19960730 TZHC Dar es Salaam
The District Court erred in entertaining and granting letters of administration while a similar application was pending in the Primary Court and without a proper transfer of proceedings. The decision of the District Court is set aside.
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- 19960730 TZHC Dar es Salaam
- Parties
- Appellant: Houseni Fazal; Respondent: Administrator of the estate of the late Haji Fazal Mohamed
- Court
- TZHC
- Jurisdiction
- Tanzania
- Judgment Date
- 30 July 1996
- Procedural Posture
- Civil Appeal / Appellate
- Outcome
- Appeal allowed
- Legal Topics
- Letters of Administration, Jurisdiction, Transfer of Proceedings
- Source Language
- en
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Houseni Fazal
Appellant
Administrator of the estate of the late Haji Fazal Mohamed
Respondent
Procedural Posture
Civil Appeal / Appellate
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether the District Court erred in entertaining the application for letters of administration while a similar application was pending in the Primary Court
- 2 Whether the matter should have been transferred to the District Court
Ratio Decidendi
The District Court erred in entertaining and granting letters of administration while a similar application was pending in the Primary Court and without a proper transfer of proceedings. The decision of the District Court is set aside.
Court Disposition
Appeal allowed
Orders
- The decision of the District Court is set aside
- The respondent's appointment as administrator is revoked
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
1 paragraphs
, ~l&/c/FZ - ~ '1 I~·T T.-·;.1 J.:ICf? OOtirtT OJ' T.1:·; :~-'~· ~IJ~ •m .~.L D. \I{ .'Ht:i r:31-J~::.~·. JT. CIVIL 1'iI-I-'~..:'.L :::o. 105 OF 1c;c;5 . ~ 1o HOL:'Ji":D) l='.:'.ZI) , 21i s.:J:o p LZI ) ••••••••••••• 0 • • • • • • • • • ll'FJJ'.LLJ.~:?r ~Tc1.,:.1v:.·; ' ···-----· --·-··-----......---··-• ............. --~-,,.,·-oftB8POTT:f. ~TT li. ~J~f~~Jl'_i JL,.::-:C a~~,--::i~lli.o" 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 • G -,.• Q O O O O - J !J D G I'; I-I ].~! .