19780609 TZHC Mwanza

~ HT ;11};.E ::::IG~I :JOU::JJ: OF T.ffrTZAHI.! A•;_: rmA: 1 'Z• .A APPELLA'.2E ,HJrifJ DI CT I OIT HIGII COlL1T CRr·:1~~AL APP:CAI, ~~o .157 OI:' 1S77 ORIGIEAL CHII~I/iAL CA3E F0.394 OF 1S7G or TITE JJI::VilRIC'.11 C OCf~}~ or· FiJCQ:1,A DI3Tff[C':2 N.:: jJC::;::o:oA .J·?_:(9-r~.~~~..! ... -~~ ..-}.:~ .......Gl~-~ )~1~i.l1:~.$. _J~t:~q- ~--' .. )~~~~~j_!_<:i._?/\·c___1_:~\?:_i_c~·-c_~~i-~~~. 1 D.it'~I.AJ-- s/o K.ARUSI • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 0 • • • • • • • • . ~ . • . . . . • • . . APPEI,LAII~r ( Oric~ina1 · Accur:ied.) versus JTJDGEtTENT fT.'he a.:1J~eJ.J_8J::t:c i"ia8 cc:nviv'c·~c~ on t\rn COL:u:r:;s ~):c° Car-:ryiag·on 1)n::-d.:.1sos r;-itliout a lic,:!:ics co . .rl-ra,ry to :is".)ctirl_-O,fJ 17(ll)(a) a:.-1.cl ')( 0 ) ,) \ o·!" + 11"' T,,c,1·11'".--1 8 J.,_ ., 1..."''~"'1· ,:_ -'- ._, ... ,:., -._: .. !.,:., _l,J\.,{,0 ..,~. Jc+ ~·•l..1 . i'T,-J ._ ,:.,, r,·c• .1.: ,. • 2r:;/7°: - ..•.I ,:.. 1 ~-·tc~ ,-,/"111..:·1rr n•ood'"' ,:.hl... J. ;')\_, __ 2.L G l.).. 1:J .J 2,bovo .i1c'.Xi~1u.c:. price co J.tre,:cy -co·:: SGction.s 20 2,,1.cJ. )G i Pa,rt IV 0 of ·i;.I1c H8:::;1:J.stioJ-1S Price Act :?o .19/1973 11 1 rosp:·c·;·,ivoly. . On the :fir-st c oi.1nt h•.":! r.:as s,m::·.m.1.c2d. to ·[~\:;cl vc non:Lhs i:--•.priscn"J.mont ancJ. on the f:l':ic on.cl c o-1,u1t h:J \';as ocn:c:::,:o.c•.':el to ~-:L2;].J.°'C8r:).iJ .:1ox1thi:; · l·-1nrJ'r: .'; ._,_ J? J.,. ~l,.:, ,-:

8.,. -'="'.,"a ) ... ,.··1"""··1-•- J.J ( .1• ,_: , • .:::.!.J, I., r·--=· C,1.-r·. .L l,._.,:. OJ. IJ.ll ...•. • 1 , r.:oo/ J 1 =9 ,, ll.l- O,J... or,,.,::: T 1:·~.;.•.1.') ~"] ... ,,..,,.,_,.. _ _._,-"\~":,·'- vl-<'o lJ ..1.. t_;:ie tcr,:-~•.G. of L,lpr:i_so_;_y·,_GD.'G shmLlc1 J.'.'2VJ. CO,:lCLl:rTC.~~--;;ly • I-:'; is novt 2.ppealinc. E'v-ic10nce was lecl 2d; ·chc trial ·co shc.w.: -~1:.a·c m.~ 12·c.h Octobcr 9 197(.)r ·'·>•,:·. U.......... "'iJ;""'lj_-~:-L·i· c., .c l_J ..,, o ..\. v T;~o , , c.",..i 8'1)nr~o•-~r.)·,,:,.~ •·.t: .':'· • <~ . ,,.,; •.... , .. \...L ,,.._-, •..;J ·'·,'.·.-, l .,.. _._., cr,-1)"l•::,.·i·,·-1~,·;·'· ·-'·' ··J_.J_,_c:., ___ c..r,.. .. l, 1';1 ... _ .•.1,,,., V.t-v c-.,,·r, c.~...1 v y ~lr., OJ.•..,, F·t~""'~"'-.t"l. .• ._\...L'--' C .,.,. 1'" r:.•/o D,..'l .::,··1 (P"\ 1]) >-> 1 0,ll.\..!.._ 7 I. • r+ 1· ',.._J .~ ..!.,,,-,·:·. '-' •• ,.Jv c1,,, ..,-J~ .,,·;',r,r:· . •.