19941011 TZHC Dar es Salaam

AT DliR ES SJiLi1.AH . NISC. CIVIL CAUSE MO. 3 OP 1908 IN ?BE NN-_•]:.1J OJ' TIC_ DAR ES SAL.APJl 'lTJ~TSPORT).... il.PPLICJJJT TRANSPORT COOMJtC1IVE SOCIET.f LTD ) vcrsLtS. ATTORNEY Gi1!l.f.Ga..,_\L ~• • ~ • o • • • ·• • • • • • • • • ~ • • • • • •· • • • • • • _ RESPO1'IDENT RULING. This is '·:;J.i.c' 9t. c,;;1(',. ·:;L.10 l\Trc Sa.:.<1,.:;';::. l1o,s filccl a bill of cos~ Tb.c fixst bill o:2 ood uc-,s 1ilcµ on 11-t>. October, 1991 nnd was ta=::c,d by l'-!Tc Nushi, tn:.::i..:nc o:2::icc-:-.: on 30/9/92c Mrc Sc.1.!lga was not satisfied -with t-hc ta.~tion.: · lie r:1uc"..o n. ref' c:2cncc -'Go the juclec ru:ic.'1. tho so.id rof orcncc nas hcc.l'l°"!. b~r ~EJ.1clc Jc: wl10 i:1;)..(.1.c l1i s decision which _1ms ran.cl on 26 /1 /9 .~ M.rc Kisusi wlvoc~,:cc rcpr-cccn-'iiin,::; -~l:c jucler.1011t clcbtox suh:tittcd that in that dcciGion, honot.u·n.blc 1,ncw.1c Jc lltl.Cl ordcxcd that tho dcc;co holci.or should file a fresh bill of oos-'.;s :fox tozation only in .respect of ocrtain itons uhich ucl'e: specified in tl'Lc :ruJ.ine, in particular, at p~o 4 of the RuJ.incc H:rc IG.snsi insio·~ccl t:mt lti.s Lordship did not rC"'."Opon the entire ·t;a:;ntion of tho decree holders bill n:f cos-'w Ito only allowed it as to ~i;hc c.btcs stn.tccl in the xulin~ Mrc Kisusi ricl1tly, I believe cJ'.ltoted t:t.e ruJ.inG of l:io ~ p "it i' ollom, tlln:t all the i tens listed in · Jl.h'c Sci,nc;a. 1 :3 bill of cootf;l priol' to .3c2c88' must of necessity be c::cludcclc" Mi't E'iau.si fu:rthcr su1Jni ttccl thn.t tl:..c clccri::c holder never cnr.10 tcf piott.;'o till .1991 when he filccl on applic2.tion :for leave to set aside -Jlih.c ozparto - rulinec: Renea, Hc;,1::; lToc I-:-36, nccox(li11C to Hi:~ K:i.ausi al'C not oovcrod by the Rul.il'lC o1 Hl'J.telc Jc ancl hence ·~l.J.c;;~ should :he stxuck. off ond o-th.o; i tens be contostcck Mrc: :Sa,J.;ga in lti.s rap:IJ",. stro:tccl by 0oJ1clon:zJi7te Mrc KisUs~ advocate, fo:c' ro.:i.sine an obj9c•~ion by w~r of surpris_i~ himc Ile wa~· caucht unaw~oi Hou-over; _h~ .film:t~.;ec.:. that by ~.;he very Rul-5,n;'!' of his _t.ordslup,. 1,tr-;;Ju.stioo Ml~lo{tltc itcl.1.s to b<;i ·c::cludcd fror:1 ·:;I1.is bill of costs tl.!'c those prioi · ecccc/e - 2 to 39 2~ 00 1 mil those itcas clftcx Co-:-cabs ucxe g.ran·tccl C.."I])n.l'te lcavo to,filo crclcrs o:i:' LtQj,1duau.o n.ncl ce.r-tio.rD.ri, that was 7/4/84, i1c was inourrine czpcnoom: 1E1c basis o-: t:ua oontcn-tion is based on tho poeo two(2). of tho :rulini of !1rc JL-:.stice IJ:;:ucle, second Pm'n(;Tn.ph f-.cora tho bottom, 15th line -i-1ho11 the jv.c'lcc s2..ic1.g "As a na·~·lie:r of fncd; since the .:i,pplicn.tion :for. lcxvc ·~o npp~r for tllc onlcrs was iaru:lo ro:pc:;;te, i•t is only ofte:c -~ll.is court exontccl ' lcc1vc on 7/4/88, tfa:.t Hrc S..."U1.Gi1• CO\Md rcaso1mbJ..y inoLU' c.';:penscs tow<1XtLs the p:rcscrvation of his ro·rro:cl u2iic:1 0.G}-CABS wcr'c non sot on course to have qtlnsl:.c(l by this courtnc The juilsc went 011 to so.;:,r s "'As CO-CADS did nothinc to :.:'ollo't-1 up JG116 BXcUlt · of 102.v-o to n.p1,1.Y· lo:c ol'tlcro real o:::ponscs to M.rll Sn.nc;a r.11.wt begin wit!1 instructions to sue in rclailion to his applic2,ti·.:m to set asic.lo the leave Cl'c1.L"1tccl to CCr-CAOS'' On. -the bclsis of t:.tio rulinc, Mrc SclllGa contested that all thq i tans must bo included in the· lJill of cost, while l-Ir~ Kisusi advocate is subL1i Jlitine thu.t itoms NocI ~ 36 be st:ruck of-le I The Hich CoLU'Jii e,:rc.ntcc'- lc2,vc to t:w CO-CABS to file o:rclcrs o:f for 11:r~ San[;a tc lcD.I'n al:;out this orcler, -;;o prcpc.rc fc1' its sett inc a.aide, ho lfO.S incur:rinc c..