[1999] KEHC 114 (KLR)
The court found that the defendant's driver was negligent by failing to ensure that all passengers, including the plaintiff, had safely alighted before driving off. The driver moved the bus at excessive speed, causing the plaintiff to fall and sustain severe injuries resulting in amputation. The court rejected the...
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- [1999] KEHC 114 (KLR)
- Parties
- Plaintiff: Alex Okello Odianya; Defendant: Kenya Bus Services Ltd.
- Court
- High Court
- Court Station
- High Court at Nairobi (Milimani Law Courts)
- Jurisdiction
- Kenya
- Case Number
- Civil Case 1571 of 1998
- Procedural Posture
- Civil Case / Judgment
- Outcome
- Judgment for the plaintiff; defendant found 100% liable.
- Legal Topics
- Negligence, Personal Injury, Res Ipsa Loquitor, Damages Assessment
- Source Language
- en
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Alex Okello Odianya
Plaintiff
Kenya Bus Services Ltd.
Defendant
Procedural Posture
Civil Case / Judgment
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether the defendant was negligent in the operation of the bus resulting in injury to the plaintiff.
- 2 Whether the plaintiff contributed to the accident through his own negligence.
- 3 What is the appropriate quantum of damages for the injuries sustained by the plaintiff.
Ratio Decidendi
The court found that the defendant's driver was negligent by failing to ensure that all passengers, including the plaintiff, had safely alighted before driving off. The driver moved the bus at excessive speed, causing the plaintiff to fall and sustain severe injuries resulting in amputation. The court rejected the defendant's claim of contributory negligence, holding that the plaintiff had a right to alight safely and that the circumstances justified the application of Res Ipsa Loquitor. The court awarded general damages for pain, suffering, and loss of amenities, as well as future medical expenses, finding the defendant 100% liable.
Court Disposition
Judgment for the plaintiff; defendant found 100% liable.
Orders
- The plaintiff is awarded general damages of Kshs.650,000 inclusive of future medical treatment.
- The plaintiff is awarded costs of the suit and interest from the date of judgment.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
43 paragraphs
REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA
AT NAIROBI
CIVIL CASE NO. 1571 OF 1998
ALEX OKELLO ODIANYA ............................................ PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
KENYA BUS SERVICES LTD. ............................... DEFENDANTS
JUDGMENT
Alex Okello Odianya was lawfully travelling in a motor vehicle Bus registration No. KAD 075J. On the 22. 6.1997. He reached his destination in Kariobangi along the Outer Ring Road at a place commonly known as the Hilton Bus Stage.
The passengers alighted. The Plaintiff was the last to alight. Before he placed his foot on the ground the bus drove off. The Plaintiff fell and the bus ran over his leg.
The very same bus drove him to the Kenyatta National Hospital where he was duly admitted with injuries that was described as a crushed right leg with extensive soft tissue injuries and fractures tibia and fibula.
Because his leg developed severe sepsis wounds, the plaintiff underwent an amputation of the femur.
He was discharged from the hospital on the 18. 7.97.
On the 24. 4.98 PW1 the Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon - Prof. B.S. Mbinyo examined the plaintiff. He found that the plaintiff had disability from the amputation and complained of discharging sinus from the amputed limb. His opinion was that the plaintiff besides being disabled in activities such as sporting, social and pleasures, the Plaintiff would need an artificial lower limb to improve his mobility. The costs of this limb being Kshs.350,000/-. The plaintiff would require to undergo further surgical treatment to contest the osteomyelistis before the artificial limb is fitted at a costs of Ksh.100,000/-.
The permanent disability has been arosed by him at 70%.
The plaintiff filed suit against the defendant company on the 11. 7.98.
The defendants entered appearance and filed defence on the 3. 9.98. The defence denied there was any negligence on their part. The defence stated that the accident was solely caused or substantially contributed by the Plaintiffs negligence.
When this case came up for hearing on the 10. 5.99, the advocate for the defendant stated he did not bring his witnesses to court. The reasons being that the parties were negotiating on out of court settlement.
The advocate for the plaintiff denied any knowledge of such settlement or any at all.
The parties were given time to verify their facts and to return to court to either record a settlement or to continue with hearing.
After adjournment the hearing proceeded on 10. 5.99 and adjourned to 11. 5.99. In all this time the defendant failed to bring his witnesses.
From the agreed issues I have found the following facts.
That the defendants driver was negligent as alleged in the Plaint. The driver should have taken due and reasonable care to ensure that all the passengers had alighted from the bus and were clear from the bus.
I also find that if the driver was pulling out the bus at a slow and gradual pace the plaintiff who had fallen down would not have sustained such severe injuries.
I find that the defendants driver drove off in an excessive speed the impact being that the plaintiffs leg was crushed. This was to such an extent that dirt went inside the wound and an infection was found to cause the plaintiffs leg to be amputed.
I do not find that the plaintiff was negligent. He had a right to get off the bus which right the defendant should have ensured that he waited long enough for him to alight.
The doctrine of Res Ipsa Loquitor does apply in this case.
I find that the plaintiff sustained injuries as described above.
I would compute the injures for pain, Suffering and loss of Amenities at Kshs.200,000/-.
I would award costs of future medical care at Ksh.350,000/- for the artificial bone and Kshs.100,000/- for the costs of treatment.
Special Damages had not been proved.
None of the advocates relied on any case law before me to prove their case.
In summary
General damages
Pain, Suffering and Loss of Amenities Ksh.200,000/-
Future Medical treatment Kshs.450,000
Total Kshs.650,000/-
I hereby enter judgment of the plaintiff for General Damages at 100% liability at Kshs.650,000/- inclusive of future medical treatment.
I make no awards of the Special Damages of 1,600/- as this has not been proved.
I award costs of this suit and interest from the date of this judgement.
Dated this 13th day of May 1999 at Nairobi.
M..A ANG’AWA
JUDGE