•C.,J_ ~ •... ~ ' - , . . ;,·srpc,·'1.,·l •J.l'.,., -•-J7 tho so.:i.cl aJ_)proach v;,;a,r.3 r1ac1c;. · Ace o:r-cEn.c; to PVll ·;;_'1j_u \;z:'.D .::;:c );J.1e a1)IJ~~1J_:--i .:.1:t' c J:1O1..,l::.;0. :r.1or-.~~7:~e;r,. c\ccordi:2.c: --~o t;_;;_,:; o·~;~::,:~r r.:i-f;.i1.:~cses i:.1 -;;;J_o c2J·~e -c~iio ·::·1·a.e.:; a-..t ·::..:.-.:.e s·Cc.tll y;l:.c;r0 ·c_;_1(:: 2~1JIY:·?llF..~._;J.tj ssllfj :fiDl1 ·-;pecatJ.sc ho is a fish ,:.1or1:-:;or. ·,.'TlJ.,':i:''2V.n· i·c ws.s ~ 0::1

.':.is 2-.rri val PYrl 1J.~1-:jicoc~ ·i;J.J_~-G ·:;·_:_1er-...:; 'ft.~ctc a. Cl1"Y'L1r: co11·;;ai~. 1i::. ci I~c:r·o::;;r~J~.:::. Si:'..1ce pi,71 'ii2.s l(;Oldnc; for sc::1.0 :fr-~r0sen.c ·;/is a9p0llc?,nt 2,e,;r-::0d. to 2,11.d dtcl. i:o. ft~~c-c ~ell ·tl1s v;)_1oln c:rGJ.:. of ICe1~oss11':~ ·to·l).i··.1.P j_.o. P.~7.1. 1 J:l1e price; n.::·/i.tion':H1 by t.1.i.S a,_\)_i)~:llar.::t Vi2.c Sh£i.l~000/= 2nd P1!tl 1JZ·.ic1 t}::..c-) .=·.1.o::1oy ·co him.. I·c r,:::.~o Y'i.b.i1c:: F71 r,c ..:::,s c2.IT\'i:,.: ..g Ei•')_i'.1.0 of 1 ·'1.,·]1P. .. ..,. ...• - -... O"'''•,';,-> T'-c,~ ~'..:.. __ .. .,. +n v.J 1 ,·; .L,-j .•--•- 'iJ] acr-... J. _,..,.., ·1,ihcc,,'1 . ........ .,.., __ 1~o -'-"'-'-' v·;:,c·, iV~u ac0nc,•'·,:,,c~ ., ""'_,,-;; 1.J...., ~ ;c•;·1f.' . . n ... •• ...t. ,·.,,,,..,r·.:,o•·,"'.1+1-r ~- !,.rlUU...., :,.L .. •,.._ ..t..V J e.._p.l)J~G.1:J.3::.-1cJ.ed 1:>y a. 11 a.,sJ:t1,ri. £lie .i~;_a. -'c·~;e1.... \'le. s r~1_r,<)1.,·C(-:cl ·l;o -~;).10 Polic'3 1 •1rl ":o a.,J ,_ ;.. . • _.J• T' l-"'L17 T <::t,:,.-~ .Jul, ■ -~:::. .... \J ··1,._-.... uL Tn1..,.'1 ,J.J,_ (7.>"7-:'; 'i .Looi-- V \_ ..:.}. ·up 1C1 c.; ..... ·'·'-n U.L. .. -• I.;.) .:.L ..:,·,rr.,,•·•l •• ,. \ ._., .. ;:,c.::i:• l, __ 0''0 ... j ~q~..!-; \ .,L. .• .._ .' ,I J I..L., •• .1..LU i11 ·tl1<:~ cc::,SG. T~o rv·e.i.1·l~ a. :.:.G. 8. □ l:c1d ·ti)1.c a .:.J~?~ll2.;~·rC ii•· 2~c l1;:-:.d 2. lice11cG -co

BsJl ~-:8·ros-31.-:1.2 ·bo y;)J.ic].::. ·G1;_3 a._pp(;lJ_a. 1.1.·t; a...:·~:.fJViG1--eG.. i11 ·ii. 1.2 :;1ega:Gj_ve. 1 Q,.r.J.. ;_,G lJ • 7"~ i l.)I" .i.:::!.,u t.Tnh,- U.!.J..:.l (P•"'!) .I_; J •.. , ... 1- •.; .r,J· "'(~ t,·.:- t,_L_L _ -• ✓ l ·'·c·· 1) t, . ..lJJ 1.1-r, ..t...:.. •:'"'".L"·""r-0·'· .. _:_ .,. - t., . -·-:--,.•. .. L· ....o .. i;. "G--1 r,y,1·-1 1 ... .:. 1...:..1 _ .-,.c1cl1 ,J _ :.. ~c. -:v.1 "8 C,>::, 01 .:. c·.y lJ'-" r> , .... ·1 _,,_..,._ ~ •__ 7 -:,••-·:- "1'v. :.).'L.,,..;, . ,_ . ., r. '..1 7 )-J 1 ""' •.,·, . "'"paci \_,;. ,,._ __ ·'·,- V ;f o·"'-'- ')00,·.. ·l·i-'- ·'·-;•,,-,,-; u _._ ....., "J o·"'j_ T,...,.,,I"OS·"''~r.> .:.