19780505 TZHC Mwanza1
The prosecution failed to establish the case against the accused beyond reasonable doubt due to unreliable identification evidence and inconsistencies in the prosecution's case. The doctrine of recent possession was not properly applicable in the circumstances, and the benefit of doubt must go to the accused.
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- 19780505 TZHC Mwanza1
- Parties
- Appellant: Saoli s/o Lansaisoli, Kini s/o Langachi, Nayesc s/o Latwangilu, Bilanga s/o Labondo, Kililya s/o Wangina, Soloshi s/o Leshonaco; Respondent: Republic
- Court
- TZHC
- Jurisdiction
- Tanzania
- Judgment Date
- 5 May 1978
- Procedural Posture
- Criminal Appeal / Appellate Judgment
- Outcome
- Appeal allowed
- Legal Topics
- Theft, Identification Evidence, Burden of Proof, Recent Possession
- Source Language
- en
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Saoli s/o Lansaisoli, Kini s/o Langachi, Nayesc s/o Latwangilu, Bilanga s/o Labondo, Kililya s/o Wangina, Soloshi s/o Leshonaco
Appellant
Republic
Respondent
Procedural Posture
Criminal Appeal / Appellate Judgment
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether the identification of the accused was sufficient to sustain a conviction for cattle theft
- 2 Whether the doctrine of recent possession was properly applied
- 3 Whether the prosecution proved its case beyond reasonable doubt
Ratio Decidendi
The prosecution failed to establish the case against the accused beyond reasonable doubt due to unreliable identification evidence and inconsistencies in the prosecution's case. The doctrine of recent possession was not properly applicable in the circumstances, and the benefit of doubt must go to the accused.
Court Disposition
Appeal allowed
Orders
- Convictions quashed and sentences set aside for all appellants
- Appellants to be released forthwith unless otherwise lawfully held
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
1 paragraphs
