[2011] KEHC 1479 (KLR)
The court found that the grant issued in Nyeri H.C. Succession Cause No. 179 of 2008 was irregular because a valid and confirmed grant had already been issued to Patrick Mwangi Gichu in Othaya R.M.C. Succession Cause No. 30 of 2008. The existence of two grants for the same estate is impermissible under the Law of...
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- [2011] KEHC 1479 (KLR)
- Parties
- Applicant: Gatutha Gichu; Respondent: Patrick Mwangi Gichu
- Court
- High Court
- Court Station
- High Court at Nyeri
- Jurisdiction
- Kenya
- Case Number
- Succession Cause 179 of 2008
- Procedural Posture
- Succession Cause / Order on Revision and Directions
- Outcome
- Grant revoked and cause struck out; parties to proceed with hearing of related cause.
- Judges
- JK Sergon
- Legal Topics
- Grant of Letters of Administration, Revocation of Grant, Confirmation of Grant
- Source Language
- en
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Gatutha Gichu
Applicant
Patrick Mwangi Gichu
Respondent
Procedural Posture
Succession Cause / Order on Revision and Directions
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether the grant issued in Nyeri H.C. Succession Cause No. 179 of 2008 should be revoked.
- 2 Whether the two succession causes can be consolidated.
- 3 Whether the confirmation of grant in light of an earlier confirmed grant is valid.
Ratio Decidendi
The court found that the grant issued in Nyeri H.C. Succession Cause No. 179 of 2008 was irregular because a valid and confirmed grant had already been issued to Patrick Mwangi Gichu in Othaya R.M.C. Succession Cause No. 30 of 2008. The existence of two grants for the same estate is impermissible under the Law of Succession Act. Therefore, the court revoked the later grant and struck out the cause, holding that consolidation was not possible or appropriate in these circumstances. The parties were directed to proceed with the hearing of Nyeri H.C. Succ. Cause No. 863 of 2010, as the earlier confirmed grant took precedence.
Court Disposition
Grant revoked and cause struck out; parties to proceed with hearing of related cause.
Orders
- The grant issued vide Nyeri H.C. Succ. Cause No. 179 of 2008 is revoked.
- Nyeri H.C. Succ. Cause No. 179 of 2008 is struck out with no order as to costs.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
17 paragraphs
REPUBLICOF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA
AT NYERI
SUCCESSION CAUSE NO. 179 OF 2008
GATUTHA GICHU...........................…………….………....………..APPLICANT
VERSUS
PATRICK MWANGI GICHU.…………………………………....... RESPONDENT
ORDER ON REVISION AND DIRECTIONS
On 11th April 2011, Mr. Mugo, learned advocate for Gatutha Gichu, the Petitioner herein, applied for this Succession Cause to be consolidated with Nyeri H.C. Succession Cause No. 863 of 2010. I called for the aforesaid file for perusal in order to give directions.
My perusal of these files has revealed that Gatutha Gichu cited Christopher Gatutha Gichu and Patrick Mwangi Gichu to indicate whether or not they were ready to take up letters of administration intestate in respect of the Estate of Zaweria Wanjiru Gichu alias Wanjiru Gichu, deceased. It would appear the duo did not file any positive response hence the citor was prompted to petition for letters of administration intestate through the petition dated 24th June 2009 vide Nyeri H. C. Succ. Cause No. 179 of 2008. The grant was made to Gatuthu Gichu on 15th September 2009. On 22nd March 2010, the Petitioner applied for the grant to be confirmed vide the Summons for Confirmation of Grant dated 17th March 2010. When served with the aforesaid summons, Christopher Gatutha Gichu filed an affidavit of protest against the same. In the aforesaid affidavit, he revealed that another grant had been made and confirmed vide Othaya R.M.C. Succession cause No. 30 of 2008. In fact he annexed a copy of the grant to the affidavit of Protest in which it was clear that the grant had been issued to Patrick Mwangi Gichu, the other cite. It would appear, when Gatutha Gichu got this vital information, he abandoned Nyeri H.C. Succ. No. 179 of 2008and proceeded to file the Summons for Revocation of Grant dated 15th September 2010. I have now been urged to consolidate Nyeri H.C. Succ. Cause No. 179 of 2008 with Nyeri H.C. Succ. No. 863 of 2010.
After a careful perusal of the aforesaid files, I have come to the conclusion that the prayer by Gatutha Gichu must be rejected. The two files cannot be consolidated. One of those files seeks to have the grant issued vide Nyeri H.C. Succ. Cause No. 179 of 2008 to be confirmed. There is a protest showing that a grant was issued to Patrick Mwangi Gichu on 26th September 2008 and confirmed on 22nd June 2009 vide Othaya R.M.C. Succ. Cause No. 30 of 2008. By the time of obtaining the grant vide Nyeri H.C. Succ. Cause No. 179 of 2008, i.e. on 15th September 2009, Patrick Mwangi Gicheru had already had his grant confirmed i.e. on 22nd June 2009. The best I can do in the circumstances is to issue an order which I hereby do, revoking the grant issued vide Nyeri H.C. Succ. Cause No. 179 of 2008. I also strike out Nyeri H.C. Succ. No. 179 of 2008 with no order as to costs. I direct that parties should proceed for hearing of Nyeri H.C. Succ. Cause No. 863 of 2010.
Dated and delivered at Nyeri this 29th day of July 2011.
J. K. SERGON
JUDGE
In open court in the presence of Mugo for Applicant and N/A for Respondent with notice.
J. K. SERGON
JUDGE