~. · ~ \_., .1..:. • 2J.10. tl.J.r:! cG.TGrolle.d j_)ricc er[ D~Tosen":! :La j'\,Llob2, Di;;·;;·:cict rias ~ at -:·J1•"" v.~ r.1::,,· .... ·"':r~ ··•1__ -:-J· , .. 1 ,_.,,~_a, ·1e c,_;._.,:-•~• Sl1c:; 1/70 1, 1·1""1~ •. •,, . . 11· ·'t-rn J~o I.:1 rn.J.',J_1.", · _ : ·,J·.-_,--·'1.,· I. o·_f-' tl1c-, l·o..,,tt""-r - Fn l)I'C1 <.1X'.C8d a lis·i; of ]1r-ic2 co:;Tcrollr2d. 8,r·'.;:i,c1::,~,: an.d tt.cd.r re:ci pec'i:iive prices is:::;uec1 ~-:Y ·che Ass:j_s·uan:c P~,:-ic(1 Cor~:·J_i;-'sionr:,r of :" t1..lc:b,,:. :Ois-'cr·ict (:S::;:.h. :n). In :.-:1.:i.r; cl-:~fe·.. c~~ ·chc~ a3;p"1lc;:.::. .t C:.2n.i:::d scll:V<:; a ·y ;::.:ero::wne 1 to PY!l. _;:.ccorcU.:ac to hi':'. t>:·. JC;'_?,rvcrJne: 1>.:hich ·the p,,liN'

r.;:_dzsd fJJ~q,-=:.1 .~J.i~; ~f io.b. s·-~alJ_ .-vi_i·as 01.;_:-; c::z· -tJ.1e ·iJ::~.1"'ee a~:r·L1..cu:5 r:.L15.c3.:. _i1J.C.=:•.1.l;~:1~c: o:i:' l:Ca32.1'Jiro Cc·-:-.Opera·Ci ve s.1.~.:J:J lt2-..cl <-?.• GJr::~a. }1iL;1_ t,o bLi_J1 :~·or ·tJ.b. e.1.11. I~o tr:i,,cd ·t;o ,:,~•·pl ~i--, thj c- ·co p·n , ; · 11 0' th,,·, 1 J=·c".'·,·•,,:, yr,-~••r -~,,.-.·rs, r•it 11 )-ii •1. ~··:, . r> >-.Ct~--~ 1<~.. ,J.~ .:.- .~:,, .!~-.,·\:::~ .:;;: -~:~:'·:~~~-.,l~·.-.•--V.!~. ~(' ~}·:::_ t:~-.. -:_ 'i::JJ•·~:.1-. J. ;;;~~- aJ.1(i_ ..... CC.Cc,:>.;..(,1_ ill,:, O.L (,.c:0,lJ,-' ..,., -].....·. ,:.0,.Lt..-•·• .. •;..tE.. O.u 1.,11 .• ,)lc,C~,. ;,,_,r. .,... !J • .1.•.. _ ; , eventu2.lly 1 tolo. hin. the;[; .'.::,, s o,:;ipclL,·,.::d:; 9 · ~'iot.,.lc~ lY:) r-sl:rn.snO. on.ly 0 : 0 1'1 C ~;-~,... ,, 1:J"'l. ...J_- .. o.L. 7 L; o·"' J. ... t.::; • 1 9 \.) 0NJ~,, ·"00/·- -• r,,,, -~ .,,~ ...,f~ . t.,,.:, __ 11•·.,.t._:,•.t. '- ~ .."''1. i' _,.1.1~·\:~ 1;'!c;.1.:: '"::l ,..,1 ,, C n•.,+,:-. •,;.,_,; v.L v,:.. Ci." ~-o v :. 111· :. r: l~,o-.,,:') _ )J · .!.;. J :.v ·p·'-i,---~..-\ //.'.. 4•:,.1. C. , .... c .:.J•. _, 1.-.r, .... -.]''(""'i .. "'(; !..J,.1.i. . ~; .. U !. -!-l-i,. U.L., .... -,o•--/j,:- '. __ J.10,Y y :....'.1. ,._.I ] -? OC·O/- ("!'! •. .:.1.J •, .1\ - • ~ fT1o _._ ~1; r.: .1 .• 4_,_..._) f 1· • • e· 2:..Pl)t:.,llE~:::_-~;' s, disr12:.y P~73 J_.::-·~~31~ ·l;L::.1"'11e(J_ ~LJJ.S