.,_.,..-, 1.7,rr-:- • .L...i.,l.,,N.JLIJ..i. APFELLL?~ J'JJlISDICTIQI~ I-IIG:I COURT Cff["'''.IEL.1 ~~PPEJ..1 no.2a4, 0) 1977 Cf: CRil.IIiT.i.L ,l:.,pp:;:;,t..1;3 ~35.9 286, 287 9 2138 1 289 OF 1S77 ORIGIF/..L cnr-r::::LL CLSE FO. 259 OF 1976 of the DL;-trict CoL Tc of n:,:xm. Dictr·ict at :i:.T2.1c::i:m :Defore 1 C. r. Sb.ilogilc, ns0., Dis-crict ,•-:·2;s;ictrcd;e ·?OPI::~GO s/o ELLJTGIJOKL. ............................... ( Or 1..l?T:";LLlJ :·T Locusocl) i rri' ...i'"'::>l --l) t.'~V-~ v:..~rsuc • . .• • • . . . . . • . . .. . . • • . . .. . . . • . • . . • . • • . . . . . • . ~s ro:·:n::-:I:·r ( 0ri;:sina1 ·P1,..occ:c1xb or-) - JUJ)GEITEH~: .. ----- - ... - . - ·-. ----·--·-~-- ..... SISYl.. ,. J :- '.:.i.1o·zix app:.hla.i.7.ts, na,··cly Saoli s/o Lansaisoli 9 I.:ini 2,/0 J_1;nr_;r:::chi, I:Tayesc o/ o Latv. :ng1,,1-lu; f3ilanga r:J/ o Labo:ndo 9 Ki lJiliyr'. · s/o ~':\',T,ngi rxna. So.lo;shi · c/o Lcsh0n3co 1 who a.ppo~,r(:d at ·ch0 t~rial L, .l·, vc,•-1~ ~1. 1 ..,,7;-l: r-·,"'n('CJ1-1'vnl·t J ( .:..·. "'cJ 0 1 •-('.• d.1.::., ''f- 7-•.1.1 v.. _, ' ·'-11 1 v1. , ··.u ·'· Jr;t'1:-.,:'-_\.A,. ('·'·'1 ,.L , ~cCl'r,r,cJ.· _) l,J..~ c. ...,..; - j ,..., .._, ..t:'..,. .:,. ,_ - J .... 0 on c;ro-u.cicls of QX_pccl.iency I nha.11 t:1x-ot:i..c;.!:.,.out hc~rso.f·i:;or c::.,11 -clJ.0, 1. oo) tor;othcr 1:-,-itJ.1 thrO'.") o·ch2r:3 \:.ho .;;~re convic-tod by t':.,'.) 'Lri2,1 courc in alxwnt:La 1scro c.:.\,:,re;c{L r.:ith ~Jncl convicted of G2·c·G1-: thcdt contrc,ry to s•:.:c-:;:i_o 1~3 '.~G5 c,ncl ~~68 · of -i:;h0 1?,nal CoD.0 - C.:Ll.').d r;~")ro ,--;c,ch ce_;:1t.-:mc,:::d to rs:L:·: :'.JJ_d_ a J.,_.:·.lf' y::,ars ir 1_priconu.o.i:1"G. _::lLy 1 aro nor,- a_ppo2.linc.; to thi::: Court. IJ,; if; not cJj_spu·i;::;cJ_ -clla-i; on 17tl1_;:o,::.rch~ 1976 ,J;i.i aboixc r:dd.cl.ay the coi;1pls,inan't '8 en-tire· J.1c:rcl o:2 cc1.t-Ll0 conpr:i.~:;ing 225 :111j__:·mls {;().,:.•.> u uo_ 1 i:-· .,-,.1.. ...., 1~.... Il -r~·,·1·1n· r- ~&.1• . ,. '"',. ~1d. 1_ {_:. ~r.~,...,; .!•. ~t_'.; •• _tcc.--..-·,.,,..,1•..,· _..., ··-'-LO_ _[!.G-·. .J~O /_;.. .J.·• 1 ·1,· I.Jl .,; ...117._p ]. "'1.11c41J.u C U. · n-- _,_, cto•· .!.l~ -C'., r'"'t t..,J ·~~- one Pindo ~~2.haja (PW. 2) "i':ho \i'~.,u ·0.~,.o .h,:a:rcls.r.12J.1 2,t t.hc .i:1a-c,:crj_2.l t;j_.,::r) tho [D,ic1 2..nL 1.,J..l8 WC)'.'C 0·tol~;;1 by a G8J.1;S of -C8i1 n::~o:r·8..:.'J.i8 :i A1J.f.I. c-. 1 ,,·---,r,,,-,1· .· o,,:., l, r-;bc.."'" .L. 1'"'11• • , , ,:.,;,,.,, L', J .• 1-1 _ , __ (,1 '·'r',l1• r-'1·1 <..