19960830 tzhc musoma 1

i\02 - !1.T!1G·•-~r.1 . •.uh~1,111-; 'I c: 1·111, c:.,11i": · «' •. :.••; <''I' t•·'.:•; .. '.31m'Ilr.:i? 1-i..'..'3Nl'IJ lfA3illA ) ... .... .. ~ ,. 1m: A1·r0.1mrr ,r.~1.r=.:1/1.1. j: 1 nr.. ·10'.:lt1irn__, W~(J -l--•·· ... ...... ",, j • ftr. ·{-.,.:-ioba. u::,.a cliF)C1~f;j11fi.r.ul "'.ll:'• thn ~onrluol; o.<: ~ho oloc·l:fon in I v:;r iour:1 nF.1p~o to ~!111 \1rou:~l'. I; 1.115 r. p'> I: i I. ·.on i.11 ultir,h 1,,., ,le-• l •1011 n.r. '.fo!ln 1rn i ns firnt ro~Jlond1:,11t ~"d l;h~ !d:l:o':."no·_r - Gr.w,rr:-1 cir:; Rnci,1111 .ro€1ro11•Jo11~ • I no. prr.yol1 rpr o.n 0.1."<lOJ.' tl'1cl(i-~i11r; ,.,,(' c].11cl;fr:m lltlll r-.11,i V:Jl_,t, ···nn on1E>r i for fronh rii.o~ld:onn, nn r,i-,lr.e ,-,,1.J,v',"t:11, t.lir. r.i.1·nl. , .._,ripc•1~:lc11 1 ,:tttil~;!' ,.~r i j -------- !., j ,, I r, . . - - -··---·- .. · reapondont :ms ror,rcor:n l(l,l l1y nr. H .jl. r: ;:-.t·-.-i111 lo, HP a110 t i,'J · i;ooond. -• roa_pondo~t uno r.<~pror-:,-,n !.011 h.v Jrn i ·,t Jt.r, I.,, ,\ I: l:orn~.Y ~'-". .''. 1~ 1~ ·n 'lmtthn. ',_ I Horo not formD.11y frnmo(l, I.ho p-:,~.if;io11 cnnv-011.loul:ly fnlln 1n~<, Lll.':"i:lC I • dofn1n:J.tion ::1:,rl·non-corn_pl:i.-"IIIC'l \fj_f:h 1.:0 ].-u,. :c Will C('lllrl_H<:-:r f;j,c.·0 nnH0r.:-1 (10) in th::i t o nlo.r • .\.llof1'.tio1w of cn··.•~upti_,.,,, c:111 r;n11··•)11!_0:ll1f._l_y bo 1~u•·•liv_!1\()tl :1.~-•-.-~ hro p::'lrl:o, :f;t,oit .!"',

n_r_,,_·;_·11pl: pr-rv~l:fl,,~r• .-,:i1:,_1·,·.1,1"1_•_, r.c,11•~' ,. ,<I .,n;,--,!"fJ 1::,~ orunpO.ilJ11° P~fiod,. which .--:-.r,~ IIT,:110 i11 J\/l~:u. -1( :iv', c,(" l;h;, pr:iHHC;'': r;.1,n i oimilnt prnbticae dud.,1tJ th" c:.\wp:1lr,11 Ji,,1-1,,.1~ 11ldch Ptll 1111(:,,r J1nr.::-. 4(.l), i .,. ( H) oncl pnh of. (iv). \ For tho fir~1t por~ the !'•.l HI; i_('l:1 n.1.lo,~.,:: UH t l,'i.J Orn t roo11011ilo11~ i · whom or{Pnit'od pn~HM L :I th~ ,;en "nr1li norninn.tion no11r<n:011c::in, I.hr_, pl::1cor1 i1woJ V\1tl 11oi11~ w:unod I i ne Tf\iro, ,u~~un,r,:ml, Kt~n?.ur.;u, 11.ln\o.l., !11.u~·r,·.d, •~•ka11n, 1~::1hu, Hlkom!lriro, (20) I Sl:\.lOm'l J{;i 1:1, \MCU'Ombokn, ?\•11'Jn1, r.,,,,; h11, ; 1,\n:lh1 .11,-n, f-1•1.l ~otl\, ~Ii h 111~0 I nn,3 l!Jnn.ju vi11nr:;oo, :H \n f: on\l'On ton r;, i;•. t:10 l 11111 I: r:,f l;)1l, <Jvh'oni::o I I subooquon·t:1:, f'-Odt .(?0d t firn I; l:o inol:• l:o l;ho3o arotHI thri. I: •'.l ~ '.:rC'.C t 1.i. Hlo 1 1 ~r no diaousoion. I l ' I -,:tho ntm<ln oonrHitu~noy ~nrl 110 ~-,i;''Jtl'J~ nf p-~1~1:.lon ,mo lorl in 1:'0(ltiriof; thoroof. Mc-:ro·:o~r, tho potil:~onr,r l<:11 110 1",-r--"•l ,.,vi.do:1c,1, n!l o:,'poood I J1ioiai, flilcomn.r.iro, J·ln:i:-ornl1ok~ n.n<l 11Ud.n1;0 ·::111,•.,;on. H foll l:o tho fl.rat '. ! , . '•. .I • ~ ~ . ,,. ,', :, •10-1 !·. . • i': ,.t ,•• ,i ,._ .. l villn~s, axpia.inint;• tha.t ho ttri.e maroly nn invi toe n11<l

t.h"1-t tho hoet~ 'j :~ . '· ·. were oeleb:.-at'inn thin or othflr oV'an~. in tho nboonoo of positlw ov1d~noe ', . ...... ,, .;I from the petiHoner on thti or.r,ti.1un~t.ion :11111 ptttpoS!\ of t.ho,eo 1,n.rHoe, I ·, :1 I do not foal eeriounl~; call,vl 11po11 I;,:, (l 1<\l1.1nlo tho ,wldot100 on tho 0 ..... ' •,.PP.~_~ite ;eidA1 bul; prompl:Jy 1.o f":l.ml, no J nn1-1 ,lo, l;hnl; -1:ho nllnR"0<1 .. ' . - . ·: Ot'rrupt rilo~ive of f;horrn p::trl;ion 11r.l'J t1ol; tJr:1t.nhl.l11h<J1l, eye~!3m8 ~ilea our own, crirninnl ,.ct1, J.:1.ko cor.n1pl;fon, havo to bo tJrovod J.tl oilivpiry,z-d '' i 1· .. 1)01ond r~n1:1011able·clot1b~-J htJnc<l w\1011 n oornplni11nn~ offorn t10 ovidonco, ,;.... . ' ! , .. ~ ho doo11 j oo ~o tho pro;j11,1..lcn ,, .f h i:1 cnr1n. :lo n,:o l:h0rof,,r0 lcf~ Hi lh ·(10) I 1...~ tho pnr~i.tJo n:t l(un7.t1(r,1J, Jlu11yn,: I, 1:dc:\10,"\, ·t\.lahu n11tl S:\.ln111n ICri.H iI villr.g13 o p1ut tho Sal::unn IC:, H .,r.0:ull.011 1-1 l Jl 110 co110:',<l 0 rod in tho 1:1oe;ond. L ; i ' pnr·t t1s H co.mo dt.e.lng tho on1•1_11nJnn .por.io<l. I IL 'l'hJ Kun7,U{.!U i-n:'.it~· wno l:tJnHf.iocl 11!l011 1,_y r·-r.20 /Llfrod J!Blogi.1~ wh" !I • I, in i:ho Ri~,;1,m1 llnr,l c:<;ll Chn I 1·w111. iln r, l::1 l.n,l l:li•ll: thn p;,.r I::,• w.in orenn:l.tm<l ! 1u· in trobru~ry o·t ·tho horn,~ of 11,,,:,'lmm l(J11oko nn,l 1-1an nl.l:<l111ln11 1 l1,v do]C1gnloa I I to th3 w:ird nominn.Hon con foronco nncl -1 foll o tt,or vlllo.[;tlrn. •rhoro 1m.o i

IL I food o.nd. drinks, I 'l'ho .fir1:1 t r1>E1pc.m1ln11 I; :-t:r:ri v3d t-.f l;or hi.rn t1ooompnt1iod by tho · wo.rd.· ~ounoillor, 0110 Jl<loV11 Choch:-t, \.lhn ir.\n n}f?-, ~.hr, ,mr.,.1 CCll IL j ~. aoorol:o.ry • .\.fl;o:r ro,..,,t, ~1.1,•:nrrrm "l11nlto ~11vll. 1 111 ll,lnv11 CIH1ulfn l;o Jtl'tll:o tho witness to itwito f:ho firr;I; r0!:lJY•111ln11~ l;r, StYlnk. 'l'ho \,Hnouo did IL ee nnd tho fire+. roo1,un,l<J11I, o,.oko rJf hi~ i.ntnntion f;o nlll f<lr ,_,j ,Jr IL -. .P;:'-rlio,mant nnd sotd htJ hf.l.d orr,:tniM1\ tho occ:1sion to mno t · tho doloe;nioEf to tho nom1na•tion ooriforonoo to :')..~le for l:hoir votos. Th., first :L· roepotidont do'niod l:hln in ldn nvli!m,r,o n111\ otnl.o,l tlt!lf; t.hn pndy wnn or£('l.nieod by Ndovu Chnohn t.o coJ.ob.rnto hin ol'lc Hon to tho· oounoillorsh!p ·1 tho pr0vious Oo tobor. J)'.I 20 Solo•;nni Ungonl'Jr.. ICinolco ::inrl Ii,r 21 Lotlh L.. Nnehon g.lvo o-.ridonoo in f.luppor t of tho first. :t:'Ot:11)011d~n t. I ·I...... i_ I doubted. e.nd rojooto,l. Ju l;ho .:.'hu 1; t'l".t}o, tJ,lovu Chnclt~ ia not o. roeidon~ (30) I I L- I., ,. .. .-.. ·.,,, . .• .. :~~:\." ·. .-:.,: :-:-· ·.· ·.... .. ,.. :f J<\JJ1zue,.,, .bu!: r•.mJ,!_011 r-.1: '1',,11,nu -_,p_ 1,,,._,,i :"ul 11c- t"1nnc,11 11.•.~ mlv::uv:,ocl \· f>:- hia n,'>t h,,1:lin::, tl:0'11:--.rl:,•'! nl; hl::i 0•111 ,·:i.11•.,,~ :,.11eJ. homo. jforJ~rlorJt_ l ~ . L hlrt

c)lootiN1 I i wrn .i.tt Ocloh,,r t.!10 pr,wlo,!"' .Y•'~-.l' ruul .it eb·il:m: t•11·. rrn old flmt ;_10 ahoulrJ. F:Jool: l:r, r.'llob.rc•:, l.11:, ,,vont l:h,> fol)_,,11h1:;: i1'ohr~n.r.:r• l I ' :~ T::C,t1 ,:on ovid1111r:;<:, f1·,1111 J''i :,n, '" ,.,,r, !:, f;h:, I: IM!1VI" c·,i.-.c 11:l 011l111J;-r,(·r,,l h.ln I • ·-, I ofoo~ion ::lt h:l.r:1 ~•".:•lnO nn,I vf.n.,,--;o l:IH1 p;.•ov.l.c-1.~r, y:11'.).', F"f20 ifl c. rotJlr.J•Jttt L I of Trym11u. . Th:~t cnl,,hr!'.l::i.011 tr.n r::irl thn 11;_r311 ~, 1,.i. th fc~_rl ,!'.'nrl tlri>1'cr:1 at--l<Jro, •·.· n11( Ju1110· 110.inr,: 11l;.c;1111n n•.1': r,·,,m ., tc:11t1ld.• 'l'ld.n ovld~1100 unn nol: i L..., I oh~.llo 113oct in ci:'o!;~-');,.:.-.;aj 11:1 I: i (oil. ! Nd~~ Chllch~- 11a.r.i .,,,.,.i1:1"vlo 1:11•1 ,, . •r; c,:1J,.l l.o ho a;., •:ho coti=t l;h~ -;ury i mc-mon:t thr,t PU20 11:19 b::r!l.jf,:'l•lr!: · ::,,!: 1.htH'•~ ,·::.~ 110 ':•Horr.,{: tr,~:-.-).]. him u L L alnueh toro,l :--.nd ~• 11:U •l -;-,...:;,.1 1"-;n c:001:~.11;'. tlto ~i.t:·n t rooi,orii1':>11t n.n·':rod ,, \- .) L with boor nmt noff; ,Jr.l.n!rn l'.".IHl :·,lr.o ;_:'.\":) lnllllO,V l;o hV1 <Jri\':n· 1:c, '•I U,n t it W!.8 o:~(fl-nir.:!rl ~i.v '?t:rrn i.ra. .\L h.ln L11.r11 ~o n1>~:,.Jt, tho d1·e~ ....... ·-···-········· r ._ roopondont pxpln.lnotl th::lt l,c, n.-!oclocl t:1oJ.:.· vo~oo :•.!: !.!•v ,_m.:r-c! nordJ,oHc:1 ; ! 5i Dl hi11 ;rloT01100, J1r,uovo1·, 1:111•

r.l.1·t1 :; r'lr.;,c;,11,1011 I: r, tn tnd f;bo.t f:ho pm-ty wns or~niJod t,y HnkrJ16':i. l:11 cN-:r:;rnl.11];\l.o hlr11 on 11.i.i:, ·1trnl10£" ;i_n tho ' Unitod (:'3tntbs. l'o l':>.n Ol!('l'or-l.:11~ 'iy !l~•-.-.. ,r:•n hJm--r,lf, mi 17 lf,":rl:hn ll:-.tn,•:,, (30) \ .. •I Oli :J.:'. :,·.---:'.;).· .\,'.: .,· ·_!':~..:: •. I Aoon for. 1-1h:i·~- H w::s, 11::,m:·J.~· o .u.~. . !•'l.nt ~lf rl1.lt .11r.k.11,1' ,. J.t.lr,croJ.f or,t::•~1 ~ot roc.lll l1l1on t 1.:o fj:·:n~: r.r:ir.1 ,1:'.J.r,r. ·: r::::c-t.1~.~.1;_,_ l,:·,<1 :".':''.'lll tl•r P J:;:-,•:. ·~t~.i:t,~, ri.ny .....: ' 11 !1. 1.r.•1::iJ J.n n,iU; ;:1 11 r Nn,~:c:c I f.fo) :.: ''!1 1•1 1.'.I -~-("l'i.1 l_' •Id !:h:\l;/.'.fi~...: I: !'{\(lf:'"'donb .- _, : S~!!lOtt f{'.l{f'-1C :kJ~ynrn:l ! -· . I I .J· • ..., .,. hold ch 26 ltt\r:Jt, ~1!0 i i l,omrJ o'f '3nr.ruol ~ '.1.\-.; .l.\.'\, .... \ .... c,tton•l/Jct b,7 pot-:mf.~.:•l I r.n !h.fluou ~it•l ol,hr.i:t in l.h<., ".ro:1. I:• rt i 1: l1 :w -<'nrrld,,.•1 :t ,,,,,! ,:,,.:1 alt'.U{.~~orod. r.11~ f,mt1. 111vl ;,l·.•.1•·-: 11.~r1, .r·~c. c"il\r.cl- ar.n-:.n:.:tuUy, p ..~t·ch, i tho hou,1obol.dor, '3,:-J,,wl :r,.,.-d.1:-:-,, ~~.-,.:: a~,,. ,1 ..;, t-.··:'..:1,; Jo:·-~ r,,;: J;:·:r 111 J:,}o" ' ·, ...., -Ill i \ ,-\ooorcli.J1<; t.o tho lfitnonnoP. 1_.tho fhnl: ror1pot1ddH·t· (1o) ,•·· I; I·: L,.. L (jo) ...2.. ,;.• l{)R Jlt> had holpod promoto rm onl:cn:pdtw kJlc,i-.,., .~:,

Vfri•m ('l'1u1;,;,.,.11i.n) J,ir.1Hod which llns poised. to enter l;ho co~. ton p11.1:c;1r:ioo l1un:l11.J1m, no htt(l thoroforo boon invit'1d l:o ti,, t:'.nlc:JCl t,, ur1t• ld.n f11r.l.11.m·,oc ~1.ll:\l th-:, i l· ._:_, gn.vo support to tho cot t.on purc;,::lno l:' l,c.r.-y 0-11Cl naicl ·th•J _r,>or.l ,,i1d ( 10) i ·. IL' politionl. ('l'nnznnfo.) J,in:l.tod w:,.o forr.i:itl r.r,neifi0:1].J~, l.t• JhLl'Clmno cotton in I-lorn. I noeion fl")lloir~.11{-; tho· poot· n.ltcnr by l;ho ;1n1{ <lo f1t110 t; co-l")pcrf'.l,fvu toi:lon. I L. It bonto im~ginntion th,'.1.!; th,l nn1.1:.> c0r-,p,111,v 11cuJ,l s:i.f: hnok ~ncl m,.,'-it L tho work it •,ms form-3d -l;o clo. H hi orcior to' t'J1rlortnlco thrJ ro ;1('.n t:\:1,v l;nllc nl>t>ll t co Hon (20) i. 'i • purohas0, bu·t I nny tho:r.o 1mn 110 I:, :'. I: 1111.1n I: h•wn hoon Hnnn. ir:i. on tho L wooing i;ido b,rt-not tho ol:hor H<'-J' rouml, 3000ml, pononnt fn:r.mors hnvo their O"'n londorehip through tl:oL· prl.mnry co-op0r,\l·ho 1:1ociotioa, 1•·. t.11id nooording to mf25 thoro nr0 fot•.r '.Juch $ooh- t;i:lr1 in ·Trtrlku wntd nncl 1 ~ a inilnr number in Y.nbl'.'nfl WC'.rrl •. .\ny d i::-mmn i0n ot co f; l;on p1.1t'ch;,.r:io . . of thooo nooio tioo but not clolog:;,.tos · would hcwo invol vod tho lonr1crnli.i.n ! . tHo CUJT' momboi·a woro proaonl nt lh,1 or.cn!llo11. n, thio vor~r onno, poc,plo ! -......: claiming to bo CCM rnor.iboro (flVO

ovhlonco for t.ho fb:r.t rl")/J_~ndont nnd nn NCml irornbor P'J'-VO ovicl0nr.o fnr ·liho pol;ll;in111Jr. pn_rh:'..pG ·tho (30) '-- i I . .. ., '.-} .•'' . ,,.. '\:•.•,•,. ..i!,. I 1- ! • Ill !I I I' • I'<, • moot ou,te;tnncHng oxnm1u.o in l;lv~.t of :OH?.3 ,TC11t1·1 lly('.rnon~. )lo in tho I , I '· • Mohnro wnrd CCM oh~in!ll:\11- n.,t.1 " tnotnlmr cif l:lm pn._r.l:y 'n 1Hntrlob I . . o:roouti~ oolT'flliii·too~ yo t thin r.,::in oocodo<l tho firnt. rotlpondont to I . tho NOmtioffioos nt b11r on 3:tln.r.,n ~1l10n ·tho lnHor •,m~t fc,;: his i ' momborah}p ol\.t'tl. m1lll; ,ln y11t1 ,:.11.p1Jot td' vl.l.l1te,,,r11, Hhol:k1t•. pnrl:y- i ·rw1otionc-.rio!J or not, onpooilll.l.;; r1,, ohon tho onctloirm h:-io -tho ndtlod. !' nHraoHon o.I: froo for,<l a11tl 1lrink? 1 f:i.ml 11Hhou~ hM:l.tnHrm thn·t tho first rdsponilont org,'.l11iocd l;ho pr,1,.-l;y ,'.\ml d:l.d no corrt1pl:ly, (10) nominntion nnd o·,1onl;u~J." oJocti.011.' 'l'ho p11i:tion unro oj·,r-.11J.ood irHhJn n nbort open·· botwoo11 FQhr:,.1,,ry nnd 1~ard1 11wl r.hodly, ltt April1 hi;, I ,.,ont publio nnd onncnmco,l hj_r, :l.11t.011t.io11 1:n :r1111 fot· l'nrll•~tnon~. '111000 ...' L P.romji .v. K'lbourou, C-Jv, App. lion.)?. r.1vl ,-p or ·19~)11 (rtn yot 1n11-oyortn<l)t tho Court of .\pponl ohr:un·vo1l Lh'.t t ilh'(J('l l\tul oorrU!) t 1•rno tioo11 ror (10 'I nro nc, longor ouffioio11t rrrounrl~ for nulli.ficnHo·~ of olooHon I L

