19940726 TZHC Dar es Salaam

- . -- ' L'llff/t-~_1_ ·- __ - # Pf ' c...v...1··c SE 1x; 84 OF 1993 b o O O e O 0 6 Cl II ,.., vcr ::rt:t.G • • 0 c> c> e O O O • • -• 4 ~ ..., --- ·-------- ,· ...a MAN'Et(:.uo, ~h1t1otci:.. I , : t.., -~ :.~. ; t, . "' + J: ~-- ~he 901.u1ZOl _fo; tluc co.ea, Jil...Jiaji 1 Tu.st.~ Bwoh..~ h.cJ3: ftlod~a. ~i11 of:•Cosii for n.· toilw. of cl~,.54-,65,,36-t:.20 .~.ch i~W'l$:> i1ist:Neti.cns -~9 ~o, shs!,5116'!-0,961-.20 £111Cl ~ ~t,9~1.o.1100. ill court, tho ~ of all i'toms 0XOOl)i1' . ttom . No~r c.¼'ld o.::.:-c,b1-"XSC.:::Ont'Ze . . .,. \ .•; -~ His cliant lio;dd:i olc,in- fron the G:9V'Orl'lr.10nt tor. -~ totnl of -~ .~•244,000,090/1:: u!rl.cli w;::,s-:P~d du::ing iqlc J;>Orio~ o~ .two :vu~-..s a.£to:r.-: . t'h°:;dc.bi/- ha.d. raa~cde Duo ·co ~:..:c 6..c:.~s to pa.f, thc::n thOZJ rT.c.tf a.n in:td- , . . . ~ . ~ of sh~.280 1 724,142~38-n SUI!l~gr.o~..-::Ql.'. ~h.o.n tlw Prill.ci:pal. .sun. ~s amo.unt~of r.ionoy wo.s not· poi_~ in tirac end then U:d. Bwr.J.iDJZto., looJ:'1'l9d· - o.dvocn.to .. t \ filed .. . \' a._. en.so . :for i t·s rooovo~, (i;ho .. dofcnannts . could•nc,rfi- :6:tla- ·- 't ." a. ,r.r:tiltan-st::,.tomont o:r··o.cfcnoo. nnd 011 ·22/~/94 ju~.nt wos on~d-f-01;' - ·'\" \. • • ' .•• . ·;: ,· ,\" ' ·'r ·\ · -t'ho. :plaintiff . ·~o-oourt 1·r.i. th--cost·s. ,,,.ts· now-told th.1.t cvon tJw,t·. ~ - - - · -~- . . ., ' { . hos boon ;paid m1c.l~li...1.t the oosto a.re to bo -ffu:xo,d ns J!r r.i rou - In 3?,'ls~·~n:tmi.io~ ~~ ~ . . . , , ~""119d COUllSOl ~-o\t ·:wtthauit ,';" . doi~, ., ' . .. a"oja.o-ti~n that tho o~c o~.d out of cou:i.-rt cfi;or~lo~ no.gctia.tio.~. Ho had. nr.c.o. scvo:rrJ. t:r:i.1?':1 t? Gornnxzy <t1119J.'O ho net' W!l th his cliontB n.nd ! r.iooc sovoroJ. nooti11t,r:os w:i.th tho-do:ficncTo.nts-·hcto in J)6;r cs Sc.J.ll<'lll. -·mic • - ' - ' • - .,.;.. •..- • I ' -· • -- loc.rl'lCd [l.(,.'\tOor;'to f'u.a.----ihor told the tn:ntr:;,rosilo:v tb,.i.t wo·' to his diliganca. ' ;ln.bo -instalments he were t·o be paid , in having tho 0onoy· 1Jo pdci/1% of 1:J.10 manor ~a.tnod DZ his ~ o r l . , 'rlw.t r.:ien.ns: tJ).c.t 1?~vr.1cnt fo:.:- l:is vr~k:~ ~ li'al$ ~.n.nd oo,t· in , ad:v.n.nccr. I tlli r.J;: tLi s is o. · eooc1 systqn n.s it na.kc:s the n c ~ JJOnJ... . work hord .or--0100 1.)o ];>~110nt i o offootcn. • •' •. ·oi:' • • \" - . - Ira so..hl .\ \. thr.,t the work. -0£ nogotit',tions. .tor-the ~ " soirtlot:10m- . .