~ !:i-'· lJ +hn vs:.·--· ·'··r•-i~l u .,. C,. p1_·.,.,c~o .!.!• .i. -(p··;-,. 0 • ; 0 . .:.. ) idcntiliGd tho 5th ace us :c.l :>,::J_cl tl.K porr1m1 \.-ho a;ppu2.1~c:cl ac ·chc · l:Tt ~:,cc·L:.ocd at the trL'..l ·c,'.) J:1..avo bo•Jr1- a: sonc; ·c.~1~; cattJ.c :rr:n-bl".Jrs. In 8.dc1j_-tion to thiD ·i;>0 rro:J,:cL·~·::ion e,cl.clFcnc~ cvi(J.c;::.i_co rJcckinc ·co :;:;:::i-t;-,,b1ish that all ·clF' nccv.s ;cl _perr-Jon:J v,ith -~;l10 01rnc:.rcion .i:-, .• .. ~·!(' 0+11. ,:;,.CC'l:L,;,;__, .-, ,.-1•"d". ,:-•l-1·;.. ----- r· .~:.('\·,- :l ·'-l1·-h,..;•:. l"'V: 'o' -,Cl" ,--· ,-., 07 - l ,- ,.,~, () .L I., ____ .;; Ou v1_.,; \'le',,.) .L,,L...,_l(l :,l0, ..• c., l.,JQ, ,0-- t!. r""\ ,.;, __ ci,11~ ....... J.1•.;c.,U. of c2,-Ltl,__: boo.rL1,r:: t.:Ja · icl.:n1:c::.i'ication _n,_2,rtc pocu.li2,r. to th-i .".'\ . l ....,,J_n,c,Llu f ,,, . c.',111.,·lc,1 ,.::,j co,.g ·-:'I .• r.•: t'l . --r. -,... :, ' (~ ,-, , -'· r: h~.L.b ~; .,. .p . ·;: . n ::J ·: -• -!- 1-i ,.... • -, 1 . ,,.:.".'..i.C.,.l vT,8.!.~ _,_Qt:.JlC. i•,l1,.'.., 8..i."'1. c.-,'l,J.lL-.2,. ,. :. ,'Ll r· 1 '.-1.,,,) ..j I , '"") ic'lcntifi·0c1 to bG tho Coi·1pl2.in;::,.,nt 0. 1 In th:ir c10fenocs 2,11 t:1,.:: f",CCUf:!'Jd \' i·d1 -;:he ")XCO_p:!;j_o~,. 0'.( -i-- cn,--G.,J. -c'l~/:'; bU°'l'J ., ~-c·c l:),,--,-a c.:, .. •J0 I! rlr,·11·-. G. :)·r,-;:1rt '-'-· ~ .-... 1-J: 2.> -'=·01 _,_ • ·1c' 1·11 ')0(";:~:eci("'"':;..;o.,... ,-~·J.' ,,..J...••. -'•.:,! C 1 1 .-,.J ~ -:-,-r,- o·':· .J 7• '::... 7"'···•j )_J.. ,_) 0 .; J...)1 .) J._ .i.). tho 2:cd:-1_.~J_s bslongin,:-; co· t;'.-1:: c<y1pl2.inr~11.t .2,n.<l F} .icll y;c:re _prcJC1ucsd 1 2,0 ,..:zhibi-i:;o at -bb_c-: trj:2,1. So,<: cH thn ;_-,,ccuocd denied 0°,;nj_:~:-.c~ s:ny J.y}o,dr:~ of cz~ttlo at all 1:.:}y_-,r::::2.0 others co:.1.nlc1.incr2 -:_}-iz·. t t.h(, :1.i ,.... 1 C',e,_ .....,,-1 (~, -t··~J-, •.• , ..... ,; ,.1· Ch •· ·r:•-crc ,/. ·• ,... :: cl .f·~0. ,...,-~ 1· '7(• . . . _ _._, - "'8,,.. , r· ~•. )'""': Q~ 1· _,:,·f':-, ro· . . +· ..0,... . . ..,_ ·'.·-''·-'· Cl,·) 1 -L.c.. 0··1 -"t ! .. ~i..-, ,l; .• r,,:~: r· u.:,lvo.)._J _. _: ' .[ - ._, --~-~ V oxhibi·ccd in th,:, case. ·:rhr:: loani,:)d. tr-ial m2.p;i:3·;.1r,-~-t;o o,cc,..J _p :~_:d th; Pros·:c,.:.'tion. utor-y anC. fom}_(l th2,t tJx:-. 