' rooultri. · It follo11a l;h.'.\t Lhoy tnu!l I; bo 00011 l;o hnvo nffo.o tqd tho L ' ' ~oetil.to or ·t<' htiV'J rc1uloro1l tho ol.octin.n u11fro-;J nml/ox t;,r~lr ns !'on-oomplillrioo_o o.,:- ,,1')1} 1.or"l 1111.no•.,wlu.c t ~• 'l'ho qucn t ion I 1loniro ·to n11mror ( 20) I I in thi~ conto::.d is "'hothor tho cr:-x,rupt octn oot~blloh_od. nboVt> hnd nny '- bonring on1'tho roault of I.ho olooti.o_n., L.... !1 pr~poso to nppro=-'-ch tho ~\l".'ICJHon froin t-wc atC'~dpointtJ tho Hmo . footo·t; nnd tho oopoot of nuhnoqt"!<'.lttl; 1\nV"'.ll.opm:111ta. rt ,-,n1 110 not<1cl thot j thoao j1oots· lloro cc,tnmi Hod bo t11oon · Fobru(\ry nnd Ht:lrch bul; ... tho- .............. olootion . I •. onrno r:tt tho oncl of Ootobor, novon -to oichl. tnonthn lntor• 3ootiottrf 971 : 98 e.nci. 99 9f tho '.'!11.oo+.ione ,\ot 110 no·t diotinguieh bdtHo~n eote oommlttod ! bofo~ or durb,~ tho orunpnir;n flOri.r.,1l, l,ul; tloor:, U1.'.lt monn Utr,t oc>rhTt I • • I ootd 0011r.1!-Hod nt nny tim:1 1.Joforo nn oloo Hon cnn bo I n: grot•ttd for i. (30) nvoidhnoo of -1;:,o tJlnotinn? I j I I I i ... I i ' i ./ •- - -I I n nncl I think ho in 001.-r.-::,,1;, '1.~H: ·111i;-:m,lm:mt .0[ tl•o _pr,,vir:1.to11,;t nijniunb oornwt-·practiooa ia to j1r~toot tho ,v,,tor ~ror.i uo:l11~ umlulr influonciod in"hia oholoo l\l nn olnoH011, Tho JlJ.'ovJ.oi,:,1111 nunur,o th".J o:x:h:tonClo of: n·vC'tor n111l !:ho od.nbnr,n cf

:m o.lr:otJcm. l~0Hl10•JI: n vo!or ·ond without nn ol0r,l;Jo11, nn. 97, 913 nnd 99 romnin; in nboynnoo. Ono t,nn ,doduoo from th:l.n thnt tho ox-pronsiC'll :q,ofo.ro'' in .thooo provisions t f, ' is anuj0:o~ t9 l:lmH;,.t.ion~ H ~n1mc.t ho ccn::;t.r.•tod no l•r:w~.ncr roforonoo lo i M·~a oon¾i,i t tod 11hcm t!,o.r.o w-.n 11<• v,~ J;or n11cl 110 ol oo Hon. If a0moN1O I lloro tod~y tC' th.row r. p:.lr ty. in -,n}or ·f;0 bo oloo tocl in ·tho- your 2000, ho I ' i would aHr:lOt riclicul.o ancl poopl,, r,1J.13l.1t r1011hl: Id.a tt-,.11H_y, 1110 OXJ_lroaalon ! ( 10) · I tnu:'H tho~oforo bovo ln Hs con l;c•.wln t.lo11 ti1000 nq ta n9 m·o::dr:in to l6 ~1) . -··· . i o1 oo Hon.,l oa to bo .-111 np--:1:11 I..i.11,1 f,,.c l:0.t· uh :11 n VC' l:0r "~ tn ~ut to vo to~ ! 'Wo oo.n ptoporly ap,1:i.k of (\JI oloction n11.t rt vol::ir. _l!l.\011 t).I') 0locHot1 I . i::: cl)rl;o.in. Tho corlal11f;y <•f n11 olJ()Hn11 c011n~:rnc,on 11'1011 t.ho clnb of I j I '·1: ti i tel o.:rootH I .on :f.rJ nnno;tn1cocl, :lllrl, in m., vlo1-r, tho 11:;q,rooaion lt-:,fo:ro'' l onn h~vu ino l"crionl ncn11~.1,R l1orr,·,o l:hnf; n1111-,u11corn0nl:. J)1 tho ina tr.nt I i onao, it \""·a not nur~,1rd;,1cl 1;hnl; f;h., rJ,-...1:n of J.nnl._y,in:::'o pnrlinrnontnry l olooHon !,ms f~rmnll,r n1111ou11oocl h,:' f,\l 1,r,1n:r:-y O!° rtnrch t'l1C1 I' Hould nooord.inr.;J.y oily tbn ~ th-, corrurt prnc Hoon o,:,111:dci0rocl in

thia pnd qi ·1 tho junSJrlont \foro too rorno to l;t' lio rolcwr.n t. .! . .\o ro~riln oulJeoquon t (20) l dovolo:pmo._nbt, it will bo nppr<Join tocl (:hat t:,o fiTa·~ ron_i:,ond'<:>nt indulBOd in t)10 illognl_ ::t,:,HvHion llilhi11 tho r,cH 011<1 :fo:t· -tho ptt111oso. or __, .; onpturing ccu,aupport. Di or nli--u~ -tho l.!d:rcl If.Joie()[ .',ur,w'lt ho ···--·- :... rooignod from,-,CCJ.t nn,.t jo.l.110,l Nr,<n--Har,o1.1;,;i, wh.-~ro Ito ,ma pr.C'r.iptly put ohru.l shortly ooo, nlnrm wan fol~ fn ~r.11 oh-cl•l"11 '.l'o pH~ H Elhorl:ly, ho :forfoitod CCM OUPJior~ the rno:icn ~ Ito h1motl hh: h11ok on ~ho J)r.r~y nnd. no tru:> moinbor of l;h,,. ~ 11(\d!• cN1.l.tl n I; .i.J.l vo to fnt.· h J.rn 011 th-:, ~01n_1d only o:f foocl l:lncl drink,; cmir:iur•t'l!l ~Hah~ •~onl;hn l)('lforo. In my jurlp,,ll')llt, (Jo) ,, . .. ..-111 I ...,,,

I

I I I u,,,roforor. l;ho J>~.,r.l;_lqrt rof'111·r•11I 1,,, ln,l llll 1,,,,q•l11p; 1111 tl11J n:loold.011 1! nnd I m:l.lc~ h6 fUt·thor ro.f:•ronco f;o l;hotr1. I· ·1 • Tho I G0oond r~t 1 o.f :i.11.::,f1.ti-J11n C'[ oornni ~..ion fo.lln Jn tho porlod, ! . ti . 9optombor to Ootr>bcr. ·;, r:,rn. ,1( 1) of l.h0 J"' l;t tioi, ,~11wr"U! npo,;oe ·thnt tho first t.'OFJponrl<ml; 00n·upl;ly 1l):1l.-:-lh11l.01l fli' pr,:,rnino•.1 1lr.lnko,. l10~FJ, ... rmlt,· sucir I ond 0 ric-:, to ~lnt·iwn111la, n1111,y.l.,.i., l(tn1g'o1:1h(), Hynsn11n, ~wi1bu, f;n.1.nr.rn K:1. 1.:i, lf,yahunmrl11, t-tnro:::~ok:.i, Hn11ohl.m•.11Jrt1 nnd \ Jctonn,r,m {.-111cwoo, whiJ.o nuh--pt1~-a ( H) nE ..\j~•:o thttt w~1d.oo wro ! dis·tr:lbuf;hd +.o potonl;bJ vc:d:nr!l nl; lh111_y:1.d., :.3:1.lnrn:i. 11 :,• 1 , 1:tl.11.1:1-:-.i J<hH, I K\tnzusu, Mt',rbrandc, Dt•kr1r.o ancl l(u11~~•c1:1t1::, vil.]:i.~0(1. ,'\::; :H turned out, (10) '• ' v:llletGOB nnci T. uil1· confiw, rr.,rr,olf tc tho th.rvo vilJn~o +.0otiqo,1 around 11 n.r.1., nl; U.irf>Go, h~ ottrY.> upon 11. Vl'hlolo wi. th n loulnpnnlro.r himaolf o. Luo'. lJ!J wan nrilc.:,,1 l:n ,,r;:1 I; j II l.n 1.1,0 volt lr:ln m1cl n1111n1mnc, on I tho loudoponkor in L,:o t!i'l t thoro ,rou.l<l \J-:> nn JICC'.t o:trnpn:l,p1 mooH11s nt ( 20) tho villa$0 in U10 of brnoon on<l tho t pooplo r.hottl(l bring r:>CC'J1toolos for sol t nnd 0\1g.,.:.:-, '11 1 0 vohicl.o drovo nrfltmd

f;ho v lJ.lo.go wh!}g ho m~o I thnt cnnotn1com6n-t -nnd ::-.11,: thr:r 11nn :ll lorn~ to J.y n,:,.clo f:h,:, !lnmo n1111ct.111cc,mo11 t in K.iswnhili •.•'u_10lh-:11: wH11·.01:i, r•.-r 1'.:j i,ttcnn 10.nin, ~::,.i<\ thM ho hoard I tho Luo nnd ¥.:trnrnh:lli nnnmmr:omo11f:a but Cl-Jill thnt 111 th(} lnHor t1nt1ounoor.1~nf f:IY.> vlJJ."rC'>rn w11-o l10J11,7: 11:·1p,I l.n t,rl1v:t ,:no<•r,lnolo1:1 for "vitu" • Both trH110atJ'):-I l,:d;or ntto11<lo1l tho m-1ot inr,- bul; thoro 1108 noHhot- ,• oo.lt nor E!Uunr, 1ml: cln.trio1l lh:tt t.ho firnt ron~,,mlonf: npol.,gi!Jod for I I •• thio ond promiood th:'\f: l:h() ltnmn llnttlcl \Jo <lol.twrc<l 1,oforo -tho olooHou. i '1110 fire t !t-onpondon I I; o tn 1:orl :i II h l !l ,tr:, fcmc,i l:hn I: l:lm t!IOO l:i 11r, n I; Uifi',1B'C) ( )O) ! ! L. I; !/ '--' Ho hr:ut ' : i oorlior thrt't mo~1itiC non t 'Jt•.t (Ill~ Ithli J~!la f;o n11:1ot'.n100 ~ho ohOn{s') of ! • • . •. L ·Htnoa mid donir:>d ooo !?1~ rocr:>J,tC\olrm ~ ~ · tho moo l;intJ or no.Jd111J pro1nioo11 for 11ny pr.nvisio11r.1. 'l'hr1t·o unn n)r,,1 ov.l1lc111co fro1:1 J)Hll ,Tonet~hnn L .. 1Coror:ibn.. Irobi t1ho · h11ci th;i t. morn iJ1(J procooclocl to ni~a,, wHh- ·tho dr lvor. Iddl Jumf.\ to nnotn1co ·tho cli;in~o or timoc.:i. !Jo doniod mooHng }".!1,1: L ...,. PU15 HM hir.ioolf l'- l''J:3iclonf; of Kiroroli rntho.t- l;hnn P.i(JOgo • 'lho pctitionor'n oicl.':1 nrgeoa tlv:it JJ',711

·~r.~r:i not in tho vchloJ.o (10) whon it mn,1o r.0111111.11 l 11 tho d 11::,,:-,.., h~c:111£10 l;hn n n~ t roopo11clo11 t opoku -:,f aonding Irldi. ,lwaa ()Ill:;, r. l.ldnk, 11:i.lh .1:i:H1ptict, tho ov.Mo1190 of p,lq auggoata ti,_;,..t l;horo 1-1r,r1 1.10ro l:ln.11 ,:-11..., r~:.1'1011 J11 tho vchiclo uhon ho 001:10 UJ'on i (;. 11 to tho po.t'aon 11h'l hol.11 l;!J~, lo•Jrli::ponkc:r.:" .-in,1 t.Jd.o, f;~ no, impU.011 th:i~ thoro w11a r.not.hl)r p01•nnn, mtJnt prohnh.l:t tho <lr!wr, .I•ldi Jumni '1110 Hi tnoe!J nleo · -,<ldod. Lhr.t nf l;or tho ro,111<l0 .i11 th~ vlllttw,, "·.-ro fb1nlly ,. oomo: to tho 111!11)otina trco" 11horo I .,.. ,fl; thon", . 'J1t.ln ~Bnln nl.101111 tho proe.lnoo of l'loro t.~l<\11 0110 pr~;•oon in t.!10 vohiolo. f!oro,:,vor, DH11 did not olnlin to bnvo 1,r:,nrclod t.?,o vohicl.l 'lt ~farrc:;J.rn'o h01,1cJ xnt},:ir, ho snid that (20) i Id<HI Jun:i. piokod h.lm n~ hin hnurJo f:i:-nrn 11!,(•1-c I.hoy }1oct<lod for Dlgogn, / i 'l'ho !'irst roopondon I; w:in t\tQroforo corroo t in onying thnt ho eon t out i ! Iddi; ,Tuma. for ho WC'.rJ unmmro l:hnt DH11 w:io pick,,d. up on·~tfio 1m.y."· I l'.m i I . • sntlt;Hod Uint J].J11 wao i.11 ~hr:, v·.ll:iclo ~.11,l t-r;ia nprn..:on H;; U,o nnno1moor, \ . . :'1110 quoeHon nr:,w io 1-rhol;hor tllor.o ;r,:,ro nm1,--,,mcomonh• of tho ! I Hr:d;u,t-o olr.fmo,1 li.v y,H 1,1. '11trn:o lri "" <l.lr1p11 to t\'11,11': l:ho

nm1c,,111t1om1:111 b-, -11 :1 tho irt,b<iounhili vorsfon, H ln:l~• uoll bo, ;tg e~~P.-fiod. -~o PW1,\ in LJ ororin-0xnraln:1.1;1.nn, I.ha!; )''.ll,f 110~11: nhon1\ nntl ntl<\cut tlotnilrJ of h.h oHn ' I·_ i • W1knoun t~ 1u11, fo, in1lul6'-111co ho ""-a o::i,_1:lblo of giv::>n hia youihru1_ yonrn. Corrupt ion i:t 1\ 6ri.ni11,11 vory lle;htly~ I fihrl H tn1nnfo t)ll Uv, nt::lt.o of tho ov.l.do1100 to ho1d tho nllo(f,ltion. 31rovo1l nt1<l t.ho firnt nH1po11dont 1 o nllnaod tlpologlo!:f tn\18~ l s it,ilorly lio doub to«l • .. ' '. I L- nigh~ of ?.,1 On f;(" hor {111cl 11:,.n rol '.\ to<l by }''f 10 ,Tur.1,1.tmo Wo b:1.rro. TTo •:1, f:h,111 1,~ l.r:ir, :ir.oun<l ') p.r:1., ho _hc.-.rcl ro-"lri:J fro11 tho n~ t.ho vjJ:l.:". 1 ' ohoppln~ o•.111!:ro. •tu pr"C,HJ<hrl th•_:1-0 :11ul fot111<l tho firiH r<.Htponcloni I . L r~Apo1vlo11I: (Up_p,)11. !,_Ir. ha11,tn ,1111.,-' lt.i•r p:,ol:~l;n nm\ took out bnnl010toa 11 'lf}iioh ho nc:->.I; to:r,vl ln ov;:1ry 1\iroo f; _bn, r,:.._ylng ho hn<l onmo kttfutn ttynyo ~'J. Wnrir:-b;-.," nml, "K"llll.'-tronl ht1k0, ,:ft1rt\11011i httko. 11 'l'horo wnu o. _s l::lr.lpodo i :. I '-- stono,1 in l;ho rr.0cfJf'lo. ilo n11ocl off ir.-rn.::,,Untoly. Di dofonoo, ho"1ovt:r 1 L tho firot i-0Etpomlo11t nt-:•.tofl thr.t ho procoml".ld to H~riocndn to r.ioot liie 1'1 polling ogonto-lo-110, D".f13 ll.--v,ny::iolto 1!Hnndn, D'H,1 Juliun '1nrobo and JJ.(15 Girogui

Dnr:lj<,rn, nnd ,luly 11nt f;hor~ r:-.1; J1f.1) 1 A hc,uao._ Tho:, L m,ro sooing him off :i.round 7-30 p.n. whon a c,t,mo oomo fl,ving nnd amoshod. .. 1· ·. I : nddroesh,g any gt:\thorlng or dinhfJ1G out 01\Y 1:1onoy. tHn wroion \ms L ,eupportod by nr.13, Dlf1'1 nnd D'TI; 11h0 fudhor oddocl -lh:it uhon JJ"f13 .\ooording to m113, r•rlo j•Jmpo1l on hi.m nml f0llo1l him, but. ncoordlng io DW1tf, ho u:i.e follod by n. "yr>u~h", nnd ncoor,Hng to rr.115,ho mtn · (30) . '. ,1 I ·I follod by iln~iri Kiti.-:~J., .TJc l:1 1 ·"\~ nr1 H 11::i,v, ti.my intorvon-:,rt nnd . . ooparo t.1Jd. tJ•cm. I ThoI ·oruol,.,l t1tt.:-!1Hot1 ln wlmtk1r H,,:-ro ,mn o cHatrlbuHon of lnCllltJY! by_ trio :.-Jrr-:I; t"J!l.,0111.lnnl;. :r. r·1tv1, 111 th(l fh:nt r],co, l;Jin~ th0ro) ,,~a: r.. frno:'.tn invnl v in;; tr.:-i!·,', l:'1a11 t ~,,., po:rnn1H1 but ·tht1 rlc .~onoo . wHno'.sa00 ' sought . to I'lity H down. llol; only rlic1 tho,v conlrn<.liot tf. ,·I . . • . l thomrlolvoa ris to Hho -tncl_clocl n•.-r13, 1,ul; ".\Jno wlv>.r1Jf\r:I n:r:13 oi,~.1 t1t-,:-o ' ! n ~\.I wnr:1 ..~o oi."oWd nroi.n1d, l.UI~ !1:l.\11. -1:h::-r<l 11.)_N) L J'l.'PPlc,. nncl ])'Jl5.,m:!.tl··~h<'1-rJ ,11.n:'0 no :ro;ople ,o.xoop t, of oourno, ._, /y~f10 ~nnd. lfodr 1 J(ih~i. 'rhoy nlno 0011 l:rncllo bc1. thcr.i!Jol_v-'O n.s to tho I • j I timo 1of tb::i ·rir:1b roopot1Cl.011t 1 n .'l.1:r.iv;,J r.ml tl0p:-..rhtr.o O!l~l wJdoh gll:t~CJ ..

