19900911 TZCA Mbeya2

I' c ;~nd IfriZ..V.•S J, ;-., I. crvn .'.1-'P:S..L N0.15 OF 1990 ooooeec• NJB3'Y.:.. :.:CGIONJ... R'J)IlTG CO. LTD. • , • • • • • JJSPOND:::;NT (;.ppoc..l fron tllc Docision of tho Tiigh CQµr-t of 'I'e,nzc.nia 2-t Nboyc.) ( tt.~oso 2 J.) d2.ted tho 2nd o..c.y of DoccrJbor, 1988 •. .:_c·~,,_ Civil ·cr:.so Ho.· 4 of 1988 JUI'IJJ .;JNT OF TI·C GOUR 7 OM.IB , J. :~. : rr-Twiing Cor.1p2J1y, for wrongful dis ::iiss:,l fron ~~is so:rvico vr~·.ic~1 w:---,s on He is now ::..ppe2.ling to tl1is Cou:cto T~1;:; cvic"i.unc<c b;r t~:c c:,ppollc.nt ::i,nd l1is ( 0r.rployer 1 s reproso11t2.tivo disclosod. t',.::.'..t Twik:-..sycgc T,1w2-igo::ibo wc.s o::;ployod by tho . . . . . _:;sic-c.·~~·1-: .·:.ccount.c.nt. llis sGrvicos woro tcrL1in..,tod on 20.,S.35 tbrou,::;~i 11h::.t Ew:.,i.;o::ibo clc.ir.1s -',o : . . ct_ c.,nd tl10 IIinistcr-i:.,l o:rdor, t'.,011 t:s,:;ro .-r,s :,o .:,lt-crn.:.tivc but for J..T.Co to be 2.nswc:rc.'clo to t2.:o consequences of tl10 'brc ---,cl1 of Contr::.ct 2.s per Secti<:>n 73 of tho 12.H of Contro.ct .'.ct C·,p 433 of our 12-us. T~1e d.c.,::2{;'CS ,;;, Mr. Mw2.igo::i'bo in l1is plc.int.. clci;:1s :.ro ::;s follo1-rs: - •

I

I I I 2 I I .. .-(,.-) ·11l= vu::J. D41-0vc.J.ont to t;.0 _,_.-,;01n1.t of s:::.l::..ry th::. t would b.::.v-c :;,cc:c u:-JC. to 1: i:.: until t l:c r (n:pir;y· of tl:o contr ·.c: .--,t t.:1c CorJ;>uJ.sory ' rotircr.1cn>t c..go of 55 ,,: . i c: is S:1s. 316, 800/-. (b) ?c.xc.stct~l Pension I'und Contributod by to cqloyc.r S~•..D,148. 70/=. 'l'ot,:.l 327,948. 70/ = ' ,•: f (c) S.::.ln.ry ~ s c..nd :::.rro;-:.rs froo 20/8/85 up to. d2.tc I (d) Intorosts on tl":o d.001'-.:t:-.l ,.::·.ount fron i I tb.c d.c:w o:f filj ng t~;is s11it until full t i pn.y::icnt (e) Cost o~ ttis suit (f) ~ny other rcliofo ( It is cssentio.l thn.t tt.o t0r;.1s cont::i.inod in e~.~ployors lotto:r of c.~riain+.::1QJ1t._ i p.:i.rt -~ I l Dxb.i'bii; P.1 s:1ould bo ~1;~~"1;tu~: ~-'b.G :rolo~rrt. : tho:roof L I i ''On Sc.tisfc,ctory Co~.:plc.tion •f probdioro.ry period, you will' be· c;:(;:mfj.J:'ced in your c,ppo- int;1cnt ,,nc. -'.,htHafter eit21.er Gi-cc ;.:cy ter:Jin:-..t0 t~1.: .::.:;ipoint:.1ont by 6 5.ving throe □ ont:1s notic.:: or 1_:--,;_y--::·.;.;·.:t of ·or,o :.1cmt~1. 1s sc.1.:-.ry in lieu of no-~ico~ 11 bec;-..use. r..is cr.1ploy;:iont is :pcr,1c.nor,:t .::.nd. po:-1sion-:t1e :.nd t:::-.t :.-.e h:.s l 10 ye::.xs of sorvicc ye+, to cor.,;_1l0to 'oofor:i he re ·,c~.Gs t:.1c -,e,o of 55 y9-.rs J wllcn he would cor.1pulsorily retire. i;(' 'I;:,is w::.-:-.t i-,:i,. Hw:.igo::::'.:>e