1~~;_0.,.L~-:~,r i.-~.-.-~o ~_;. .:::. C}[::.i l)i·G. 2 l1c a1J11·.::J.lr~::~·~; ca"lled t-r:·D rii-t11G □ s~c-J 01J. l1jr3 r.::i_d.c;. D.?!.?, ~: 1 -/8J1.Cl,,8..:::J.C1 Cl•.~i:,J.G.iJ:t r:ai,1l,lG.ii:i].lt~·,? ·G(3f3"tiif•ied. ·so t}l.(~) .-;:f:(~~3c·C t.'J.3.:t; Git l?/10/76 t:::, 9 e,s s.:.1op ~::·s.,1c.~Ger of Kj_•3.r•J.l1 Co-op(;rs:i:;::_vr:: SJ.mp, c:,,)_·U:,.o:r-j_c;sd pc.'.y;:,_e . . ·:L . of ·c.)St·, Sl2.ri .1 9 200/= 7 to PY!1 j_:,J. l:.is caps.city ..... r-:-: c.~, C-J!, op (""(~. ,...,_,_ - 1· r··"·:.r,s.'.- ,_,_t.J.a___ r-·o c~..,_. __ ,._l L•c...j' T'err•c_l '""'I., ·'-:, ('\v C:, ~,_ ,'!l-1c-. ,._,,::, '.,, .. v .p ,,.,,..., --~-~,~0 ""1 rl .L ,_, , .... ,,,--. ..u.,_,, ,r: ~, r,,) l. • T ~'-'-er· -.1<-:· l, ,1.L 1: .. he rGcei vecl inf ,)r.i ...ation t.llc1t -c>_:) said Keror:;<:.)_:·\0 hac 7Jc~):l sei7.ecl lJec2.1..1..r.~e the sellr:"'.!l~ had s{:_.J_c1· i·t; at; a11 iJ.lc,·:~al lJr:Lc(~. 1 JY:?, 9 Eclwarcl 3inon 9 \-;ho der::lcri 1x~d. hi.c1uc~l:f 2,:::; ·:.;l:.o "\72,r-d E;cc~cL:.·:~:tve Of_[icn~r- of· I(["':,'_"·!_a,cJ.2.:).r.1u.. , t:;ot~i~fiecl ·to· -:;J:1.~~ c:r:c~:c·G -c11a. t c::.fter ·ch,: aj]l)Gllo,n:t; • D ar-row-'c ai:1.c1, app2,r:3ntly 1 : ,ftc;r_ h:.: 3.1c.d bc:sn rele2\,sec~ on b2j_l l1e 7 Ec1\:ard. 7 f3LlrJ.::1.011Gcl t.~1.c~ 2~1J11~0J_lDJ.·::.:C iL.ttcl ar:1}~0a. t hi.:.,. alJOLl'G tl12 I~0rosc;J8. '.'_:_'.}.8 2,p~)(_.llc,nt dci.\:·.i:":!d

;;=;01lj_T<~ any KGr1xc;ene 21JJ.c7.. 2,c:.. clefl ·l;h,;:i,-t the clrlli,. 0~:: rc,-::;:;_~c,r:,;e:=::i.e oil Y,.!.iic:1 h:!; ~?.pp,:.ill'-'n1·'.;, had belonged to T~isin3;a. Co-opr::r'--i,tiv::s rn:.i.op. L2:1~'.'.:,J:' L',: f 5i,11_-.m~ vvent to Kizi.::2-~\a C o-operat:L vs Shop 2 ...1cl asJ:::•=,;d it:::J Ck-::.ir. · :::,.:.1 D.nd ~r0asu.rsr if what ·lihc 2-,;_)pcll2..;.1·c 112d r:;aicl wa::; tri.:i..c. :Both of t.:.v.~.:~1- agreed aclclinc: tha:t they hc,c.1 i::;::i.. v2.n a_;__)_p:;112-,1.t 8).'.'.S .1, ~00/= f'or- Kerosr;;nc. LEd;;er rstill the Ch2,ii~,,;.a;:1 of TCizinc,a Co-opsra:civo SJ.101J confirmed to hin1, i. c. Si.r--:o:·::i.~ • ·c.hat 2,pp0ll2,;.i-c w_as thej_r E:,G8.n:c. Ti.1 hiD p::~ti tion. ol a_ppE!al the e,ppolJ..2,;rc L1~;is-cs t!:1at 11(; dicl no·;~ sell -;;-11~1 drw·.:;_ of K8rc,ssn::: tc F'll • .u·ch011-.?:h the 8,_ppcll2~11:~ hi.u)f:3elf cl.id. n6-;, 1'"'8,if3(') ·c.hiZJ point th~' 01.:(b-scctions g_u.. o-c.3d :Ln Ccn,D.r,, 1 2.re all wron.2;. ~:~he proper sectim.1E, are Section.s 3(1)(a) [',jJ.cJ.. 17(1)(a). L.1. c.1_re;t.1..j_:,:.0 ou-c t'Jj_s c,_ppe;;·,l ix-:!:f ore m0 -;,118 lear,1ed Ste:-,.-;;,; At·;:;o:cncy, ;_~r,;. T~t:tovv., was o:f t.b.e vievr ·l;.1-mt -i,):(? ch... ·,r8e i.:-.:1. CoL.1.11·c 1 tD'.lC.er vvrn:~1c snb:-r::iections was an· iD._porte...11.t irr8gt:iJ.. o,rity r:.hj_cl'l co1,1..lcl h:wo pr:~; jL1.C:.ic:;-;d t}:1.0 2.p_9ella:;:.i_t.

