19941115 TZHC Dar es Salaam 1

lit T::._: 0 app1:tc 8,.r1; l~i:1.1:).J.tTICK O.,K., HCiO.:..GO :f:Ucd t\is a})l)l:i.cation Under Oection, ; 14 of t::o i.auo of L:Lwitation ~·..ct,1Jo.10 1971 .:i-11d. 3ectio11 9~ of t>. e c.r.c, 1966. lie is pr2.:,;i~1;_; :2or o:;;:t0'.1sion of tin0 to L'1::rci tute an e,:p:,102,1 aca.i..:."lst t:~o ....... jur~eino~1t a:..1t"i. d.ocroo in Civil Case 1v"o.4 of 1993 of t:io :Di,:,·crict Court of HoroL,oroo :Zo is aJ.Go prayin~· for oostr1 of t;1c applicatio;.1. Tho aJplication is sup po rt oc1 1-::i. t'.::. i\I0 oni:;o '13 affidavit• The facts c:v..: clisclo □ ecl by tl:',o v.i'fido;-d t is t::.:.at t::;.c Ros:powlont • plaintiff filed an c1I11c::,1cl.o(l j_)laL1t on tho 4tJ:. 1.~u._:;1..wt, 1993 ar1rJ_ t?.:o CD.De uas fixed. for mention o;.1 t)·,o 19th 1..u;:_,"1..l.at? 1993.t:us l.3,ttor d~,.to ( 19/D/93) tho respondent On succcosfull;r obta..i.n0d lo;;.vo to :pr·ovo t 1-.o 02/J'J ox-J_)arto n:_·· af:~icln.vi t clue to tho applicv.nt 1s avonnont that :,_(, w2,rJ ::1ot ;-,-,1-:-2.1·0 t!,nt t:.c c.::-..r.,c u:;,u 0ot do1m for 1m1tio11 on t::c 19t:'.: iJlgust, 1993 no:r ·,r2.o ~:.o aware t:·'.;:,t c::;:-pv,rto jud{;'ornout ):tad bom o:,1tcrod. ae;a:iJ.1st tto applicant. TJ:..c C:;?]}lic211t 1 ,.-J c;r:.,:.i.n Go,::::?lo,int is on. t]10 .award of 3:.~Go5,ooo,ooo/= an scnoraJ. cl2J.1r-..ccn base,<l on to:;:i;:',.0110 clai;:1 I)lUS another a.w~rc:1. of 0~10.,25,000/= a;s oyocie'.l d.aII12..::os allcJoc1.l;;- ,:'..:r.isinG from injury of 0!12.ractor a. .osaasination on tJ.~o p3,i--t; of t:10 rosponclont - c1:;:i::;ilice).1to Thr::t; such awa,'.'cl coulo.. not bo just Drn,ntoc. 0:1 ;:,., more swoe.rinr; o;:- a:i?fi:rming en affidt.vi t. Proof of cwio..cncc is 110000;:.7,ry. Hi:?l.:lightinG t:.:.o applio2. .at 's c,lYQlication, Hr. Kapi11{sa, Leazned counsel for tho applicclJ1t, r;1tatocl t~1at it is r.::t r2.;;.1,::o on t:"'.cj_r part to observe 2,t ::;>arn, 6 of t:10 cno;.1docl pleint of t>.o ros:;_)oncl.cnt to contain 2. c1ofar.:1atory clain on tto accow.1t Jc:.:2,t tJ:::.o ap:pli<!:2,nt rofuccd to -po.,y no,1o;y in 00,.1..10.:ri on wi t::i. t:.~o est at o o:f t;\c 8.0000,sod . 2 ;.nne, Joyce Rut2,bo.nzibua 'lrho 2-iod. ir:..t~;::;td:, i,1 fl. c?,r r,cci·'.c;.1t on t::o 10tl: uf !..u,:,u::it? 1S191 to t:~;.; ro,Jpcnd.01t - :!l:'.'3.,1tiffo ~~1:::,,t -~:~::i rofuso.l .