( 10 ! of t~~ I onr U:)g a1,.-,.__9hdcl. I l d0. not tnb ':!Otlounly do1n,1 of U10£'0 oontt:Ylio·tio1111, /:or +.tny 001Ll·:l he nn hvlicnto:r -th::i.t thoso wit11onaos l ~' uorojnot. r1:d1.1or1 r,n •rh::il; ;o :1:1y, Intl; ])'.11,1 wn~ h,,rclly 0rcvlil1J.~ 1 .tn i ' . nnotl\or rc•:'li)•)cl;. J!.:l r!ll·~r,o<l ~.Int"" Uw 111.r,ht of 10 tiny thin'yonr · ! ··tho io·t..tHonot' r:01,l h.1.rn )CX>,nnn/,..; ·•;!n· 0 t1((h··I'',l1 11:tfoir'J\r 3rtc;h-::i lkl1~•,.f;ol~ i 0 -~nil -~-i10 th -,r 1,nl:.1101-rn r<,!::;_,,n t0 c•,1:-,,, tn cottr t nntl r,! •ro f.<1loc t,v liiouu, Thin s~.rn pornr.n n::1I let he not-or. -\;,:,uchocl tho. m,Jnoy tmcl nuv.:>r 001111totl f.t lml; l1r11.o p-,n b~ lid.,~,; H ·tho· fcl16ulng l_!lornlne,. 'Y.17, n. roor~c·to.l1lt) oB. 111:--.11 nm\ f 1tl;l10:r-l11-ln1r l;,:i th1J ( 20) l'?tHic,n6r 1 e1 nncl tho -firol ro1:1prrn,\,:ml; 'o brt:•lh0ro, <lc,nio(l. BOing on attoh an orrrnd. Jmlcocl l;h'? ,l.(1:':-cnb-:, 1 a c,1111 0011 hrnd lo Hon rrr, ·to uho·th,,r ~ho i •.:= t:1inaic11 -~ook plnoo o!' .10 .~,pril or- 10 fb,v furthor 1,olib~ t!10· oln~m. ·, ,)luf; O'),'On';(4i.l;h •:\ll ~!.nl; "-'(t:Olnnl: tho 11'-'f<moo uJ.fa1onl3on 9 th() crodibilHy of Plf10''ti.:La hr\1::\Jy rlo•iont::tr:,bJ.-:>. I 11.:ilio"-'. ho ~mn itl' tho forofrc,nf; in ,. tho nttl'.olc on n·rt3 nncl ~-\:Jo ~rrn~.ull; en l:ho firn~ roa1_>01~t1011f;.ts vohiclo. bns t., bo npprt?oohotl \Ii th th:?

gr.or:- to<Jt• or.tro in tho nhnonca o.f · orowcl coneiR~'Jd of J)O'l}ll.O lt-.,r:- '11 him hu~ ho coul(l r,o-f; nmno ono ~c, (30) nornmblo a."1~lo ~rnon who p::irtiolp~ ~oil in lha cha11Ho tho. mconHght- L \ • •o1r:···•··-.au>.·•-!rl" ·I .. .. .. • . I . ' I -1 I :i \ " I ,ut I ho cblonnd -th,:,ro u-_ . (:- UOfJ. llo olnimo1l to h,"\VO 111:,..cl.o /.!.'o ot1O olllo bu~ nas,Hro: Yo·t ho 1mr1 n)no to clnfr., ~-hr:tt ho n::-.i-r in bho tlro~ I I roeP,onclont•n oar ·tho t"IT diJt.t}ct clic.1rm.,.n, D~t11 Hn:dho H,'l~aao, nhon I , . . on t.~10 rn:itn:d.nl_ <1,'.lto 1\1111 11lr.h!; nhn lli\:I :•.I; 11'.nt•l11111~t\ in Mlli\1:irn .! oon1J\l;Huonoy oN~p:iig,,.111~ for hor p;a·t:.-· cn111l1cl,'lto. H u-,ulrl l10 '. i tlnne9r"1tt':l ~Cl hol.f.nvc r111ch n u.l.bmn:1 r:1111 l 11\ll 1101; r:I.C1I:: tlto dru1gor. I r·fi~cl tho nllo(r.lHrJn of rnnho.v cliC1h·lhul:io11 ::i.t 1-lc".ri.\.rnmlo not orHnhlishocl, \ ! I 1•: ...; _f'irn~ rospondont fl.ddrosC1od n c,,.rn;1::,lcn r.io.:io-lh1g nt tho v:i.llnno c,n 20 Octob'.fr •. 'i.'ho mnotjJ1G 11nr1 lod by n1q 11•.,j_n;,.!ci K.-:i.11110::-0, tho JICC'?. (10) I brnndh chc.inn:1.11, \..110 op,~1100. -1ncl cloaocl Jt. .:\fJ to1J~:Lfic1l by Iii12_ •· food., . tho fit•FJ t Mr:: 1vm,lm1 t (!.Y-' t nul; Tl-111\ t hn11kncl thooo Hho m:1<lo tht1 oocnolon 0\100000.ful nml lhor:io oho nocoptrJ<l tho i!IVHnt'J.on t111cl promisod tii~t bofoM 1ho ol0c I: 1011 ho

w,rn.ld t,r.l11g t,oor, ·,;nl t, rnignr, - rioo, ·oto.", nnu n,ldor!t "l<urt, .vn ll'!Clt ht!itolowi (or hoipt\tikn11i) huro"4• I oonstrm thio to r.ioiln "n vol.n for f/CC1 in n v,:, 1:o •.rHh i:l r.otm.rcl." (20) 'vc.-tina in 3,"\111~., w•.t'll, nf Hhi.ch 1n1:1,~n l{::tt.1 .l'3 n CrJlllponontt did hot tnl~o 11lnoe1 nn ~:' o~ l.11\u.1:r ,,~. l;h,, 11:1.x I: tln~· 1111 I: 011 J1 ~Oo tC>bo~· • ..\.round!" P'''-1• .t,n 30 O~hhor. lho -:::,.,wl" OCD, p··!~ '3r rtc,.-Jh:l.,l Hohl'.lr.10<1. J{lmltJ 1 i d.rovo to ! tho irilt,,c:;o to choolc ~11 nccur.i ~~- folJ.<'11l11g roports th::1t .... '< olootiin hnd not tnkcn pl nee tho1·c • TTo fot1111l tho plnco ·· ponccfttl nnd. ; 1 I •· d.t-ovo bnok •.. Junt c,ul: of lh,, villn.:;o but bc;foro 1Mil18 h 1mhlrnlt ·ho I S'l~ tw~ voh,olon 1-t\o i.11~ furi,:,u~l;,• :111 thn c,ppon.l to cl:lroo t_'.fot1. H ,me i n ohnoo; and, had nppnronl1y 1Jlnrl:01l ."\l lho N,vnmolcn l1:d.dr,o t.o uld.ch I i Ho iri11: turH for nllrJ tl1or 1110 ltlo11 b. 1110 loruli11g whicllo, n 'l'oyolo plokui1y \ -lihoj proporty of l:h:1 fJrrH ro!1po111lo11I; nll!l tho VTJhiolo ohn(lillrt H., i I \ \ \ '. I I .·, ' . · -I I Ii '·. 1· : • • ·? _n Toyotn T~,iw),:,ruJ.nc,,-, 1i,,r1 i11 th,l 1\•10 c,f'f,l\o ,,,,1:il::innor 1 n O-'lll_l'nig11 I 1•1 tonm. .. Tho oourl \lt!O tol<l t~1~t tho p,1llf:.lnn:i"r b.n<l _Elot Up -tltroo . . ttonr ond tho oco,1pl'.\11lo rooognir::od l;hn.

OCD't1 oc.r, tho.v bt:ldo him to s~op. ........ no di~ nml fr0m l.110 1•lokt1p ju,~p~,tl nut Jrr~ 111:-\rd. Chr.lng 'nng' n oornplnini.tig bi Hor.ly thnt l;hoy 11.:,r0 h 1l11(( ch:inn,.1 :,_,, tlio J;_.,11dcn•.i~oi: bohinu. 1 'l'ho Lnndoruiso_r hn,t n.lr.iilnrly 001:10 ·tn n o l;or ttnd n1n11~ Ho ocoup.....n ts w:-,s (10 OCD o~w EIU c,(ttco or hoor n11rl four p;,.,·ccln or 1:ico,_ In [.\o~· lhcro hnd-ooon ·tho drr.,:i':\ nnrl ~-"lM•~ flno1c.l•~ l.o 1.1:o 000110, , .Somo, ~cr;iording · to ;n~M; · onrriotl fl ~0110!1 t )}N1{F'!1, hr,W!.1 IHHl nr.~;(,Wrl, ..\ :~ion brl nrgumon t n1Jp11od into Um v.,lJ.n"J' tho ollior f~otfo11 boi11~ nppoand. '1110 i l .. oity.r:itior boo~mo no tc_no-> nnd <l.111,JJrn.,m H1nf; tho OCD orclo:rod nn nrnod. . \ · P"l~oom~n with hi.M t,o \10 on tho .,tor+., ''loot 1-10 clio iiko nnirnc1ls," (20) ! To t!ibvin b n C-' tan tropho, ho ordr:ir0:l 1:ho pic'cup :-.ml Hs ~0otla _<3.d.von \ ! . ' to Nyt.u.!lui:rnn Pol :i.ctl T'c, r. I; • \ _, - I -tho \good~ b1lonb,<1 to l;ho firnt ro!'lp-:,nrfont t,wl thoy noro not _dostinod ....... i . ,.~ .. · for St1lr.mo l{-'H~ ! 1 Mugo~a vil.lll~ ~110 r:111hr1nc-i1n11t.ly ~r,Jl,,oin,l f.hor:, :ti; •~1Uvli, r·~•lico !JtnHon \ nn1 i1io ci thor r,0011 r1 1m J 1 .111r,,Hl l:o l):tj 10.chni, 1 Ch"<ll\l\ llonohot olt10 n \ rorHdoni ~f Hugo i~ ::iml who WOG I'.\ 11,"l!lOOllCl.l' '>l1 tho ,,iokuJ>t t.iho simllnrly '

. eubsoq_uon·tly col loo to<l thorn. j i ·" ·- I fire i roo~16mlo11 I; hut Id roil n11L 1:o l;!Jo 1.o tur11.iJ1ff Cffioor, 1100 honclit1g to kuntsc-nan. lLlona,. · tho 8nJ::irn::i Kat'.. r0uto ulw11 H clovolo11o·l o punotm.·o upo!n rot'.ohing tho r,_y.-llnolca hrl1lr,o. .~r.1m1({ tho p:vmo11r,ora won J}?l'.j r,nbriol Chr.itnrll.10 Hho h:vl, n111011~ r,l;hor. Hornr1, ())ID li:1.7, of ~u,c;r,~ n11cl ('. bne of I on.It. lfh-:,11 l;yron woro lv.Jill;_: r.hn1u1,:1Cl, +.t,oro ~rrfro<l }''.t17 llot".{oba . ' _,.. 3inhokll w:ltlt :t11,,th,1r l.,·i·1n ,,r 1.:,,, ,,,,l. .i,l:l..,110.l''r< c;-.1·:;,:li(!,11.-,.rr:1 h1 n11o·l:ho"' ·:1 i Londoruioor. i 11t, • Hhn f; fd lo110cl l,,'\IJ i ·tho:. occupnll'~!:I o <: th-1 pichlJ• tn l:0 l;h0 h11r.1h \IJ'l()ll eooing tho J,i:tmlontisor; i I A glnnco at l;h~ nl;:.kk,111 whic.le r,~,~,,1J.r:,.1 f:IJl.•.I; it h;vl nugar nnd 1mlt. (1c I I '!.110,y oonCi.nr.:tl:n,J l::1°•11 :·.•1,l ,Joi ~,.,.,r,i;l f:11c1:1 :ti: l/y11n111mn .l'nl:l.oc, Jl1,r.l:. ! l.oc6r<~~.11rr ·to J>'l'.J, L!1n11:~h, l;h,J pir.l;i1p ,,cmrp1t11l.r1 w,,:o r' .:c(1c1.1.tl.f:ocl t111rl 1 rob lJod C\.'ld h8<l. to fl :io 1;,., 1:1.:o ht!::tl I for th,"'! .i.r 0.111 n:.• f<J t:,•. Ho I i _; olofr.torl. t}mt ho 11.-::ri rnllov-,111 or 1,1,()()0/,... i11 f;J111 f'l'('(1000. \/hon thoJ• .. i rottj.m'Jd fr,:im th:J hwrh ,-,,fl:01· Lhll l,n111lcr11i.oor !11vl lofl:, Urny fotn1d tho l 8U<f-l,r

nncl on]. t r~.i :in i11m r,0110 nJ.110 11:t::: tt,o pt111c l:11rocl · t.ho ,..., ' '<01".3 roa tidoflo to<l. Ho eul1::1orpJOlltJj• colleotocl lt:1.o w,ocls nt TI1U1clo l'olico ' Stal:ion but hEto not rocovorocl hi,; r,011O:, toclnto. 11l1ichovr,1r story bo ! i ·truo', I 01:1 enHeflr:,d :in J11 the tJrtrlior cnno thilL tho gt.,odo woro no~ tho fi:cet roepr:,11,lrm t 'n pr011orL,Y • (20 •\lthotJ(t!I t1011n or f:!1,, ,::nfl!]!" j11 1,(ll:h i110:l.r1n11f.(1 1101011,r.)cl to tho 1 fire~ roe ~ndon I:, tho f h-11 t i110 :M<'11 f. h -rory a j Gfl i flonn t. J.n t. uo roopotldont invitocl :,io nu1lJo11c,, f;,.., J.1111c!1, thr,,,Jcr.cl thnrc10 111,o propnrod ·., lho ooor.n~.fJtl, Aooording -to tho do f,;,1100, Lh0t•r,'1, f;J,o it1v l tn t.lor1 tc, lunoh woe o:domlod by JJ'.TT, tho oh('.irm.'!.11 nt tho m,">oHn,'_{. llo oiiJ, imlooct, nllurh to tho food for . ' thio Wi:\::i c0llr.01locl l1,y }''.fl J 11ho o Hll n clclod thnt U10 romnrke by IU7 1foro in ndcl i tinn to ·11\/Jn ira' o .i11vf. lnl:i011~ J'orh:-tpn I nhouJ.d (30) I . ,. I 1. .J. . nt1d. tho oouri a:l~ h io mornlJorald r cnrtl.. .tHhough pr:\dy mombor~hip I did tiot• soem to mako much diffo~nco lo mnny o_f tho witttoosoe, i ·,,. I ' tld. e ;unassumit1g yu,mg mnn npp0n1-orl ·l;o lmo1,1 h.ln ,.r,1.ota. It wnr, ngnin .,I oonto~(\dcl th~t tho ,~dnl wnn not orgnninocl h:r tho .firnt roepondont I but b~ NCCn mombcrn. 'l'h::il; so61nn le, ho l:ho 0000 for. H :le oonoistont. i ti'ith iho o·.,.~donoo thn t •ho thnnkocl f:hooo wlto 1riMo l:ho c,oc~oJ.011 i I ' . ,, ,aucc,ossful, . n, my judt-;mqnt, thoueJ1, tho fi.t-ot r,1spo11do11t in hin • I f •1 I ft ff\• • o -,, • • • , • I f • 0 0 , • t O , I ' , 0 'rookl_bntmorm ·f:ur:110,lr. 1tt1 •oc!r111io11 will.oh 1,1oul1l lttwn J11\n1Joc1 ~ho to~t rAr

