NA TZCA Dar es Salaam4

( Ori~in'"'.L Orimin,11 G~o.:ie Ho. 13? of 1969 of the Digtr.ict Court 0f ~,nn,:.;e'-'- ;}i;::;t:;. :i.ct ;_ct ;:;ox;,:;,c,,). I ':..}J~.:, .1.t...::1~tJH.:.:1lC •· • ~ ~ ·• _, (! t l Q ',1 it'J .. ;i ·:.)NjJ._:~. /Jt I C.LnY·ee:- Cau.f:tin,;, t'Ic.:r.:Lh. l:i~ ren!::1$sB ~r tl;:.1n::~eroJ.F; ctriving c/s 44;. (J.) (A) t,r1 ,1,10:Jdcd by ooc.tion J_5 ol:' 'I'n,f/ic Gr(iiHn1c(.: 1w. 1/64 0f 70 Cap.

168. B.l.!7.Ci.'., ,T. TJie E:1l)p,3,,Ll1....nt l•·/t.te co1rvi -ted. o:f ct:.v.rJin.t.. <:l\l1-1·-!;.d D;/ d.1..int~'cr.ou.~ d1:•i v:i.nL . .1d he ,~ '- neitteJ!Ce;_-t to i,ap.~iso!l .He t fo2 {jit,·htGe . 1 ri1o~itl1:~.. tic is noi-; <lJ).., •C!~~linr.510 I I 12±10 .1).rocc~tlinL;:.; i.: ..ro ccu1J.l).Di11w in t1,,e e ..ttro,1d 1 ~ . nd i:t' ~1yt11in,. 1 the conf\wion. hi ,1orne ooi1i'0..:.rke'1 b;;t t11c1 1;ketc4, .Pl en prodw.::ed b;v "' police o.i"ficc~r wl10 t-:rr:Lve ..J fJcon. c:t.J.'"·r,..:;i." tJ'ie <-~tcci.,1ent$ ~11d, a..-j iJi.11 oe not,.:oct., mat:ic•t;r . . . te ta tjuti.r~Jmen t, is 11ot ver-:; l1e.:.p:t.'ul, but r""t;1e:r~ t-.n.0 r:evurue. 'l'he 1r.nt,.irL,J t ~,ct ..; of ti,G C~H;o in so f f1r :rn they cari. be e;•tr::ot .., ..: fro1n tl.:-C ;_.1.rocet:Hlin\_ c, ~lf:~ v.~'.r-t]tl{~. r,,iy b..;tl-.1. learned rrtt.ttO dtto.t'i'16Y ·...1,tt ~1r. 1 f'ari.Lb.~r1 1-,l1u &J)pehx·o(l :for thn ,. 1.PJ:"~--11~.:Lt 1 etrEf- d.n f:ollow£1,i- ?hti ap,1E•1L-.n·c, uho in a driver e;:1ployJll by Comv1or.<";.f; w.H::.: 1 m0i.tl1'.!:ial the cii/ t:i.r:iH, Llriv:i.PG a ,Jedfoni lor·.ry beloni-:,in,::.· to Co,nwork,; and 1.,:.; 1.; s c,.irr~.'ir1fC fol.lo~-1-ei~·,pl,,;{ee:r, 1 r..;0110 of 1,-,.rl1om ·we1 e ut t11t. bt-.c~: of "tl10 lv.i:-~·:v W'fL!..Ci. hHt:, 1 w-:;. or.11rn (HW.. In front of tto t,pJ•{i11.,nt 's , ch:i.cl.0, goine, ill t1.,<i r.:iame ,_lir..:cticn, v::tu s

