Yevgeniy Pavlovich ZEMLYANSKIY v Russia - 18969/06 [2012] ECHR 541 (13 March 2012)
Applicants were entitled to enforcement of judgments awarding adjustments to minimum wage and food allowance, subject to discontinuance or rejection in supervisory or subsequent proceedings.
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- [2012] ECHR 541
- Parties
- Applicant: Zemlyanskiy Yevgeniy Pavlovich; Applicant: Pakhomov Sergey Olegovich; Applicant: Popkov Nikolay Vasilyevich; Applicant: Mukovoz Vasiliy Ivanovich; Applicant: Bondarev Petr Aleksandrovich
- Jurisdiction
- European Union
- Judgment Date
- 13 March 2012
- Procedural Posture
- Civil / Post Judgment Enforcement and Supervisory Review
- Outcome
- partially enforced, partially discontinued or rejected
- Legal Topics
- Minimum Wage Adjustment, Food Allowance, Enforcement of Judgments, Index Linking of Awards
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Zemlyanskiy Yevgeniy Pavlovich
Applicant
Pakhomov Sergey Olegovich
Applicant
Popkov Nikolay Vasilyevich
Applicant
Mukovoz Vasiliy Ivanovich
Applicant
Bondarev Petr Aleksandrovich
Applicant
Procedural Posture
Civil / Post Judgment Enforcement and Supervisory Review
Legal Issues
- 1 entitlement to adjustment of pension to minimum wage
- 2 entitlement to food allowance
- 3 enforcement of monetary judgments
Ratio Decidendi
Applicants were entitled to enforcement of judgments awarding adjustments to minimum wage and food allowance, subject to discontinuance or rejection in supervisory or subsequent proceedings.
Court Disposition
partially enforced, partially discontinued or rejected
Orders
- Enforcement of monetary awards for minimum wage adjustment and food allowance as specified per applicant and judgment.
- Discontinuance of supervisory-review proceedings where applicable.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
1 paragraphs
Judgment by the Novocherkassk Town Court Sum awarded (RUB), nature of the payment (adjustment to the increase of minimum wage or food allowance, other) Enforcement status Quashing (date), Presidium judgment received by the applicant (date, if relevant) Subsequent developments ( proceedings before the Oktyabrskiy District Court of Rostov-On–Don, the Rostov Region) 1. 18969/06 20/04/06 Zemlyanskiy Yevgeniy Pavlovich (1937) August 2004 No. 2-1618/04 108,657.68, adjustment to the minimum wage Enforced on 5 February 2007 Not applicable, Supervisory-review proceedings discontinued Not applicable August 2004 No. 2-1522/04 109,706.21, food allowance Enforced on 5 February 2007 29 March 28 May 2007, claim rejected 2. 27707/06 01/06/2006 Pakhomov Sergey Olegovich (1957) August 2004 No. 2-1618/04 202,832.39, adjustment to the minimum wage Enforced on 5 February 2007 Not applicable, Supervisory-review proceedings discontinued Not applicable August 2004 No. 2-1491/04 104,642.85, Food allowance Not enforced November 2005, copy of the judgment received by the applicant on 2 December 15 December 2008, proceedings discontinued 3. 29771/06 09/06/2006 Popkov Nikolay Vasilyevich (1949) August 2004 No. 2-1492/04 114,725.44 food allowance (as further index-linked on 9 February and 7 October 2009, see below) Not enforced to date Not applicable, Supervisory-review proceedings discontinued Not applicable August 2004 (no. 2-1636/04) 275,858.89, adjustment to the minimum wage Not enforced December 2005, copy of the judgment received by the applicant on 20 January 2006 February 2006, proceedings discontinued February 2009, as rectified on 7 October 2009 114,725.44 index-linking of the award of 30 August 2004 as regards adjustment of the pension to the minimum wage Enforced on 22 December 2009 Not applicable Not applicable 4. 29902/06 15/06/2006 Mukovoz Vasiliy Ivanovich (1944) August 2004 No. 2-1655/04 309,988.01 adjustment to the minimum wage Enforced on 15 May 2007 27 July 20 September 2007, proceedings discontinued August 2004 No. 2-1531/04 130,706.83 food allowance Not enforced December 2005, copy of the judgment received by the applicant on 16 December 2005 February 2006, claims rejected 5. 32493/06 26/06/2006 Bondarev Petr Aleksandrovich (1944) August 2004 No. 2-1631/04 374,220.26 adjustment to the minimum wage Enforced on 5 February 2007 26 July 20 September 2007, proceedings discontinued BAILII: Copyright Policy | Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Feedback | Donate to BAILII