I I I . . ,. hlldnion!l). J,oopiltllil:y into n11 oh.iont (lf oorrttp~ olootio11oodn!O Lot 1 . ~ ! i ! us nott ro~un, •fo·.tho fi.rnt h1oido11I:. 'lho fnot -tl,nt thoro mia n nonr . \ • • • I I • . riot .Jvor ti1C) <30•da ill tho pickup in " tolling f:1ctor. ·/ 1101-r·m~ny .\ t t lt,a.do~:,w}d.olo)J _mun t hav,:i trnvnrnorl th,.1 l11111d:t. 00110 f;l h1onoy -durf11g tho ,• ! .. . t. oampn{gn t,orHd wHltout nttr,1o~i11~ 00111:rovon:iy? ; . Ar-tor kl vfng tho mat lor duo ~ri.d.'_Eioriti.uo co11nicloratlo11 I hnv0 cnmo to tho c,q11plm1lo11 thn.b tho • I ; f.n~t:.~r_thio m1tw1ml i11ciclo11(; ~.--nn ov1cl<ll1co ~h"'; w,•tla of thnb kind hnd boon ., ·by:Mio· r~b!it.Hmor 1!3 111t11Qn11on.· '11d.11 r.Ucr.-"\l;fon of oorrupHon iA .thoro.fbro de tnbl iaho<l. · _t Tn .¼ho. oHcl, I fi.rnl provocl nir,tinn I; I.ho fh·o t roo{l()ndonb 0110 · (20) . . • ~~- l_f ~o~ru.p(; prncHoo.- '!'hill b,v H!lolf c-11111ot h:ivo nffoolod tbo roeult of ~horJ]octio,i for.OV"!Jll ff tho poHtionor wur" to 110 R.lvuit n11 t'k.-, .'\'5.?..:._":'E-Jfcl _vn !:nn cnet- n t tho two poll h1::; ll 1:ot .to,,a· n b ~nl.omo. ~t/, ..,.J ~ .... tho 'first rospo1vlonl; woul,1 oHl.l nmo.tr,o tho wfonor~ JH,uovor, tho not · ·.boing n oriminnl offo1100, H w1J.n _;_,._,y;~ 1.,1tlblo wHh n- roJlr olooti.011 ..ns. ' I · -onvien~d undor j;ho Conr-1titul;ion r:lnd tho ~loctionn- ,'.ot, ·· l: Hill Hioroforo ··,_.h.nvo·ooon~iQn_to

rovorl toil r.t I.ho opprop:dolo etn;-o l~tor • .But beforo I lonvin«t. th!ri pubjoot, I think ,_I; ht c,ppor~tn10 ~t ~hi8 jtu1oturo to ooneidor ~ quoe tion I lof:1; t.o Iooniod oounnol, nncl lh!'t in whothor H is nvtiilnblo in thio p.t~coodin~ to ;,.,1.iurl~ tho f.i.rst rospondont ( )0) 11 gttilty" o_f',o_orrupt pr:101:lcon. Mr. Ma!"rmclo ~rg,.i,,_"Ht ~hnt H ict 11ot nvn!lnblo \ ...... I I 't.., ' \\ I ·- \ I I b,Jf; thtlf; g\loh n flooinir,n ot\n tirir,o 1111Jy from n orlnd.n~l prosoouHon r~·:t- \ . lnktHutod ltt l:ho npptc,prinl.e oc,urL nr. N~mjkunn lc,ok oonn!dornblo \ l--: '' I. I' pntno on thrJ ,n:,.Hor n,,,1, tihilc 0()Jl00(lillr. thn.f; Udo 00tid "le t\()f; i ! . oo~of;ont to convlot on;t )'Ol'0".'11\ C'tf n CQtr11pl: 11r.nctio~ or, for Uint ~· l I \: rnot'hox-, of l'..l\y offonoo," H io- 110t o:icl\l1fod 11 t:ror.i 1'<.l::>,ohl!,a ~ fitulhtg !' ! ;-- irt t,111 t'JlooHon J>OlHl.011 Him lido c110; thnt; nn,v pornon htttl 1'ooh ..: ru,d '.1 h::i.v;o juot. tn'Jdo_ th.1t r{n,lL,g, lJ1.H ho r,oou oh lo nrgoo, toriuourtly ht t;"ty v:l~u, thr.t tho ":t11rocmio11 "i11otJnl rrncHc,l_" in o.11'1 of tho ~lcotions .\ct inolurlon "ct1rn1pt l"::icH:::;:i'' :l11d, thor,,f0ro, -U1'.'\t :U ~El ol>Oll :to tho coud Lo cifrl;Jfy n (J0r:·1.n·f. J-.t·r1otlcn to l;ho J>lrootor of (10) prooHooo Oro npootflc:\.1.]_y no 11:-nn<\ \lll(l<lr l:hn !.ot. ~ndlo oci11!Jld?1:fo(t "illo(f-'l ~rnr.lJ,,0

11 In I.ho (ll\110 of .91111,1:\111;;'' v. !Jup,~ /J9oy '.l'L~ 12, tho Court ot ,'.ppor.l nl:nl.orl l;hn.i, 11 • • • nol; ov-.:iry offonoo or conhovo11·Hon of tho proviolona of tho 1':J.oo Honn ..\nt, 1970 n110U11 ~a' lr, nn "illo,r-:"-1 p~ctico 11 • •'Tho oxprnnnto11 "illo.;nl JH:act.lco" 1:10::I; lJo ·confiJtod to tho .. opooifio offoncoe or con 1.ravc11 I: ic11n o:cpror:1~J.y r:() •lan.cr i botl •" Al thouah tho Court "';'CJ then OC'lll!'l)()(Jr)JI_.; tho 11r0vinio11n c-f n J.nu oinco ro1,o~lol1. ( 20) \ it ie not irrolovni,·t thnl; :l.llo,_r,:,-1 :incl corrttpt pl'"lC Ucos ::tro e.tnilo.rly \ Sps>oifichlly I stated • urnlor tho 11rooont lnv. \ \I :Dr~ Hwnikutm furthor 0\10.,,vtHl lhnL corrupt pr:,.o Hcoo woro \ 1,rovioual\y in~Ju,locl uncl"r n. ·11,1 a,v.1 l:h.l11kn f.h,'1.1: :ti; uan ,luo ·fa, " loginloH~ 1~pao or innt\vm:-1:onco thnt tl1ol• wuro not roeloro,l :ut tho \ ' ;. ootu-oo or\ tho 1995 O.ITY.ltv1mnl:o. Iii,; ttrgomont- ir:t -thnt it oc-uld lond. io ! c. logiool ·'.tlbsurdity f;o o,cr;l 1.1110 con."opl: prnc t;Joon fr<J1:1 lho 1:ionniug of l I 11 illotrll ~rno Hoos'', for lh:i.f; trould nonn or.ipouori.na tho court to • • \ ·1 ·, : .., dioqurtU.fy; n poro-,n ~ho in GttlHy of. nn :lllv1;nl p.1·r:l'l l;.loo ohilo . . \ '/ \ --1211 . "who io gu.lJ.ty or n11 illo,::11 pr:-.ot.lcv:, cor~niltttcl ocrr11ptly c,r ;tif;h ,: I bcon r,r.c-vo'd o.nd (:hon procoorln to

c,,,,vi,::I: !:ht' ro~r,,.,11 ch"r<;•1(1 ..w.U:1:· th-, (1~) prf\o·l;ttJ:-. ~t~t ;,c,I: :'1'."l1:,,I;,· "'""'" ii: ,1..,t,,1r11i11'.:n ::11,.~t a CP:':'c:•pi: ~-:-.·:-icd:.lco I hna bo,:ir. cio::1mi Hod. Yo t .l I: ir.1 ".l11c, .l.11 f:~!.-,H; I: ;_'.1,:-: I.,:, rv, 1::-, t/-.-::. ~ tho j . : cone:.-,qu,::n~c,n of n. Np0\·t tH1tl.0r n. 10·1 n;:o i11 m, iny !l:1..rmlmi.1•~~ to tho oonrmG_•r,n;o~n of n. c1.,rl;.lric:.1t;j_n11 u111lc,r ~.-11'1. I nur::I: nl!?o flcfodt t-\Y ! i unh~:ppir.o;o':lwlf;h t.ltr, rn10 c,f l;J;t:1 o~-;,_,,-,,n1d1m ''f.~.1ill.:1" in ~-11'1, for I • i ·thin, ~o/:iy titirl, i.o c,,i,co!.1itn,~t uHh a c 1 111vi0Hn:i. i'ho ococ,nd m~•.Hor ; ·.~ _o]}pnron~.i~,r C''K!.·loolwrl 11y lor\rno1l cornlflol J n t.1'.P,I; rn11br ·tho:· Bloc Hon a I I .~o·t illrJt'!ll -:-r.:.o t,:loo~I r.ro ,~ i 11:>r cc,!1)''lrotl ~(' o"rrtlp ~ \H''-'..O Heon I I • . ( 20) Ot)cl H '"'o.1 ,,:s,J. bo f~'!: 1:hin nclrli.1:.hn:i.J ro::'.~"11 l;hnl: llto lo~loloturo clid j 1;(J not soo ;H fH h, :coq11l.i:o l.!10 lli.r_:h Co11d/ cnr.llry en th~ l~Hor I'.'" tlm I 1Jo.sia mdroJ.y· ol n do tor.·ni.11•'.'.thn. F\:ir tl,-.,~o r.:>a~c,11~, I '-'·"' ,.-ol('ol:nnf: •. I ' • to holdi-l;hat~~h<,o;:cluP.j_,,n of.corn1pt pr~ctl.00!? in o.11,t w,a n rorntl~ of o l_ofso Ol" i.n:'i'.vo:rl:cnco. I hrwo n.b:::rul:t fow·,ll t).1nl: tho' fi.rsb o~fonco of ~tirH-:-:-.• ',. fr tb tho off,iot th,"lt t'1rJ

pot.~_1:.i.on,..,,_. :1:•.11 pn,:,~,. '?'fi~.-}o.h~ ~'.. .::1o_r!1l,,or of i Prrlintton~ "·"'l llt)IU!l IJ'l!lll rlln'of a r tVd. ·llcaf\WJ. :,)JI n ;•tt1.int, Ju i 't110 cou\·Ac ,:,f -1:l,o trj:.•.J. I r0.,ioclr.·l f.!,,, r.011Hon of ; . .\Jns, r.o· H ,m.o no·t I • EIJ~ooifioolly nllo,3011 t11 tho 1•otJ.l.io?1) nr, :t i\i,l with nl10,-r-,Hom1 thnt I U\o poH·Hm,or W,"\n i11c::ip:1hl•1 ,.,r !!II,\' .Jol· :1i11l r.1,ol-:00 'fttt•fouo1~·, ·tho~o, I I • -t:do, t1Qf. bainf, .h, l;h:.i pl,1/\11 i11 1:,,. llul, · H .l~ :ir•p('~rr:ifbln l:o clo j\t!.3 Hco ' ' Li tj tho .ovl,lcm0·= iC 1 11:i.•l 111,t n:;111:'i,m ll,,·:1,1 fr.r .ilr.rnnl;. ~\.-O:':Y td.l;no~o 6)\ ! i . . •I·, th\.i.G ii10-JO gor.,rncrcl onwn:- 'I.~ l;11Jt1f;it':1 t!·':11\ i!, 1,nrHotrlnr. Mo1:-o~vor, '·: C I . n}iJ,,:\U~h 't!!O p~•til;i,·,•1 1.d:,,tor-1 l:h'.\I: l?v, 1lnfnr.i1l:,,r:1- u0r-:lr; Hol'c nHorod {'10) !i -~ I '· :?,lr,os t t!u:-ou1hnu f; I; he, c•.,)11 I: l. I; ll,'111r.;.·' ,_. 10 I'-~ I: :i I: j_,,,,.:,.r t:rl 11:,~~d l:n '1)1· l 111r. \ . wi~11oos::in fror!I ,r.,vcn vll.l:t:~1d ,·:tl:;, ,, ''•"•J~." '.!\:il':H1·.i., ll•,:i:·a111J,·+:r1., \ '. ...., 11:?.r:iwl:\rycln, 8,:,J.,,.::n f~:.,.I: i, l(une;' cw!m, r; :. , . ,. ·:::•n·n :iwl tty:- nr.11n. l;H ill I ~011\:J iclor onr.11 vi.l] .,,.,:o ~-" l:11.rn. ' rnooH,,a hold nl: fira·t ro!!pon,lonl rrnrlo no N fC'rm,c.1 _I.,~ l.!10 pc Ht i.onor :an hie

~pooch, which ll11J uitno0t:1 tl011io<t, ThrJ rkfciv::,:: nltio browd,l tm. W C.'hn.rlM !<irontJtl (20) not orono-o.:-::mino<l ~,,, t.ho dnninl. 1 1.:.d11k, llil;h rciJpool, f;ho ovldenco or tlro_· ol:hor,. t111d -~ ·.•. T!to r.\.'.l<', Hllf! /\ t lhr.:t!lhcl:n 11:iri n I~ •,c11<l(lc1 l1y p'l9 llr; 1 fl113 1 o Karn.ndo ,, who ol.Ainod th,:if; :In h i.n oroo,1h 1.110 r fr-,,; t: r,n::11,11irlon t n:1:l,1 c,f l;ho 110-f,if;iouo,•.tl·•n.t lt,1 i,.,,, 1:1:•..,, n.111 •~•rt _:_ 11 l'1t·ll!ll'1<111t, !'.111 ripoolnltiy wn~ 6:isnrott.o ·~111okL11,t •'.\llrl r,,w ·,lJo r.1::1 t,tC-'1,')!"il;, r.rt)l'l ,\.[NJ, M:,rr\!!lltokn "1110@', I 011p-,iulo,t otti b~fc-r:,, incluclo~ i:ht> l:J. ~~n~oj:l of Tli.ao~o.; nn<l i,o la,ow from n· · i; prevhm ·L oont~xl -thal tho fi::-n I; J'.',') fl ro11,l1m l .-.,J.-1:;:--:-. "l~•)c1 r. t:!C'•~r till(_t !'\ t n il)OGO till ( 30.) 9 3optombor Hl!lch . . ,i ,.,, .\i'l tho first! roapomlont :i.<1Jr.cr.notl t,nl:r c,:m' •~onf;ln<; :11, f'i:\r~.,".:,lm, i "hioh poitih to tho 'HgtJf?> r.,r),: ~ 1.n~~ 'l'hl"' v;lr)lf i:llno fin1n nuprC1rb in I tho o•rHohoo of tho firR t r7cr0111lon t "'"' !1 t:,l.orl lhn t nf tor JHr,ogo i l., ho uont o~i' I to 1•Jrin~ti, ~\ nolr,!1bn1:d.'1G vill;lo>• I'..:, cou).d not b:-iw i x:, hir.nod ~o ·r-tn:-nmuok"· Co:r y~ t .~.no Lln::- 1:i.)n I. l:1~. .'11d ::lHh~,1:_;h 1.-;n,i soi.cl II th:1b ho tlld not nl;l,,.)f',} ··:nrmir. 1 ,1

1a~(:t:i11 1, rl; n~rnr:il,ok:l h~ 1:ilght l'?11 I htw~ rno:ln:b lh.:.t: f;l_\oro w::,r:, n-:- r.111,~h ol;hr.•i: m,nt.111~. ,\1:11111':IJ.h<I;, -1:!:orb(ol'o, ,. t:ho·~ ·\hoi, 0 11~0 0110 '11!''°' H11,1 :\ L Uarn11l1okl :i.1!,1 .•~ '": ~ H. "'.:.•.o .• ~!!'-:, ,111£-f~o 1 j ,J mo~ti~<J, ~,o hn"vn w,ro ,,v.i.1l'lllC(I r:f' wh,'\I, \Iv, l'.lrrl~ :roct,:.•011,Jn11t: allonoclly .,:·•.:.-eb.{ecl"th~ro~···;..cc-,:-di.nn: l,:, r·r.1i1, :,-, nr,J.rlt •1 (10) i. •·. i: ..., : ,'\i1d nonortt1i1~r, ·to r·rt'j, h:1 nr,J,I, 11 ('r,,,1 ,tia) hr,,t1or,.l kf\7-'.I.. lll\/!IUOlli lm:i1nl1:t nmokohc1.(1nn::i? ,'.n::,.11,_, w•. -i.k:1 rn ~r:,k.-.. ti 1-:0111) b". J11 r-11l'J Hal tho <1ofonoo lirouaht n:110 r.n,1 n·r1 I ,1,111:i.t1t::11i K:'lr.cmh,, Ir:-,lii 11ho <1:ml.otl n11y ouch 8 t:'.' tornon ~8 •. ·, l ~- havo onro.~t1.1ly o::-'-r.tlno<l Lho o•r.i.,!oll'.:•> :\n<I I th~JlY.· two fr..o lcr9 '. . '• b~lio thq_ dofonco. Fir11I; ')f ':\Jl, Hr. rf...~nn:lc 1 n cro1Js-o:;cn1~inhtio11 ' -····· ··-···· ...... . i· r ,. . ; . nHor.q,t to' jU3tity ·tb,,t1. lk. >brnmto :'lokucl P:f9 whothor H w.\8 dofnmntory- '' i .,_ to sloop:''·'.ind r,ot hlo nnmror l.h:il; i I: \l:\r1 ,lnfrunnl:,n•.,, J.r it. r,,J.ntcut to ... • i d.:1;.eH11,_,,! lht'-t ie, "orkiJ1~ hr•tt.rn. J11 ,~11 ~thll'tpt l.o nho1-t thnt tho i . I poH·Uonpr woe ln;,y 1 ho a~iJ, nokcll tho ~,11:11000 '1!,:lt <lovolopr-1011~ ho· ht\<\ I

(30) broUg\it iind tho wHnonn ropl.l:~,1 that; ho hntl oocuro,t for tho villogora 1 I I U!JO lond: uhioll 11~0 hoin,1 ~n~rrlotl \1~• ::t!• in'.! J.vl'Ju,,l I on'l rtunoH. Mr. ltnr::tnd,o ·, .t -· . . .. ,. I .., ., ~-' • I . •· . .... , ... ··•·'• ., :, t1oxt nal:on PH1,1 wh:>t:19r 1:110 1•·)tlf:in!101' ltJ not i11 f:lr,t t1li111, "hothor I H 11nn ~ff,in!Jlvo l,o r-rif,,r 1.n f.hlr., r·.01. :·.1111 11lml:l1n1· l.h,1 f:1.rnl; r.,r.,1,onrln11t 1 mn not cm1p'.lr•'.llivoly 1,l.l"lJll, . .i.mpLv.1.ng lh:,r,>hy th:,t thrJ ffrot roo1,011dont '· I th.lHk tltt:\'t ·_u·~:; nn J11 fn,.,.m,.10 1h:"\1r11 b,y I.I!., wlf;11crm'ln, ;(t1VOII ·tho I nc torious O.T.J'O:d.0:100 ti() ").r.o c-.;0 i.n,1. Uu-i:-w;h, $occ11d ly 1 : !;Jmro i.f:1 ·tho '. ;:_ thf.\~ CCI-I oldorr;. fr 1 ir1 ?1111:q I.:•., ,:d.1•1:1,,. :·.:i-J >fr:1::1u·m.\ •.:.-,!',lr:t r:,:, t n,I: .~ho hono . cif'F'.121 llynbo:;011:1,0 HtH:,'',O f.o 11.l.11c11'.'lr:, (\•·,,,;i,~ •~•.h•,r l:l11nrJn, ch:,r.;.;ot.'1 l;}i:,.I; t.ho po_Htion•'lr \l:'.rJ )J••.,.,y n111l ril.opl: in }':,r!i.,~-.1.10111:. '('l•.o 1•-,l.tt.f.tmor, \ll,o I hr.11 till than not conr,:mcu<l l.i•J c'.l:.,p•"l ••• i.,,.,,, :~~11 n11r.n:1011ot1 '·" th'J tnoot iH(l' • • • • • • • •• • •• - • ••• ••u • • (20) I i.o lhoi offoot l;!,:1... nl: n ,,,.,,,f.l11,~ 1101.,\ "': L1,,, vl11",-,:, !:ho n.r:31: I I 1 rolc!11on 1lont <l.ocl:~t:::·.~ l,)qf; I.I:•> pot.H.1.rn•Ji.'