1:"."itl': :rer.:;_pc~c·i; I do .not t.h.inJ: tJ.::.2-t ·c.}'.~ 2.p~)eJ.la.:-:i.:c ·was Or ·. c'oc1u_ 7 (~ w- )-::,_,,-, J...... 1J8"'i"l v_ .tnrn _ . J·,,,1i· ...,_u,. \i , c 0...., r.L 1I"JY ·!·h1' , :.:: _·i rr0.rr-1·•l:::--r'~ u .. - c' . _ ... ..J.. ·;;,:r -i ·t'- 1· 11a. 1 0r::c~ L9 ,.>-· <-) ... .. , __ v;J • __ , , ··- ., ... • hf;lp:=i to r.:.11011 tho:~ -che 1~:8,J'.'"_,_,]cl P-u.blic Proscct:-:.·i_;,:J:' · tirl no·~; bo·l~JJ_:~r _,,, to chr,cL 1.~i:L t.ti ~1ic: lc:xi p:ci c,r to i"ilj_ng ·c.h'3 chc·,rg-:. A'c 2,;_,J_y ratr➔ I 8 .. :r, 11:. C ,...1.·r+i TI<~Vi.:,_ . . r."lr,.c:_r: u.L..:...:•. ,,:J ..:• c:-.--:-J4_ c-:..-.· oo.v n-; ► :>..L.l.:.L~ -L~"\g·'- G.,.i.._,.,t, ..!...]"\~ L•:.J.U ...'.\l""'t .. "'\'•'l ]. '.:')-r,•'- c..,_i_JJ_-•·,; _ -:...•_i.!.U 1--,-·,,-:·-···'-1-'\~. c',.,. ...-,.... (1',...,C'I .,......i._vvv ;;.ux.. .u.c·,-c.;.... ,..., ag~:-ir!r:i -t: 11-im. v ·GJ10 .o:is qt1o·~c::i:i_ 01.1 c:r:· --l~J.1.c s1.~ lJ-DG c-G:L c;_:~.Lr1 j10·,i ,,.~i ·-CJ.1S ·Gai1dir1g. . ;J!ur.~,j__:J. 6 to th-:-; ov:i..O.cJ1.c2 ~ I ·do .ao\; tlli.t:L": ·t~.11;_·•:c ·:;L,:: lear::Gd ResiC.etd; :~2,gis·l;J:-2~te g2,vc i-~ 2, t::~or-cu,S:1 ctin:::;ic.(?-r;;i:\·,i;:r:•. al"'..C'l analysis v:;_~J.iC}l i·l,; desei"ved.- Irl l1j_fj cl:;ir..n.ce ·i:;1:tG aJ?_p:-;]_12./1.·:; fi0.id_ ·G.b.8.:G .h.e -ff~3,::-J e;i ,rnr~. S.::.(s .1 ~ ooo/= bs tl-J.e ::~c:J,.i::-:o.ger of

Kagg1J::i.i..,o Co-0_~12r:::d;i vc .-.. ,~ F>1· ch 1ouy ·'u-hrPG ?:.,..,.~,.;,,, ()'j_" ·•,-r,_,ro'-':"''l"' 1 o;..,l1r S110 ,.J 1 •:·.:·i..,_l.,_t._ 1 • .... l ..... ·'t..,._, f') ...l.~Lu,.,;,i ;,.'\_,.., __ -.t. ~· }.:.1.~.L.~.-e Y;.---. '1-,.c c.:J.,l iJ .1.-~~ .1. .• 1 •• .:. Purc ._ l1a•·y,.Q~ .,_ ~h ()11°' ,; V' 1•G'"l .._,._- l.lP '(~r.ir~ ,..,__ e,~•p·;)-.L •'••·• J. ... -'- (~]1(>•· .; .• ..,; 1 a_l,--.c1 J_. • t_~l.J 'T1hc __ _. ., __ :·.>112.c,•,:,·,-. ·•'••• ,,; T!';o,,r;,.,1)1·ro ..,-.J • .i. '-' :.l,\.'..) -'.--: vi J.}......,'-)Q-' _ Co-op:2r2,~i ve Shop, D".71~ c.~G]Jj_,)d (;ivj_D_g -the app.-:.,JL',JJ:C :~:;1f, .1 r 000/= for pu:c:po::Kis of 1:n1.yiri.:z Y.(erC'80:.1e oil fOJ'.' the Co-nJ_x,rat:Lve ;::,.hc_p. ne 9 .hov;evsr 7 reca.11(,:d -t,_;_;_2::~ on -c:1s .C!E:d;er.i.aJ. d.. 2,y1 he 2,u-ciwrised D ~y-,,r.:y'- o·;: ~!