-mD just:i.:.cio': lJcc2.uso t:10 G'.;t2.to - 110~10;.r --:m.o J:),:>ii:1. to ·f .c: true: a:.l'.1 -::-ctuaJ. :-:..1.;·:iaiotrat,n•, ot t 1:o d;;,con3od n o::it.:too It :i.s furt'. or f.ii..1.'1T.1:'.t :~cQ t;~~',t tl:o so callol~ n~··u,1.. _ ouoa1tn 2..t pw_;o 7 of i/:.c ')rocoodinGn i~; :::,t j~1,130:no..11t at :9roscribo::; "b'~o,t 2., juc\:;omc.,1t nuot not on1y bo consiso ~ut cJ.Go t: .2,t tl.J.o ctato...1Gn-G t;:ordn rJU;:;t i:;:,ou t'... o :poL:t2 of J.ot1-..:1iua,tio:,1, ·i;' .c, C.oci sio;,1 t:..,oroo::1 d.!ld t?.to i"too..:1011 fo:r St1.c:l cloui::;i_oj.1o o.~1 tl:;..c rrt1--G1:1t_;tb o:£" t}.:.c 2)11.yv·c rcn..oonz, t;:.c Pra3d.rtg aTllicaat :L::i · ·/. ·, :i:or c:;ctonsion o:2 t:!.r.,r1 ~·or lo~v,:; to :f::U.o .-·,:1:-:,ocl out of ti::10 to enable ),.:i.r.1 0021tq-;t c.:_;::w.,1. ~ t'·.o 8;;::i.:·:. jl,•::_,0,1Qi1to ,;.t tho :iocr.'-':f-¼i ot t:-.ic a::,,)lic~t:~c-;·1 Iiro ~(o.j?iaz:a oJ.:·i.,:c/~ t'.,c.t t.'.:o rosponc1.ont J ozophat Ilu.,:piLllCc;JU wan i:ropcrly [J,;rrcI '.:ut u2:-:i n.oi; j_):;:•.:,::; ,_ :·c :u cou:i.--t o i.c1ni tt cclly I ovuJ~ looh:x,r:. on t:ii :J c~L;;i~,ct :-:,,11:1 I t,J:1; 1.:;d to a~roc ,;:i. t:. -~_. _;..Lo,:-:i:ncd Cou;,1;:101 CJ1J.r.t1bor i.1urJr.10i1s a;.10. t'.~c forr·i2,:rdii1,: .1ot:Lc:; 1:~..;ilc writ!.,;,:·_: :;:•...1.J_··- .l_. of t)"o ap-pli cdJ.0::1 I l,,:wo noted ~-ri t;·_ :ro:-;1·d -i;; _,,,-;; 1:fro K:1:-Jill[:;2, ~r;:-,c ·.wt co:;:'j~cct wllon \o info:..--r.1ccl r.ic, t:.:.o,t t1:8 ro □:pon:'.cn-t u.:--.r.: ,Jorirodo T}:cro :i.i:_\ :.·.o i_;,r:V.onco to t!:r,t offcct. ~TcriTortholocr;, I t'.--..i.:11:: it :Lo clr:;o r,~y c1.v.t;y- to c:~;:,r.1L1.o RS w!.10t>.o:r t:.to 2,pplicatio:1 :i.r3 GUGtaj_nablo in t~w circumsta.ncos ;:,,r.:; rc-locl,1:i by tl::.o 2.):)lio2,- nt' s aff:'v.°L2-vi t c~;.cl tl::.o cv.bmis3ion DLv:c '0-,y Hr. X.:1:ping2-, counsel for t:.1..0 ~okoin.o u~1i vorGi t7 of .:.:_::ricul turo. 0:ci;r.;.1c1 to !-:,or~.od of lin:i.tatio:a. for t>.o ,-x9::;lic2,at to ii.1;;-t:i.i;nto an a:,:,p02l out of timo, not":i t:'.::.r.;tr..ndi:az tt.o,t t::c po~Lod o:: lir.1i taticn J1.C'..;:; o. .::;)irocl. n.rJ pror:.icr-l 1xx1 U.."ldor soct:i.cn 14 ... ( 1) of' .:..ct lfo.10 of 1971 (Limitr.•,tio~: .·~r:.t)o It ia CC'i'i!.-.10:1 (,rJu.1c1 t:l~,t c:;:-p2,rto jud;;o,10~1t .-re,s 0!1tf0.,1cc1. oll t:·"c 2nc1. (~.,-~- o}': :.ic::,tonbor, 19S:3 2~:;cinst t:.:o 2.::?:.1J.ic0.:.'lt ~Jokoi:10 U:.1ivorr.;:Lty o:~ ~", ..:rioul turo (:.. u::·o:L:1 rofor::c-od [1,f; ,3U..'a). T)::.on on t;.1c:, 1'7t:.~ dc-,,y of :Jopto:,1t0:r., 1~;:_'3 t: . o :c:):1licacrc :;·u.c~~ 2. o~:.c.u:Jor n:pplication ( supportoC:. ,:;".t:.::. en 2,fficlavi t) c,~:ok:L'.t(: :::_;_1 o:i.