c•.11tJ.,t m,1: tirlnr, 1l:wJ:t,,pr.1011l; "mt ! ! could :dio t\Jcy- rnni:i-:1111, 0£' .,\]1):;. lh> 11.ttl 1wt Givo tho '1f")cHj9..0 t-f l:h.u I i r.a-:,oti~g bu 1; t!fot·l'J 11 !•.n nr: •linru l:0 th:,t a noo f: in_-:i l:or,lc rlt1.co. I i,::113 i t ..... o.loo goHinr; soopt.\cnl 11.l,l.h f.l,o --llC'!((Orl ~l:'ll:'Jr.ionts 11)1ioh nppon,.-.,tJ. I I r • 1 iko IJiOl;Y.) t.?lini; ,;, f n n '.-:,ru,:, l;y:,o :itul l h:wn o:•.):llor <lC'UO 1:otl r:r. lo b-:>oaudo or' hid . rol:) t.-, 1.:,0 ::wcnl.e of 2'1 oc tohor, 1urpriolngly, . ,. l· ' thoust,, tho uHnooo ""~ t\l')I, oro1J11-0;T'111i11ocl on thin 1,ttrf: ot•hiu ovidonoo. i lforoo~or, n IL' I .,,,our~,1 ,. ,;)ir,10 ·J. :'I fcncn ,:if:nonn:m, Jf.f. 13, Jf.i1,1! nncl D~ff 5, 1-ibro I • onllod from' M::-.rt~,:incln, t\0!:) o/." thr:n 1n.o ~:ilorl l'.nyUd.HS nlJout tho first: ()0) '· . ' rospondon t'•o cnnp,-.iv, r.if'lo t.1:-,r... !:Jnco 1""11(' wan I.Im~ unol•n1.lot1~d, ~hon • ,. •· -· ' I ! .... -· 12., I : I.... ho <>oul<l hovo boon, cm Lhin nn•H'<' I lnvo t0 ho.l \.,~ hfr, nm\ rh,cl ·l;l,o o.11,,,r-i.Hon provod. . ;,-· ~ . 1H th roo_,xrd to 'J;-il:,in:\ I(~ l;J, ovliionr,0 .c11mo .frcn }-'!I 12 t-iyC\kNl((:lr-' llantos~ to ·!;ho. offoob l;ho c,"\111,ntr:,1 1n-1t1tl11(!: of ?.O Ootr,l,or, I: 1;,_,:il; nl; ..,...; tho first ro1(po11<1on I; docl C\I'Oll I;!,:-. I; tl·.o p:; 1;i I. .i011or nlocpn in Forliomont, rL, eUffore fror.,

AID3 nncl m~.v •.l.io ~•w 1:ion<m I;, Th ir;: 11;.ln_ clon loc1 by JJiTT M~rirmki. Kr.,nrlpro ,-,ho ch".iroc1 tho rnotJ I; lnG• I l,r.vo otlrl :lor f<'Umt U,r-.t r. I : P'f1:! \fl\lJ; 0 orodiblo "i 1;110!111 ~-11<1, \ll,r.t lr: JlltJt'-,, ho, ·\:po, W\O nol; L '---- oroes-oxhminod on ~hio pt:1rt of . h.ir, ovltlonco. I l;hinl~ ii; 1m1:1 nn r.ftor.lhotlf!ht rI . ' L to &0t JfH to dony t.ho ,"\llor,::-.t i"',. ~lho:1vo1· ~o:,kn ·tc, ohnlJ.on{r) tho ( 10 ) I orodihility of C\ uHnor.io 11\lrlt rlo :Jr, ~,11,1, I.ho Hi tnoo!1 him!':olf bu~ .t\ot I ! L tnoroly ~y ot'.lling \fl ~ncrmor: 1-11,oric, ovi•lonco ho ha~ 110 c,~,por h111l t:v,,. to 0011 t-rovort • ): etill lmJ.iov;J th!\L r:fl?. 11,:irJ h·uf.hful ::--111.l fiml Lho I -' I L o.1lognt~.on oal;nblir:iho,l. !' .. 1,. 'i I uill donl "Hh Kunr£'cnl10 l\11cl L I i ,roe onlilod by tho vutHi•)llOJ: for \)nth. IL I i \ L: uo. Dnl;1ro f;l111l; on- 2_!p 1-,pl.~1n1"1r Ii,, l\l;l.n11cln,l l.11,_, 1111.1<11.inr,t :tclr\r,onnocl l,y I tho fito t roopondont t ::,. m00 l:in~ I ' L i ' ' onotho~ in tho nr-~orrv,nn nl; 1{'1111,t'nnho. (20) .I i .! rospon'.iont doolnrorl t.!,n.l; 1;1,., JJO l;_H \nnor W\O lr..7,,'/, C\ c .\(1,~ Ho etnokur, L i ., I .\ ci1oopd: in Pnrlillll'lon t lJ11t •ral:on tip w!1011 I.ho \t,d on ( r.f 'l'nnf1'ntikn nntl :j ! :i .•I Z.."\ll~lb;nr) f's rnon_l; iono,l, cloo!l 110 I; h•'lVl'J n !louno ::t L h0mo but oloops

in .~ 'i •i ,! L gu:,o·H bouooe·or C\I; priool;o' fl\1/\rl;orn, ,.,J wan Jnfool:011 "Hh .\l:DS nnd could ..... ·1 d.io ony mom-:,nl; nncl occnr:iio11 pr,,l1l-:,1r.rJ l:o tho ~lcoLC'rnto. Tho clofonoo :; I I :} L oilllod. ·t>~r 25 Thunru1uol ll,vc.1:11,irHi llt\on:l.n(f' whn cloniod ho<1rit,g ouch uHo:roncoo I.... rotnnrkn tro:-:-o r.nld.J1g tho n•1111,1.n,- rnr ho nl'.\ lclt "'l'ho rounrkn lruro m;,,,lo I up by ovor~olous fnna 1\1/ny f:rc,r:i r.i:,o tinn in oJ:dor f.c- 1111 tnr,oni1:10 'ilnr.lot,n L hnc\. ltorrnlro ••• 11 '1110 <lofoncc c:l.11.o•l nc ovlclonco fx"om tttnrngur11. A (30) . etylo

I I I I.... pol:lorn o.nd. Lio rovo:,Jo,.l, tho r,riHorn of blurth,g out acurriloun roforonoot' whonovor .l~ 1•l•l'\!'1:,,l 1::,:, rh·nt 1:•,nj•n111lonl; l:r,,. 110 oo. tl.ln I ,.• ' .... I ., r; Tho r<>mnrk "'' th6 UiHoti \ in e.inut\l.'1r r..tvl lcil.l~, no in i:h,) rcr1:-rl: n!JouL;~lm poHHonot hnvinl{ \ n,., moiclo1v10 •.. J. n 11,J 1.:10 "1.1.<:.--,,,,,ior, :, 1; 1:ho l:ul, :., U lr"'-~po oil l;nlll :l~~1od• \ \ JJ1"-(Pt tho f i.r~ I: 7.'~ R";'."11•.inn I: ,"'-'.l · 1 r;wr:~)l\ r. r:i.::~ I: :lllG ,i1~ th.:: v il.l "GO on • .. :: • I I 1 l., ::L I ;, \ .. ···-· . '.,• ~2--:3<.Jpl;or:ib,,r .:\tvl ,.nj-t l.!1'.·.I: !;!I,:: ;-.~:ti t..lo11cr "ni 11c:·)!1\;o, :~11a~:l.!1~in J)'.t.11goni, \ ',. \ fll(_;()lljt.1-t \l'l tJ:'.J!-l'nr !:ld !:.,1•i.lin1,.i :--.t:•.lrnr:-.., 11.-,.,.-, !1.;''.!!1b;,,."\lc~.j~ U.15.jini (to \ . \ kw.-\Q nu:'.1.1.:,J:a n-,,,,1·,.-\ :::· 11:'..'',.!lt i." \ . ,, I. ..·• ... :~ : who :,;-ofut,c:~l _o·r,1.·:•·:1,.i11it n:,.i.<l hy I''.f2;>. ·, r~ n111:1orv~1 i • . .. tl\or:io '\ ~'i.tn,-:1:r;~r, :,1v1 1 I.'.:, ttl: . l''.12::> H~G to toll his .:i~llonr.<>' ulnt hu w,,.iJ:J <lo fnr. l;!•c,1.;. Tld.~ .:,11<1('1'l;:f.c.H cf: .. -·. . .. - -·-··--··--·· .. ·L·· (20) ,;,.~ fivo vill•....pF.l. n, l.i:cfr f,ol.:'llil::; l.hn:;r. •,;:n~:., -U·,al; t.ho p.oHHcnor wnn l'lzy, al -:>r-t 111 Pv:-1 i.n1:1cm l, 1.~o i'O~•r. .--.:1,1. j_ n:--:-:1;-•~·,wi lj]:~i' to

n.ffQl'1l .-i ,, ,:,f n 13i:~~<m,;~d; 11ld.r.h l.r,11,l:1 f.o lr,•-111· /\ ~,-~r.,,11 ~.n tho l')nl;J.n~tl<'U <'f :l'i(.;;lii- (30) I I l~ I i L I! ·- <le:;,ict:od l.::_::1 '•!;! . i..,:-:-,iri:-·~•1:1U1J:1 --!1' 1 J 11ln'"1:.:p:1l:0•1': ·•.11,t tinl uni~~hy the L '-....,· 1.· I L ... -. i '-,.J L lJ i L- L ,. ( ~) 1'!•~ t•).oc L i0:1 of :\ r,;1:::; .1: 1.. •.1:,-:i -'\~ n r.1~11)10:r ( 20) IL ~!,::-.J.1 i.10 •hol~-::-:1d v0:i.•l nn.1.:• i·.'11J.r.o l'.1,_y - .. . '·····-- ,:.f l'~:1 [11JJ.r11j11r; .-~i:nt•n:·, .t~ jH''.lV')<l I:,:, t~.1') ,., "l \ .b r ~c ~ .I. ,ti , r . l;l:o ~01 '.".' I; nn,1 tl!l ltC O !-,1~1•_; ,~?_!:01:l (•1;1 r,r.ir,hanw:), !1:•.11cly - ( .... ) ~.- ·,.1;, ,11tr~.11,; f !!c, <:.I.rt~ I; .t<'l1 nnn1,=ii[J1 1.1 I:~ l.cr.1~111;::, •rc.-;:-o :;1. ·.:' ,; h~r -~he l·i!l l-11r-11f,:•I:.~• .:1d r.r111n.:,11l or rip;••·,.,,,._. ,, 1.1,1! I 111.:11,I: 1... o,-,,J ,,( I l,.t;'C,l1Hl, r:\c.i.,:l ')J' .i.'<i.li;~ir•11:1 l.'lllWH1 or clifrcro110:is ~,01.·l,j_11:,11I: l.n t·~:, -:,J ,cl:ion r:-:1.· ;:-.)).::-..ting ---~····~u..---• ' ~ ----· -··• ·: .. ~.,...,..ny- nf lh:1 o,,:,·E·J--.1:on, er-: ·~n~ord tho !;, c:\1H!i•.lnl:cn ,. ..o ,: .. ~..... ; !;;•.rJ ~amo r:1cx\ :r-Uh hil:·J11 I: ...... ,")7. 1lrd. 1; ~1•.~.)~ ,~ ~ rrc"!"OllOO • on 3 t ~lr.nt:'lr.y, i99•j ,,,,t 0111.iJ. I.hon l.l·,<1 :i.111:1·,.,,\t•r. l:1,ry olnu110 to 8, 100(2) ;N:-i.c\ :•n fn)lo:11:11 :\ (2)

-r;,c ol11r.l::k11 ~flc.l11:H.,1.,tn nn n. nor:110:,:- ILJl r:11,:•.D ho ,10(1) ·n:,\ V'1:l.1I r:-11 ,111,y of 1;ho fo:l.!o•,1l11r, r,r,n,· 1n ·;'.dch 111:0 p•:,1vr:i1l to 1.:·,1 !'.'··.l.lr-1f-.~r.ti"n or ';ho r.,:m·I:, 1n'10lt1- u u fl!JP:··r<-11il, 1:I;:-(; i.l)'.l/'.;•.l pr·1cl.ir..,!I !lol. •~::,_•;:rHJ:;J.,v :it:~!.,1,f.1rnl•!r r1,IOO cc,ulcl . nr ' II 1,:, \1.-·,rnr,:1 f'lt' 1111).I i f'ir: •,I. i,,1,[111 ·.d .,.1; t•·ll, r·•.d.:i.,:r.1•.~11'; kn!~ l;ho CUC) '"''' '. ~ J.n ~-Jl.1:"H, 01 l.'.,:-.t \'.J~r H l'"-!:: 1 ,,1' ' !, ... .'.,~~ ilf-.,l ~11:l i11l-:01l1:r...:.1l i11tc, tho I.'.. L.: L ' L : ; ~ho 'n1T1Grn:11~111 tP.. :•.r.11 I r•i .r r'.t ·it, ! I . f'c.••1·1 ,. 1,:u:111 ·: I. i 111'. 11!1..: 1.l·r.r H 11:i.~ i.n to11clo•l ~o 1'.o so• 'i'J.c, po~ i l:i :•11 :-·,r.,-...i 11•1 I II I. '.r: I: 1,oc,--..urM, .l.n th? f 1r::-r I: pl.tQ<', I L t:,\! ~1,;:,x-~1~ng r;,f :;t\b-r-.~c()) r.-1::nJ11r; ~.!: .~.'- :r:.r.11,cr,,ro.·· it-·ta 11iiir6tor.o I •. I atill :,....,-,,n,-.1,10 k c:1::-~.)011~•-•} 1;1J.) •n1H5.t_y c-f n11 clncti-:-n :m th,.l w.r.Ull(l (20) I I of i~lc:;:,:,.li';i~n l:!1°,. ·•r7, ,_,1.1,-,rt~i.~•"> 1wl: ·:~:-:,·•:cn:ily 13t,f;n,1 ttr'.for f.1,100~ ! i IL 'fho ~:d.t.1 c::nrormic w,i1.1:J oGt ,:,:<e~~•nlr:~_~):..~~!htO t,:, tJ\-:, 3c,c1tlc.n. 1 i'-' At.ill l11:-..!'J1licnlrlo 3i:nr,v1.1;:, 1. 1vn·,, ln I,!·.. , Jt•.:-i_r,prll'lc,11Hnl r~r~.u,,on~ ';'hfoh tI

I • ._, .• J <lorivoA !"r,:,rl tho rp::d I; nf 1.11<1 Cc.•:wl:ll.ul:i!'II 1111:I lho ~l.:,cH<•.lt'I '.ol) i ! f'.nd tint i irJ dc:1Qcr., ~~r, r.l, i::l.ionc, l•.. :vc f;,- 1.,,:-, ft"OC' nrn\ f;:\ir. r!,iat ton, ! !:na tiot boon nffoc to•: :•.nd r.,:~l i:-tt:C!I~ 1,;,.n 11('1 !JOH,~!' to 1~_~i,:1ln\o ,'.lg:t.lnnt i such ~ rrint;)i11lo. :.r. ~locl:;,:-11 r;_1l11lc•l H.i th old.cr.11:-.cy n·hcl crlr,1l11nlHy ;: lo n,;,'i o.n olr.cl.i,:,n h, •,1.,, ,:,nr- of I.hr, t.aH, liocnuno i ~ ,lr.-oe n<'t o::rpronn I '· th,:, true wlshoo of the o}c:r:l;or;:,.tc. :_ilt1H brlly, :-.(I H:,:. J.1.,.r,:-ml,:, obso!:"1011, i hnoton to s~y thnt, <"-1 t.hnti._1!~ n iG f\ forhit\1.l lnr; propo~Hlcri for courl8 ,,r l~w to cUcl;:i.l.'l I:,., l:ho ,,,.,J.i!:loi"1H1 11h,I. l:n n.,y 'or ,,o" to any Ht ., 9, 108(2) r.):-.d :-n fn)loi,r:it :\ L ( 2) •1•:10 ol nr. I; i 1 :11 ~ f c~n:.1 ,.,!., t:1 ,'1n :,. no1;l10;,: .U r:: 11:•.J.l bo ,l.-cl -.1·c,l v-,j_cl en ,,11y of ';J10 fo:11,,•,rinr, r,rrn1· 1n ·;'.dch :11~0 w·nv,:i,l to (.:·, 1 !".''". l. .ln f.:,r, t i"ll of IJ,c ~,:urf;, 11''-'101!'t- ·,

