19931102 TZHC Dar es Salaam

. . . \ ,· ~ :··.·: '.. . . .i .: . '· ..., . ' ·- . : '. - . ". .. (2]':com ozi.c,,.,.i:nal C:;:,i.::.unal Cc,cc :.:o, 1:;2 o:Z 1.992 of the Dist:t'iot Co~"T-~ of J38{;'~oyo D:i.T~::-io·t ~1.~ B~amoyo) I.Ul~.:OJJ'"t.i .s/o J '--'-~-.f.tl~.,, .J; 1."' o , ,l , o ( , .. v" •• ., ".Ii. -cll.PPELLANT \ ( Original Aooused) vers;_;_s T:({E. UNII'ED ):1J}a'(JJLIC 4 • • • < ~ ( • • < , a • <t I < I t <o t • • .RESPON'DEl\JT '"()T,1; - ~ - . .if:u!t.i:1w., J...i. 7 T'.,ie a"'Pell,;J:1.·t. ""- ~ I1a.'..1c--:.rnudn s I /() u\ • □.,.·-•~ 1-ra.s o.b.a2::--A- ~ _.; .. .._th tmlmn:\.tl po0f:1eosio11. of "b).lal.1(sn 8/; 2C)), Ca.p.134 of the P.rohibitio11 o:Z J.To::io:'.s Plc~lJ~s, · .:J ::na::.1dad by Act Uo.4/1987 • Ee was 0-011vioJLied ~)Y ·t;.1e Di::rb:io·~ ;:Jo·,'l;:'Jv of Bagrunoyo 011 his . 01-111 plea o-: rru.:Ut ro1d u2,s senJ;i{l:.;.o:::d. -~o 3 ya~s -jail impri- sonme:.1t.. AJ~ia-vGd ~JY the coi:-vioJ.;:;.on ::rild. aenteltee he appealed. ·~o -~J.lis ootU't. I:1 ::•.is meu10-..:- ..,ac1.,o e:.? 2.ppeal he set ~u.t 5 ,'.;l'otmc~s J)t'!.t gro:.r,'l.d 11i.:mbm.' o~:.c ::.:i.a o/,r:;:,aoted the sei--ve ~ the DP.P, and i.ldaed o:Z. t>. is co1rri ·;;o ao:.1sii0I' and' deOide wheth81' or not t:l.e appellani made u:;ie~.r: i•ro.:i:;J. plea lJeforJ the ~ial 0 oeni~ distl'io•b Ilaci::r~-rn:~e 1 L.T -i :.:..,J.e'. :ela. 011 this g,;ound -~>.e appellant u18.ims i:1.a:'c :no 1urobl;:nn

-:;~_1a·~ eminated ·fl'om hi,.s 07. .i.lct-: ..ood. is -~he almo:-c.Qiali-'i;:" "::: >.io :u:i.nd. aia e - v ~ by .-ti~ c::x;:-:,·;io and :.1.:1::>011.:~ll~ :)G>.a.•11io~u:- -r.owa.rda the membefa t::C 1mci;;·~-, Z.1.at in SLtp~-~ o:f ·:i'.:is 21e did not knp ~ihe~ :_i0lioc :::omtc1 :'.i:J ,r:Lth l)hatlg t,I'_ oi_::~i;;:-~n;ttesa 011 the ~ d ,:ro;.:,1J. o:~ '- Ilj_).;: ~i ~-le dan:i.e-d li.:-i:v~~ "-7.<lm. tt.ea." before the t:1al .,. •' •· • -'-,, •'• _,:.C-..,'J.Su.,.:uC •••••• ••• • ., __ ._:. ., .. e • ~ ,-T,c.S .;,, ..... r•~ , .... ~ ,._. 1 po..,..,o,_,.,.,_.....,_1 o ....0 -~-""l;;IJ., ~• _,.,_1,_,,.,.,., ,. , C11,1.•+L~.µ· adr.ai:.i;·ood 10.at J.:..Q awl:aa 0~~2.-:;.foa~ O:n the 5th g:cound he stated t:'J.at 71e i::; a psyo:ria;iil'io ·:,::.;~i3i.1t. and in euppert tf t:Jis he attao;1ad. a medical ~ .j,;:;·;.a::y .r;,s a ~ ,t .hie ~ . and e:rr~o mau:;al beha"ifi~. 1J 2 "I 'tL011 -~>is matte;c ,ms placed beio:re hir1 ~o~u.o:u.p 1 tlle late Ju.s-~ioe Ik'.1J::una, on ~:2/3/1993, t:.'.6 Learned P-.d11.o.ii)2J.· S·~ate Attorney subnri:tted -r~ns:- 11 E.ie Repu.blio does not suppo::1-'i; oo:r✓io·aon~ .Appellant was EJ.6J.Y~ally sic;.:, ·..:i:~o:.·c is 6Videnoe t:10t'.[,'h ;.1ot p:rofu1.oed c:l.~ina -~ial- psyohia·:zrio pc,ti0i.1t, The oen-:;e~1oc o2 3 yea.rs is exoe ssive l }j:0 :us served ai:: r:uut}.1s al- ready and ma f:i.ncl t:iat is mi.1:Zioio:rli pe:riod~ 11 As I hce;re