underst.c..nd.s be his Contr:-..ct o:f 3crvice wi tb :'.;boy~ :l.: '-'. C, I.':r. i-1w:-..igo~_;;x:: :::.d..:"Ji ts his cnploy:JEmt when ~1is cor.11x:.ny did not wis:: to .,'::lid.o ty t::o :lhnisteric.l t . order to roinstc.te hiD in the sorviCB. i. .. :ZVon t~10 P.:-:.:r.::st.:-.t:;.l P~msion • • .F·.,·n,~ <.>'f Sh.R. 11 ♦ i ~ 70 co.nt.tibu~cd by hi~ 0;:;plcyor w::-,s :9.:.id to hi,o t~is Couxt t::o :receipt for it.: T!:is 'P2.1•c-,st.:--td Ponsion Fund. wc:.s. rejected. by t:'.lo tri::l Couri _on t~1e oistcicon tc].icf t'.:,::t it represented the ... oQl'r\\:J:-!"P\!(~.-icw1 -:!:'r):i.: ~ 7'Pu;:;i,»i~1-0 .yo.tu:·s -w~inh J.e h.:-A noi:. )l'.Ork;ed for but ,· ••• /3 3 beliov:.Js ;.10 is entitled to its s·.Lry ~ ot:icr bvncfits~ :..ctu.::.lly this p.::.yr.;ont wr.s for +,~ie ;icriod tii-:..t h~ uorkod since his confirontion in his ooployr:;ont to t~o d~tc qf his• ~erwinotion of ..... • ,~"" - a • / sorvice. Other pnyoonts n:.dc to hi□ ·:-..:ro1 t!10: net ~9-l,--XY_ ~or'\ 12 ;:;6nths, I . , :; .. .. . .,,: ',....... .-, ,. .....·_:,·;• ;, ·:.·... c~ J the st~tutory coopenea;tiort~ ono ;;ont!1s s~l~-~}~ ~~o~ o_~-... 1!~Jf~~"-ie;,f. ~~.:,~f~ r:• ~ • -- I l)Cyoohts in •liou of a.rra~s of lc:-.vo foz: the ycr.:rs 1983j -1984 .::.nd 1985.·,; ·: ·. - r • ....- • • - _... • • • ••: .~• """"-,;:-•,..,• ,,. •• ' • 1 • • • • • • - •' • • .• .'', -,~,: He w.:.s c.lso pc.id Re.ilwcy bu~

f~e for b.ir.1 nnd his fonily _to his hone ·l ' I' f ' District in !{yo~ ruid tl,onsp~rtciion o~ '';'• t~st~f~~\ . /~: 1f ~\s c.:i.n bG soon :fro□ t:io e~tr.:-,ct of .ti~ lot tor of .'.l.pfbintoorrt :' ;,{]~:._:· • A~ . . ' .. ···~~~~- .· ,. . j~·"_;_ ,\ r I quoted .e~lior, tho Contr~t of e□ployn;;nt between tho p.:i.rtios lw.id d~wn.:i. ;, . . thc.t at c.ny tiwC either ~ide my tornin-:,to tho o::.ployoont by- giving the,.;,~.;:·:.:'. ,_,;;,;.... •.••. ·:-7 :--:•. ··.• ' .. ·, . -:,:.:"#/~.'·. -.. ~ ~ -·,... :-. ··• ... : . . . ,;Jt:~~~ .·:-:j; .- I. <1,, other po.rty three ::ionths notioo or po..ynol'\t of_ o~. t~~~}~\:g\., _}~'in- '. ' I' of notice., This i~ olo~ly not •-n. CoAtrn,ct~Qf~Jf-'· .' _ _ , .,... . ._ , ---~- ,..,·_:-·:::-,t~~:::~----:.-1 '.·. ,-'. "',i' . • • ~ · -~,- ·_. ~ ~ -.< -_::· ~ . ~~:~~. ;}·I\~~~:-~;;?r~i~-7:~~ ;;.:~~\ :4y.r_~~ _, ~- _: ~ . , q-- -• - - · ··· ~-r••f - J •• 4 - the ego of 55, nor docs its terQi~?,tion en~~,U:r_-fi!i9, <~prip~s69' -~~~nt :,ofJti~-f~ .. f ·.. -....,;, :.;,,, ~- ,·t-t1t:r,::,~t~:~~~}-...-f#,'.::~,, ... -~~-:-~ ;;1 ~~- the reoa.ining period 1,o the _retirill€ ~.go of 55 yoc.rst::::':If. th"iei" were tho .--~<'I·;.,~ ~ , . . ~ . . ;. ·:: ~!",.:...j•---= i, .... --· -- .... ~ ~ - ~ - - - --~ :' T'J.¥": .. co.so cny person w:.ooe sorviccs were torriindod this wo.y would be_ cb,la to, ;,.,,r.:-'.~,,_., '-~.. • . ' . -;, .,-,ti,:··

