[2020] KEHC 8161 (KLR)
The court found that the appellant's plea of guilty was unequivocal and properly entered. However, the court recognized that the appellant suffered from a mental illness at the time of the offence and had shown significant improvement while in custody, as confirmed by a recent medical report. The court determined...
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- [2020] KEHC 8161 (KLR)
- Parties
- Appellant: Christine Mbithethe; Respondent: Republic
- Court
- High Court
- Court Station
- High Court at Makueni
- Jurisdiction
- Kenya
- Case Number
- Criminal Appeal 121 of 2019
- Procedural Posture
- Criminal Appeal / Judgment
- Outcome
- Further orders deferred pending social inquiry report.
- Legal Topics
- Infanticide, Mental Health in Criminal Law, Sentencing Principles
- Source Language
- en
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Christine Mbithethe
Appellant
Republic
Respondent
Procedural Posture
Criminal Appeal / Judgment
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether the plea of guilty was unequivocal and properly entered.
- 2 Whether the sentence imposed was appropriate considering the appellant's mental health and circumstances.
- 3 Whether the appellant should be resentenced or released based on her improved mental status.
Ratio Decidendi
The court found that the appellant's plea of guilty was unequivocal and properly entered. However, the court recognized that the appellant suffered from a mental illness at the time of the offence and had shown significant improvement while in custody, as confirmed by a recent medical report. The court determined that these circumstances, along with the period already served, warranted reconsideration of the sentence. Before reducing the sentence or making further orders, the court required a detailed social inquiry report to ensure the appellant's continued treatment and monitoring upon release, prioritizing both her welfare and public safety.
Court Disposition
Further orders deferred pending social inquiry report.
Orders
- A detailed social inquiry report by the county probation officer is to be filed within 14 days addressing the appellant's accommodation and continued treatment.
- Mention scheduled for 10th March, 2020 for further orders.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
24 paragraphs
REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA
AT MAKUENI
HCCRA NO. 121 OF 2019
CM ..............................................APPELLANT
-VERSUS-
REPUBLIC..............................RESPONDENT
(Being an appeal from the sentence of the Senior Resident Magistrate Hon. P. Wambugu dated 31/08/2015 in Kilungu SRMCR No. 475 of 2015. )
JUDGMENT
1. Christine Mbithethe Appellant was charged and convicted of the offence of infanticide contrary to section 210 of the Penal Code. The particulars were that the Appellant on the 2nd day of August, 2015 within Makueni county, by willfully act or omission caused the death of her child namely MK a child aged six months by intentionally suffocating the child by lying on her.
2. She was first arraigned in court on 13th August, 2015 when the charge was read to her in Kiswahili language which she understood and admitted the charge. The facts were read to her and she admitted them. The postmortem report (EXB1) was produced. She was convicted. The court after hearing from the prosecution and the Appellant, called for a probation officer’s report which was availed on 31st August, 2015.
3. The report was not favourable and the court sent the Appellant to prison for ten (10) years.
4. First of all, I am satisfied that the plea was unequivocal. My only concern is that before the court called for a probation report, the prosecution informed the court that though the Appellant was a first offender, there were reports of her having killed two of her children previously.
5. I have read through the undated probation report before the trial court by the county probation officer Mr. Munyasya. It clearly indicates that the Appellant was having a mental illness. That the family had not supported her in that case.
6. The Appellant has been in prison since her conviction. She informed this court that during her stay in prison she has been on treatment.
7. This court ordered that her mental status be re-assessed to confirm that indeed she had recovered. It is true that she committed the offence she is accused of. She was never charged with the other deaths and that’s why the prosecution asked the court to treat her as a first offender.
8. She was finally examined on 3rd February, 2020 at Makueni referral hospital and a report filed on the same day. The report confirms that she is on medication and she has greatly improved. Considering all the circumstances under which the offence was committed and the period served, I find this to be a special case where the sentence should be reduced.
9. However, before doing so this court will want to be certain as to where the Appellant will stay or be accommodated to ensure that she continues with her medication and is closely monitored. For that reason, I hereby call for a detailed socialinquiry report by the county probation officer which should address the issues I have raised above.
10. The report should be filed within 14 days. Mention on 10th March, 2020 for further orders.
Orders accordingly.
Delivered, signed & dated this 20th day of February 2020, in open court at Makueni.
..................................
Hon. H. I. Ong’udi
Judge