2.ccrJ,;cd r:0r2 9 ,)n.Ch 9 found. L1 po:--icc:JDion of c, stoltJn 2 ..ain.s.l or 9 i:n r-i:::J pcct oi th 2 8-ch 2.ccusccl 9 -;,}1_.:; :::-;kin 1 of c'1. stole:;:._ 2..0.cl 012,in aniiJ.nl. Sin.c,J ·L;hz; ,-:::i1inalr,; 1,:c,ro c-:;0l8~1 in --~D.]'.'C]J. 9 197G 8..i."'1.c.1 tl12 J.aE:i; r:\11_i·:E1,l o:f t.tt0sc .-:;xhibitcrl He',~; r:Jcove:,rcrJ. j_,:::. t~ay ~ 1976 ·l;hc 1-::::a:;:-:::.c.cL tr5-al :J-7.g:U:rcra-t;,_; 1v2,r.;; of tl7.o vicF ·:;J:i.at tho interin. _p:n~iocl ·cai; sh0rt 0nouch for t.hn doc-0riD_::: of rcoc:nt poorJcocion -~o 2,:p_ply flncl~ in al1 th,; cj_rcur-1.Gtcx;:,_c:J,~J of tho cac0, hold cJ.11. tho 2,CC'll'.:\~G. ,::-..ctual thiovcc. Ls rcBHrC.c ·cJ.,_,:, :first ru.1d fifth accuc:cd t.1.n 1;::2..:c:ri<Jcl trj_1:1,l n.s..gi:::i ·i;ra/c,C: . ncu:ip·coo_ their- :Lden-c:Lfice.tion by PiJ-:tclo (F::. 2) •.. . ./2 f• '.::i·Gho11i; ·g(,ir.tJ ro1..1J1G. ·CllO i·scuo -c110 idG.1.1-tifj_ct:\tiior~. a:[' fj._l1-1t niifl :['i~c'~'cJ.1 t:i,ccur..::crls, j_)1 F.tlJ_ tli·-: - cir·cc;.r1ots.r1.ccs oI tl10 cc~c::;c, lJ:y p •·r ') C' )l,'""'(1 " -l·n "'"' l.,ill''••,·'•i ,,f,,,..,toi"' 11 01.'ill r:vicloncc . On Pi,1d.0 1-G h~... ,~_.;,~/'~:·,::;l:/;~ir~g -~~;:_ls;ci~l\;()~::"' 2.·'c .-tir; tiJ::c-::, Y:.'1:::11 l1: :1·;2,rcl ,i)c\-C•j):'J_C',l C.'i<)T_~\:·: 11G_if~~D. 1-Ic. ,[I,O·t l11) ·:;o f:j::.t: Y1,.-;__~_3;~ . ,t~:;:--"s l12.1Jpo1~ir1c; or1l21 -l;o r:.toG 1 .J. -1-vOL,.... .--0Iat1.,.~-fr,:f 8.)0Uu ,, 3:1.K(~ •-.-,.....r:r,•• f""lrt ·--r.-•7- r:--,-~ .. · r'""u.rlVJ ,c,,.'<-·,J. • t,..1.J.)U,..>a:'.:1.1 • - ··• .. J.f; £1,,.-ay l lL.~ •,,_ •r: ,.=l·'·-'••l" Co,t,G_.,. 1 i,- 'cco··c -i ·:ir1 ·'·o Pi,1Co- {p·r '~ )· ' -i-- '.rd ~-, onpor ··u1i·i:;,? to .,.,,.,,.., T•'>C: 1 1 1 .;·\ ·• ~-.::{·~~•-·~~ .. U. ~ ,, ·~:..·.:•· .;\ •·•-?~:. ·- r. ~;~' - . ~ ~~~~:. ~ ·1n ~~ c\Pl),_,1..,_,_ll,ly9 oh·.,,-JIY.. l,.,,.~ luu 8..J.1(1 5l,~l ,·.,CClc,A,-Ci. \,L-.,1.1 u .. '.•.• lc-,l,,...·.,_ ~- 1~ - -:-,~~·-.. ~, ~ ~--•·:·.~,.-, !-. ~J J; r~·e~ G, :it, ··-- ":'}'7· 11 ~t"'.'111·-,. Pi"·,c"o C· .,'1~·r' h1·J..!. ... r··1··-~,,_.,· "(.), . . Le -'-h,...,_,_ ·•.... ;_. . r,n;:i 011 1 r·:v-,,--.~rc· .. C·.•· ,--~ ·; Ci. ,::, 1•.! ~ - • v. Jl..!. ln,.- c:s , '.) 9 · C-', \., ...