~'°' ..L:C--' .J ...... 1 9•-">00/- .'.!.•'.: ..... IJ - +o pH] -r-·cir p,;rpO'='DC' OI" f.J\..1-_;-'-•··•,._:, -l- U. "'1"!7 ;':/:; T'-:•rr,r·a,-l,:, .,.•, •- V ,, __ -•- \,_ ~ 0.._,;::,., .)1-), ..1. ,.....,, oil 1 or ·V10 c o--ov~ ra;~i V':! shop. Ac c O1~din.~:; to JJ,-.'l ·:;~i:c: ::-:]_1_c, _pixie; of articl("S of .c.iarc.:.-10,nd:Lsn f' or th:? Co-oj)Grs::,i vc. '.]L.oD ',i2,s lJ2 j_n_;~ Q~ o---, r, !..:.,:- ;y -'-lu._..t.,.,, . rr',a 701~ r: ·'·l.J.·11,~- i 'V'>~-1.. c.".JP v.L ... ~--.L-· rrr~"' ... ,.. L ..... _._ ""'UI~e-.,.. .....

c;~-,.. ..._ c-vl. .. o • .L o·j_'=' 4-'y:. uJ._\_. <'.'I!- on ... .l.1....- a.,)_l -:-j-P. ~. . 1·. _ • - • (' ,_£:J • • D\'D_ 9 adcle cl -clla.t it wa,r::i y · ho,c..:o ve rs 1r1i -1;.h:i_n hi8 .\no-c:1-:, dt,;0 -clw.t D::; +ul!:1.-.:S ·- , _,_, •' .. r,, --~ - . . l1J.~G SJ.1.01) '.Jilc.. :._Li."\!l.8..0. 9 pc-;-1 - \~-L? lJ..D·-d ·: · · -'·u() uv.U.<;i c,-.-- ~ -'-l1.Ll~·; 1- ·· · · ....; , 17 2,})l) ,., . ·'·l, -•-l,O d 0 ....... c.l.,.TI. _,_, . rt, . . :· . lJJ.18 ,:.)J..:.0J)l.!.'l;3 f or J.'J.l•.!l D8C,.. ,Uj:,Q Qj_ _,l,.; 9 ]_. <;.;. app ~ .... ,..,.'...'.,(, •'-' J.1~"'\r c.,.,c._L,r,.,.1.. , n 4 .r:• ]-,·.-~ •• ,. • ..... - -cl'J~-.--,.•'•1;-. . . "";r·: .., ...~-'-'tr u, to the :=:.11.op:i..nc~ centre. '.l:.1;10 evidence of )J71 on' ·c_;:_ic; poir,:~ j_s in pari par3SL-'!. vvit.L, -i,)1.8,t of D'72 aj:.d both of the;;:c D,r0 i.ncle_pencl8n-c ,~:i ·{;:i:J.6~300f.) ill -{;lie CC.Ge. . . . /3 3 IJ.1dee0. pi~JJ_ i1j_J;J.S ilf· c:3..c~.:_·;.t{-;(1 -C.l-ia. ~~ l10 r:ie.~1-L -~:;:ic: a;.1·1JcJ_la. .J.1 ..G ·Go· -, . ,.,O,.i,e 1)1.,.y c: .. , T'i.) s _... ,ro,c-18 Ol 1 U,1Hl,.:, ~1 ,· .,.. , .... ,., J..• c. Dl~fl • J• • • ,c:'" ,!).~.1 ~"!"~1.r.- ...,;..L • ::;-.~:,-:•'- d 1,"' .;. .1•.1.c)l,Ca 9 .J.1c;s P\7i, insi::Tc86. that he boL1.;s-1.~·;; ·c.11e ~~!':!rosene oil :~·ro.=-': ·cl10 appsll2..n:c. P1:ll 1:J.:L1:1::J :~lf c1j_G_ · r1.o·C 0a.y :for \-:/l'l2:t~ .l-1.~::