mo"t,0.1:-cscL, .rivon by t,ne Socep.l1 1 witL u pillion 11u~;sent;cr 1 l);t ~~b. e .u~~i!G- or ~3e.le.ma,ni. 'I J1c--; n1oto~-c~rclf' ~ ~~~llutl. It i.s n.ot v~1r.;. clear 1 ho,,; th0 1·ider 1;u",, it .i:•e-:.:.t;.,rt"i<l. 9 UJ .... ot. ir: i:l.1JJh.1r,;mt; f'.t·tur: Iii. o,:n :pilU.,,n ;,d';;:;;QL ,:,;r 1 :; 0viJ~1:.(:8 after l:li.i.,l' .,J2,r~·stV _,_r,in.,~ he tu;•nc,! ro:uhi. ill -r,hr, fi(i.;.dle of tho road in tLo pi.1th of the cmcomil.i{, lor·:r·;y ,tri vc,n by U!e i..,ppelJ.. r1t. The .:),p,t:;cJ..1.Lni~ 1J:rnk.e(l an\..l r1;-1e:-::v·cd. to .his ri&,;I'lt tlppa··ror1 \~l~i ct1tiJ.;:i.n{~ u?~ci r;oir.:t;:; over "(i CMOU'!.kment. 1 t1,0n he t..:..:--,rnc', ·to t1.e l~"·t e .. i..!.i.-:_ i.tp on hi:.i pro1)e.1: ..• ir1e r----·.._._, of t.be ro:,,d. but di;.:gon,:illy to "tfo::: J'o,-..d. '.l'hn rno·J;or-c;y G1c i i;~;1:,J.t rie;J, ,et1 to have {Hhh:i::\ l.•:- in c:. tL·,dn. !!either vehicle 1,,uo ,,r, .. ,t-.:'ent1zi dmnnc0-i hut an employee t J / of Go ... :-:Or ,:o uho \E, 1:JittiI,i., at the bu::1: oi' tJJO lorry at the "tinm, w..,_c thrown .nu,t of ·-t.ti.e ·ve.t.~ic-~o 1• n;)JJ~.Pcn til'J w~. en it }Jtr;..tGk. tL.c t~1not.1.11.1:mcn.'t.. ~'l1.~! ·,.rehit:lo ti:1<-;r, rc.n oVe1' h:Un {;,\iunini.; ccriotrn iri,juci<':H3 fr.r;w1 ,•1.tiicl1 11<;: $,.Jme•,1uon tly di(~d. r if •r1111,) appdll~!..nt 11 in hj~c <l,{?f·~11ce, ,ne.rel~/ :1tt..tted til1t1.1: when Poe u»n.t'I

tt.1(;, m.oto.r:'t-~oy-ole tt1.1~n rouw\, l'.c Dou.n;.;,cd 11:i.J hcn•n, but the r:wt~.r-c;;cle upp~rc,utl;v c..;.c1t, to,n,rda hii:; tii!.lo t he tt.01.~ i:niarved i..nd hi -t tl.e od. u of th.ti :l'.'1:> .:d., • •;1 l A<HH'.lt•diut; to the di::.otch plan p.t·cd.twod by the pol:i.Gt': Q:f:'i"ioez', -.I'ter rrt:riJ,ing tho e,~f!<.J of thn :r.'(:ic1dt tLe vt1hh,lli ,•J(Ht't b.::iok.,.;m~dtJ, .~111,., :.J1.1.1 magirstrc.te in hif~ .Ji-1.d.grner1·t cx:r,:r.c:;f.t'.i.y (!Ci nt,a.ted.. But 5. t io impor.H;i:i.ble ;bo t.:ii:H~ h.CN thi,13 .,-, coul1i .hnve b~)en. e.c. Th~ m~e:i.strc.te in h:t. 1:.· ju .tgmeni;, .o.t:·1;e1: eta.tint;: that the l d.eceeu.r.ed. wi,,1 :rtlrl .()ve:r:' b;y th. vohi.ole drivc.ai. by the r:rppell.:.rnt, Hh~rn, .s:1.,s P-ilr(,Hld.3 r~m;;,i,rktHi, it ,,ant b~ck~1ardo, ~,ent on to lhty in the third JHH';.g;raph of 11.in j.itmord,, 1.,nd I quote:.- "There is :d~10, \"lithou.t th0 court Wur5'tin 0 a. lo-c o:t' \ -t:ime in su:mn.:ri i:ii,:.&· ~,he evidence 1 :.::,mpJ.e ovidr.nwe which the (l(.)l..U:'t 1HH3 aocep·Lo,;, t11.;.;.t tui; liCC:J.:CO.i. :.rt 't,i.e timo W8.fJ (i!'i vine reckle rrnly. He wr.rn rec.itlei;s in that w) .ic.:3 t1,:ci v:i.n.i ,,1.t u grc.:-i't speed ,.ind. did. not obse:rve a p:rcl1·ier lookout :i:or otlrn:r· :r·ond twers •••• •t'• \ __j .,,...,.,, ..,.., .,..,,. ..,,.... .,.., ... ..,"'.1.u1:, ~u-- -;;;y..1.,.... 1.1.:.,-,u J.H ttuim:: uu1o