-{:.o:r to :.rnt '.',:::-i-.7.o t~}.o ox-)cirtc ju·.'.cmcnt ·-,,,..______ 3 for ~,n orD.or cottL.1c; nsi(lo ·Lu o;:-::_;nrtc j1.·_,__ ,c:·,,..,:.1t., '.~':,\Y: t· · ::·. •.;..:.,;::.,. t\ifJ 2.:7:-ilicr,tion appce.m to :1,::v-0 hocn on t'..:c 1Ct!: of ""':,i:;:.-:i.1 7 1'.)9t1-o Tl.:i~~ :iI',._; :nre t:.:.2,,11 90 c1n;;ro frorJ tllc c.bto of t:-.o rulin~: ,.,__ ,tcil 11/1/1'.J'.Mo Jor:rpi to ·1/ c .:i,:):)lico.tion for otc.y of o:r:ccuti on it r-;oul.: 8.~Y)cnr t'::ctt v·: .,uL:i:i. ,1i1 1· ;; 1~;-~J~;,:;,G;C: .•i~l---:./c of t;;. 0 vol.:iclco ,rci'o <v_·,.:t,-;~:j.i .. '- out n.:::t por t:·.c. c8u1,t's o:r:·or c12,i;c:1 11/4/1994. T):-.o c1ttncL:od r-10tc:r:--vo>iclo~: 1·rnro roloc,sc(i. afto:r t:.10 · a:i?11lica::.1t. ~-o:L)ositoc1 s;.,.s. 1 9000 9ooo/= 2.i-:: Gocurt;r :i..,.1 tcn.,s ol Or:2cr 21 ro24 (3) of t:.:.o c,;.0., 1966. It woul•::1.. c1,1:11:1oar t::,:.t t~\c :sooci;1:".. aJ1)lic2.tion fo~c r..;ott:i.:n___: ,:1.oido t.'.,o o:z::-.02,:;..,.tc ;;'--'.'.~-~:a-:io-1t war:; to be ',o,\r,~ oa t:-.o 2'.:::t> f.-J?ri.1 7 1994 but ~-ms 8Ajourncd to ?.,/5/?A bocn.u.30 t~:.o c\i)lic2,,.1t - ju:·.j)L!o.1t ,~.01Jt0r w:1r; -wt :_1:..'0G•~.1to .Jtill 0Y1 ·c:·-.r,,t :::.at,::i t:.:.c <1:~·,,::,lic,~::.t m,G .wt :).ro,0~1t ,vi.~ t. ·.0 n~ttcr u~.,:: :pus.':cc1 to !J./5/S4 f,;T' :.,rr:rt:;_ono 1 On t~_,i,.; T:"c Di strict Gourt ;;I'r.l..ntc:l t\(i n.;__,]?l:i.catio:a aJl('.. r.1acl.c n;1 ,r:".o:c :for t' .o 1r:l.t'~cl.r,,,w1 of t::e,t o,::_:>J)lic2,tiono T:10 Loc1rnc<l tricl 1-~n...:,iotro,to a.lr;o :'.:i.rc,Jto,1. t:~at t'·.c n;ppli o;:m t lff,fJ .::.t li bcrty to fil o , .. .; c-· .......t..l>,.) Mro Ka,p5.:132, tLon reacted on tLc 30t1.':. of L-uyst? 1991;. w:.:cn l:o f:i.lc.;d t:.o 1)rcr_;c.1t c'._.o.f.i~Jcr application for o:do'.1;:iion_ of tir;1c.. ·i;o f.',lo c:-qpocl •mt A ti □ co :u.tti11:; c1f',_i.clo 2J.l of u!J.at roe.lly hc,J. ~c;ppmocl. in t::c '.',.:;.r.:;trict con.rt concc:r.ni:n.:; t · .;.; Lti.::;e,rdHo a:.1:.l in o:;r-J?lica'!:JJ.o r1.cl8.;Ys to f:U.o ~1rovcr u.pplic['.t:i.:Ji1 f,-Jr t>.o sotttn:_; c..ci:lc 0$ tl'.c o:z-:)~rto ~u~30,J0nt 9 t~w 2,__rpJ.ic:::-.nt I o a:ffi,bv-:'~ t .... • tJ. ..., l:o 102,:cat oi:' a_l)Ocl :.,,1.: '.:)c·:;1 ):('Gtor:ro~~ ,;0 t:.,:. ,~J.·i;.,i:.~--·c::_:.;:·ro..:c:l_;;- .•:i·2~·_:'._,:1L·. 1.:ll•.~:Jr Rule 13 o(1) ,.•:c O:C\1.or 1X ,)f t:·.r; o:·,.vn i'r:;co::tr,:c, C,).'.o ·-_:.- .:i.,:.