- of tho ; ; \ dob-ff took ~in f'o·L-:.:- ;}fCCI'S rmcl_ t!::d ';'Ork 1-rns n9ro 11d4-tum t ~ 1ms:> ,court. . . . work. n:0 thc:rcfo:i:'c :rcquostcc!. \ ' tho to:tti:-e. no.stor to -1:r.ont tn.c issue o.s \ .\ \ .\. nn o:x:cc1>tio11c.J. on.so so t~:'...".t 1"-o is not to follow tho ll.clv.oo<-""..ias n.nc1. B.tlmli,.. • • . • . i' • • • ' ncrn..tion·ruJ.cs l),S. !,)'.t'OVi.c..o<l by c<:m.:-Tnnon"t; nft~oa-~-t.! ~ - ... . : . . .... fl/~.-- / / ... 2--- lliito1• fa"':.oni 1 .·lcr..racC.. 5::,; ;e, .: _tJ~< r::.:oy i:c..ct ob jocfod t9 t110 9loims nnd ma.do of' uc.1culc:,tion, 1.::::ro :'J:: 0:~:nr, .:,c::>Hoc1 . . t;·_d to b.ccl truc:on ... tl1c ' •\ '•' •'\" • • pnncipfu • "1 " ' 2~ /; .... ~ " , ,.,no 1··' • .i, • • t· SUD. o:,:; C...:.So 'r'~~.W-4 [\(_( .n:: i:LC o ,:_'v f •a 1:n~cros I.,' C..'.i:'l":!.J'l-~. 0 .I,! ' ' sbs\.5?,@1• wh..i.ol:. ho is clcir.li:\.. 1'or ~- ::c co-::rtn in th.is non cont'ontions ·- IIowovci• ~,~- ~oC- ·l'• .,,-t ..:., of s::t ~ 244 lli.llion paid di ~J_JUt~\c, .. ' '-r. __ \..: <..-~. -..1...- r "•-'-' s-·r1 L.... , •,· 'fras.: t -id. thout cq1:rt 001~:D.•-:mtr..tion;: ; · )t 0cfc-:':-c t:.::tu couxt, ha ~.nto to;bo paid for its co~ts. I t:.:.:.:;J.-: l:o.:t in Ji;co 1..:1..1.cr-~• -t;Iiho 001'..I't oru1110-ft ooko:· mzy- or.~or. on nr..ito:.?~ 1rhich we ':J not 1jc:f.oro•it a,t~n.ny l)Oii:oc11\_~ ~ f:to.ttor wbieh ., \ . t'ho-hie].1 ·court jt~cgo-·cr ;c1~oc1 juc1.[;n0nt . for tho 01)11lico.11t 'rTD.S tho in't-orost'si l1.'1.iril'l[J~0ccur:rulctc; -to c:.:se280i72!J.,142(,38', · G1:ti-d9d by tho 1:..chrocr,t. 's Ror:n.u,1ordio1~-~_r.-ncl ~c.xc.~ion of Costs--·rulos, . ' I ho Sc"'l.id. thp,t u11clor i:tchoaulo :3 ho 5.s~fo 1Jo ~id :rJ,-of tho sh.s.524 J;lillione ~ \ ·I \ \ -~ roacling tb5.G ;J9l1ocllllo VL.J. ~ dcbii collc_9+J.on, i1hc f9os ,ho:rc. QJ:'a: thosa t'o bo ch..1..I'0cc1. by t:10 n.dvocc:t~ to llis cHofit encl costs to bo t'n:itod by .~ ( ~ ' ' . •: . ': . 't .t ~o tn:x:tnc tno.stc~~ Still, in tl:.is ca.so., ~t];lo . :t,rooooc1ines •insti tut'od in . .. \ ' ~ ' .. . . this coux-t . wr,s not· of ohs_,5·24 r,;ilJJ:on ' but·: that of chs.250-hilliori. -. '. ~ o Turcl)r,-,0.-,,, .<:. .· lon.rnocl ai;.v.occ.to farther 0W.t1od fol.. t:~opb.ono on.lls ... • ·, \ ho. roclo- to hio clients in rcl,'.--..tion to this isauo.-o,ncl mf'l.lfiel. . of air. \ l]Hcirots-ho rnil.o in :f:ful:-ono to nod 1r.i. -th h.i.s client· for :f'urth.or oonsulta.tions ' \ '" . -lo nnd inst·ru.ctio:ns-. Rh-r,i.TIG s~i c: ::.11 thct $ ijrs" Ir~o~ ,. lon.rnod State .litt-0i-noy, ogrocd ~o ~om.a i tono r..n~ :t.'DfuacC:. to soric i "tc(v:r-o In~hor OJ?Oni!lG. S]?OG~f she. sn.i<ll. t'b.o.t she founcl it very d.iff:i.c-11:!.iy i-:~:-J ·-:;o:h0rr the 10fa or 1·% Coatti..ssion . • ·,· ,f. whj_ch . lllr. Thr....llamn WM \ . ).X.',iC . .. 