1101, g1:u.:.n, uu1,ui..1., ~ue magiotrcto cencludetl hie Ju. .. ,_,•cnt ~.a follmw:- - .. "It i1J luo cla .. r tr... t tt.'3 t.cc .. ud ,., .• icl uo ;•roi,cr li:• ·: o.,·.; for if l.o ,, u., it h ;uito cb r 1.11;:.:t Hu \ ult. r. ve u.),ico . . tJ1: in·.,:;,,ti. nc cf t1 e . 1:•to.r-1~C(J, "G~1· (r.1, to1 -C;'i clo7) l4! i ver i..nd clo,.-Eid uo1.n. ~ilit· ir.: t\ clo .r c.,Bu c.1 com•,1-..:tc 11'.) __ l i __ ,·nce. ''hc,·0 is (,V(',--·t1lniu. evl\.l_-,t.., O!i r·cc, ..·.l. co•.1,·t in ~ .... t.:.Li°i.J •• t1 ... t tu-3 .1·r·or:cc•.u,.L n •'h: h.ir.: !1r,.voll i i 0,.t E; .if': l'n,1 , r·y L'e...t~cu. ~le ctoul.,t. '.i1lo cou.rt fitJlc', l! c...: .t,,.k ...,,u.:. t. ,ll.,, COLJVit;ti.; •• i..i." Pitu~ill · tLJr~, ii. ,;oul.1 .)ft, r tl _'.t t.u L1 L,::.:.itr •. .:e'c co. c:!u:..ion i; .. :, tt.at t~ ...1 ~ ••.. t,lLr.1. ... ~; ;· :..lt: 01' ;,._·,_Ll,cn~~ in .... r1vi.:c. 't'ldi: :it r.J-intnrcud b:· ti . ..: •;.. ,._iutr.t...:',. t t · • ' d . in coi. :n.. in,; t.·.t: .,ppo.)11 ..r.. , t;ncn no .,id:- II .11.J :OU o.::. ·u C0 .·-.; 1.~;rJ.vL t' (1J.lLi. .... t VJ.I..! ~· ct:J vi t.i....! C _..u,o t.J.t~f'~ C'l .. ,_,le;tur.oi_.ligoi .. c~ on th J ;, • .r·1, vf tLu ~,c0 ... oc.. ~=- _~~tu u~cvo ~kil LDn un~e Jf l ~ nvll thrJ 1' . 'i: .... ;d:· ti,0 ..-.o·t c,,u•i t. J, .. vi's.•,., '~--~ 111.;_,ic,t_.,1,o ..t.<·,.:..·1...,.,.j c...t,u,L..,-.1$ no·l· ·e, . i~ 1 I'IJO 1.

i.1/o'-' 1 .,r· ..1. l'l\ i., , ... l i . .;,t;C .L.1 .1·~" lr,t$ inc_:L·o.,·.. , U:, ~c~; n-. 0\,•1 co, ;.tit .. te ~.•:,1_i;,, l ,')11 o,~c~, 'JI~. .\-!C t;:- 10 1•,•e.l :.t, c ,~·L. L,:u,, •• -i c.:.1.victH.h fJL' c;i..tl:._· .'Lo conc.:o4cd de:~th ~J; rec :1,' :.: o-- , , .'1" u1 . r .. viu ~1u fo .... 1.. , c .... 1nc.-:; b ; ...~;, ...... l,. ho1::•v ", l:?J-;"'J. ~-~.t. :t~1 •• e~ n ..,L1it.r; tq,t 1 dai:,ite t.1~ .,,,._i;..,·~.-, ... ;.l'..; nr;ar.-:i .. fi,• '.L 'th·., ".,L, .... _.,Ji. ,,. 1 onl: 11c-t,li ... :-nt, thiu O.;u... ·-. colll:.i. :n•bcti 1;1..ti:o ..: convic-tioi1 fo,~ c. rclui..:" ,l1'i vi1-l, cor.t,_• .. r. to ::icct ... <-1 • ., 7 (1) of :110 ~r _ i"iu t .•:ttl"1 .. ,uo (C p. ltl - .,u1,;-,. )"7} no J.~ 1 1·<:J :;l; J.lrovi. o- tv".- in :.. ccti or · 4 ( :i) nf i.:.o C,,, i · .lWJ ., .on-.o-.. Ly t .. o '• r, i :,' u.: lra.i, .... , "" (t.1.1, ntlment) 01:, 1,'61!, .Jl\t,H'C•J1 1~r, t,. .J -~>cll 11•i. :.~fJ nlurLJli. .u.~ co:1\ic:Lv.,, t.t 1whree-f. .. cn (3) \!l1io.u re;.•!,~:~• 11 :r:r, ·.i.," n 'tri .l oJ u f'O!'con o;. , ., o j <., c J .,_ ~1L:..: ~ i;i i:. ·:<:ct1 l:Ti, +1.c court i:., 110 ,1 l t l ct iuJ ••. t iii... ...i-i vi. ti-c ct..u.:;::i of' tJu.. ,:~ t!: b,:t i11 c~t:..Bfic.:.l t .. ,.. -t; 110 L, ~~-i.:.·.;, C'f ~•1"iv.ir,I I fl ...i.1;t1.c,:.eq, ir: □ h;octir,r, (1) .:if !3vCt ,. 45 o,~ :- -b j::JG ti.·n (1 j o:, ;,uctlon 4 7, i \. . ,