UI I not in l:,;1J1rl:11l f;n ~:-, c,;:!i:111:1 I. i ,,,,, · r i ,·:: '·• •,.~r. -i1r:~c .\ I, •.t.i,l,_ !l<> I: 0,:,11 ~-•-in tho u u 'fo~!1 "~;ily".::-.n·l, nccH:,111\, l1~c::>1,1K, .-•.1·0n,~.l11r; of r:11h-r::cc~(.1) ,.,.,~\o it (1o) '-- fl!Jp--.re,11 I; i:l::-- I: i]] '.1,::'.J. ;n··1c I. i n.m !10 I. r.1.:;,_•:.:or.rnJ.,11 :-, I.:~ !.,,,1. 1r l!f,,r ". 100 cciu1d n(' 11:, ;1-.·,1:w-.:1 f'lt' 1111).I if'ir: ~•- ir,11/111 :!] •,•t;t,.11, i J•·•-~·.l..i.,'.r,1•.::111 1:(-n!: tho Cl.II'' '"i.-1 ln /.p:i:-5.l oi l. 1.1:-.t .:·.J....,r i.l: J"'·r::,,rl' .'.r:t ;tr-.il ....,11,! i111-:oc11:,::.:.11 i.11tc, {:ho \ ol::'-11:J(l !:11('. p'.:-.•~.,;,,, ·.11•1 •• , ..... ,:,, "--iii•• ·~1: ·1::1", ,\1111, "Hi1rl Oil"" <•l:lfor l ~c,{;:1c1 11 , ,r'.iic!1 ! h"lv,, ,July nn;-,1·:,,i::o,J., l)_j,J 1:1:.1, ,... ,.~,fr 1.1,,. !'·'.l".'·"lh•rf \ L I rlo; n 1::d; tl:i11!~ ~:,_} ! -"lr:1 i.11 "',;r~'.)1•1t!!)f; II). l;I! ])r, l'.:1.-..ib.1!1'.\ l:l)!\·I; f;l:o poGl,-Hon. onimoi--.1-.~.r) li,v l.h,: r-t,rn·I. ,._:- '.1,11·.nl. h:-v1 11,•I: :,,: m o·nrrulof~ h,y 'I '.;ho it1.1'1C,llc!t:it>11l:P., ~-.r.,1 I 1•r:fr-:,·i11 f'!'."ll'I r11,:11~11l·\l.i111: t1!t..;t.l:r.:r j_l: on:::i i.ntorn1o•l \ . .. O:.o ~o so,· '!'ho po1;il:_i:•11 :-·11.,-,.i,1·1 l,tl.,nl: l1cm,--..110,,, tn l:lm fj_r:,f; plu,,ci,

I I I L t!1.'.! -~for:lina of I i . aHl~ :i.;r.U~t,J.o l.r ch::-.1.1011~·-•~ th., ·...-,lj,lJ.1;,y c,f n11 clncti~n ,11 th,.1 m:-r.uml (20) ! i of illC-::s"·lii,i~n I ., l:!1~,. ··r:-, '·''·'•·1ri!i.~-) 1wl; ·:~~,·-:cn:,J;i.· FJt•btl t'rifor o.tou. i IL 'fho irr-:dr.i o::nronr,ic u.niu:J oGt •:>:<chmir:, -"ll~~rl\1.S in t:ttJll 111."'.rpllcnl,10 \ t~ tl~c, aot,t lc,11. . 3;:,:,,-,1,1. I::, -·-----·- --·--- f. 1vJr11 ·i.n I,'.·,., ;it•.:- i.npn.1•l(l11 Hnl r:.r:_,u,1011 i ~Id.ch _, ~ dori,roa ti:r:in lho r.p::::-if; nf l.lKt Cc.-:irJl;j_1.11f;Jr,i1 n11:l tho ~l.1_cHms '.o~t I m1d tl,"ll ia t1o:,,,cr., ~~r. nl: cl.i.0110 l•.:vc: l:r, 1_,,;-. froo nn(l f..\ir. l'!1ia, too, ' ' ' !me n,:,t bo,on nffoc to,: :•.1H1 r.1:~linnc!I~ h;,.n 11,:, po11.~r to 1~~ir.tln\o -'.\g'.'.lt1!1~ such 6. riri_n'Jij'llo. :.r. nlocl:ir:-11 r_;_,lrlk•l 11.i th chlcn11ncy rtll(l crlr,1i11nlHy i hnoton to s::i,y lhnt, r.} ti,,,ll,1!~ it iG n forhicldinr; propo~itlit1 for . I ' I i 4JO

I

I I I r•ltHl.l.trJ ,,_,~ ,pl~.Jil. .tc:n~d ,,r n11:l.t.1 .•~.t, ·;v 1 ,~,n cr.11 111:1:· l:on \l,~t,, nc-t ! ' i>nitod. t.~ bo pt•~!lont :,I; f;h, ,,::oroi:::•·~· .'.rtcr :l1mot•11d11:~· th-:> ros11.H13, I I . \ ; JTT) I ?tit·,~:, ... 1.1,'}!1:-;_-.~ J{:-ihn~mk", roo tiO.orl (;Ot.10• the 1ot.11tn~.:ii: Or.f.i.r.or., i 0 r l;ho orrr,1:1 · :,_,1't1 rl'JII f; I.,·, I.hr: • n "" 1. .. ,. ,,, ~•·IT ,f :111 ,.,·11 :\ r11pr, I.' f; •rJ\l.o)•., i whilo 001if11T.1.lnr; tho firr. I. ro,.11 .._,w:.,:,111; 1n •.'io ~-<lr.~', r>nvo rlitf:H"mt ! I fi(Jtt.t'08 f,r-:-n 1 f;hor:to ,'l11110tJJ1<J()•.l r.11 ~ 1-'r.·."11'i: u·. •or,,.,rrl ,. t'ho · in l•·r tn·· th.:, .,:npo-r ~,. "1xh • D12.'i, ~- t'311n~ .... =~ nf wh 5.c:1 11:,n pv:,J.:l n!\,,:,j i1i_Qr..zo ~J!1. ,,f :?.'1 "Jrwo•-1110.r, j tho fire1-~ rc:Jpo11dont h'.ltl. l'1, 51.1 ,;rd;on Hid.lo f;ho po tH.i.0t10:- !::.t\ ) '. ·' •. 'Ji 1;!1 tlr.1~1n ~.;1 f:nd1:r. l:c•r.Y r0r.1"\_r 1.crJ 1 ~•<1 r;::11 11011 !'!"N~,1ocl. I;,:, l;h,, qtl.o!'ltic,:1 :, th-'.\t. th'l ~ho::-\· GUjipl:t l':'lrJ of 11r. 0011~cq11rmco, 11.f. 1:11 :'-tr. :i:11,,n!lh~ l)(.l1lin<; , . ·th~·t tho 11l:cnl')tj10l1''!1 ,,,~n 110 f; ,lnl lh~.":':d;o ,uul ft, "'"" no I: (lc,r,cinn h·:i i:o,l hou l t r..ffcd•.><l th-:> po·:J Hon<Jt· •. ·Dt'. 1~11::iikwm cot•nl;-::r11 ·t!•.-~.1;, c.Hhotir.h you or,.nno t O?Ui1.t on :'\ 1v)i vol:rn• btl·n •1ul., in l;h in r,."\lJCI tho

phC111or-ionon ' 1me n •loli,lnr.:i.t.o r.iJ.rJohict nn ':Jn1 l.1:b•.rnJ.11,-; ornr.·>r. 1 1:' ;,;irl:. ; i I f')'untl l;ho ::-.r(!IJ11011b: n;;l,·,r~:i.lnl:1;·: 0 11 I.I,~ on'J p·w~ :inc'!. u~of\\l iI on tho n th~r. ])l my viou r,.o (~'•.rJrf; ow,;·J y h"tl r,oro n()r:i.0un J.•:.!,'l icnHonc.h ' . ., .1, .· C , I p 1-.3, . h·:1, 11l·},,,:1 J.c:·r·t .::;,: \'C ~-1:-:; !~10;- ';;-~·•)ti '' ,::J ·~n,; -,~:•ilm ht',l ?.91) l In rocor3,,~ 1:.lN\ of l;i !ir. l::,.·ui rm . nit :~n ·· d<r: · b:• .,r.c ... ·, l;id. !', :d,;' •: {f';: . i 3100 l;ori·l;:;• \ l;ho ~li!i::11.:rcv,~. 1) ,cl :1,:a l;f•· n ..,.?:' 1;, , ... ,. ·t ·1 '.".td;n: r:- f · '•:•.: ;, ·it ,, ·-1 : / n lt.\ar:-.t,,r.v, \ ,; ,n; pr,:11llll c'· h~t~ n r br I••~ I :.-:-9 ... ;9,J'; f.'lPo i r. :· H.. r, /,\"i· ~ . I( • : \ of tho DooJ.:,,:,-Hon r.~.~(.•:, ... : l q,r.;:t ~,, th,, r:•r10:,·•mi:n .; ,..f '.1.i.r: r,,;::1 I.:·.,: ' .l ! '1 (3) .(_u:c l;!•h:-: rs I;:· ,.:rn: ()) • 'i~,::- 1: Gl of th~ p~•o~llc t·~· • l1. I·:, ti,~ ...... lY:~P.is c--f ';!:.~ 11uliior.l tx ,:,I' ~~r ,,::,:,,::,;:nt, -t·,~-'' r.!1~11 l:J-, c~ 1)1·,u.~ocl Jr ~•,1 •:i0cH-, nn,1 ,-m•Lf ,.,, oJ.oc+..hni:i "l,ic;, ohaJ 1 l., ,,y •.ud •1t•~:,nl :-.. 1,l ory_p.,~ ~·J.fix-·1,-;,-, ·:1t1 n~~:~J l h<. !ioJ.,1. ,,,1 r.t0t ,.,, I: vct,1 er 1::,· 01111.hn.L.-.1,t. f":'oo -.r.d:lnr; ,,ron0,lto:-on • (Jo) bub for tho ~ttrJ!Of:IO 01· l:Jd.n J11dcroht H J.i,

nurr.l.cl<ml: ln oll:o .\rt.21(1) whJ.oh otntor, in J"f'-rt- 1 ( t) \. ·• lc.lln rnin w, Jn/~t.u,:,t_ ~::·. !;t1eJ1fflno nnnyo lir-.:d yn k:11::th :Ir iki !cr.l; 11<~·. C1hu,~l.t1.l l zn ut::rn;,.Ju ~., nohi, n1ln moj:i. k1m t.10J, Ht Jorn. kupl Hn ,r.iu:ilcil iE:hi 1rnlinc'.~1r::u.l hm 11'\ • ' \JtHi:i.nchi k1ll'.\ hinr.l :;:-.n, k;,~ tn,~Jn,:r,t.1:l l . . . ' ..~ ' . ¥N ... ;.. I • • :•,i~ r••-11Hn:-r1Hi_l111 111 iuo!,:w, n'l ,.,h•):;::in··n,1•~~11;-.· mu1J:llii\ ". 1 : • ·• · In orclot lo ooc\ll'."O cor.1p1Jn11c::i 11J.l;J•. I.ho Co1,ntih1H011 uml t'ho lmr of tho {:lo) : I J.nncl, Afl;. 2_6(1) r·.lno nf;_il:onr iI {') l<i.ln nl:u :,wt wa,l.i.hu w:-1 k,1rtnt.n ,in i .'-'.:, l;iln. hi l rn l i ! 1n tho {11£1 t:-tt I; 011:.y by \tho ,'.\:r;;u·1.:-r.! ~!nl:, "'.[f;or all, 11:,I: ,,1_:i.. r-1rrlnto,rc'1 •rct-n"' tun1 out to ,Joto •. 'fl1:m 1;:1-:l t l:r.q,p'.inn, :,,rn\ ! I; !ia;1,011n :-..1 ,m,-,,n ,. H is oi thor tho ! \ ' --votO.t'!t 1<,wn ciornul I: or hy l;J!o h1 brv0•1 ti.nil (lf r-~'IC'r.111:1 1,oyonn hlF.1 (20) ' cn,-oryoho \,ho _rcr,!."lt::irr; h -.,,,l;o J.;itr.n:1r.t ;c-, w ..i.o.- · '11,o ·no~ of~~thc,--······ '11l.<Jturnb1et offic:-.r 1m11 hr.1100 t\ r:,:11,cry ,1'1rl" b'<ll!Ch of ·iho 'cn.11nHhtHot1 n:ncl tho 11:.\ooH.Nrn :1e t. ' rt wns ·sui'.raoa h cl t!m t l:ho 'lo ht.rn inc; Of floor I a no~ 1-mo not '· ·d-.olibornt,, bu~ {l,eoidonlnl. I roopoc~f1t1.ly

1liottgr:,o, Hf~ oc-nrluob in r-olntion to tho criain bo:.::ponlco of conni<lo:,;-::thlo 11oli11'3rnH?n M tho f'>llowing nno.ly-oio wDl nhc,u. :.::, lh~f~_rrJ~ 1,l:::co, ho hNl 110 nhor~rtgb -· ot.f lmllot p~pors. Duncln conoHtu.mcy llnn nuprlioil wHh 56 1 cOO p~r1!ril:10h~r:lry (3o) I. I II -1 :1 :I ·' \ I i 1>::\llot p,"\~1.):-:11 H!d)<. J.I: J·."lA\ 53, 1,1'( ro 0 Jnl.:);,.,,1 ·.tnln::rt, hi,11m, n11 \' I oxooo~ \ 1.1y thtj ()('f:i.C~:t' ';'I) /W;,"0:(11'; r•f ,,.,n,.,1; \'·,·::,~r! r-u:;::,li:itl -t;,, nll ! ! l., tho 11,"trdr- .ln t!~.n d•w:tl:~.lir~-::· c.;-,.;io to :,t'~~00. 1'!1r1~ lcn ln 1~ia i ' ponsos~~.,;-n 3,~,,o ~,-~1, I: :• .,,,1::.,, n,: )f 1 ,.,.·•!::i ,,::- lr.o l.o ... ,..HJ :,1,\0h. :n1on {t(I or.i.(:.l~· i) -.~;•,,:5.k•: ::-:,".;:c·.l 11;:J 1 1 ln \ ·l::·,i~ x-6,,o:r.·,r.~ ;•:-1•' ·::•····., 0,11; 11"'.'I 1:•,~c:, ...._..!tl~•l ?., ~.'.'1 r~·-:-j,:t~• i:,:, vc,t-:i. \ I ·.Th,·, i::u:;•••l;:.· ~f 5~:4!:0 ·,.,.11,,1 i:• ·_.:, ,.l'n w:,~ not i11ibr.l ''.'.' I·'.~:. H:\lr..,rih~ ( : II II, ,. 1)- ' , , . .. •• .. •• .• ,. • ·•. • .. .-··"... .,. ·\. ', ...., .,_,. ~, ·ro l:.:l -J.,:: ~.:, holiovin;~, 1 I: ;ic ::•.-,~ ·1 .1.;: ~.1~•;J. n \,:,_, :1 :-:di i. !.,m--.~- ':llli!l_'J. i.<. n; .. L (10) t:.....: I}_lwh ·.1.,'.:: ,:d,:'in: 1.U: · ;;1• _,;,,li.:ii). 1()! ?OO lntl, l:ho ·' Ru-;,ply ~.-os::, _tc 10!77?,; ~11.J !3.,.1.-,;·_,.~ 1,-.1:. ~;··,.ri.n:-.11~,

:"•:,rl5.·r<1. ) 1 '.:i5'> ht~l I 'l ~, L l~o:;.t, i;:~o -;?.;t•.t•~n5.:1~/ o:·.r:tc·-~•; !,~VP! ., ~- · u,,, ' u nt1:, P,."\por8 -in e.tc9k \.H.h 1 fr, f,-:ct, ;i.~t,. ncd: 11:00 ~hc-.n ) 1 1Jpo in roMrvo. Fint\lly, l,, ':lpito c-t ·li!l._ ~-;- ··.11n1~:rt f:ioU i.l :',_·.:.r.: nt Id.~ 11.l~pc-0:1lj 110 rr.t~~- 1 -· no c.ffox-·t 't-:, N<H·•tr.P111l;o .:'1t, :· '.n:•_1~·~ . !:°'1"·!1 t!v.:-~ic ·~•;,>•<1·1 :1~1·t-,;, ::-.n o:;:<.:o!:',.,, ~ ( ~O:t'') tho 1~tjHHitbr 1 n dr~,,Gh~Hs, J•.J t.ronc\. ·,.,r l:::> poll r-,;:•o!lrn ! to vind1.or.: t~ ~Hr; i.-ic-1r, 1n : 1:;-·1.,ln,m, ~l•r: re t.f f:~_,,1\Cr p-:-U~cl ), (,07 \ vc,toa llhil'>\ th,3 .fi.rr:,t. r:mr-01vk11 1: i":lloJ 90~ •10 tor1, .~nc.'. in 1~lnr.,;,, tho potitb~o.,..· ~'.'11~>1 ~, 10j ,'I'.'~- r, i:,-, f.'•11 fi.t'J!, r.o:"lp•.:-wlcnl; •o 90? v:-,lcn. 1 ,. i \ . I.., ,, i~' ' \. . ~ 1.,. ' ' jL.; -~ ~) . .!I('• ·-· . ! • .' ~, ~f :: _L I I• 1lotttr.t1lna •)ffir,cr co1~.:c-.fou<Jf;: ::wl '.'rd:hc1y 11.1.low,d f;hia ~htr, of 11 1~ nffnb:-e, h, .nu:it !,.~.vc, :i,_..,1, 'nc• l:o. n01n l''•'• "<'r!Of lo no.,- lhr.t H 11:l!:1 t\ oof.ncltlonoo_. uou_J.t1 M .11 J'J,·: ln:-·..1.. I :_,,., !l:'11 J.•· :"f.;1,1 011 l:hc -wJ.,".l!o l;hn t ~ho 1· L..' I I I· L, .' ; I L..; quo£ Hon of oho '-- ( 10) -_.·: "\.'~ ·. .;,, ... , .... 1loc~---1,,,1 .... r r.;r.-· · .,. , •• "J • ., • • • •• . • ., tthc:::-o, in cpl f;0 of 11.n ~l".Vtplo

:1,, ~.n:; rhl i.1m:,:.·, tul;:' !t,;)v::::,fov. to v.,•tfl; !ho ~ lo:•:t·nod ju,t.~.o , •. '."l,._,, 1/·,C",I; l!io .,..,.,_,:,_,;•pl 1. 11ICO ·r.:t~ n.l." il(l ciffc,,t 1'ljJ1oo' ·l:ho Hinnl•,,1 C:lllr\ir]o.f;o h:•.'~ ., 11-:.J<.•rP:,Y ,,r 3,511: r,l·•J~ nl:111. Ply hHc-11"!.:l,:,ll . . f;h:, oll)'r,Hcn' prov~_r,.1.-::, (;'OOn l:c• l:'.10 r·1nl: (or: n11 nlccl;.{,;n) r 11n11-o,,mplin11c•l ! ~.IJ ao~rnod·l,y l;hn P~-·o~_td.~•IH! or lll)•)l:ln11 1'..l'H".1Ho) "f 1;1,;, 7,loc,l:fom: Aof;" (20) -· • • • r•~ ~.)11'.l i.rl fl -i;:~. It .1. II(\ t11 ln n.ooou:1 I: tho llh ic~: umlorl ioo u~o f} •,jl:1 H t.~,1. -~.nil ~•11cl ·':Lo ;;;locHonn ;'.ot, ·1<;:l5 t;•:•I; oli:,c-1:iong 0H1-.ll 110 froo nml rnL•, ,:o -~-7:'o r:,f t!to t con1Jirloro<l orln:lnn I.hr .t r,i;., clooH•m ·' ,edoh ~':' r,011:,r.nll~, t111''roo '111r1 1.111(1d;-:- in',t (Jo) 110 I; "'-lt o loo I; l011 ~:l ett" inP-i,t'J<l h•r l!10 Co:1r,l:.ltul:{nn n11,I l:ho ~~J.-:,,·f:lnr:,, .\nt, r.mt cnwtt')nu,,n l 1:V t\n--r Lhh1~ :,h fC1h rc-mlo:r:1 t.h".l ciJ.oct-k·rt tmfro,:,. 11:rd w1fr.ir l~ :l.n ltw vt'l·lcl p·n~1••.1 ·-:-or m•ll ::.f:1.r:-:-.tJ-:-11 (if t:t'.c!-. ~,:_q"l()J;t-:i.<l .~_,_,ct1u,,. ., .1 !i L 1 ~, dld n o·t ;:-,f~c:vJt ~~-~-,.,,~.l'•W.•, 11.l:·n.- ~:n:l ·~:-:1•!_1-:u •.:·:-:-c1:1 ,:,,.,J.:;J l:!D:i:-o 11oro Ho ..~, i. •i'1r.cl olooHotrn ~Htl: m,o ol-,ctio11 fo,~Lo11t~.::-o o:111:-;tib1ono;r, Tho 1,rottoh L'.

