~).)l)L:·.:i.~.nt -~-1~.ntcc:" J?C:;..n::-..ncnt o;ops booau,,e· • ~ woro no such ros"t~'ictioas. I11·-::•.r-J;; c~.rc:lt thoro;toro it wlll b.c f't,b U ~ rospondont QOlll).)onsi:-.:tes th,<:) :--,2.)poll.e:!.-J,. In this ro(.y;!Zd ! join 1 ~ with tho I I . Dj.str.iot'· C-oui-.t. I thorof'oro ordox t .,., t o. _:-::-_,:pr.·r ,-:i.uc..tion bo clono by tll.o a.uthori,W.os concorned. and oouponsntion bo 1,.:-.;:;;,.·-1 011 -t~: o -,rclu..:tior1- kl 'the;i ov-.t ♦b£,J ·, oaeo is :lloroby rcru.ttod be~. to- th() 7.·L:,_~dot Coux,t ;>o~ oom,pl!L'\ftoo ot iv· ordw., · "'lllo ~-:1,"ll)Onl is thorofo~o clinrn."~sscc' ., ~..net or.ch pc:>.-rty "to booa QWJi ·ooet1, ✓--- ,."Ji? )~)L\ /,l~ l.,;. t~ ts~ BOl'I1lmtt JUDGE 21/1/c;; omm,b Tho cortificc!. oop:7 ·ot this jtvI.:;;,.'.lrj; to 1,c l:o~,d to tho· ptt,l.-1101 , l )- ;, . i e.t I(ilosa biJ ?-L:-x;tat~4·t0 ill o:1~eo ;.~~J.01,·a Di::-trid Ooi,~. JtTlJ<m ,·► 27/7/95