•~. ,, ,_, • ~- : . • ,:, soc :i..:1c; tJ.1j_;;_ .t:. J ·to0l~:.. rtf>·· }1it< .>.-'":>J_f)·\.. :~~or;o~v~:r-~ 110 dooc; 110·:; :JJ..:r l1nr.~ .. £01"' 110: 1;/afJ fro.s lnt, cl.n.cl )·CJ:1 2:.CGL:.r:;,_:Q ~-c tlJL: ·Gi.L1.1.~.: J.J.c c1ccicl.ccl ·Co r2_.J1 P.,,-.~~J'. ~~.l1i.s j_-s rG·l\./'l2J\t; lJ:~cc.1..tJ. C) · .. i-~-. Yi2/J Pi:n.cl.o J·ti(;_~~~/·~J_i r;:5_0 fj'C. icJ. -c:1c~t; 11() C;()Ll]_cl '110·-i: -·:Lc"lt;::I·ti:C_:;r -:;lie.• (_"rtJt:,~CfJ 1J . -;Cc\.L1C·~ ·c_:·1.e~~"f \:.-cJ~C; ~tt c-, -c1io-bcii:tc:·:; f rora 111.J~.l. oi1 e:oing tl1rm:c;L. tl1::: cv~Ld.:,D.cn en r::.:corc1 on(_,: y;oc'.ld. l1avo -'·h~; ryl1-·'- t:~~ '-'1.:, .t. v -:-1 . t ., •.10.. u,.-l ,.• r-""',: -l-l,1. 0 n ,.. ,_.,... c, ~r;_:.1• -:- r~0r:~·1· .L _ ,, " .,. , .•. ..r.:•,...,..,,., .L u .L .~ .."' o...i..i. 1· IA'· r:,...-.._ ..,.,_.; .r:•1· er:-,.-'-.()]' ....ct, .L.L ✓ t, l , .. .t,., pf"1, .,1~-1c-- c.,C 0 9 e. -t~ l.:arJ·C :r:-01,...:lfJ-~; c.1. .;_~rl 5-.;:;_ :2_ c'.-:CCT~r;:.·r;e.. 1 Y.;it,J.1 p\:!~21 y:,~_~J.O v-va"r-3 11·o·i: 1:1...,~~c 1._t a-t -;~_:_~~~;G2 C:\cc11~:>odL I ar:r-c0·cf r.?. :~, ·t;t~_.,; j_cJ. :JI1tif·s·ir:.3 ·h·j_·i~;1c.~c;:J. ~].:j_c: 1 C ._,J. ,....·,,.-.1'1'J ,,.,,.... t,cl.lc..!. \/ 1.,11·~c~ b··-,,r,-'b,-,r_··-· ,·-o _c.,v,J ...;,)L'. r-.-•--y ,,.LlJU,V C:c,:.:>,.,J_,, V.L r:)r:cr-·r--.-l·r-i•. ,.. ·- f"l'-V-,, ......... ,--'- l,c.J.lC1;.;_ 1-JJ. <-o;.;iC.;Y-L,-.,lJ..tl,lt-, rr ".")f"'" ... -'·····.,,·- · Pind.o' o ere di t cc",8 a l,i t:.ici.3::;. · ]:-~.1c ickn:cif icc•::,io;; o:t' 0.n :::i.ccu.oc:d by o.. y;;j_tn•::;ss in tJ.,.:~ o.ccw:,,;,J.o' cl..oc.1.:: ,,-,,11.:-:.rn icJ_cj1"Lific~i:Lj_o:1 i:--, on of ·'·U..t.l 1 ,0 ic"'"1 1 ,·· 0 t.J1:J _,_v_1,._.1, tc , be rl~cid."C i,...,Cl;(:~.,/--- J , \..- ,,,-;: J.~ -~o or01J~,tiv0 .._.,, _ r_., --: . ~.. v·c_.,lu. 0v • -1:;1. ·cl12 ..t..;,. •. 0 i~.10-C,a;.1-t ce.,r_;:.: .i:l~ iu J?OGcj_l)l1., -c112. t lrJt a11cl 5-GJ:i acct.IS8d JY :x :~\J.11s ~~1. . .-:: 1 ·.;.J(l"'>:"a" -1,.:J. ___ ,._,,...__. -'-)y-:, t1 •. __ ._., ...,.--,rc•.011n l.1·,., 1:.> 1.J -:-,ti'.,,,,... .'._.... V-v (nn L., •'- ')) . '"'"'··· ._,e,,\i •1 ·'- -'t,·'·1~- t_...,l, J. -..;- •l'='''t·r,r1· _,1.c •••, ,v :?l ·'·1· -~ L, ;cl('•· • ._ •.'