elia fredrick ulomi 66 others vs severen stanley 10 others 2023 tzhclandd 16888 7 september 2023

elia fredrick ulomi 66 others vs severen stanley 10 others 2023 tzhclandd 16888 7 september 2023

Applicants have not been dispossessed of their land; they remain in possession. The decree in Land Case No. 168 of 2011 is declaratory and does not specify the land occupied by applicants. The court cannot grant orders under Order XXI Rule 99 CPC unless applicants have been dispossessed. The application is dismissed as the reliefs sought are not available under the cited provisions.

Citation
elia fredrick ulomi 66 others vs severen stanley 10 others 2023 tzhclandd 16888 7 september 2023
Parties
Applicant: Elia Frederick Ulomi; Applicant: Jonas Kastory Mtisi; Applicant: Pascal Boniface Ndiyunguye; Applicant: Felick Yoram Kalengela; Applicant: Frank Onesphory Mrema; Applicant: Lameck Jacob Stephano; Applicant: Baraka Damian Toyi; Applicant: Joyce Joel Komba; Applicant: Murimi Patrice Chacha; Applicant: Ramadhaniissa Bakora; Applicant: Jamila Hamisi Ucheche; Applicant: Rehema Nurdini Omari; Applicant: Yasini Hamisi; Applicant: Beda S. Kimario; Applicant: Jonas Florian; Applicant: Baraka Nkabo; Applicant: Chrispin Palakata; Applicant: Ayubu Alharuna; Applicant: Rahim Beleko; Applicant: Ngowi Edes Nolasco; Applicant: Amandus Chatila; Applicant: Mwitta Chacha; Applicant: Justina Daudi; Applicant: Christoper Moses; Applicant: Mwajabu Athumani; Applicant: Ally Khasim; Applicant: Rashid Halifa; Applicant: Kedmun Anthony; Applicant: Amos Bendera; Applicant: Ramadhani Upunda; Applicant: Steven Simon; Applicant: Mohamed Likecha; Applicant: Samweli Dangwa; Applicant: Shaibu Hussein; Applicant: Annul Hadi; Applicant: Hassan Alfani Hemedi; Applicant: Faa3issa; Applicant: Andrew Omary; Applicant: Joshua Laulant; Applicant: Agustino Pascal; Applicant: Kombo Miyombo; Applicant: Pascal Robert; Applicant: Ally Viedo; Applicant: David Moshi; Applicant: Beian John; Applicant: Kajala Dotto; Applicant: Stephano Asenga; Applicant: Fujo Kisima; Applicant: Anita Zakaria; Applicant: Lusekelo Seth; Applicant: Raphael Julius; Applicant: Casto Komba; Applicant: Azimio Nkini; Applicant: Alex Abdalah; Applicant: Gervace Yotham; Applicant: Moses Elias Msela; Applicant: Joel Komba; Applicant: Adam A. Makala; Applicant: Boniface Mwasiposya; Applicant: Iddi Ally; Applicant: Ismail A. Abdallah; Applicant: Hamisi Athumani; Applicant: Shamte Said Ngwenya; Applicant: Spian Mathias; Applicant: Isaya Ezra; Applicant: Janeth Ally Urio; Applicant: Frank Steven Chogogwe; Respondent: Severin Stanley Mallya; Respondent: Gideoni Shana Daudi; Respondent: Bosco Daudi Shana; Respondent: Chrisotpher Laurent Sajilo; Respondent: Mikongo K. Mikongo; Respondent: Allen Nelson Massawe; Respondent: Stanford Kway; Respondent: Joseph Alloyce Ngallya; Respondent: Sungu Jackson Nkurlu; Respondent: Ambrose Ngassa; Respondent: CDJ Classic Group Limited
Court
TANZLII
Jurisdiction
Tanzania
Judgment Date
7 September 2023
Procedural Posture
Miscellaneous Land Application / Ruling on Application for Investigation and Declaratory Orders
Outcome
Application dismissed
Legal Topics
Execution of Decrees, Declaratory Relief, Possession and Eviction, Locus Standi, Res Judicata
Source Language
English
Land Law Civil Procedure Execution of Decrees Declaratory Relief Possession and Eviction Locus Standi Res Judicata

Case Brief

Summary, issues, holding and outcome

More case intelligence is available

Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.