i.ndioa·lied above, l.Iiss Lwasi 1 Le,,,r_1ed ~J-'.Jaile Attorney, is in tSa.l.l :Zo1.u.1s'U in support wi•:;J1 -:;J. .0 pre-viou.s a-~-r.br.ti.sdo11::1 made by he:t' 1 Lea:rmcd ao.llaC(:,<'.l'll, Hr. Tencl'trn.. Indeed I 2i.:-]. ;:.:i:l.c12i..!l of the faet that seo·;;j_cn 3Go( 1) of the C:r:iroi;Jal P.rooedut'6 Ao~.;, 198G makes it illegal to allOir a;.1 appeal in t:le oasa o:l aJ.'\>7 a.oo~:.r.:Gd per so:;:1. who has pleaded gi.tllt;1 ~;ld h.c1.s been oonvioted on su.oh pJ..02, 1):~ 2, ::rc.b.l[i:dina-'i;e court e::roept_ e:::oept as to t;1e extent o:;:, legality o:? ~~:.c sen·benoe • H.oweve:r, sinoe 11:-.e llcpublio is :..1ow mreI'e of new mc';~SJ'.'ijJ. f'D.Ot, wbich u.nfo:rtu..'Yl.a,- foly dicl aoJ.; oome to tlle:i.x b.101rledge at t\e ·t::.:.10 atJ01..1.sod was arrested, ohal'a<:id n::.11 oonvioted 011 :1is 01m plea 0~1 t>£ f'~:.0-ts, wl1ich material f a.ot a□ Dell' t:10 medical :repoz~ is in oom.1etio~:. 1d·~\ the aooused ts unso:1.:1d.11as □ o:? mind, i-.t is now t~ the :LJ.1-~eI'cr.r~ of justice to re-consider that 11c1r no;~c:rial :faat or evidence and cleoid.o e:1 1i:.at is justioeable i.J1 -'tiJle o~se ~ Today when i:.10 c.ppellant 1-ms. ~J:;:c·.1.c{1-!1 to me I had the aclvau-'oage o:l Jwa:ring from hL1 a:3 1-i!1eJGher :. .0 :::.101,a 1l1at h~pened to him.I> 1 Apa.rt ~0::.1 :J.ea.ring bis a11mrers I 81.so ob □Gj_"VGd ~lia demeanour~ I am saJGidie~ as it seems to

have appeared ·ha r.'.18~ J,f-.o,t ~e is not mentall,y alr~}1ti ::e has admitted -:io r.1s t!1at Ji;I1e trinl oo~'!I'-b properly convicted , . :un· J.J. .".'o-• J... J.: -•c .J... .... ~ -4'la°'(i 3.,a,;,v..LJ. L,:· J',·e .... .,._T..," oa;·irr',t r-t Cl°I:.,l•i(:y'. ..'. \"• t'1 •--n.· •· l!J·,~-v,· J.~"l,;, t =1: is statement oontradio-m what :~e. L1.a:;1ooed in, his me~andum of appeal il io'.:. oonolud.es thus, 6 I.I.ohnJJOd ;;';.,;.L is defina;ooly psyohiatric. ba;.1.'.':;i p:r.70:1oais, u F.rom thj,e state;:.iont_ -~:~o:.i.ch medical ope1ti.on 1 I am p~::r~:.ad.od -~o believe that the appel:..c:.1·b clid not know Hl1.at I.te ;.1ad or what :.,o iTa3 do:i,J.-ig at -'Ghe time poltce a.rrec;·~od ::1.:..11- L:i1cswisa ha was not very lil:nl,:- -~ ;.Qtow that what he was. daL--ie ir::.o 1r.2 o:1g, Conser.[l..Wnt 1.i.po~1 ·bha la-'1;-~a~ p::c:.1ise ·the ·appellant might not hr:'vo apj_Xi:.'ecia·~ed ·i;.'.,.e fao-t 'lf1at J1a -iras ~:r-.c-o-..:c::b be.:ZQI'e a. court o:f la.w - • -. 3 and was reql~ccl ~ ·lie plead on. t:ia ~Ya.:.100 1rith 1 i ~ l'.O a~d ~ In the oi:ro-:.-:.r.J.Si;n;;:1.-es it is not moJ:'c ola9.:r whethe:i: ·:c~o ,Plea of the a.ocui:,ed before -~:1e trial ooUTt .-ms t'.11Gy_1,tlvooal o:.te Qj:' not. Tharef'o,:te. the oonv:iptio:.i a..-;a:L"'lSt the appellant oa.nnot be f!.1.at~ii:tcd and as suoh I uphold -t::.a il'G.i_Jti.blio I s ·-,ray~ to cri.1..;i.s!J. J.,;h.e

oonviotio~ and .set a.aid.a the sentenoo iJ,1s:::cd against t:.1e ap:pellai.7.t. In t:1.e re sul-'i:. ho should be released 10=-t:1.-rrith. unless he is detained for o-'11.:.0:r la1-rtul oause, . A.C .lIREMI.I. ,JUDGE 2/11/1993 Judga~.,~r'.; clPlivared: in tba abea~ of the prcr-'i,i.ea. '!1:io ebauJd ~ notified f'~U:;Jti.~, in chamberG •t;;.11s 2nd day ot Hove~, 1993 at Dar es Sal8.cl,11l.,. J'UTIGE 2/11/1993.