19950203 TZHC Dar es Salaam

.·' ~"{';l ....,. .-,,,. A'£ PAR ES S~-1 (PC) CIVlL APPEAL NO. 149/93 LnlI. HAf.>SORO lIDAIDNJ'E < ♦ t I • f t I • •· • • ♦ • a • JOSEPII C~LO • , •.' t t t t • t 9 o o o • • • < c 4 ♦ RESPONDENT :&is ie : :~ sooond aa,pe~ ..;;rising from tho dooision of KIDOD~O'ff'PA . . ~:¥l~Y Cour··.J within Kilpsa. District, in respaot of a. dispute oval: an e '! ~o pie .10 of land.+ Bo:f'ore the P.rimary Covrfi tho appollaltt, one LtQI UASSORO IIGAW?U:J., ~d ·: ·bl-lo Respondent, one JOS!n'II Cnm:EW, seo~ 1 . . . to JZOOovor such disptr~od pioce of land. 'Iha .P:rimalzy court deoid.Gd ~- ;favo1;1:, of the Respondent. The _appollan~' a _appeal ·bo tho. lower ea:,POl~iJa ;our~, also ended in f~ur of ~o Rosponden-'~. J3cil1g furthel' aggrlewd. . ·- ' ~ suoh ~aoision ~e a:ppollant has decidod to p~su.c his SGat'Oh f~ justioe befo:r:o ti.is oouxt, _As found b?' tho l,o!~~ courts, it is oomraon g:t<oUitd. that "lihc_ ,parties are oans:Lns. It is also QOllllllOl'l gl'ound tha-'i; as ea.1."ly· as 1943 tho appe~ant, "bog(r~! :r witb. othGI' oollo~s, ·of· whom was tho Fi'. 2, one F,ASTJlDJ: ~ . 1pq11cu. up S:.1.ar:ib~s ~om v:1.:,:-gin land, at -IKOU. v.Ulago. Tho appollant nianagod. to oloat' and -~..G~te~ 'cv.ltivatil1t' ·about~. ~,es, It ie ¥ , ~ , ~und. t!1at la-'lior somotimo in 1952, th.a Rccpondont and tho ~pellant 1 s fathor also movod to such ville.go and l:r'lictr"ted esta.bliahw '\b.oir o,;m :e~ns. It is also Qommon gr-:,u1id. tl1rrt o-~or since ..12.2.€:~, . . . . . . . . - ·~ ''JI .. a.ppolla.nt obtai.11od omploymoll,t in the Miltj._stry of Communioations,. He ~,,. :Loft suoh ehcJ.i!iba. aiid •nt ·to wr~ j3,t, Ui.l~~ -~tat;on. .. .Tho appellanti a . ~ 1)~o;~ tho trial. ooiwt that who?'l:ho ~ro11;:; to -~;Jilil.tJlli his sh~a, ., • s iof~ i.'1. th<;; hand.,3 of his relative ollc Po-'liC~ Ma.ssoro, a.nd.;tha.t lmQll . . Qaid_ .Potor 1b,o. . Nasso:ro pa,ijsod ... aw.a;, in. 19621 .SLtoh ·£Jhaml:>a was looked. . . . ,. after . by his dallghtc,r 0110 ROZ6t'tA, r..ll):t NASSORO, _could not f:i.lld ~pport ~ , ;} . . '. ,· . . a/ry ~ ;'\_ ' ... :. 'bhc 1-r.i..~ss_os . ... . 1m.o tostifiad for. him•. . lToi tller. was an attompt . 1Qa4o ~ the appoUaa.1-'.; JliO oaJ.l one ROZALIA.f as 0110 of hie wi tnassoe. \ ~ . .' ' , ' It is also undispittGd that after retiring from his cmployme11t i n ~ . tho appellant wc1rc to sottle a:C ~ v.Ulago 1-mG:J!o the re Eipond,G11t b\it not . . . . ' ' . ; ;. ., " f~ clom Msoworo villa.go' li.1.o;i:G tho RQspond.Gnt livosf It, ia'ovidont that - d.i·sr:tttod sb.amba sometime in ·.-~;IS silieo ~io lcf.t . to tho dl\Y vli~n thi"s;; i~~o a.TOSG :::o:::o'timc in ~92,:tn.01 apPGUant n~~ ~-_"80 of tho \. ahalnba. i11 question. · ""· -~'-· ;·· Ht•~CI 2t 2 ... ~us in absence of row oviclc:100 that dlXrb.g albh · period suoh ahambas t'IO:t'O ao-'i;ually lJoing 01..u. tivatod by a:;;y otter :poi'r:,0~1 SU.Oh as one ROZA!itA1 as allo{;ud by tho appellant, such sb.2,;~bas ,~ouJ.cl ).1avo tttrnad into naar. virgin 1Jush, that oou:I.d, 1,.1Jldor oustoiila,'cy law lrold holding policy and. tho 001.uitry' s land polioy as a whola,., bo disin'i1Jtttab.