--::pcnco:::c '.I:!1<.::ii is uiv tl::c llcncuxn.blc ju(\3'0 snid "it is onl.Y' ofter thic ccw·~ cr:sllk(l leave on 7/4/00 that Mrc &.11[;a could r,oa:aon.t1:b±t, (u11c~crli11c SL~ppliccl) incUl' c::i,cnscs tov.~c1.s the prcsc:rvu.tion of his. award which CO-CJJlS i'rcro nou set on course to have qllasllcd by ·this court~ 4 ai.1 of tb.e vicu t:1a.t the u.::;e o:Z tl10cc words above mcnt to oovor aosts inc.ur:rod as pnxt o:Z -'i;hc prcpc:1.r.:::aonc and. incidental to the px.csorvntion of his c:iward which CCr-CADS. war c sot on to gt.W.shc Mrc San;Ja must have . r e d ·such. costs in propro:ration as he coLi.lcl not just file the oh.:lmbcw a,pplioo.tion without suo.h prcpnxationsc T'.c.is viow finds its base in tho GO,SO of ~ibson's Sc·iitlcmcnt '.Il.ru.sta licllors and Another VSc Gibaon.@d Anotllc~,. t1981~ Ch. 179 lr!l01'(' .it was held •;;'·.1.r. ~; inw oliaf lrJ.1ho.t Lt.1tlcx m1 oxdcr for the pc:ivu1cnt of costo of pxoccctil\.,~ costs incurred bofo~ proccodincs be cl.is.:lllowccl solely on tho.t CODXJCl'lOcd WoLi.lcl not oocount, nncl tlmt nn order :fo:r the costs _,of <.1.-11 iuoidc11ta.l ta 11the procccw.l1C3, extend rather than l'C(.luccJ. to the 0i·:1bit cf the ardor~ In tl1c rulinc of -~;.ic :uj.1 c0urt jud.cc, it tn.lkccl of the rcai o;:ponsoa which stn.rtccl with inst:ructions · to sue ai1(1 tl1c xcasonablc c::;:pcnscs ' . inour:rcd aftn:r 7/ 4/GG, The co c::po1:.ccs. n.r c thosq incuxrod i'o:r -'i;ho preparations prior to tho filine; qJ1.cl -'~he xcal m;:penses arc those 1-1llioh atartccl uith instructions to sue in I'•clc,·:;io11 to set aside the leave {t-t'tintcd to CO-Cil.BS. Ha.Vine- saicl so, I ar.1 o-:f the ?Pinion -'i;hc:!; tho rulinc; of tho honou:rablc judc;e ·talI:cc.1 oi both si tli.a·cious, the cost:;; which we:ro nccosso.ry to bo i11.Cur:rccl befo:;;e f-ilil1G, and those 11:uch uo:rc real 6:pcnoc·s to Mrc &.11{sa which stol.1' foc.l 1r.i. th the fili.n,:; o-f the applicn:tion O 0..-:. that strcllt.,rrili therefore, -~ho o1Jjoction b;r itr~ Kisusi advccatc to struck off. i toms I to 36 is rc:::'u:::m~c The Sllpj_:Jlinantcx.7 bill of costs shall bo oon·i;estcd as proscn-~etlc J.ic;li-~ of ·fux thcr :rc:f'cxcnce to the ju.c\3'0 is oponc L, B, lil\J.TElJTO SEiUOR IJ&'UYf ICOIST.d.AR IIICE.I COl,,11111 11/10/94 lJ./).0/94, Cbram- P» B. Manonto-s;)TI. Mrc ~"'a for the D/riolclcx .l\fl.'1t ICisu.si - for t:10 J /Debtor CG- Kombe .. CpHtrt1, Rulinc is xcacl. before the p.:i,r-'liicoc fl» ?to II.Al.JDTTO S--1!]:-JIOR DEPlJTI m:::GISTRAR I.ITGH C0L:Jil'I1. \ ll/10/94 1 ··~ MT1t E"isJ51 We arc_ applyine f'o:r a cop~.,, o:Z the ruline so that w:c can .. conl31,dcr if we can ;;1&:c a rofcroncc fo a jwlL,·ec: QJi;hcrwiso, I pr[\;~ for mcn-',ion SO that I COllf::dt 1-zy' clients ai'tor the :ruli.110: .. O:rdert •-..=F Copy of tllc :culi.nc; -'co l)c SU.Pi)licd. ;ir.u-c1cdiatci.•~ ...,. · .. ' A. ~ -·-1~:~~;~:~-::t; SENIOR DEPUTY REGISTRAR IlIGII COUP~ 11/10/94 CC I ,;;,:;/4 - t Or~ Mention 19/11/94 ~ ;1@a.ring date or otiroami.w, ff -V~ be ul1.J." xcfcrcncc Jlio n. jP.C:l.r_;o, H should be ~ ~ iWra:t montiY- aTum.te. S:SlJIOR Dr:;P'J~:Y I'~GLTllJ:Ji.R rrraa com1.T