19931126 TZHC Dar es Salaam

k/!f#/1#/··• . . MKU:DE, J. " ~e pl°..1.J.l'l-t.i:Zl", i10BER.T C .I,JZERG, is the owner o:': -~>.o ;&asa on Plot lJo. 53 ::J1oc~ I Ki.-tiomoi'l.do Strce"'~,. '11eil16ke c1i~:i,c·i.,. · iii 16/11/M . . ·the second.c:Zr,:.1if"d;, as driver oz tJ.1e first def'(;:.t~t~ 1·0.ile driving a_·pasmn~--;er -~J~~d :t.o@~ TZ 57202 belo~1":;i11g toOtb.e lir::-'i; d~endant negli- . ~ •' . . .· gently•dro'Ve iJ.1" \jO -~ha. pla.il"dti.ff r S ~O'l~C and CaL'.Sed.. a:::-'".,c;:1sive damage 1 ·'!iio •uio it.. Il:</o E:.t::;iriEfe:t'~(S co: :L·i;cl assessedt]'.e cke~1~C 'at shs.2684900/-. ,.,foglig8noe 011 t:..c pa:rt o:!:' the seoo;:1cl dc:i:end.a,nt is aclm;~ted and so · . .... . . ·, l:ilabilitiJ ,:,:: ;~:~,, --~I·ro. _c1.ef--:"'•da:nts is" no'i0 .~1 issu.e in t::t:'~G case. After '· . some· ·disc~1□ oion ·1Jc·~·,reen the parties H was agTed. -'.;>~c:~ t:1ey jointly ·- • . :· appoilit -:;_: .. Q ~:-_;·cio:.ial Conet:ruotiol'1 Oii"L:J.noil to c c:i;i:::c;;~ o~:t an evaluation • of ,the da.r:,c..e9 01;i·.·. oc:;d to the house ~::, tho Gover11.1:1e:;:i.t 78..lllo:r had -assessed the.amage x/v ;:J'.1::;,910(; ,/. ,.: 1i·· ;_,:.;~•:, Q-s Enginaeri:1-:; Co L-'.;d nor the -~ Government V,,L1.e~.~i.ad inY.~h·,=6. 2·,·• o2 the o~lib.or pa;:•~iG.O 1 ~ c a r ~ " .. out ~ei:r· v . .,11:.2.;d~ e:;::ero:tee, . -C~~tiop. Cu:.1.aoil dc.rL '" qo1i1prom.i.se - . . . . . . .. posJ:iiion. '.t:lw jo~.nt a:o1Jointie11:~ o:Z t!.le National ·-3.i.a Co:u:ioil- has asse- ssed the d1:.;·.1 ....c,~ at s>.s. i, 199,500/.··, 0 -~ :- . _-;Mr .•. r,,~·,., 1 ,~neC. ~ou.nsel :Z'o: -~J.,,s Plain-"1'i.f'f' >.arr rJ<..1.bmittGd that • . ·. .• .. . . ., ,. .... " . ~d..,, 'd ' , ' . ~; - tl l,T t··,.,'./!(;... ~, C ., .•, 4the 0-0mpla1::1 i;_ ,Jzr ·i;~1e . e.t: e11 a.rn;s · ·i:;~,;.a;v even · 1e i,c1 io11.t1,.1.. ons1,ruotion . f ..... .. . ~. 0~ respect, I c:~-0_.. ·•l1h:J:<ough :i":.,_ le··ii·-~er . ~~ cc1~:dod.-~::i. .·i;4J3 evp,lq.a•l;ion iJ'.!, .;their abs_enoe .ir.: ba.sal6\s' as -: .seven. <UJJ7Si 11o·~_io:; was'5iven ·l)y :t\e Com1cil prio:r _t,o. e;cilua.tion. With . . No. FCC/03/32/2 dated 1,th - . n.o:.r. · ~ii l.~Q~. '.~:j,6 i\,"Qi();J.n.1. Conlt~oJliion C·ot~ncil. lu,.d i::i.vi~ed both the- , I~ - . ,. ... •• ,:f '(. ; ~~"t½"'j; i;:;i.1.cl, \~G cl.ei'e:p,d.<e1,1.1te to a-t. ~e.nc. a maetinc 1iti0:1 ,rould discuss ;·i•a number o~ :;:-cl:;i,~d. m1.rb-cers, '..1.1:10 le:ii"'iier · said; il'.i. p,:w.~·~, 2 .... "Ua uo:.i_lr:l also request to meet both I?,:-::ti-: a3 ·tb.• . l"Jhd~riiif'f' and del'ead.ants at site on 22:.1.c'l.. Ap:dl, . ~ l5'C9 ;:i,t 09.00 a.m. to rlisouss rui1011.c ot>.er ·r.ungsi ( 1) Ikic:.unanta and. :l.11.i'or::1ntion we s:::.