£. T ·p .......... ,,_ -. T1"l ~ TT-~ 1 r~.., pnr,r i7l::-"·'.. "-")•·l•>d 7: .. -'l,; ,, 1 i r,-}-.! .· -.., o ~--J..'X.: .!:.JoJ."." J:';,J."""'.'::~-·~-l:.J-:':!:.: ucl_ ... v.. vv..:...-r.•,C--;_~-~!;;.~1 rn.1is is a}. (.\}):~10 ..~_-1 ~-l(~'.::1ir1::-1t tl10 :.1-~~c :i.G:Lr)~"l o:J:" th.o n:_c.t2,j_~:t ·:J,)1.1.rt I ; ' .).0 t_:•-:.1.._ ,...'\']f"!l :• ; -.•1. -~ .• '!J,,.,.. -:;,~~--•~ /1'1 "l'~..-. 1._...,,.:J -.t , .. ,, :""l" -~, .... .:v1·•-,,,., 7(1•·1•1 • , .. .L l\..J~,O •.•l ...h'lJ_ .T., cT, ·.. •.(.,:.. ·. r,·-) ,,: ..C.. .ll..'l;!l[l.(: •1. .. ,tcJ.,.l. ,,.;.ll.:: .. , ... : ., .cl. pc;,,{l , iPJ,h..:.LL G,;,•. '"'JJl.J_11- str,~tcr of t!J.t:; OG°t:::.tc of t:1'.J.c L;,tc :-i:i:n1:1c...:l.:_:ha. ;?i.:,1J.3,,1o.;.,.:i., 'J11crc nr0 fot~ i .2,:c~v..:1Qc: o:f e.}?~::ur1.,l c;:·.rJ.:t.o.·1 . :~~iD[t tJ10 I>5.:!·C1~~i_ct G::.;1.1J.. . t il1 j_·~~- a::. tc::.~tc..:,j~·rr1~11t--"· rn ..-. t·:ro c:.:~:~~·•Gllf::1to :~_r.:;.,_:··o L;--~~J\.:~:r.tta~t c;.-~0~\:; ct.>_,;:;_~ ._;1.. t)t:l1dn of ~G~~.c mt::ttcrff J.,; •• Y tJ:~.s. t t}1c t:ci2.l GC·i"'_•~-t (;:~~jod j_1.1 e11to1,-cr~j11:G.1[;' t~9 01~~:;c 1rb.~.}_ ~: -~1 ;.0r~: 1rr.~s nlroac\:r a"'lot~~.cr en.no o::~· ~~ slr:iil.:?..r .1·i.~1:Gi .i... ~ :i.:-:. -t\·.c l'r:iL-;.:-.r~/ Co·J:;:t of .,:"'I .... t -, Im "11 .j ,-..+-,,- t ion . T,,r., ".°"r ... .: l-~~Jf1lt:.!1..L T"'·1 ......... ,.\ ;,.:...,.,J.v .. _,_ :re;••...,..(, ,,.....l -t· ,. .,. 1..;:.. •.;;.;:.• .. :.;l..., .l.. •; l l; .... (., ' @:}.c,.,.~.t ., r).·:• .. J. ""! r· ·'··'-.•·· ~ ( " I t, v~.,r•-1_, ~1... .. .., ~-y.O ,\"-1- •~1.t-----•-1., ...., .J.:.'-~' o.L,..p th.c ustn.to cf I~-:-rmJ.c..1_,irf:.a &;lcmax~i tc I·:c,:.1r:n1cr:l ~r?~-zio J.1! aJ.. :':·,"':.:•j;.1:; t:.~.O ir n.p:9ccl -t!10 o.,l)p-:-]llat~to j_11d.i.C;(.,,.tod tJ.1i~.t t.:. . c·:·· 1-;:;:\:.'lt~cl 01J.t to t}lG trial J'.lk:c,:i::,t~L':J,tc t~;.o f;:ct t~~~--t n.~1 ci.pplicc':tj_-:,:i! of a~ sjJnil~r r.:.r~.t .\1"'0 1TM 1 :;;;c~1r}:i113 in t',.c f:rL1ar-:t C01.:.r•t b1:,t t::,.,:: -1;:c'::.:-:J. I~t'.,:;iE-:t:r.:ttc j_gnoJ7CC:L t'.:i.c;:1 I --~cl, aJl(_ ·r•' -~]-, .,,,.-~ u_~;l)Q._ ..C.1.ll...;Q. v.....c1n ,...... -~ . ···, ,,t,•·1i.l-..