1.)~r hiS-'"cliont' ' . ~-:,ttld-bo .. includocl ,· i:i . . t'llis bfll · ~ { of toi. -~fil:c xo,:__'Uootod ' tho cou:t't'-to . c.<.U:o~o~t'o-tho . l~vocc.to.$1: ilDtlillll10rot:i.on ; '\ '•, 1"Ulcs in tt'Jd.nc tLl.s bill cf costc c.i,.c1·-th..1-t ft' should be ·<lDl'lc according 'i . . \ • ·1' - •·,~. to S.obm:1oJ.c . IX -which is prov.it.ct.. . -. tho.t. tho 8cclc for -: . liquiCD.t'o.cl .. . . SO.O o:li' ' .,; ove.r 3 trl.llion is-~ ... n.ncl ..' tlmt 11horo- t'!lo u.ofcnc:..1.nt· docs not di.aputo the •', \' _9lain and f,oos not file tho c.1ofonco, tl:o S.Oclo of foos show.cl 'be two thirds of tho f.o_'?',S .tJ,~Jovo 1 t1,n.t j_ s :,%. ~ In rcl)lY to-tho ... ru.log::i.ti.on . thc..t . M.-t-. ThrahoJn[l. a.dvoco.to trnvo.llc.d ~ 'i t'o ] h r ~ o.ncl Kurroit, . she co.id tlmt . sucll j ~ s l ~ ir.... ~1crro.nr· as ho - ' wa.s onungc.c"i.~ho~c :tn Dnr. cs Sn,J.a.c.r.i (l~~o.) ~eo ho 'WG:t'O not to 1i--ll.vol:. As mgnrc:Ls t'o t'clc:;_121011os ~ ho~ □r.-,it,. tlw,t 011:i.:y toloph<;>no onJ.J.s worth - srui.1,~609 459!96 woro nuppoi..-tod. 1Jy rocci]~G Vbilo t ~ of sbZ ..,52,091i.45 a.re not suporloc1. b? o.rr;;- c.1oouncnts, honco t11ay ~ not "boJ.+ovcd to ·be gonu.i:no clnii:is ~-::: t~,.c,t tho;:r·woro · ria.cl.o in oo~o~ion m.-th ti,ri.s clnira. Sh.9 never 9bjocfoc'.. i tons ? to 22, sh9 objooto.d t9 o.ey clci.n wlrl.oh is not SUJ?I>Orfod l;;r c.rr:J rocM1Yt cnt1 c.s tI,oy arc just·-oolosaol. . ~ \ .\ She concl1~i:.o-cl ho:r: subEd.nsion-b:1 s'-'.J'ill[; ~o;t aha C.OOOJJto.d. ~ 0£ . ' . - . ' '" ilho•.l'fa~of. shS.z8o niJ.lion, i"tons ? to 22, all 'tl1!WOllil'.IC OOI;Tl:s. ~ c comostod r..nc. tolor:i!lr,no ·ui 11., 1-rortI~ ,::J_uL.551, 991.45.. ~a ltir.r.l? SU.'1 roliof. is~c.l(jc 00joctoc: to 2.ri':. th2.;t tJ.:.c i:oxc.tion should he a.a- ]?Or I . • ,, _,,liG'1-y:i.l16 ~o~~ 1)oth pa.ris, -:-.-~~,- J iii tl: .Yrs. 1'Tdosi, lom'nod Sta.to .ittitor~oy t'h:'..t tho i:-..x..~ti on ?-:f i ,''.Jt::;u ·.~ion foot should 1)c bnscEl on -fiho: n.m.-ount of;moncy cL..-,,ir.10_~- in tl:o ,1a,i1Tt, or uhioh, bis L?l'(1sh:i.J?, JUsiico Kya.ndo cntomil juc:,:_:nont, 1-rbi cl ·i,'.s ,lso -:;he dcoroo of ··tlJ.s oou.rt ns:- .... \ ~£d 280, 7?L1r, 142~30, -:·ScconcUy! I r-,.:rco uith ;.rrs1: H~.os~, J:o~~ncd~Sto.to, 0 A.ttorncy toc;dtl:o:v lTj_ th .i.J.::~o J3ir,: '-~; l0r'..rnocl ail.vocctc tlmt this :i:s o. non defended cc,so·.o ~IIcncc, if··thn l: j_o 'tho 9nso, then we. slmll bo GQ.idod by S.cl1odulc IX of tho Ac'!.vocn;f;dt; J.crn;.11cr.r,.t:.on r..nd ~OXc."'