[1li 1'eoeiva:,. . . (2) ;_;),_e- erlent end lir,1i·b of damaces 02,,.:occ.1 lJy ~oiden-t~ (3) .:\r.c 6th~ bt..:.sineas • • b It woiad appe,_:: ·f:i.8't ·i:;l1is inv,~::'~ation 1:iy ·i:iha lJa"'liional Oarlsl.Tuo'tion Counoil was turned do·,J:.1 ~)~T -~~1a deie.nc:Uiits and so the vali.:::-;.t:i..0:1 '.1.ad. to be oa:rried . out in t.h.eii' u)J;:icilDe. Mr. IJJ;~'c1., lG (::rned counge1 fo:r -~>.e defenclal·r'.;p >.as, in his submiseiona, made two po:L,.1.·ts, PixEt l1e l-1as ooinpla:i.ned tha·~ ·Le ~al.1.:1.a,-'i;ion wa.a made by by the 1fatioacJ. Oo,.1.s-iiruction Covmil in ·l:ihe aosen.oe o:? t:1e defendants al1d O· urge.~ the oo::rt to tforder an ind.Sl)(lndent a.&,ilasar,1e11-t o::? -~.1a damage by a.n expert in cc:rn.i·::..:i..1.ctio11 wbio:1 as~aGsr,1e11t shou.J.C:. 1Ja . lU:lla...in the presenoe of the plai:n.tfZf ::i;nd.' the 1st d.ef8l.l<:1..ro.1t. n M:r: • IJ:it.,.Yt, 1 r.i seo.ond point is. tha-tt, . . ' in tha aJ.ter11.,.1i·ave ~ J~he quanti:u:a oi' cla'a,,3'8e be as:2csoocl on tl-ie ba.sia of the reporJi; o:? J;:!.e j~tiorinJL Cons-trt.io-bion C~uncil lesa· -1;.\o m:i..m of shs.400,000/.:... already .paii:l -~o :c:"i.e plainti:.:=-:· -~ :!;.;:~' IJa:t:1,anaJ'.. Ins;_~;;,;.toa Corporation of C) 1fith dL1.c :;:--3·01)Go·i; to ii.re, i :'~<.: ~- -1.•L.1.nk 11.is ;JGQOacl point is the more 0 tenahJ,o one. I .\i..--,;·1a already said t·-..,,t t:.• € ifo:iio:18", Go:1.::rl:a'u.ction Council had -w:rit-'.;en to ~)o·t;.'J the p:i.c:ib·i·,ii.'Z. and the a.e:i.:encla,n-ts Ol1 a meeting SOheduled to be held 0:1 22.4,89 to discuss Jv:.l<:: -valuation, :..~1.e letter, ,iritten on 15.,4.b9 grcve ·lf\c; ;,a:rties S€Va::.-r clays n.oti.c.s :m.d so t{ ·rta d.afendahts chose ,. .· ,-,U not to a't-li'e'-1.Cl it 1Tou'.i.d :)3 1.m:f:· :fr "to tl1G Cocj:10il i:2 t>.cu 1-rork should be di-srega;rdad j;,1.ff; ~)eoai.we the a.efm1d: 1,i->,ts chose to u.o~lbo ~heir invitation. The National .Concr~::ruo·tion Council is a pr':if'essioi:i.ul i~l::aJ.;itution with sta.tf _-who a'.["e· knot•ileace.:.,.,~)i~ ih Con:,rcrl1otion ~d :relatoc.l ,it:¢1;:◄ I have no reason to doubt ·t>.ei:.: ,:;,:Jili·ty to· oarisy oP.t ·o.11 avaJ.uz,tio~1 a) ~-l.O type they have . Oa:t'l:'ied.ou".; in -'i;;1is instance. 3/••• : 3 Ltd should be clecl,.:.oted from the aul()Ul'lt certified lV ti:,.o frational- Cons~q.otion Co:.,nail, ., Aocord.inc{L:· I e:o:~er jud,:),1ent f~ tho plainJi;if:,? ia ·;;:1e GU!ll of shs.1,199,500/-:- less shs~400,ooo/- pa;y2,ble by -'i;;;.o jJ:i;~ional· Insura.noe ;; Corporation o::? i_.\...,11:.;ci.nia.Ltd lGa;-vi:c1,s a r)ala.noe of a'.l,:i, 799~500/-• Order aocor d.ingl.Y ; Delive:L'cd i~1 o::.i.aml.>ers rd; :Oar es Salaam thia 26{b. day of N'ovember 199~ _in ·i;he 1,.l:'er~e:;.1.0e of I'lir. TIairc, for plaintil'i'. 1 Lt:. 1~-.ira for Mbuya, for ihi;··'~f'enda;.1t • •.. T. L • IvlimnE JUDGE 26/11/93,6