> c.t::.tlc; ·c; . .r ··_:);'0:::1,-:.r:;:it tc i:'-:?}:l~-- ;:.:1,.c:L t: • 5 1futlo I nn f'ortifid by a nuobor of aut~·10ri tion ii.1::rl sting that r;;uffj_cicnt rori.son has to bo tl::.o docLlins- factor in en 2,pplicatim for an onl0rco-:1cnt of tirJo 9 and. also teldn;; into vi ou t).10 fact tht'..t t):i s c:1urt :.ias u:.1fottcrod. dis..-- crcticn tJ extend tine for loe.vo t0 arrpoal out of tine, hcwovcr9 1·0;.;ard rnmt e.lso be !1~1 to the nnnner and way the procccclin~;s wore h,_,ndod by tho trie.l court. If I unclorstD,i.1c1 tho applicant 1 s effid2-ti t coneotly9 couplcrl with tho subnisoion nc..dc before no by Hro Kapinge., counsel :fer tho applicnnt, tbo nain co1:11)laint is that c;r2.vc inju.otico we,s acce.ss:i.::mccl by tllc trial c,)urt wll.011 it awarclod to tho plaintiff - decree hold.er (rcsi')on--lo,.'1t) Shs.,5,000,000/= ao gc:a ore.l cl2.x:i2,eos:, an::~ Shs. 25 9 ooo/= as spoci aJ. cl.eJJ2,3cs ba2c.<l en c. sinpl e c.von:1c;.1t of tho responr1c:1t IS ai'fi~le.vi t wi tb.out proving the .?J.l oc;ecl conpJ.aint by Ol'2.l e-..rid.cnco., Tllri.,t ~1 affic12,vi t cuulcl. not on tL.o (balance of) i:,ropendoro., nee of ovid.011ce prove tl:o ell cc;od (Lcfn;:12,t,)r-J d12.r2-ctcr 2.ssasRion of tho )ln:intif.f ·without heYinG recour,1e to real cvL-;.c.1cc by tho plcintiff's wi tncssos. It is nlso quostic112..blo 2,,'J ~n1, t:.~o ;,lciritiff' z cl.:.2,r2..ctcr cculc'. have been injured en t:,o 2.ccount of tho f2,ct V:::.2,t t:1c 1.pplicc1.nt-clofcnd2.i1t rcf'uscd. to r.1nkc J?c~011t out r)f -the est ,1tc of t~ sC :1ccoc.acd f~no. J oyco Rutr)Jr1.nzi bwe to t:::.o ro3p011dont for rc2,son th2,t t!ic r.10:1cy we,s ·"',ctuclly paid. to tJ:e e/'.r:1:L-iif:ltr2.tor of t;:1e dccoasod' s cot2,to ono Wilson SarJsono Whether this state::ic.nt is correct or 11'.)t, t!10 :point that outs right accross ny nind is ullcther t],e tricl He.,,::;istrr,tc W2>'3 right in :passinc; tl1c Jud5'ment en facts bP.sod on e, swom e.ffid2Yi t an·:. not on o-ricl.cnoo proting the oxtcct of a.ax.1agc or injury to t::.c plaintiff's ch2.ractor 2,11.d cxposi tion, t~-ic princi:plo used in cloteming tho quantw of c1an2,.3os awarded 1 ct 00 -tcra,., It is clso tho rule of law that spocicl danagos nro n:,t ccnerally e,ssesoccl but nuot strictly be provec', 'by concrete ovidcncot 2J.1cl. in nost cases b;y- c1.ocuumte:,rrJ ovidcncoo I have painstcld.ngly dclvc::l into t:.:.o entire record of t;lc loucr co:.irt 1th a view to asccrtaini110 as what woro tho actucl. avomonts