....11 b'-' l. 1." -J. J .., ..- t .. 0 coui•t to co 1 \ict u1.,, e, uh O1fJ,.co ...... 1.·.u.1.· e:i.t,:_r -..i tho•~ irnctL,;1u even 1.1..,,l,l i. iH, h..is r,.it be.•., ci·; --t :..._ ·1.i:..:t'\cl. :i ~r~·•• l tlj1..,,U{'Jl tLore t. c ... "ID \..\'iUCj!t;O ta~ t tLe ... ~ ~~u, l ,,u., \! ... · .... 1, GiJCed, ...Pi vi.Ju le r·•.i1 co.•t.e.l fo:.:· lie ..~i:ioll .. :1~1~ .. i-t:..: t1 .. '.Leco 1:· :H.• ,.!Viu.c.cu · ..... t the ,J vclii:Jh1 , .. ,• n•:,1u; J~i·,.::·, too L :,t. ·n <;01 \·: ,.<,-, 'uJ lo~,i'!,o._ u·~ .t•J .1,0 ···~~, it ir. ii'l o :jh·e to :1u ...~ .L· frc!,i t ... o rL·cor, ,LCthur tue ro .. ,: i.t t,:o c1;.:-t ,-·liCY'.3 t110 cei.~c,. t occurro, .. 1 r., rc:.t1·1c.tc,l, i.e. a .. joct to t. npc.:1... l..., .. it. lnd Urnr•.J ic C}ViL.o,ce +,,,.t t.o co ..:ti. 1·.lt,.,. . ~1 1, ,1 1• ;:•,..:,.~1. i,t.c· l..._:1t, :..l,.;,c • . o,m-hill, hhic~. :;0-.2.ld incra ,:-o tJ.o ,d .., j ic 1lt~ of r1lc,..t.1i ,... own. In ull 1!..; ci:1·cur.:1_t:: co1 . . ltto~, , ,Jiti1 rc: 1H.H:t, I fuli.; 4_rc~ .. ith tho c •l>r1i•·: i,m ct' lu I' oi.: ot .t1..: :Jttt1r• a: t,.,,t ) t..i noc. bou1.. t,; t.i. r ir tr .. to's ~lircct.Lcu .,: fin . . tr lll~t :. !':il_JJt';:i -:.1i.vi1, 1.. ~1 ,i.L~--l, .• ;~, o,; ti10 :coo.rd r_, i 1. Lt ;• ::: 1 l .m not pur, 1.. .._Jcd ,1 .t I uc ... lu bo ju.i.t.i.fi~.: i:1 c;o.1·.ictintJ ti1e .: ;.011.. 1•. of c.· rel ~Pu ,trivLlL. !'hu .. ~.

,c 1 i. . cco1•J.in, L.' ,.lllo. t;d.. 1'!1.., Cvil\lic•~i )1I ~•• IJ.Cu, .J no ...:,~, L·i not 1 ,;,,__ ,o,- LUL, ->;, tu_, ,Cl, .... ul J.U, i :.t· . .zhoJ .• 1, thv Gen '.,m,ce ir.1poi:1u,.. tu...inrnn 1 i ·.., ;,.:..:i·~ •• 1d1•.(;; • I:f i.110 !p ,Cl l .• it. nut ot .. e,•,d;,o l .1·1i'..:.ll~ .... ..,t..(L,,rn. in C;lci;o:.ty, ho i:. tn U,! r0lc .L, ...:iJ. i'm·t~•. :!. th. .1 ..l, t, l'.J70 • (Pllli~lr :,l. .~.i) JU i,;i.