~ t.1_ .. ~.Y ,_.<> ,',:,,lr•··•···';-,-, \. ..!. (,J.r.c....·.-•--• • ...;_l ••.• :~~.i.ij tl· ,...,.,,.,;,,:,t~ '~.LC '-:.i:.J?-~ 4 ... ·1b•r ..!.O:._ J -1.Jt.,..., "'.To~;;- oi... CVi(J.Gr:-JC O =1.. .:c 11 n.r•:?c11c~.11t~ a1r;c c:-~,.:~~--..i~1-::l1. t11:1t t:1,:~~f ;,.::>.(".~r8Cl. t110 I l=:.~~,i. :'Jtr:,.t:: Ct-11 ~;..,~: J.o·~re:.).t ~1.(~e,..1.Inci~.t.s l)crtC:i.:1~.i~--~_:_1 to tr,_cir a:•.:plin::.tfon b11.t ·tiJ.~.lJ J..onx11cd tr:i..Q1 ~Jo.-(:j.[:trr~_tt..: J.'~1.j_c]_ ~o :_-.~:;c(.o lirc·iil ~L-:~cv..r:!~rt.tt:·.; ·(f.1_j_(;J~. (!-I'C :f~~lu'-1. j_·· t>.0 i1eoortl (.•f t.1 '.c 101:c~c c~~v..rt :i.t is (-;~;id.o:.1t t:22.t -~;.;.1-:: :)i~Jti,ict Gct 1.:ct i:! ~-t-~; Rcv·isior! C:fucr r:1c:r.7~G ,.., . p11.rr-r..:..1.1-~t t v C:i.:-:r:L1 T:::~·:T:~.r::L,,1.J. ·:~co ;, {):;: 1C'.~Li r' ..... ar.rlorccl tI1nt ~t i--c t:1."'irtl 1 i:::1 fa.e: Frirr..2:r.}:- Ct~·l.T'b be cn;.1rl1.:.ctod 0011001~.:~:·...;,~;~: .:1.})])lic~-:t~:..c1:t ZGr lcttcrc of~ .~:c1,;~~ll1.:i.;:;tri'-:tior1 ,.-.::- t~.:..o '30tv:to o:e r:i_;c::..n[~).~_;:1;~1. 3:.-;~_G'.":12!lic» /,.;p~~1.~..:i:<Gntly, ,,,., ~I'!\:;].!.;_.._,~ 1t ~f: J_:.,-:i1C;..l Pr~z j. -..~cr·.t br~-clc i~:1 ncoorcl~1;1cc 11it.~ .. t . ._·_j_;J orc.1.or, t :..t.V to t::to P17iU1t~1;,r C, :11..I·-t u:-..,:. pt1.rs1..1.acl t;_ .c. .-.?J}_,;_~:Jio..tj.c.:1 i:~! c..c-._·,..·,:e{: _ ~_\::.1cc ·utt~·!. I tJ.16 l(:ru n.s 1::.::.(i. lJ,~~-:11 0l\~:.-:,~,c~l f:.;_3r t.~·tc D-l; ··Gr?.ot (°)c-1.:r.·to :~:o ~.:]]Jc, :.carr.!.Gll ' c:)u..--iscl for t~1.c P~:-{:~o.:1L:c1~t ;.:)1t2j.r:t:1 t:::.:--.t ]:.:L.:.:, ~l?-i:n1t fiJ_(;\l t~:.·., ::'~:)}1li- oat:Lcn in t:::.c D-l::;t:ric-t; Cc.:-:_.,_.-:it f"1J.l~:-c;i:.1::-~ J'-:.:!..:\ 01. c.l a.}11J_j.c~t:~G:~ t:'·v: t tto I!1rl.ttcr 2..t t:10 :f1.. jJ:1~,.;~:- Cc·•::!:t be tr:.~ll~!:i~ci~c(~ :·Cc- It::.: Dictrj_o·G 001:Li... t ir1 order to Cn¼blG .~.:j_n~ t~-; i:1'1~·:.:o 1·c1,r.i_ic_r:;GJ.~."G2..·ti~i.!}~~ :.i~~Jl, J.:.:Lc cliC.i:1t t~:~ 001..1.rt. 'BJ.ere is b. c"'.-7G-,;TG:r :10 :3~,,iQo:~:cc tb. ~-:;t t:.:.c j:'L.7..;~-ec~~: in tb.c P-i~in1~.:.:.:/ :J,Yt1.