st2.tcd in the effide;vi t filed to prove tho plaintiff's c2.oo cx-pe:,rtc., It 1ms not iii thout <~ifficulty, I cl.arc s~, to pcrcoivc fron all ·t!lo e,ffid2,vl ts foua.:l in tho court reconl that only one 2,:f'fidavi t tcndo to show tJ.:.2.t it could be t:w one purporting to be one as such filed in proof of t'.1.0 :Jlcinti:f'f's 02,r.:30. If then I an riGht th2,t the ovary effidavi t I ar.1 rofo:rrinc; to is the one filocl in support of the plaintiff's cle.io, with i3'reatost roopcct, one doscrvoo to be polj_)loxcd bocauoc tho a.fficlavit itself docs unoquivocelly ste,to as for what it socks to sup1Jort. Fbr tho sake of this ruling llXld bcncfi t of tho p?,rtios, it is worthwhile to ~'.)W wl1e,t t::10 affidavit avers, stnrtinc5 fro□ pare, 2 thoroofs / • • 0 •. 0.06 I.. 0 6 2. That I 0J:1 t~10 ]:older of u :porror of c.ttu:...-r1037 by 0:10 llilson Hyituo, ,-i:,o was duly O-i1:0oi:r'licC. .Ac1·,d.,--iistrutor of t:.:o oui;:;.,to of ono 1:.nna Joyce Rutaho;,1zib-tra now docc2.scd. T}:.at as a J.1oldor c:::- such pouor atto:ino;~r I prooontod all clo.iIJs due \ to t:10 estate to tJ:o dcfonda.nto 4. That initially t1.10 dofcndaJ.1t paid. all tt.c prooontod duos to file ro1d I <:Wontually roc.1ittocl t'...-;.o same to the 2,GI.1j_nistr2.tor of the o:-:Jtdoo 5. T:::~c:.t ,ken I pror·catod t:·;o dccoc,r.;ocl 's insurcnco claims, anJ. o.:r"tcr I ,,. had incurred GL'.,DO OXJ:l0i.1GCG following t::.1.0 clains up anJ. clown to · Dar cs salaam, I J.:.2)¥lod .over t:.10 cl:oq_uo to t!:,o iofondG,.lto 6. '1'.hat instead of' ir.;r;l1.i.;.13 ,..10 w:i. t~ . . t:.:o c:.::.oquo 2-G t:·.o:r 1.,A.d done before t::le dcfoncli:l:at flatl:·· :rofu::;o'.l to clo oo, inplici tly casting doubt over ray crcc1i bili ty a:1d : .ouorc;ty. 7. That as a rcs-~11 t o:Z cue:. 2..cti on I fol t :::;re2-tly hm bl od doun a11cl insti tutocl the preso-i:1t suit to, restore i:1/ :Jic.;·nity Mc!. t0 :rcomrcr de..1uaecs for t:.'.o uro113 inflicted upcn l'.1e bJ tl:o dofcndanto I ar.1 D. That I vonily a,nci__ stron0 ly believe L:.sntitlec1 to tho rol:Lofs claimed in t:1e plc:in-t. lihcrcfore I pray for jm'..gracnt a::ld. decree E:g'9.inst tJ.:e cofc.1da:1t as sl:oi-~1 in t:.10 plainto Fra:i sud1 e.ffidav-it, in tb.o first place it w~s not cY.b.2,nstivcly pi·ovec1.. t::.at the applicant-defcnd.2.J:lt we..s obliged to pay the raonc~;r from tho dec·Jascct' r.i est de to tho rcs~o11dent - plaintiff. In othenror:1s no 0Vidcnc0 called fron t 1 ·,0 ad.ministr2.tor