Full judgment text Downloadable case file Legal principles 3 Authorities cited 6 Party arguments 2
Sign in to unlock

Parties

Elia Frederick Ulomi

Applicant

Jonas Kastory Mtisi

Applicant

Pascal Boniface Ndiyunguye

Applicant

Felick Yoram Kalengela

Applicant

Frank Onesphory Mrema

Applicant

Lameck Jacob Stephano

Applicant

Baraka Damian Toyi

Applicant

Joyce Joel Komba

Applicant

Murimi Patrice Chacha

Applicant

Ramadhaniissa Bakora

Applicant

Jamila Hamisi Ucheche

Applicant

Rehema Nurdini Omari

Applicant

Yasini Hamisi

Applicant

Beda S. Kimario

Applicant

Jonas Florian

Applicant

Baraka Nkabo

Applicant

Chrispin Palakata

Applicant

Ayubu Alharuna

Applicant

Rahim Beleko

Applicant

Ngowi Edes Nolasco

Applicant

Amandus Chatila

Applicant

Mwitta Chacha

Applicant

Justina Daudi

Applicant

Christoper Moses

Applicant

Mwajabu Athumani

Applicant

Ally Khasim

Applicant

Rashid Halifa

Applicant

Kedmun Anthony

Applicant

Amos Bendera

Applicant

Ramadhani Upunda

Applicant

Steven Simon

Applicant

Mohamed Likecha

Applicant

Samweli Dangwa

Applicant

Shaibu Hussein

Applicant

Annul Hadi

Applicant

Hassan Alfani Hemedi

Applicant

Faa3issa

Applicant

Andrew Omary

Applicant

Joshua Laulant

Applicant

Agustino Pascal

Applicant

Kombo Miyombo

Applicant

Pascal Robert

Applicant

Ally Viedo

Applicant

David Moshi

Applicant

Beian John

Applicant

Kajala Dotto

Applicant

Stephano Asenga

Applicant

Fujo Kisima

Applicant

Anita Zakaria

Applicant

Lusekelo Seth

Applicant

Raphael Julius

Applicant

Casto Komba

Applicant

Azimio Nkini

Applicant

Alex Abdalah

Applicant

Gervace Yotham

Applicant

Moses Elias Msela

Applicant

Joel Komba

Applicant

Adam A. Makala

Applicant

Boniface Mwasiposya

Applicant

Iddi Ally

Applicant

Ismail A. Abdallah

Applicant

Hamisi Athumani

Applicant

Shamte Said Ngwenya

Applicant

Spian Mathias

Applicant

Isaya Ezra

Applicant

Janeth Ally Urio

Applicant

Frank Steven Chogogwe

Applicant

Severin Stanley Mallya

Respondent

Gideoni Shana Daudi

Respondent

Bosco Daudi Shana

Respondent

Chrisotpher Laurent Sajilo

Respondent

Mikongo K. Mikongo

Respondent

Allen Nelson Massawe

Respondent

Stanford Kway

Respondent

Joseph Alloyce Ngallya

Respondent

Sungu Jackson Nkurlu

Respondent

Ambrose Ngassa

Respondent

CDJ Classic Group Limited

Respondent

Procedural Posture

Miscellaneous Land Application / Ruling on Application for Investigation and Declaratory Orders

Legal Issues

  1. 1 Whether applicants, not parties to the original suit, can resist eviction under execution proceedings based on a declaratory decree
  2. 2 Whether the decree and execution order relate to the applicants' land
  3. 3 Whether the court can grant declaratory and permanent injunction orders under Order XXI Rules 98 and 99 CPC

Ratio Decidendi

Applicants have not been dispossessed of their land; they remain in possession. The decree in Land Case No. 168 of 2011 is declaratory and does not specify the land occupied by applicants. The court cannot grant orders under Order XXI Rule 99 CPC unless applicants have been dispossessed. The application is dismissed as the reliefs sought are not available under the cited provisions.

Court Disposition

Application dismissed

Orders

  • Application dismissed
  • No order as to costs