ti ,, "I, ;k~ _,, . .. t·::;.'.ii•'t. + . collect ·:s n-:-..ny future cr.rnings cs his capl?y;:?<mt with mny eJ_JPloyors d ?'~ , ~ different tL'::los ne,y por.::1it. Tho cppoll-:-..nt w!:J.o cppec.rod in. pcr~on hcd four grounds· of o.ppoo.l. but tboy c.11 boil down to tllo contonts of the socond_ gr~und.. Ho scya tho.t " ''the loc.rnod tric.l judgo orrod ~ lo.w end.. il1 f~ct whon ho fc:il0d to onkc i o. finding thc.t e,n ooployoe being on c. poi-oaiicnt c.nd pensiom'bla terot1 oe~t that ho we.a cuployed :f'or 2. period UJ? to_ :his tL;o of ro'tirooont"~ . :,fo 2.ro of t:10 fir::1 view th.::.t t::o ha.rr_ic_d. t_r_:inl judge ~u-eotad hinself ,, properly and an:.lysod .:i.11 the rolov~nt provisio_ns· of B;:;ployoont .'J.ct, end··· .... \, ' ·:-.:~\~{~< . t!le Cantre.ct ..~ct 1 rolevc.nt. t.Q tho cb9plcint. of tho- ~ppellnnt, crtd ·.:i.rrivod . ·at the right decision t!lat every contr1ct tlUSt bo understood in its provisions ~ . . o.nd its binding tor~s, pd tbn.t there w.-:11 nb such ~revision in t~e lotter~ ' I of ..:.p-po.int.nent of t!ie c:ppella.n-\ vhich would ontitla hio to be ~id oontinun.lly,' · , .. . ; '- • / "" ' ' : ' 4 cooe whc.t n:--.y, up to tho .-:.go of ~1is :rctixc..:ient, Ic.l tlioU{P his services wore tor□ in~tod 10 yc;:-;rs oc.rlier. We e.ro in full agre(;lr:icmt with tl].i§ decision of t!lo Iligh C~~t, ·. _ I .. - AA~ .· c.nd wo disciss tho :::.ppc;:.l

except for t~:c ?=.r::-..stc.t~l ?cnsionKontributod by his cr.1ployor w!:lich f'Or the purposes of record we c:.llow end \i:J.ich tho I • o.ppello.nt !ms c..lre:::.d;y boon pc.id. T'...iis is distinct froo cntioipc.tod Pens~ poJti-lxr ~ ~ ,Q~t' e,os-fs, DJ.T:ID ~t NBJ:Y.t.. t!"lia -i1th do.y o(•·S~ptooborJ 1990 • . .. .(. , I L.M. M.'.K.:'JIID · JUJTIC:.: OF !.PPE.:i.L J .• u.:.• OM.:'.R JU-3TIC2 OF .'..P:?D.:.L N. S, ?,Il{Z:,.V.'.S · JUSTICD OF .:PPE.'.L I ,I 'I ll" •. I.