of tho c-atate 9 or even the bcneficio.r,y· to positively confirm the,t tho aJ.lo:;-cd power of attolllcy haJ. exclusively eJ1c.1 abnolutoJ.y reg).l~ .. r:d that tl.i.c doccasod."s property sl:.ould be hendod oY.:::r to t~io plaintiff ( respondent )o Secondly, it uas not shown :iJ.1 ovL1cnce what w1"0:.1c tho 2.: 1pliccnt - dofoacl£'.,.'1t 0 112.d. 008fi1i ttod by s0-i1dinc t:10 nonoy in tlle -'l..eceaoou I s ostat o directly ~~,: t'...:o prima:r;.7 cot1rt of t:.~e c11•02, in w:tlcb. t::.ia ,-._r1-:dnistr2,tor of j_)roperty is or W2.S residing? TirirrJ.y3 it is not ox_plo.incd in v'rii'..ence9 c,s to what wes t},o stULlbling block prcventinL>· t2:.c rospo.1c~ont - plcintif-.f to collect tl-:.o Seid nonoy f'roiu tho primary court to ~i:ich t~rn Doney was oo..1t f,,r collection as long as he W2.G holdinJ t~.:o po1rnr of attozncy no to do? All these quostioaa 9 in ny conoi.:ororl viow~ ra:iain unanswered and in effect it ow1.1ot 9 wi t~:out rca:i:lonablo cri ticisn 1 be said t:int tJ-.c ju.\::;mmt we.o ju:1.icinlly~ let alone jucliciour.ilJ1 made I 7 unclcr ::iuc~~ circtu:intc,..1cos. I N.l ta;1ptod. to bcliovo 7 i'J11 Dlso b.oLl as in.timato::l by t::.c e,r>::?lio2,nt 1 ::i c0lli1::rnl-; IIro K:1,pinc12, 9 tl.12.t rc&li;.i:; f1..:)m tLc af:ficle:,ri t 2.:,.1c1 ju,lco-~u!rc; 9 u~.12.t t'..:o :9l2,..i.?.1tiff hol,b 2,:--,i a, juc._:;oi.1011.t, if; not 2- juJi3L10!1t wi tJ,i.11 t:.o no2,;:J.i;.1;; of sub-rule ;:. of Or,.or 20 ,:-{,ich pro-,riJwz of t'.·.o c2.co 7 t 1 1c., poi.nt:J f0r :~otorr.1L1.'."'.tion 9 tl--..o cloci~~i0:.1 t.' .,.;:-.?co:1 9 2:.1;: t~Ae: roc:-..;:;0.13 f:,1' ouch c.locir.d.on 11 • ;l'hat :12.f.l boon c1c.. c-wi :. . ,-y1_, ,-._._,,...., J. u.:.,';":-1"•lt .... I.J:.>Ol'r,,l 1.· ,, ")n .,,... 5 cf t,h ,, t,rnoc1 ')l"OCoorlinrrsft ~t .:.<-u~ • .L-'-'-''-''-• ~"- ... _. cs , ,.,~ </J:' • .l. ' O ~ a,.1:l. io cle.tcc1. 2/9/93 9 a.,.:d it rc,--:,.clsi "Court: :!12,viP..J c;m1c t;:c.rouc;J:., t?.:.c e,f'ficlavi t lot t;·.o ju~\;Dont ont orcd ao prayo::1-1'., .As I llc;iTo 2,,ttcmptocl. to /J'.ow ab:)Yo 9 tho nfficlcwi t (heroin above roci tocl.) Hsolf io insufficient to coi.1::;isoly 2,:.1.:l conclusively proved tho fncts for conoic1oraUon. ancl c~.ct omination 7 nor ,~.oos t:- o said 11 jud,3□ ont" shows tl.c l)ointz for c1oto:ruination 7 ancl o;.1 11' ,c.t rov.oons on u!:.i cl:. tl'..o '."loci oi on w2,p, fow1clo::'... Al tl:ouc;-h the ap:;_)lica.tiOil before 1.10 in to sock ax:tonoion of tine for