_··c~ t Jt,n•..,__, <:•--:>.,(', u,_, ._ •1I.J.J...•.• ··in1(' ~ .•• ., ·r:l1···,rn. _____ .,. ,....-. ··1· 0· ·1"•·'t·>1" __ ,••. _,_ • ., ,_.L ·i., •i"n .. ,,-, J. .•,,.,., L• ....... -...... c::,no . ... ,., . ~· ,•,:h1""c~1 ·'·o 1.., _ . v._, + -l,·-~ u 1.J \..1.!.l ~1..,• .1. J_._ 0 tlJo:t PirJ.c1o did n.ot picl:: on tlT.:no t~0.;o 2ccu: ;cd poj:-c,mr\ for '.;11,, 0 sc,~:n l o:,i:. . .plC1Cln.e; .. 1. OLJ:G, · · 1 . c."..lG ·'···· u'I,') :.•, r,11-·,, .. --·d- ; c:,~,0a1 ,;___c,(; -·J.CU1 t~,:;, • r:11.")•C.., :-•("\r-1 a..,kl,_, ,.JO.J. !, OJ.. .0 r; -..-.- - 1 sj_tuo:ci,on cj_vofl r-is0 to ,\ I'Cc.Do:.-:i.::;lJl,:. c10ubt the bonc1fi<; o:l:' ~,-11.icll 2.J.1 c1.cct.:r:lcc:1 iD D.ntitl:·:J. ,?.t :)J."' :-~cc)rc1i:n:'.; to lc::.1,;,·. ' '. ?;·o;_,_. trc.r:J.in:.,; ~~o t~.K ot:~·;r lr_ 0 oi ·1~L..:, ovid2i1.ce, nc:. 1_3J_y t.:1at o-P J)ODOGDfJio11 · Of --l;l1~.; st~rJJ_c..: 1. ~\:_7.j_;?i_c,J._;-; ·G.!!.~- ~viG.e1··i'co of ·LJ.10 DLl]?lJ']GOd eye ,-ni;11c::1Gcs~ Pi."i.3 9 p·1.5 ,~ .:nd ?;.T.G 7 dilfcn~-".',d in ;\n:tc:c-:i.2.l 0 Ji,:r-:·,:i.cula.r. l:'ro '. -~h(;-; cvj_clo,_,_cc, F7. 3 9 son o':c ·r~ho coF1)lc.1ina..r or C\D.cl r.:-~--~-o ri'·0.c pr•GfJcn-t. 2,·t~ c. 11 ·. ·?.~-~0r-ia.l t,i/:L:c y;J..1 .:~i1 c:-:,11 -~;1·1··- · oic:.:.1t; 1 Jr;aclc o;:· cattle a:,1d a 8:'.L1 \:or-:.i r)cr,v,.:r,·.:d, it ir:J· clc2..r -c.~18:::, z,,.;_1 rn::i.L1al·y.;2,c J'.',:.:;cov 1::rcd froc1 :ac.:.1. accus:::;d ;-.;:;:ccp-tr ac f.~:or-e: r1::)j_TGio:,1scl 1 the: 8th accu::00(:.. It :l.~·. cl:c2r 1·roa·1. hin ovidcnco ·L/12.-c frcv,_ the firot accur:J:::a.' c .b_··:rd lr :Lc:c:.1t:Lficcl a.._11(1 rJcovr.;rcd. one: J10G..C. of cs.-::.-!;l~"•· Eo·,\ovc:rr 2..ccordinr·, to Oi•, ·:)e.lr.d :Slo (P.7..G)j v;hC) dcccrtbcd. hi. 1sGlf 2,;,; ,-.. r::c1··uit (.!onr~·i.;2vb1.:: 2.~,tac.~1cd to -~.ho 0 Stc)cJ;: i_':J:1.-:f t Prcve:ri;ion Unit oi t.11.c:; Police) I'oJ.'C(, 11.11c;_ c-:,2;;;io~1.,:cJ · r\t -··1r.~.~.-..1.:1apoJ_ala, e. lt;1'1ot:t{~)1 l1c }2.:L ·•1::1·~1f·· Sttid tlJ.8/G 1:r_: · -i1c:\8 lJ(.:!C~~l o:~1 unc 1 job r.0ith t:-ic 8. ~::. P .u. · c 112,ct.:-:c; c·.rotm(L and Cc" :tcl1in:; cs:c ;;le: ·:;lli0)v::::s 0 ~ :1.or n1n2 • yc2.rs ·c, ...,1cy~ J•.• c. ,:1ir:,:;,,,_I· I • . 