I 'th10 ~.,cnt- to t!•.o root of t),o a.,~ ii:c ·~:.;c::nif:lo nnd :ht 1\i• i toolf i 13t'.f 4:'ld:lnn t' -1:r.- i,d.1 if:.· ~;t,<) cl 1c 1; .lon, \ !If t,1~:-:-G:{.110 of v~.ci;r,_,:-,~, r~~~-~.11 :'n·: ;·.t 1;;:-:~o~icm ovoa ht th, (10) . I .. ci:-:01.tr.tJk.llc'.ll': -,f l:)·{o r,:--::i:,! I :·-.:•,; ·;o -r,~•:t:,m: :~•111 ~~CO:t'VO t~...;-.t I .,. 10,1~ rocj)lo "oro <lf.r1cnZr;,11cJ::l.c::vl~t)1: f~.,:.rn.·o cou.l-:.i, nf cottrnof:. I I aJ.i.:i-Jd,lr lom,: ~1'.,c11 -~-~-c-0 ..11i• .l.~ I: ·!::in ,·:: 1;1i,, :.~·:!:,::~ ,?. I vi,t,r:n .ln ~10 .. • 'l I . ·;ariku.\ \ ... -··. ······• .. ~,,l t!1ouf vot!J1G lmc"•t•.::ir, ·, H!10;- t!·-') c~:c;·.-.., l11:, rd::•.• ~ fnc1 i-~ ,;_; ~ '.or, i.11 l:ho I I .; ., onno C'f.\ !J,•1ri,n:i. ::-.nrl "h·•,,_,-.-,~i, J t ,.1i1_\ _11,,l: :d;:~;:I: ::,,I: r.'IJ. ,.,r :-,lc;n.lfir,r-.nt).~r . \. ~ . i till 3110otcl1or.. ,.,-..~ i 773 votdo at· th:-i t;,:-.t.::1 1 :,wl t!•nt 11:-.!J li.~r~•:o t',o <Urtr.('l•loi:y·oi o further I I • I 27 --mtos( of tho l"'Jtit.t;-)1()!' 1 n ,f,tlc)l h~l !try~ r:-o 0!lf'•.•.::ilr 1i;--:oi,. noor,\'}1tocl ' t for. 'l~,b p.:,t.~.tionor 11:,tJ.<l_ 0::10.r:-;o 1::::, 11hmc~.• lr he ,,:,~~:, l:o sooro r.J.l (20) 'I thooo votoFJ, u!do:1 oho1:o t:l'.:1 I: ovoa t'.m::ir> 1vm-c,,,,. _,1 i:•t1con ~.:t.ono i ' 'Woulct htivo ,~1\0 to ·r.,rJ.C\~n :-in,\ ~'OIi r: · 1w to ·'1:.,::1air:l <looEj "o\ on'lor tho philooor:iy

of.olocf;i:m p:- P.H01rn, ' Ae 11toto~ l1af..,,:'(), t),o cn11d1rl:1 to• •ru-r.o n-,t fnvi 1:od to 11_0 prononf: r.t tho o.ddit:i<'n, H ll' 8l\b,-,Hl<H\ ('111 f;l1tl J\:,ldli.4.nn'.:lr'n ~,0!1--.).f th:i~ tho -~~o::tiookn uaa <lolibor,,~o m1<l •rHh o. rlrrpono, ,:,n )1 Octolior tho (30) I . ••. ' .. to bo pr~aont; ot tho' ruM J.l;Jo1u 1'ho.,:-o ~,;,.n no t."Ojd.y to Um lo Hor, I ~x.h. Pi./ Oil ·bho mn11d11 1~ of ? tim·n1111•nr, I.ho 1<:1ld.Hn11nr nmr Mm I ! ~o·burnirig otrlcor in p.."lrnon nrnl bnkorl."\lhoro tho (t(\,\iHon would i ·bnko plrino, lto . w.,.n l;n] •'- l:h:i I: 111 wo11l.1\ 110 t 11 rflr.rnm\ whon nrrl.\n6(lmon bn ! ' woro colilrfotodf bu~ f'.t J p.rn. thnl: da.i' ho rocni vo1l r.\ ]:,Hor, Jil,l1iP?.~ I invit.lng' tho onwH1lr:il;<:in . f;n 1-ocofvo l,Jio r.>r1uJ l;n n I: 6 p.m. 'l'bo i n0turntjtg Officor do!1io;l Moo i.v int~ tho ~-~ H Hrmor I n lo Hor nml doni.od j moo bing: hj_m in por1.mn on ,' llc,v,Jmhor, nml cln.lmoil to ltn.vo or.nlJ.y I .I I . .. . . I•, • ·• . • .; inf.ormo:d. him +._ho vonuo of tho nd,l:H ion. I l'O joct tho <1onlEils for bho I . ·;, ' . . :tins tJ,oy l\ro~- bt fncb 1:1'.lr; r,r-.11 11.:ltl nol; cwon ni!.y 111toro nnr~ 11ho11 ho I I modo tHo 01:'t\l co,nmtniic:i.l;i,m. '11v:i nol; of o:itelt¥1i11~ l:ho pot.iHonor / from -uln rnl.cU Hon wnn ovJ.11011 tl :y 1.lol .lhor:\ 1.o, ; Ib lll ttq~,1 <m 110, ho~ovo~~ I l;hn. I: l;ho pMt1m100 of tho

cnn'cHc1r.il;oo f\·t tho.'.odcil·Hon ir.i n0I: n!'.\ll<ln.toryJ 111.:l<li.f;ic,11r-.-l~.y, f;hn.l; tl:oir. nhr;onco tn BlooHone -~ct ol:nlo1:11 " :1h'.\ll ho' a,.,thot·ir.01\ f,o · 1,o p_,:-,inonl; :-ii; ·!:ho mld.Hi•.:in ot v0Vir.: hy f;lm lo tundna Offict1r (20) outhor lsoc1:1 nm'>nt; l;hflin a c~n,\.l,\,~ l;o m1<l n cfltt:1 l;.lnc· r:--cr-m I;. :nut my o_HonHon·l-":lS d.rrmn to (;ho •~Jcctr,r:,J. Cor.v:1:lr.1:1ionor'o wfow1r.;;1l YA ltt\1FLi:JRE2b ..... ..

5. Z!lEO 1.\ JCJJ-:Jt-ti,l'nt.\ KlJ.1.'l Enon J.r. ki1.jur.ilin!1::i. kurn l Hnkt11rn kn HI~ nnh,""" 1,11,hn:,n tin i,,,u,d. 7. l m, t.Jnhn.nu7.l n l~)l;'n(f'- '""' "l;o"a l;:l-.... r i fu ira'3".'m1,on Jew, 1nrv,n,1 .1.nhl. (30) ·Mr. MalnrilUl\ti aul1mHr.1 1.1ml; n.00(?.) ir1 1'<1J1n.lnr1tvo nm\ tho Cor:1mieio11 1o d.irootivo is in C(l11fUr,I; wi-l;h t.ho ,'\r,I; ul•ich rn1.int ·tnlco prOOO<lonco. .. -:-"~·j .\·. ••• __ 4 \ \i ,\ . i I i i . I' I' ' r\ tl~lnk, '-'ith'r,,npoot, Mr. H~lnmn!~::l o vktr or·n.00(2) ·r,.ml tho 1 i C91111:1ission'o cliNcHvc c~innot bo.co:,~roct. 1ocl;i"',·00(2) moroly n~thotisos en l;ogu.,;-i-Jo o<" i votos. '11tolr l;\l;l;o111ln11co o'(' 11011-~l:l.o?vla,100 iC1 011t.irolr tho:lr oim .i offnh·, nnrl tho pn,v l!l l,,11 ,1<'-,:i ,,,. I; t.-or.~ui-ro n '10 htti,in~ Officor ~o invil;o ''.tt!om. .But l;hnr•l :l.n :1).r:o e:.126 w!tich or.1poH1)rS tho Com:lor:1ion ·to i w ioouo "dirontfon:., of r. f;11n,,r::,.J. or of n Bpoo.lr:-ic cl111.rncbr in rolnHon ti to tho 'funo tbnrJ of 1ob.11:11lnr-: Officn;:-o o. funot'f,.,n under n.00, l;J:.~.t ln Lto &1r1 tip vol;~n. 'thn ~11!·11:1 i fl!l i "11 Ji:1:1 pr,1•0 ,. t., i :111110 1\ h•,,r. ld.tlllf:l of n -[401tor:i.l o~ r;p,1ci.f.li:: r.h:.\1,·n,:l.f"lr .l11·rr.1J:1l.l-:-11 f;n 1.11.,t; ft111ntim1, 1'hrtl: io (10) whnt it •Ud w_Hl.1 l.'I'} i•.1:11 1:•nr.r: ~r 1.1!,1 rlir::ol:i<'n cHn«l l'.\iov\1. !t i~

n uiraotimt of n _npncifi.c 11,--.tllr 1 • l'f.l')U:i::.l.11,?. 1,,l:nr.i1.it1i; Orficr.::-13 to notify oond ic\-1.ton t.fio' v.::1wo or l.llo :t•J,l i tinn ,,.1 w0 tho v:muo .ln. ,lo,,idod t1p0n. L aub aoo.(2) of o.130. lf: ~.ill alnc- r:0011 Im <llo~,,vororl wlw t.ho c,,mmiooion ai11gi~cl out on1tc1i,1:,torJ for. 110Hf:icr!l;io11. .\t tldf.t jw1c~uro I or..n obnorvo I \...., to~~ proAont. ."\I: l:ho :11',lll.irm, h·.1 ".l:::o 11.lri<,l•o_yml I.ho CNun:t.anio1t 1 a l ; l J ( ?.O) . . L 1. ,~ddi,Hon,sll:,·, 1-h". ll.1J."\111nh·t i,rcoon oomH.dnl'la noh1Hhobrnl lnr-; 1 tho ro".11.11 f: of f;h<3 ol'."!oHc,n 1-m11 not Cff<Mto<l l.h:~I:, t.Jm rt.li~onco of tho I i ' ., thorol\y, ' eoo:J ris n i,\u:-oly ,"!.rilhmn ti.c:•.1 ox~rcinc. L . ' I howovor, tho 11.boonco r•f t•10 o.'ln~lid~.tr.a ,-:.,.~ :, r.cori?U9 m"IHor ns tho i . ndditibn 1no no·t Mon to ho fn.ir. I Gimil "lt"ly think tl:o l:ll>sonco o·r 1 . ...... tho oa~didC\l.os in I.ho inr, 1:nnt: o:,.eo 11.,a " rJorioun m"-ttor oncl it ia itt I' . i thio oo1nnootion l;Jn~ 0110 •''l'l'r:ir.l"\tor1 l:h,1 :-.n:d.ol;y or tho C0mmia1:1:f.Nt to I I \ l . \..... iaauo tho clir-:ic t hm ~ r~, r roil 1; 0 -"\~l'vo. . I ~ .1 . I ·. ., • ,i did not diroot his l:Hll'i t.o t.ho prnvtNi('ll{I of R •• n.. lrll•.• .....1 - .. L O"Ar .\ '.IR •.n,,m ill Ulla .\ot, rtny 11.el: or f:ld.ti{f 111 rnquJ.rotl or ,".ul;hod~oil Lr· ho 1lN10 lt1 tho

prcsc1100 of 11, )1oll:l.11r; nG'-111t or n c~11nti11g ::l,-;::,nt (lr·:n onncll d ~ l;o, l:h:-, 11011~'1 I, l;o n•.h11c,·1 n r nny ouch nc~m l r1 11 r c,".1d irl ·, b n 1: t1,o I; Jrn-:, n11,J 11l.ttOQ I :-.ppr.•i.l't::>•I r.-,r l;f!'lt pn~,..,,1:10, r:h,'111 not, i r Lha :1c I: or thinG i:1 o thcr1-1iso prop:>rl_l or 1;!1; 11,~ dona. 'J'ho prc,vi~ion, in l;frn :f.irnt pl·1c,,, r;.i11;;.l,-.n ,:-,\II. r,:i11rlid".tca nnd· n.6U11°ta for ( 1o opooif..lc mnHon, a11:l nonl; fr1p~11:t-~11t f)f ,'l.ll, -i.~ if:! np 1nron~ fr,,m ·th" " to vorify ,f:ho r.or.u.l. l;r. hu r,,rv I.It" n11110t11111r,11011 I:. •111.,ro ~[1 no pi:-:-vird.NI for this sort of o.-.:orciuc n~. t,hnl. nt"'.r;o hul; n1111--tn1como11t nf tho (20) I11:locd fror., tJv.l atnolc of l'·"Jlors rurn,inr; in l:o l·,u11r.lro1lC1 of P¾~S llhcn nn.,-:J.cty j ••• ncldi Hpu \r-;8 p,:nporl:: ,J,,11,, :~,d r li:tri l:o~, l;n n::i._-, l:h,'l I: H,c l Hn11y of 01~l!l!'lio11a on<l Ol)~iEloiollr:t rloor. 11':)I; lwtpl.J-o COl'.lf,:,~·t 0r c,,nfj1lo11co. ~irrc ~ cif 1'1 l, t~o n1l1J Hi on ll:1i:, c:n1::,rk\11l "1"'11 ln c('ln l:rnvon Hnn of i lho pr~viabno of o .00( 1) whir.h nrpli0n 13.)51~ to tho n,JtliHott of i . parlittoonittr~• v-oioo. 'l':10 l'\l,tor r,,'!11.b:on r.,1MlHn11 tn OC,t."l~,,nco nf~or nJf· i rOJ)fJr~IJI of f:lto • r•.>n1•J I.rt h:~.VTl 110011 1·:1cc:lv,1,t fr,,r., :tJl l:ho 1,,,IU.ng ~tnti'>ll'T; (30: l i . 1, Jn

t.lli~ orino, howov,cr, i I: w.'1n ;,111,J I: t.c,l h_y tn]?. l),'lv:i.,t r-r.,-r1mtt.'tt1lcy-n thn t !ho. i '~ o:xoroi~o C'>rrr.\C11co1l c-,11 \I Onl:c-,hc11: h,,foro l;wo polJ.{11~ diFJtrictn (i.o. \r.\M11) i I I I ' ... I I • -I ,1ll .. ·.:. ,. h~l broOIJht :111 U1r) t.1· T.'•H111l 1;11. I.II fl•~d; ·,1•! n .t "'~ ·,,,~~, f 11 t•t'!l(t,'00!1 "" ·U11\ ~ ·:, '• :. diif in. Znlnhi'n ni1c1. Jlun: -11.d H:lrdn, ,n11tl 'hh ,;rtJ umnfr; l.:tknbly ohowtt. iho~ , 1 • tho,.Dm1dn roeul ta woro cloHvorod le tho 1ol;u11tin6 Offioor oil 1 Nowrnl,ior, •, .'•·,·;'•:· , •• , .• \ ¥'\ . • , ··It \ms not ,ih VC\in thn.~ Um loaioHur.o t·oqi.d.rod i1'° ':ldcliHon \°'lm,roiao io ooinm'onoo nffa:r f',11 -f;ho l'Opot'La htv.l lJ,'.,()11 rec..:> i., ,,1. JT I rny l1orrou Mr. quoyomnr.it.l'n ·1,!ic·n.::iuol,,,!-Y, l.lu, !•1irp,.11n 1-1:rn II l:0 nl .l.1,J.in(;o tho 'po13ilif.Ii-Hos• of 13poculn.l;J.vo v,mf:uro~," nni'., n.o will p.ronb11tly bo clomc,naira~od,· '.I .ouqh y-ontur:ia -woro no~ wonl;J.11r, jJ1 ~U.r-.: c-'l!lo. Soooncll,Y, _in co1n1 Hon::i cnr.o:-;, ~:l,,1 nrmrco <'f I.ho ro'J~U. tr:1 l(.'.lO clubiou3 7 n.~ ~irnos voreir1cr "" f;hu cr:l:· Jwt:l. •rho ro:-;1tl t:::i ,,,1-0 roq11irocl b 'ho oonv•11.Jt1iollhl!1 I;" 1;!111 ·111t.11.1,1i11i:nrri1:•·•· ,·11 :i ,1,"nw,.111'; lmo1111 :1n fo'orr.1,!lF'2, ( i,) 1 duly aignocl by tho .31r(HJi.r1i11,; orrJ.c::ir .'\11•l L'.v.,1.10 ·of tho·