.°~ion of 09st-s, d.~. N~.5~5 -of _19'.:1 • i1ruG t:, . n.rro~nt to llc o.11r.xclod is {- of tho ~ of ewi.280, 724j142.30,. It-ens n )Do 2 4:o 22 cro o.wri..rclod as ., ].Jl'cy'Od . in t'l.10 . bill of cost'so J:J!i¼:o i ten 23 is O.WC'J..'cl0d M. J_)r.a.ycdo Itor.i 24 :i,s also a.warded M }.)rc.yod, _, l-h's. Nc.1osi, 102.:::-nocl ,:to.to Lt'to::..--ncy lU!.cl obj?ctocl to se5!!l.O of the itolor>hom · cclls w-11.i.c:: o.rc 1rt m.l.IJj?Ortoa. by :rccci~tso filhc ~co:t,t'.9d only sh~. 1136"0,459.96 o.nd rcfus0C: Gl:805521091°.45 for t110 rc.o.son tJmt there • • •• •'i •• is no ovi(lo11cc tl:c"..t auch cdls wore mi'.o in connection ' \' vti. th· .tbis eo.so. ·\' OZ! WOI!C J'!k."',QC in com1oction lti th otl:cr nssicnnont·s Mro T o ~ a.clvoco.to vn,s c:i. von, t'.S J-,_o~!'L..':.cl sor.10 otl-.o~: e,n::::io1.:';ionts by Dwahc.rnn ~r.1oclf wbioh t-ook him to . Kuwci t· nnQ there was c:lso tho Docl-onr:i. . project~ ' .\ Gu:tclod-by s.55 ( 1) of tho 1...cr.rocntos P..cmunorntion o.nd lo;iro.tion \ \ • 'i ; • • •" ~ . \' • o:£. costs irouothoi~ with tl:o Z'CMofil' s-lh:i,to_9- o.:bovo, ~I o.ccopt'· tJie -imleJ?]ione bi.lle Wl'Ji~ m-c 01~ SU].J].Xlrl°<lC. 'hy :rCcc_rrrns ~ou.ntil16 1o ~~.1:,}o0,4?~o90, LD.Sirly, :.h-no mi..osi -ob5oct(.(7.. f.o tLo · rlis1:-xcsGm.cnt of ~:.i.& ticka1i-s I • ·,\ I •• ••• ' filed ., by lil-;. Thrnl.10..tl.n. .·.- for t110-roo.son t~:ctt' ',\ such journeys to Dw:·oJ?.O. were ,\' ., no~ oollod f9:;; rurthc o.c.vocn.tc wa,s stnt:i.onoc.1. ·horo in Jx:.r os Snlonri. Not only ~,.,_,t,·1J9.t l:~~ IJ, Yotfs. lm.s boori :i;,osiw.nc here in T-o.nzr.ni._~ to . . , ro:prcsont t110 int'or.ccts of tho ~o~l~nun-t. :a:owovcr, ~'7?oi-rr Imlerplmx· GMbH ht?,cl-f.ounel 1 t··nocosoa...ry t::..c...t···n.t·-thi_s )'.~~ l>r~lOJ'le wont'· to 1:ii.:IPo]?G- for: . . \ . . . .' ~ .:' 9-~ms,ultt?,tions, briofi:nc a.ncl dohclcfinc.. I t110r.a:f.0£o. cw::ird the ,.,1·..e.sa t·o the tune of sl1s~ 1, 34~,326'., 25., l!thvi.-~ s_yi c.l nll thd, •tho l)ill of -fi-cx rovn boon tn:irod as -0.bove Corn.tli .t.. R.. :Uc.1'.10 nto, SJmrIIC ( 'l'/ivio.s to~) Wi, ~a.lilo '--. Ii1or c..ocroc holao;c Ab~nt for juGC,1'.lont tobtor Ord.or: llulinc ~d.c.1 in _t1:c ~J)scnco of tJ.:o f:tn.to 11.ttornoy o.ncl ~-• ld.zalilc is rocoj;v:l1,c ~ .. nw~• s rulil'lC.