· _pt,1..:cc}:1e. r.::oc7. c.J_J_ •·:.~11a. ·G ax:10Lu1·G 1 of ILe rose:ne oil? 8, whol0 drL~.:•l o:f i ·c, that is -to oay 1·.:J_1e the r he v1a?J_-ced i·c for hir; dor.1est:Lc use or :for ressl1. J.,oVi'C')V:.;J::, on the evi cl.enc e o:c D'71 'i,JlicJ.1 s ·;·:--21c~s 1.mci:,a,ll:::nc~~i d 2w:icL n.:;.,.c cm··cracli c te cl on thiEl asrJect o:c th8 Ci~,SG i-c j_s c1ear ·che:'c 118 9 r·n9 bou.gl-:i_t tl1e drt..1.m o:f ~:Gross;-:,_e on b'.>._;_,LlJ of the Co-op,"!1~.::;·civ:) Sl:.OlJ of v,-.::!icJ.1 l1e Vic~s C}1(::,ir:,1_2v1.1.. ~1_1.:.1~:-;·i~ bsi:.1g so a,l'J.cJ. I J:--0"!_p2;:t·G ·i_;_b_c::tt; ·t.b.ero i::1 acl~1.is'.3i b1·:, a::1ii crecli ble evi<le,:.1c2 t>at j_-t; was ·chel.:. the <lerliaJ. by P.71 "i:i.'\at he as.1:ocl the e,pp;""ll2J.1.t to clo ·ch.e buyi ..::.c: for hiD:. p2J_e::-J j_n-co oblivion. T.1:.:is v:L:Yi is str2.ngt1-::.:=,;_1(~d by t>c ?;:-.ct; ·chat if· F.7J. wc:re to bo 1Jelievcd oD. ·c};_is o.sp2ct of th8 1·1-s:c<icr ·cl1en _'J.oVi 9 1 ·G .nay 7Je asked, Y1ou.ld 1::..? ]12,ve 8,cc ou.ntecl foT -c]:;_::-.: :10::.J.;::y gi von -'-o pl---··--.""\f'""'fe .)J. .bi,,<} .~J.. lL, TT--,ror~ ,c ..-.-""r.,•r:~-•""l coo _pc:!"'J""'t··.-·e 1""','T ])1-;-7 .!J"I~ 41 "lr.\ r-17,: .'.'1-i-'l lJ.!.1r· :0, ,l J 1 ·r·i-,....,,rr 1 Li .,• .' .. ,. u v 0 .,_,_ .L ,., LIJ. .• 1-, :.•!. J::;·_,,_:, ·, ~.,:;, ...;._ !. 1·: \;J_ _:_ -!.. ,; shop'?.. ·:'~ore . • s O ·1~:l.

1..G,, -·-~- 1· .n -:;:,,..,, ... -~ ., "v·o-,,..1. \ c'],. s o·-L"' _ T'J'-'Jl -· . . , ..., )~c--i,•,,l '1TPJl{' . ..... ... 9 ~ \; T•:;w 1· C! ..a .• t,J T:11y cl n 1~ic 1:-- Dr-iu"' 1· ( p•"TJ ) ·'v·hr.> C1"R •'- ..,._ ... _ .• _. • • .,v \), • •• • _ .j.._1..,. J .; r . ...,a;, Yi'ho 1"\"!c, l.J J.--~..J..- I. ...... ...... ..,J ,II,.'.) l.;,;J -~ ... "' -J~·()-.L'· 01 1 ·.L·· r.•, '1op U0()1~ ..J.1-' • ...... )_;,}.1 _ • It is upc.:.1 1.-:;irn. to knm: .=;;-11•-=-Ts ·co Get ·c.1:.8 e;ooC.:L,~. ?re:c.1(n•ico \·io-..;iJ.c1 t.l1en ts:nu.r:ir ·i:;lJ.3 1_)11-rch2,sinc; r::c8ip•;; c,nu. I r·li.11 snte;r ·chor~. i;:,.-~;o ou_r boO.~';:S of·a.ccorn:it. 11 S1.>is i;1cle2d is 1Yhc:d:; 02·:.8 '.',C),_:_1d c::;:i)ec·t, thj_nc;s to bo. In -'ch8 i_;1st2,,_;_1t csJJ.:?. FH e.irl no·c Ilroch1c:-: ,3,ny· l)l.J..rc.1:J2,r,d.nc; rec8iI,rf; purportedly isnuccl by th:., G,_p_::i,H1e,_a·c nor 9 i1.1cle e cl 1 · Ctl.t. 11(~ ~ PVIl, s Lt(;t?;(~ s ·t ·iil1a·t e. .~J)T 1r;2.s :L sr:n10 (1. I.J. Cllcli ·Cj_ on to ·cll:Ls r -1_:_:1crc cs. n be _:_::_o d.8ulJt ·c.1.1:::,t t.:2.8 Xr.:-;ror:Jr..:112 oil whic.