-rt OG./2 .,-· 2 ~-r::::s trel1sfcrrc"'1. to t>:,::; :Jbtrict Co"L1.rt n.c ,,r.,-:::U;y roquo::tcc1. lJ:,- l.I.ro ¾',.f:ioo :Dren if "'·+;:n.u-,1:u.,(-; t:.02t it h:-:rl lJc,'l:.'. tr,:nsforrfrl? 'thm: lW doubt, L1-~ r,J .v il-l:-'.c "• ,,1ts ·ro··-1 ""')11'_,,a,. '.' ,_)_,_i,.•· ·_,,:,,_-,.rr.-_, _" s:, h('0···1 .., , ··J. .. l l.... p,.,,.,; 7•1·,11.-;--0~1· .L···-'~·~'.• -~,.,,, :.~,- c: •.l, • .n~M->f~l-~•11· I.I.ct~-;. '·T"~-. (~, • .,,,...,, Tfould J-'··'-'"''"" ,· I to accept n, riattcI' t:..·,t u2.-. aJroc. .\y 0•,::D.1.::: ckt lt wit;.,_ L.t t>o F:,:•jDe:ry 1 1 Glllli:12, ~L~Jc J. 1.0 :1~n : .!:)t n..-ri ;t.J.1onc r1 t mi~;. 1 tricl =>·:;:1.:.:t:r·. :'lie J):d. bot.~'-CJ'.'O(l. to I I no t ·"'.c -.,_, lj'· t C b,O I·cJ1 n· ! ,aw ~ '".-~-~~t,.. ...... n..L,;, ",,.,.; U.l. ,.: vr cf . T.-'.c: rccc:cd of . tb.c J.cmcr coi_J.rt • t- to td.1t:1-v ti. 1.~ .Ll .L n,J)]!O ,..;.J.al'lts \!C~cc .....i:-) v ·_111.:r~,f -r ·-. ,..,_n a..:.vi oppo..L'"''\.l..•,1>• -'.• •. • t,~ ..-.L:t •,.'f ohe.l la:tl3'8 tl.10 appJ.ic, 1ti0n -by wcy of c-;;-:::·.01:')Go /'I!:l.d trin.l oo·~u~t failcc:l , I -.,- \ '. I ". "T" .•. nncl_ .;.ll 1i'.).o 101rcD.mota,.,ccr; . ~1 - :.nt tl~.o :)istrict cn,:Tt r:ij.scLircotcd. Hcclf L1 snt,:irtnj.nil1r;· t'.:i.c 1 ' I a1.oplicc.tion by R.:\me,cU::::.1i C;':.,,a.Jo. :,~o: luttcrs cf :1cil:l\11btr.::tic.~1 ,)2 t].:.G ei1t~tc.· of I=I1·:ai1c.j_c-~1a fJ,Jlc1~1o.,.1.1i 11:1ilc tr=.o:t"'i:"t ·ir:~~-: c:{1:re;:n.c\t !)Gi1L:~21:; j21 tho ,., Primm:y Ccu:rt at,J.., t:wrc _was an o.pplic,:~-/.;ion b_-y- eounDol t:,.(:.t tho fa~.tt0r 'bG t1.•0;.1r:i'cr:::·Gc".. I tc [',, cou.rt ~7!.101'0 l).G G•.)l'!.J.;l .2.ppo.2r, t~lCl".'. ca OI0r;:c shou:1.,.1• ;'_;}V(l be·:Jn nlGtlO app].ic~:-tj},m ,, ,.:LE :!;to :DL;tr:Lct Ccv.rt •. As it is, t::.:J:'c ,m.:::; :,.o r.n.i_ch crd.cr ::t.t:cl i.:1 the circur.'l:3-/.;.:1.::iccc th8 j d.ccisio11 o:r the l-1"in1F:~r CJ1..1rt Gf :r~'1c;or;1.:;11:i. c.r:)Po~½.ti11s I--!::'" .:1r:1ot2. P~~i i' .a.d.ministrator of t1;_c oct.:tc of l-'I;rr:nc.Jd:..r!, :3cloE!~\ni nt:1.--:,·b st2.i.1do ~b:r )?a.zi succeeds. ·\f. ~ ~~ ~;: ..... /3 !rLL~.7'clJ! 'I'.J.:i-1 tLl.:I.':Cl '.::,;~11 '1Yc:I Ci '..lJld I T~,:rnc'() '' ~ £ ~ ~. . {i?, ,. ., .1