~ to any o-'Ghar :person in nood of the sai.1e. It is homrv.o:z:,, St~Niaing to noto that il1 his mama .of appoal tho ~pol.la.n:b has come o-..r:'c with allegations which a:t'O 1tot at all roflooted · tn,. hie da.sc befor .1 the - lorror t:r:ial court. To:r insta.11.00 in. his 1_st ~ot;\d · of ~poa.i. ho ho o:l.aima, among oji;hor things to havo oioa.i'od and oultiva.tod. ~i;v.~. (1,2), acres of land 1ihor.oa.s 111. his reoor.dod ovidonoo befor.o tho . irial oou:rt hc- :talkod of having oloa;rcd about -'~e.~. (3) aorGs of la.nd.t Jjl.. his 3rd g:r: P.nd of appeal ho claims that in 1989, , tho Respondent l'lOllt 10 ROZf\..LIA 2.:.: :. c_l:,kod -t0 be leased two aQJ!os of land.1 -which ho was aoo~~ so loasod; r.:1:.'!. that· H was vi1Gn the said RO~ hail fa.llon siok and ha4 hospi-'fi3.lizoc:. · a ~990 1 that the H.osponden-'i; for.oibly aoqu.:i.xod six (6) mo,x, . . .~1.•p_s, and plr ughod _1::Lth a t:l:'i.1Ctor tho who:c - lru1d of e,ight ,sc,s, tho subjoot et this cli.Erute, ai'-'~oJ'.' liL:.ch, i.t is a:lcgcd 3 j.j.1 1991 when ROZALIA had .. ' .;eoo~ol'ad, .:i10 filed i10.r oolnl?la.int w.i.-'.;h tho CCII offioo, but as by thon tho Rosp011.dan--~ was the C.OM c11a:1.rma:n, the matter oould not bo attond.od. to. All tha-'G, h01-rover, is no ~ e to be found in -'.;...1-ic l!ooord of tho trial oottr~li.+ }Teithor has t:1ore boon any complaint -'oo oha.llongo tho ooITootnees et suoh .i:'GOord., It follows tl.le::eef'ore that :;-nc:.1 is all now information, ancl.' tho:.:-of'orc una.ocoptable betoro. an appellate oo~u...1;, Further, in his 5th gaound. of appoal tho appellant malcos tho allegation that whon ho 'book his oomplaint. before ·~lu; 'W~d Tribunal, tho ~ibunal dooidod in his favou. b~ r-equ.es-tcd him to givo ono aoro of land ·l;o tho Rospond.cnt 1-.bich hG ·~cod to do. Yet according to the record of the t.1'.'ial oourt it appears ··-·- ~at i-'a was l-m.on tho Wa:L'd Tribwial dooidod to p~oel off suoh disP1thed ·p:f.ooc of lalld that' mad.a him {am_3ollant) disatisf iod and thon dc-cid.Gd to r. tal:c -'Gho matter to oot'.r-t. Apparently suoh reoord of tllo trial coUl'·li is in agroc1:1er..-'.; 1-ii-i:ih ·llic rcoord of the Rospond.G~~li I a ·story to the of':feot tha;'i; clisatiaficc."'.. uith the dcci ::io·1 of tho tol'llolOoll 1oa.d.erships he d.eoid.od . . • I j to -~a.kc -'ahe □att0r t.::: t:.lc Ward Tribt.mal 1 ,;-ib.:.c>. dccidcc. that tho Rospondont ·should give thG ~.yipcllrol"~ t.wo ac:.":s, -;;:.:ich hc·i".::VC::' could not bo aocop~d by -'Gho appcll2nt, hcnoa his decision to trJ.;:o -:::1c ::1c1,t·bczt to court. . ,' . . In. tho lii:;llt of -'aho f or.ogoing I :?ind JJzy"so :tr 0011strainod to u_phold. . I '. tho ctooiaion of the loi;-ro:r a,ppollato court and M ~ this appoal with tfGtSt ••••• •/3. ; ' ' 3 .... l)Glivared this 2nd _d.aV- of Fobrua-cy, 1995, at ~ o~ Salaam, in. tho / ll'J!O$G110G of• 14 ~ - JUDG'f} ~~~~ ~W,,. Mwaikasu, d". Jloth parties aJ.lscm;. . .. . . . . • ~¥➔- As both :pr.;r·bios a'qO absont, ju.dgmen.t is -bo bo road by the. Deput"iJ 1.-:ogisi-ral' Il!gh Court ZionG on a dat~ "bo bG notifiod to the p,:_:•ties. / ¥.~~; S.oJ-Wi:l,. . l1c-.ncnto 1 SDR ~~ for tho appa1lcU1t 1&osont for th.G :11cspondc11t QQ:i }.faAumbu {t~s) • Tho ju.d@ncnt . is .. road in tho proscnce. of .,i;ha parties tofu\Y;, 317d. February, 1995• 1/ ·, A. a..~MliNENTO 5112troR DERJTI REG'ISTRAR EIGH COURT .....---- 'J/2,/1995