valeram m vs republic 2004 tzhc 41 7 june 2004

( O r i g i n * t ib 'T f r o a G ri'H ,;,! O - s e . H o ; Q63 o f 2003 t i ^ s n _ . ? - J ^ i).„- D riv e * t Dn r ©0 3 * 7. - ^.!' . '3 v r *** A T v ? T .' 1 r AT T -*• - ------« * U < 1 i ’X # 1 .-. . 4 » »»•»?•••« * » * i # # . fl * V '~ v > T .v.o 11L v‘ T . -^ rm *r -•. ,., ^ - - '- • O >_> TH.i, UNlT.Jyi5 .; i_,_...0 PJ$SPON7)“3TT y ") Ku-mxA, J . The q p p o ll^ a t a^rear^'- 4.^ J:c?', t. -Gx .ro tfao/Jesidont M * g i a ± r * t e o f D *r es „ t Solsoine U riv a on t o b ,r g e s h e et 0<*>fa.itHng e o u o t* o f M t M w r i a . ; t o 'TojKMantp n « i a s , Tha c « o la th e W , - O - n - t ^ l t e r t 0l -ir,tn »x C -so rubber 9«3 o f a o o 3. n ,e P ro c e e d in g s o f th e J.o„er c u r t t b , t *h a „ tha , p r e l l , n t <ipl?e*re0 b e f o r e tl-2 c a r t oo 15/10/2033 the t r i , l S e n io r < U « l . * r * t o n otoe « , . t to e focu sed person b o fo r e h=»r b „d p lea d e d g u i l t y t , th e f i - s t c ou n t. Tha l o , r „ od S e a lo r R a » id a » fc B » s l 3tr*iJ® then adjourned th e im t t o r to 23/10/2003 f o r h a « - t n g o f e v id e n c e on tho jsocoad „ » , t , c - 33/ i o / z :*>3 th e case « » ir ljw r n c d t o 25/11/2003 f o r m ention. Mo Te „«o Bl « » f o r 0 n 2 5 / l l / 2 0 , 3 ,) h l c , 5 » , S the d « t e s e t f o r th e e , » o to oc ■ e o t l ^ o d , tho p r o b a t i o n Withdrew the second count *»nr? nroce^d^d ^ o c o . u . r j to to irnv-' move tno cotart to gxvQ nn o r d e r o f 3osnoliti.cn rr ---- -► ii-s c o u r t o b l i g e d . Tbs o r ^ e r o f d o T i d l i t i o n did- not ,ro *>G- i «, ^ ,, , - t,ie a > , p o l l ^ a t and he p r e f e r r e d qti ap p ea l to t b i o c o u r t • M r, N g e lo s b i, a c t l a . ’ fo ~ *-.*~ *• t-g R1rp 1a«»r]+, xn.. *F P © * il t h a t t h e 1om©~* n , , . ^ ■, ~ ° ^ --c te - its e lf in not t*k in - th e a p p e l l a n t * s p l o * * y i Ba -, . • ^-.-io, lu ^rned S t » t e A tto r n o v *p p e **rin s f o r tho R e ^ iv - -:6 . - 4 _ sy.'^'>rt tho c o n v i c t i o n . 2 T h is was n o t s u r p r i s i n g ao , was .,.-arko-d d e p a r t u r e fv o n procedure on t a k i n g p l o a h an l a i d down i n S a c t i o n 228 of* t h e C r i m i n a l P r o c e d u r e - c t « J.f e V 9 r t n e r e w -.s a plo*» o f g u i l t y ». t h e tria l c r . i r t '-;as to r o c o rd the accused p erson 's plea p oooib lo in t h e words n e a r l y be 0808", Thic is p r m ^ : :\ri' C o c t i o n 2 2 8 ( 2 ) o f t he < J r i " l i n * l P r o c s ' l u r e /.ct,- doc ,c~oo ■c c o t l - o a l s o lays it down t h a t a f t e r r e Q o r d i n y t".;o ;/lea o f - g u i l t y , tno t r m l c o u rt s h a l l pr oc ee d to " qo nv ic 't f ~ o . a c c v s e d p e r s o n an- pass S©ataQ<jpS o r make an o r d e r a •■'•“ -•t .-.ip 9 u n l e s s t^ero sia ll a p p e a r t o b-© s u f f i c i e n t coo:, t- f'o cn B t^ry", -I n th®. " r e s m f c case there is no c o n v i c t lot: o o f oo c e c t o n c o b u t t h e r e is an ordor o f dem olition . TLis t r i a l c -rt a loo. us.od t he p a s t , ' 'g-^aommtr xti makino: a ro~or-~ ; cou rt record# I tnink ttiere is need t o r e c o r d t o o :. **CTt Since, accucjo ad ~- it to 1 s t c o u n t and was convicted f;r too ca~o wb'it' f o l l o w s is th e ard.er- f o r d o u l l i t d :;p!5. . Ta ke n as i t is, t a i c . r o a ^ r l i doos n o t make s e n s e . - It was Mr* N g e l e s h i who r.ado se n s e o f t h i s remark when hs rsvc^ls^ th?> t t h e r e wao _an- . o r i p i n a l C' u r t roc-oro i n Which p r o c e e d i n g s were r e c o r d e d * A p p o r e n t l y t o e or-1 -, i n a l r e c o r d " g o t m i s p l a c e d and a d u p l i c a t e file was ' pone3 . The Ij^ rn ed S e n i o r R e s i c i e a t lJapds t r a te> a p p e a r s t o h a v e " l i n k e d 5' the two j f i l a a V b e n e e t h e rea-srl: nado i n too d u pl x ca <oj f i l o * % h l s ' w ^ V l r r o n g , ' "ihcT l o - r n o d Hon'ior R e s i d e n t M ^ i s t r a t © _ ^S ou t^lhavs ta ke n the p l e a a f r e s h i n :tho ‘d u p l i c a t o record ' ""and p r o c e e d e d ' a s th e law r e c u i r e d ’, Since t h is "' w a s n o t done the proceedin gs in the-' l o ' j e r c o u r t a r e a n u llity . The p r o v e d i n gs o f t he l o mot co vr -i a r e cpjoooed and t o o dem olition, o r d e r 'wade* i s set ^ cido. ■'Poo. cape s’ o/ul'l he h e a r d de novo before a n o t h e r ®a,g.ie tr<*to o f eo .o p e t o a t -j u r i s d i c t i o n # - . • It is so., o r d e r p d , -• . D elivered , '“D«»ted t h i s 7 tli'. J un o, 2^' h,