1 rs-- 1 1:!._:;-, 8,'.lc.L-, o·cn.nrc;j • ,. :i.01.,111.ci. . ?.;:1d t"1 ~ 9 GOizc1cJ. four oi tho s·\~olc:.n · ~1.>:,1,c~:-j o< c2;tt1c - tJn:()C:, 1J1.,Ll1R 8. D.c1 2, co·c. -- fro.c'!. tll:; fir:.J-c e.ccusc:ct' c; L.Jrcl. .'.ccorcii::.1.ci; to -c~;.in ;:;,GlG::.ri 9 P?.:.s, 2:.f·~~Gr quostio11:Lx1c: ~.J.i··:. -;~l:s..: i"irn·t C:iCCl:I.S:·.:a_ t;J1nr1 c~-.1j_'!.i'::\~l;~~ 1Jd. Jl,-1,__ ... 0:,v❖ 1._.____. 11 c::-'-r-,7 1-..> l _t_J~,.-) 1'""!, V.!..-'- ----1i·.-,r;1r: c_.,_, t..:.,J.. ':J·· _ 1... c::, ,i 1 \. •. __ • __ • l, ;•,('' ~:.,-~1... ·-'-·'Lo11r:-,'. 0 ":"\d )' 1..,v_ t.-::..J. _;J rd c.,J_ 0 ...,.lC::i.l ._; •.•.C..t.. :J r:-:-~ . !:.,C'\Cl ~•-··'- c: d ..-Ll1.:>G l..'- __ ,-i ac 1.1is COJT:.1)2-...l.LiOilS ··d.t:..ri.lL:_~ -:-,J~.!..C -:~.t.cf-~;. ~l1.is pj_sc:J o:f P.Vj_(l_c ... ~.c,: •·,;_·__ ich ,.-;::-..n >ie;JJ.l;y _pre juclic:L;:-,.1 hi..:G in2.a_;;;_j_:,r;i blc in ovidcinr.,1.~ • .,..J..-~}0 . . -;~cl·--;i'lS-i-oi; ",. . h I -•-_ ·-·- lJ1r , r:J +hr:'! v....... , . . .,r~•,.-.-;'l':i( _,_._,. __ ,.,l. •• 1 --4\., "• ·',r-~ ,_ ~J_ _L(;.., (."\.·~ ("f'l "-· , __ l.J..._ •.,0 0 c_~.Jl,._L·~D+;""\ . .____, U,.,. -\··.,::'f0 . _..,~:.) ·:-: 1 ·1,r-i. ...,,,t':'.".1'7•·1····-,,c v_.., .,J_ ._. ,J_J_ illc\:::;al. ✓,'.t; a.:ny :cat::: :fro . ·clic:. uvicfonc,:: ol \;':d.s 1,·itncsc i-c icJ clc:-:.r t:·.~at 2nd,, 3rd 2-nc:.. '.:.ith ;:•.ccur:,1;cl -r:orc 2,r-1:·cc-ccd 2J_o-~; ~ 8,8 P· ·,,7 • _,') ,...~1·ra 0cc _tj th--,y .c..0, ,·-.--.rn '·'-' ..., "'~c' __ ,_, ...w.i c" ""]·-•.,,, •...;c:, ..1 -~1··c·,1,· .• • 'vl.!. '" ,.:.,r•J..01r,··-1 c, l, ,.., ......];,1 -,L u.! u J. 11 ..w· ..... .. 11 ~ "·"·'· ,,.;.,.)ly ,,,_,_ ·-J.- 0 ~ bCCL',UL(; -~_:1c i r ca-accused · ho;c1.. >](:.,,1tion,:.;O_ -:~.lien. 2uch - v~_(1:J:'1.C'J C:,••r,n-< C C.,,.J..U •• lJr a 1)'"' ·1·0. -Po-,,-. -~c,--·,·v1··c·'ci,)·1 ,,✓ \J - ---"l. . ·-- - J.. ,,_,_·1_1_. +_)_,,! l~<,Yi ;JC 1"·}: s·:;2..:::.ds. 0 ····"-' ._, -~ J. \.., V - - V V .:'.~~32.in 9 -c:11 ·!~l1c o,ric1c ..- 1.·c~.: -.--;f-F.7.3 i·~ f'.<)1li1.Ctr.i c1,~~;.~:. r <J:·.;.?:~--;~ ~;J.1~: -'ri1.ocl.1...1s 0p:·J:c2..ncl.i' a.r1o_pt:::o. by ·:;Ji,..: i:irvou·cie:~c~'.;:LnG;- p:c.rty. at I:"::r::J,,iland '170.,8 )-;J1.2:.·C 0.ll 2J.lir1_ 2.,l[i 1·ro.:· 1. t.:·~ ·vill -··t:~tJ c;~\lC.