pol~i11rrl'.l{.roJ1~s··· .. - proaol1·t.: Tona ll)1cl tonn ,.,f l;l1rJ 1fo'?. j11 tl,i.rJ oar;r,--Hrw :tHoyor;n1:1u oou11tod un~vailnblo r.~ tho. ndtlitdN1.· n io .....Joo ::i~ivfous to,'--• onytino i~1-'.lt eomo of tho forrno Wc,1" fHlJ:r.l.o".\l,orl ,-:-,f-tor f;ho potH.lon ~o filo(l, no doulJt tp_ hoodlli.tuc tho ooutt • I fn.und l.11() 1:1 Ln to of nffnho .o~h~moly oxnoporntin~. lh·: :tho,,on!d • i I poraU'ld6cl m.;mol f lo 001111 t,011111100 Pn· l;ho purpono of f;llin l jutlsmont,jtb.oao rn.rm1 "-11.hout tho )lr.·:Jr,1{,11.lln c,fffl)'lr 1fl o.im111htto l1u~ uit)l n~ lbnot '•tm, ~,;o11to 1 ulr:,1:tl.1!ron. I cU,J.no bocnuoo H nr1l0"-ro,t tln·t j . . I, ,: in rJon-o 0?809 tho 61)C(l:1(l ohoc, t Oil Hhfoh ~-ho pro~ irl:lncr offi'oor. hn<l to I I i ·' • 'I' 1Jie,1 _Imel ~10011 do bch,:irl 111;rl J nn I;. '.. i,.. i iho rosul~o ! could . . nol;,Jmvo ,, 1100n fnhd.cnt:o,1 nt11co ,"lr,,_.mtn roproooniod. ! I ·~ difforont :poli'Uonl prt'dion, Du~ nnt no ,,1 lh tho no 1,nrori, · i:hl\ b onrr iod . . l . ·. t:IC? _oign11h.lro nt: nll, t'r n11ly m10 :1,J'.1111, 1,1 r.-lr;unt.11n,, .for thono nppoorod • . i ' • . i to bo. for(jorioo. I Ifill prococ(1. n,vl Hor.Ii.no Lt.'Jr.O l;r, romovo nny 4oubts. i I \. ?tf~~ c.r. I'.,.._ , ) • .. . \. I \ 440 ~~ .. \ I , llqg-tn:1ing wHh Bunda \t:lrtl wo h,~w Jro.16 OTTU, for l_rhich 'T.xh• p.25 ! io rolovnnt,. 'l'bo dooum,mt is n p!,o ti1oopy flf

orttloly wri Hon wonls I; i I • nnd f i ~ a . 'l1to p11311irHn(! offic~r, )J1l~O J:\11100 JJunor::l, donio<l nny .i .· \.., \ '! knouloll~ of it oltho\lgh tho rooulto nppo.:irin,; thoroon 11ro oorroot. l . i Ho infortiod tha court that ho did not h-'W tho proocribod form nt his l et1'tion ~ut tho form ho improvhod 1ma oignod l1y hf.rn3olf, tho· poll~g Msiatont nri1 tho NCC~ ogo11t, but '!!xh.P25 h-'.Hl t\O oign:ihu:o ot oll. ' ,'..a if thr1t was not suffioiontll· htul, tho -witnoss wno roquirod to produco ,.,., • ..., ·•. L. l,.ia own c',opJ• of tho forr.1 it:1ptotleod by him o.nd ho pro<htocd ~h.D55 "1hicili I.' is nnotb_or forgory,. ( Aftor t1ol'lCnto of vncil10Hon, nnd •,1i +.h a dinbol:te . . . ( 1o) L emilo, ho odmittod tha.t it w;,e not in hia hnnd, hut ho could not roonll .• ! '. wbotbor it wos Wl.·itton for hit:t\ Ho n;:ivrJrtlv::iloss disclosocl th(lt it \roe in tho ous·to:lj; of DH32 D'lvicl lfynmuh0lcyn who E(-'-V'O it to hir.i · tho clny I. ho tootifiod .. ? L for I. 1 I Thoro wnn o.lao ono L J<f.\bMa ware\, llo. 74 J!yiht.111r;::t, ~h. 1)27 (Ptlrt) • i.. ti Altho\.1{91 thio hna si{P1o.turoo of four pollilla nSonto, but without tho I '··' oign.~turo of tho prosidin6 officor,itd npponrnnco surpri,sod mo. lcoording I L to ~h. P10, tho roturn of nn torittla for tho wnrd, tho RF2. ond othor I. i. motorio.la woro lockod in thG proeiclontlC\l bnllot bo:x. 'l'ho

~otUrning L I broken Offioor doniod to hnvo :L.. nny l>ox, hut bocnuso tho for.na woro boing ( 20) r-· \· tondorod in bulk for onoh word tho oourt oould not rtot nn oxplnnntion L for th.ts documont. Suspicion o•ro1• -'.his dooumont ie dooponod by-···tho vritinge thoroon., lihoovor "'!oto tho Hards "DrrA't'iot!1l.T 1'YTIL\N<J_\ ~ABUN<m" thoroon is tho Sl!.1110' parson who prop1.1rod tho f~rr!I i tnolf for tho hr.ndwri Uhti - . nnd tho ink' nro olonrly sir.iilnr. ( 3ir.liln.r iclontifict".t.\on romt\rke ih tho RF2e for Kis:imi \ · I. somo h<!.nd ~kI anmo ink . nro to bo found on/yo. 13f_1 A" t lfoo 13 Kitmmi 11 n11 , ' • ! Ho.72 ~it-ir~(!tlrU.!3tl)Qni, Ho.·p Ditl\t'!'Lfl\l!"U Di:\.T.llSO la IV 11 ,\11 nml }fo.84 i I \. . • · Sru,to Mnrio. 1I: Sinco it io out of t!,.:, 11uoot1r.n thnt tho 1n-ooi<ling off.i oor : ; nt tfo. 74 Nyihnn@ w~nt llrouml r.i::irldnc; m~20 o.t othor polling atntiona; \ · ~mt :I nm oonvinoM thot tho ~ for sbtion -w::-.s no+. r,ropt\rod by tho.· ~L (30) i I '< proaidina officor nnd could not h:1VTJ oomo from tho p~ a itlon tinl l1ox, I l !l ·'!, I \ l......, ·• ~; .. • ~·· ·I \' I -fl ~ r L, ; Y.ttn:rumt· lmrcl nlrJc, h:•,t Oil-)· :1 l:rllri~o 1:i'?, f,_,r ,Nr_,.IY3 !Jhul<• y!\ MFlingl l(1l,\t'.l:Jrl Jlukoro, "!lrJ1. P?.6. •rho 11ron1'll11,.-: o.ff.l9_<p·, n•r •. Jn L nutomi, <lonfo1l . ·1··, \....., o.ny lo1owlocJ;;o 0.r j_ f; • :n1':lro11:, ':O.::cl, i

p;,(,'· ln lt.rjlrt)V l11oil -:,:1 ,.,-,pins p:'lpor, tho i "l tnons :toltJ t!in n1111r I. :.:11\1. 11h11 ht•J\ ,.1111,11.-:h or I.ho 111·or.:or Hio<l r,,i-1:1, I I L.; I'-) L > '\',\ · Jfynrm.mwn wn:r•! hn•l r_1,,vo11 tlnuhl:ful ci~non. Pirat, T.;::thJD13 for Jfo,1,12 ·• f' J '!~ •I ~ ! ♦ e • o ,. \,• • • I U _. I ♦t'° ,o f • ' ,ol' - • f ·• f L ;, • (or.1'130) D11oor.o ,!1111,:-, .V'' llnJ!i1:I d,,uht thn.t _tho nv_:n:•.L11t·•1 ,,1.· 1.111, vJT "ni'i If: w;,.n C1r;l:nlillhl10,l l1oyo11cl c,;:.1 p,.1Ui11g or:-mt, l'if?.) 1h,:1bttrn Sfotlo 1 l . \. we.a. f~rt3llllo ~-l!1at io ..,,.,ro. l:lm 11Jl,11onn i11fnnno•l -tlto cnt•.rt thnl: ~h'.ly niw1od (10> ~ 0110· form only, llhich w.-,~ r.0111: I.!_, 1:11.:1 ·1ol.1111,i11,.r Officer, uut '1xh•:--~ 1)1) is L in ;~hroo oor:l,rin. 'l'o ""·I' LI: I\Jt, f.?i;, w.i t11orm naj_d -1:li'ti.t f;hoy 'str:,1,Jcl U10 u t) j orr~ r> I1 "9 n o ;f i c 0 r; I,,, l " 11· , , 1 .• ; • . but E:xh. D13 in rln f;o,1 30 eo f:,1l!,j1•. ,,Mr.,,.,.11 r· ll I' .1?1. : ,,; lie, ov J.<1 OllC:0 1.110 1\111•~.t.1,t-·• , w:"tiJ .. r ,,.rr:wd1f; f;J1n f;r, J s.. t~HC'Ht 0()11 hovor~ tho wi tnorrn. L . 1· L.; whi6h tho tlotuxninr; C1Ulnt1!: nhl;o,1 l.!,:,1: l•o 0,.,11.11\ 1 11111: h:ioo t!lt) 'lF?. •. · ·i 'l'bn t is rot our_pri o i.11r; n I ~ t\ ll . '!'ho pronirHn({ off.lcor, D'·Itl,1 Jlnmocl An:ltotr !• . L l JtJa~t lll;~or 001110 to rmy i ; th:11; ho locl:u,l

tho f0rrn in l;J_10 linllo t l10x, 1'ho Rot~ninG Officor mus I; h:i·.ro o'il,0imHl tho .1-01:1ul l:n \Jy mcn11F1 ttnknom1 to lm•r~ (20) ! ·, -~ 'l'ho ~locum-:,nto for ,,,,, 1'1'.jC Orini y:i nwn} !rm r~kuu, N0.153 :\ <3hulo yn f.;la:ln(s,i Nym:mn\.ln Ofin l .'t~' Ml:1n1 ,n !:llntlo, nwl NC'• 1 '.H tfi~r;ihomnltnalt nll ! ; i • podI of ·;'!i1xh.J>10, ,mr.o J'r;,p,.;·;><l by • 0110 n,,,1 1:ho snmo po!"om,. 'l110 first !. L.. is ~i@'lo~ by four p0lli11;': n,•,"11tn, Intl: 11,-,1; tho pr-011.i:.qJ1(.; c,fffc,,r, nntl tho ' ink:of tho m:cn n,:r,111: i!1 i;l:11 i_11I~ uil;h irld.ch l:l~o l:h1.'<10 fc,:rt:ir.: lloro wriHon .. l L.. Fqr No.1'1("\ Kh·oroli '3l·ul.011i, ~ho form i.o i.mproviaod en n yollow-ieh L ... . ;•: I I .I • I • to bonr th<:l ei,-;nnluro of ·tho prosiiling officor only. ! tloul,f;o<t if;.···· nnd.: tho •Bi(;!"l:\tut'O thotol"i1 l1oo!tttAo H yntrpor lo<l to h;:wo boon propnro1l . '· by- ,i i,olling neon!:. JI. 1,,-.n 1:h('I \lo,,,\ ~,n,t nr.tm-:, ":TJY 0 f,'.K.\'.t\ 'l\\11\UA IS,\Y,\", .bu-t .lhis. .no:>n~· . di,1 nc.:1: 011:11 H nor dl!.l Lhi> throo oth~r polli11g rtG01'~S (.' I I von-t4roaomo fobrlonH011 for, nccor,Hu~ I:,> ".!xhH'9, ·tho· nr2 \r:-tn, nR11in, : . look6d in tho bnllt, ~ l1<>1C• .; . . \. Thoeo . fifl:oon onGoa n1-o tho mont offottaivo to ~ho ai(J11t or tho '• i, moat ibogaliitg to l:hc 1:iin,l. SooHon J;F :roqu1ron tho roaull:n to ho I obtniod.

from ropf"rtn r-1coi""<l from pol1 iJ1~ GtnH-:,mi, ,nnrl thooo ropor-te \ nro rl,qu.i.ro1l by a. 191\( 1 )( h) 1:,, t,o "h1 I. ho m.umcr f\ncl f~t:11\ M ·tho \ I Commi~nicn mn:, dirool". 'l'ho Cor:1mir.irdon dooim10 .l tho 1F2 form lllltl nil'ootod 1 '· -· l i , its ul-..o by: tho 1n~u111.ln,; Ofrico,r11. · In f;h('I 11'rd:n11I: ca~o -1:ho 'JottU11i11g i I • ) / • ' 0 i . . Offioor . ! oypl.onL,ylo«l l.!,n fot,:i.fnr .. «1:lnl:rih1l:io11 "ml diroctotl ' i1~p1x,vlm\t:ion i f. i whoro itho -fol:fn \~n in r:\1,_1_1:t ~11pply CJ.· 1111nvnil"~-•ln. I Jvwo n0 qu'.\r.rol \ l?ith thcit. In U10 lnol:n11coo cib,o nl!oVQ, hnwuvnr, oithor t.horo nn1;1 l llo doo\.lrnont nl; nlJ, J.o~v-1111!, wcn,-inc•1:in fl\hinl;_l,-,un a~ l:c, hou 1:lto rot1ttltf] ,, \ uoro o,1tnihocl 1 or, ir th,11,1 w:111 n <loot111onl;, 11: io n f,:,rro:,ry. 1'h0 I • I. I J poti·Ho11orfe: oomplninl; -w:i.!1 net n1•<>ut tho t"Onttllr:1 nt ·l:ho-_volltur;·ptnH01t9 (20) I ' bu~ nil>out tho mrumor l;hono ronul to W)t.,1 c,htninocl for tho ncl1UH01\. IL i I omphneb.JJ tl,io liocnuot,. ,lur.ina tho -t:r1,,1 nnrl it1 hh eub1:1lorti<:'1tO Ur. Mnlrunsbn orrono~ur:1ly thnU({h t n11,\ th :h1lrn :ht to11no c, f ;l:lio t'OnuHe rh lhor . ,_ . thhn ~hq_proco·ea o.f tho :vJcliHon. .. Ho C\t lon:-1t o.d1.,He th~-t ec1110 of tbo _..) .., . dom.1moht~ purportodly rol iotl upon woro "cloplorl\hlo", bu-t nHributoe thh ·II.. ., "- to tho

"lo\l iow·1 ,;,f lH<>r::t~y ot r:io'.'ll: of ·tho J)toAicHna off"ioore nnd I·. :thoir· ~nteJ; I thi.nk-·I )mVQ uut:'.ficionny clomonntrntoct,1,,. from tho I L .. ovfdono~ of eomo prunid.h,c; offim1rr.1, th:il: l:hono woro oneot:i of for(J'Ory r>l':thor -thnn tl10 !Horney of \1mnconl: pooplo_. . .............. . Doforo lonvh11J l.hin nuJjcct I wj~h lo 111.11: tho :rooorcl. t1trnlgh~ in ()o) ' ! .,. i· n mnttor thnt\'.Jtr'llltJlY oco11t·r-i In l:lto r:ul1minninnn nf lC1'l1110,l ootnH.101 for ''· '- : ',. ; !.· .. ! ·• .... I I ;, tho nt1aonoo of Lho cnm\id'l l;o '.'othorwiao \)rcpcrl.Y ,lono" mo:ll\ i11 l'Oln Holl t0 t.ho nodHfott or V\-.t.o,n ·, . Dooa it l'!Oilll C('l"l'l..,Cf;J .Y 111:110 Ht Ll;o 111:; Lhotnnl;ionl, 801100 . ot cioos ft .. . ~orin d,,no nccnrd :ltV; tn l~u nnd procodu,o? Mr. i,~~eht\ nn~\ Hr I H!"rnnd.o I, . •• • . • ·• .t.ff,,.,VJ.::, ~c3·. m_ap101;1~~-i~inl _co~N~ l;noSl'l ~~1ilo ·?,1'• .. Mt•rr!lb,.tt:m /" lt· :rt~t~. \ f· :}: nh<ifJi~obdllio whm, ho c.l>ool"iotJ th~t lhot-o in ho prl~n~- \,_1\ti,b: t-1h~lo :.. · ··.,:~-?;: ' . : i o-t,roiso of r,oil1CT to lho poll if olno tkn offioinls chooeo 11 ~o got tho ii-=;\. (1 i Cl~t roaultn" from nomowhnrtl olso w,~Haolo:3od. '1110 Ox.ford 1!:rto¥Qlopod_fo (\ofinos tho w0rd "corroo ~" .,n "iruoJ rightJ ~our,olo" t-1hUo 'J., · tb (tho ru.loa", n11d "pr~porly'' in _•1ofinorl na "in o pro1mi: rn::-Jmo:r" • I \ nm

';oooordincl.v of tho vimt l;h:1.t "otl,_orH::r.t::> propotfy· dona" mcnne <lot10 ) ~; \ o.oo'.orcHna to f;ho rtt:l<rn. 111 I.ho ;-\1l,~Hi0.1 r.f vol:crn, thor,1.foro, H io \ . _. ... nof Ot)Otl/~h f.hr..t l.hn o.JCO;·clim ln ,k11c cn·rooU~·, l,uf:, rn•)ot of ttll, ' 1t hns '. to bo <lono noc0n1 in,{ f;,_, tho rt1lor1, .. I. J,,.._vo fnun<l ·in th.~li onoo -· cr,1.11...,mco<l cr,t1l.l.';i.r:/ ~o n.J5F, -I hnvo founrl thol roau).to 1f1>ro obtninocl from oourcoo u11~0Wl1 i<' Jnu, I 'h"V? Aloe ro,nicl ... thn ►• Utoo~oroloo ''" a whnlo wm, "· rnoi.o, 'l'hcr.o l"ctntM ttro tlo~ o:x:ou::mblo oinoo tho ·-aotuminr; Officor ouGtlnnLol:r rofmwd t,;, uot.ify lho ·ooncUdnto~ of tho vonuo of tho rvldil:i0_11, nml upp~-ron.Hy tlicl nc, iii <.1td.ctr ·to :porpotrnlci th~rr,t liUlo lt1tn.t,dJ1p, UH\t tru\h nlu:lyn hiw:tplm; ])1 ........ . -···-·······. \ ,. -' I I, . ,. ' j I Iii ·• .II \ For nll -t\lO'lu ro,'lod11n, I ::illow tho pr,~H:lr,n nricl doolnro I • •. • i ' . . \-t:hot.lnst ~nr'n p:lrli:unonl~r_y 019.0:t~,,~ 'b,11Juit1n ooni,f;iht,t1oy_!n '.\!1til).. nnd. I,. f ·• ' . ~19- ·nti'cl H in not· n~iclo~ 14ii firot i"08l'()t1donf; \fill p~y ' 1\ . . . ·, t~ • .- . • • •. .•• • ,, -~~~- 1>0-HUonor 1n oo:;i lr.t nftot in-Xt\H<'n;\I \ r.; ~: : . f · · -~ , .... · \ JHii: :,. -: .·.•. i ! • ·1•·••··• .... _. ___ _

JUDGE n11d Dr. J.·r.Mwn:iJtuCln for PeHH011er • ... . . for Hr. Hnrn11clo - . for 1s~ neepomlen~. Hr. W.C.Hagom.'l - (for Hr •. Unlonv:llin) - for 2nrl n~c:ro11clc11L .,,.: ... ,... .•'· ·.• .,. . .. ; .. ,·f, . ... •.·.-: •.· .,. t: •... ·, • '·I