lcr.vc to file a...11. i:.itondcd al)pocl outsiclo tho prcr~cribcc1• li1-:litation po:riod., ir~ LlJ inclinotl. vi ou1 it will not Dcivc tho i:.1terost cf juotioo w:1othor to ,_;r2nt or refuse t:::.o application boce,usc t:->.c ju\§JO:lt or ctocrcc sot1t1ht to be ap-Jc2lccl f:ror:i n2,rJ noi thcr jutlgc·,1c11t nor proper clcciflio:.1 fou;.1;loct 011. the corr0ct ri:d. i1ci:plor:.: of lo..wo · In t!:.is ro0 r,rc.~ I ::,we n.:, dtorn,..,,tivo 0ut tc ~ ..i.Nolrn t'.10 2.:'sC!:i.tim1nJ. powers of rovir.;ion coa:fe1.,->;r;>od upon t.ir:; court i;.1tcll,rJ of r-;oction 44 - (2) of tho 1\1.?.,,::;istratcs' Court □ l.ct, 1?D4 w:.:ich sc..~m: " Ll,LI,.-( 2) In a:1.ch tio~1 to c'.,l.lY ot: .c:;:- J.)Ji'iC:rfJ iu tl:.o.t bc~1df confcrrocl urion tho !Iieb. Court 7 t:.~c llit;b. Court - racy, in e:ny procccclL'10 of e, Civil nature n.otomino:1.. in e. r.1.iotr.i.d vv~- ~ er c\ c:Jui"li of a rcr.::i-.1o.'1.t mc,ciotrdo~ on ap::_)lic2,tic:1 1.Jo:i.nc; maclo in t!12.t bohclf by any p2,rt;r or of i to o~in motfoE_, if it a:.)pcn.rn t~.1.d t~icro Las been 2Jl error i;iatcriel to tho mcri to of tho ce.r:io invol vine; justice, revise t~10 :;_)rocooc:Ligs 2;.1cl make oucl: ::1.oci Gion or o r\l.cr t!1oroin 2,D it soa'.lD fit i I e.n ni.r1c1f'ul of t:.~o se:vinc :provioion un::lo::c tb.o e,ub-scction thE,t unlcr-m tLo offoct of ,;uch rovif'.ion in tc, i.ncrc;;i,sc any SUw awa:tt1cc'~ or al torin~; t:·~o i-1.r;~·lts of 2,ny pc.rty to :1i3 '.1.otru1ont? it in not ncccose.r·y t:.-:.c,t tb., pc.rtiooi o:;:o 0::.10 of tJ:m, m~at be I)rco0,;.1t 2..t t:.'.o t:i.Lio for revision ir-; r::c.J.c~ or t~c'..t ;.1ud first be .... I c;ivcn an apJ?ortunity to bJ :.1.0.1,rtl., In tJ,c ;,resent caDo t:1c oi tur,ticn i::; tl,.f'.t t~::.e j_):r.oooe1in3c in t' ;_c iH strict court arc such t:l<'--t t '-o:~ bo rovL1od, r,;.1:l arc acoor,,j.11c;ly roVi sC'"-l, 2,.i.lS. -::ri tl: a di rcction t}.12,t tLo rJUi t be J:.02,r-.1 _d.:..o_2l£_YQ. bcfo:co 2.,i.1:-,t'. .c-1r Me.:;istrato of co!Jpotont juris,.:.tctio;:1e It fcJ.lowG t!:.croforo t?.:::,,i; 2]_1 t>.o 0r:.orn 1:i.c1.,,lo ccnrJog_uont upon t:.:.2,t ju:lc;wo,T~ (1.l~o iµ-vaLdat oc~j a;.1::l. accor~:i.11clj- 2,:ro set e.r.rl.d.c I ocl<:c.: llv order e,s te- codu., J1DG-.J J1J.DG.J .l..pplicant Li.b:::ont Respondent Abso:1t A.O., Il!lUJLJ~ JUDGE -· GR0ili1a T?.:.o Ord.or for rovil:;ion be SU)Dliod to the l)artics upon pe.J11.1ent of' foes~ accor.:lin[.;' to l;.:,w. JVuGD Cortif'iod t:tuo copy of' t~·:o Cricinalo