~ ·~);--:l!)IL{:j_J.7.G ·L~o d,:i_f'f.e::-~•~);_7_-l~ • ·;· ·2. 02.i ·t;J~j_b~·;s_.·1cJ.1 Tio1Uc:. be l1.·:rclc;:·:_ 2~n.6. r-1r.;Dc.1.;1bl,-::cl·, J.t 011.c pJ_~·.cc:. 1 P,cr 7 l ; ' . _) ·--~ 17 ( 1 \·. 1.JL:_i_ ~ ------r' -'-·, l,'. . loc'·- -'·'1· J.~:. c.,1·,J" "'r·,,·1'1'0 •;.I_ \.,;l__ l 1 · '-,-,.,,, L . . ., 1·G·,·,c,,1·'·-i-l>~r '.•.,,J. Lj• .1L·,_1·,,_·, ,.,,- 1 -.• l • c..:.;..),,1_,_·~ , 'j~_-:,.-::_)_·:-.·,r --- ..., - 1 f"'..;· .1' - l.. : .. • C..:\~ .. ;.)4 !;_,__ 1~1icr.ij___;_~-·c; c\t1i(.1r~.1c~. =1 l1iG \-;f'.J~; 2. _.,~ci:_;·C tu.1u~~ :tisfact01··\J7 · r.:B.. y· o:f 1 1 iclcn-ti:f yinc the culpri ·c;-:i. I C'.c',J.mot _pcrcci vo hor,, in. ·;;h'.; ... /3 ' :, .) circr•::,,_c,ta. nces 7 j_·c coulc1. h, :Jo,icJ. wi ,;_::•. rrnral c,:n~·i;ain.ty anc1. to ·;_;}1e e:::~cluDion of every rnaso11able cloubt ·t;ha:!_; -[;112 anin.alr.:J p:i.c.1-:ad OL1.t v.-ere a pz:,rcicr'.lo.x· pe:c·r.,o;-1 1 D J.J.:::r<l. F0 cloubt it r 1.uc::t J.:.2.v-:.i bee~.::,_ a very wor-L2.ble 2.nd. 2-c1r:;y Yic.y f'or i?J. 3 aD th3 · iclerl"i;i:fyin,r:: r;itL,.0so oi: the .w.ir:::~;i.1i,~:: C\j]j_,·-·:o,ls but r 1JJ1.for·i;w1r,:i_;ely p ;::o·chi:7-g J:1c:re. 1 rhiu bcin", a cri;;linal cc-::.se ·chc C.uty wc.u on tl1c Prosc,cr..·ci.::m. ·co _prove t.:.1e:Lr case arn:l nc·c o;:1 the o.cct1s8d to px·:Jve their :b.'.01()CDx1c0. On ,_,iy ev2J_l1.atiori. ot -~/-::.:::: evidc:uce cm record I finc3. tha·i; the J)rosccutj_o,1 .~1E:.d f.sdlccl ·co e:c.d;:::.'J)lish s. ce,se o,gainut D,j_1_y 0f -t11,:J ctcc-c1Bsd pGI\302~.s •. Ir1 ·tJ.-.tc 0-ve.i1·G ·GJ.1ese a.pp8s"lc; st1cceecl cw_1c1 tt:.:::;y are conneg.1~.c:::n.-0ly a.llo'.';-eci. It in fur-~.!1.er directc:C:~ -;_;1w;c unlo:Jr:; t~:1e;y :~.re b8i~1c h,)ld o~) ;30:10 other· L','\",f t.ll cha~ccr:;c al1 the 2,ccv.::ied should b'..c I'8lsc,2.c<l forthwith. JJlor · tl1e avoid2~~1ce c<f' 1 \ idcnti:f:ic,, ti on of tb.8 2~pt tJ:1.s ~t;2---ic1-il a. 11d . al tl10 Ll[{J. 1.10 OJ\rJ.er vva~~: .u1e:,c1t71 b-;;r -G.b.G l1,=-:: 2~lj_}_c.,l tri2,l n.ac._;L3-L:c::::l;e for ·cll.eir C.ir.3pos2,l it is h2:r2by o~cc1f'!rec1 t::_at ·Lhe sight ani.;12,ls k, ret,). L1,Jcl to tJ.10 co;·,1pls,i_;::a.:-cd:;. lf .J_._ - r O"T J.I • ,,/ D • n' ;:j'·:r.1J • ..J.. ,r·,: T C! .. L.t'- JCJDGE