~:. bo-ch P'.71 anc_ P-91)'.::llan_-;~ talJ;:0cl. C:'.llo1.:.t i.,:;as tb.c 0;a::1.:J on:::: because ll accordin,:; to u~.n. 1 F71 rcpcn·ted ·co hi_.·,. th,:;:l.i th:~ :(erosr:i,:_:<.: r.:_\j_c;.-1 li:~ bou.g.:_,,_t heel b:3c:;::1. 5,3j_z,ed by tho· ?olico. La:i.i8r the s2,icl ::-2rosens

1•;as GJ;:_:_:~:Lbi-Cec1 8.:t t.l1e ·trial. '.~Thy P.71 Qecided to cle:..1y r::,2_:Jdine; ·i:.b_e a_p_p:·.:lL\(1:c ·co buy ths Keros0ne on his b2hc::-J_f irJ best Jn1m~,:n to him:~_;c]_J. Porhe.ps it nay rwt b:<:, insignific<'..:1:,.J.t to ,.1_0-;,c) th2,t ori;::~inc=:J.1y i·c 'Fias P1,71 hir;1oeJ_f vv·ho was arrested_ 1JY ·i~11e. Po1ico with th:: :::cc:::-r)G:Jne. On -:-.'\T -'-•-l,y e-r"."'-:,7 v c•,-- ..v-c·, J ,!::)-'-1" Li 0'' ~J. 0·.L -!-uL. ""1(>, "'Vl '-· 0 a:,r,•;..,cn 1 ~o-1V...1. -.-LL ,J la t., ,._,. 0 u_,_, clr,r:ir -·:·1r,c. .i_' •Jc,, • -:-r, .,,. . , _,_,,r-,t "..., _, ,.•-· Li.,_._,::,_. •p··;--n • , .I. v,-an no·c c. ·cru:thful wi·cnesr:;. I:f the learn.ed Resic.7.e:11:G :'-LV~irJ·crate had prop,:::rJ.7 analysed tl:..e evic1e_;:i_ce as 8. v.;holo I tl1it1!..: he, wot:~ld :not J:ie.v~i :failed ·co fin.(~. ·Uiat ·chr-i 2vLl0nce of P.'Tl, i1_1 ·;;he lj_c;ht of ot}::i..sr t:Jvidcmc0 en r'::cord 9 briot1es ·c;ith ir,1.i-:>J.r LJ.Ci 1Jility. In -G.i:1e cj_rC"L"Lt"tlf.JtatJ.CGS i·t ,vEtFJ VCI\)' lJ..l1B:~:fc ·co c011vict; OIJ. ·;;_i,:..c.~ (~Vid.e11ce ol' P~.-a. J.\.S ·cherc it-j 110 c.-:~.:,_:-;:i:' 9VidG:nce ·co 8 Ll.P.:)Orc ·c_'lG,t of P.71 0:.1 -tho c::L1.2st5_ons of s2J.2 :~.1d price l1i.l:inc I 2.:-_ oi ·cric co],Diu.ered view -t;;_._,it these convic·cic.:1E, c:.:honlc3. .J_o·i~ b'?. s,llrn.-ecl to s·i,2.ad. In t}10 eve;:1t ·cllir3 ,:J,DJ)Cal succeeds.

:J!.!.1::: co:c.vi:; t:i.cns on bot.1_:, c OL1J:1·Gs r;;_.rc ql:t..fJJBJ.7.ec.1 C.J:J.d t.l18 ct~11·Cer.1.c(:8 ~>.re s0t; 2.cidc. ~J:]10 a.p1:>clJ_a!.1·C shoulcl be set free i.:1ct1c:cl.ia·cely rnJ.le □ s, of coL:TS,~ 7 L;::, ir1 l)cinc held on D,Js;1e o·i.;hr.1r le.w:f1..1..l c 1.:.c.:.rges. · If -c118 :fL:::3 _;_::.2,r.:; bocl'J_ paid t.hc c.a;:12 s.:10uld 1x:· reft:.:LldE.,d to 11.iet. It ii::: orc1erecl accordingly. :r::T: AJJZA 9th Jl'..l1G ~-- 1978