[2019] KEHC 11730 (KLR)
The court found that the Certificate of Confirmation of Grant issued on 28 March 1996 must be rectified to comply with the orders made on 28 March 1996, 17 June 1997, and 8 December 2011, which included the addition of Jane Njanja Kibue and Veronica Njeri Kibue as beneficiaries and the redistribution of shares of...
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- [2019] KEHC 11730 (KLR)
- Parties
- Applicant: Alice Nyakarura Kibue; Applicant: Veronica Njeri Kibue; Applicant: Paul Njoroge Kibue; Respondent: Jane Njanja Kibue; Respondent: Christopher Ruringe Kibui
- Court
- High Court
- Court Station
- High Court at Nairobi (Milimani Law Courts)
- Jurisdiction
- Kenya
- Case Number
- Succession Cause 611 of 1995
- Procedural Posture
- Succession Cause / Ruling on Rectification and Administration
- Outcome
- Rectification of Certificate of Confirmation of Grant ordered; administrators directed to comply within 30 days.
- Legal Topics
- Succession, Grant of Letters of Administration, Rectification of Certificate, Distribution of Estate, Beneficiary Entitlement
- Source Language
- en
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Alice Nyakarura Kibue
Applicant
Veronica Njeri Kibue
Applicant
Paul Njoroge Kibue
Applicant
Jane Njanja Kibue
Respondent
Christopher Ruringe Kibui
Respondent
Procedural Posture
Succession Cause / Ruling on Rectification and Administration
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether the Certificate of Confirmation of Grant should be rectified to comply with previous court orders.
- 2 Who are the rightful beneficiaries of the estate of Kibui Kangari and how should the estate be distributed.
- 3 How to deal with shares of deceased beneficiaries.
Ratio Decidendi
The court found that the Certificate of Confirmation of Grant issued on 28 March 1996 must be rectified to comply with the orders made on 28 March 1996, 17 June 1997, and 8 December 2011, which included the addition of Jane Njanja Kibue and Veronica Njeri Kibue as beneficiaries and the redistribution of shares of deceased beneficiaries to the surviving ones. The court further directed that the three current administrators—Alice Nyakarura Kibue, Veronica Njeri Kibue, and Paul Njoroge Kibue—apply for rectification of the Certificate of Confirmation within 30 days to ensure the estate is distributed in accordance with all prior court orders. The court clarified that the shares of deceased...
Court Disposition
Rectification of Certificate of Confirmation of Grant ordered; administrators directed to comply within 30 days.
Orders
- The three administrators—Alice Nyakarura Kibue, Veronica Njeri Kibue, and Paul Njoroge Kibue—shall apply for rectification of the Certificate of Confirmation issued on 28 March 1996 to comply with the orders of 28 March 1996, 17 June 1997, and 8 December 2011 within 30 days.
- The shares of deceased beneficiaries shall be distributed equally among the surviving beneficiaries as directed by the court.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
49 paragraphs
REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT NAIROBI
FAMILY DIVISION
SUCCESSION CAUSE NO. 611 OF 1995
IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF KIBUI KANGARI (DECEASED)
RULING
1. This matter has been pending before this Court since 1995. This Court directed the parties to file case Summaries on what has transpired in this case since 1995.
2. I have had the opportunity to peruse this file and I find that several rulings have been made in this matter.
3. The deceased herein KIBUI KANGARI died intestate on 4th May 1992 and CHRISTOPHER RURINGE KIBUI petitioned for letters of Administration and listed the following as the beneficiaries of the estate;
(i) Leah Wambui (Wife – already deceased)
(ii) Hannah Wairimu (Wife Now Deceased)
(iii) George Rurine (Son also pre-deceased him)
(iv) Jane Njanja (daughter)
(v) Alice Nyakarura (Daughter)
(vi) Veronicah Njeri (Daughter)
(vii) Paul Njoroge (son)
4. The grant of Letters of Administration was made to Christopher Ruringe on 23. 5.1995 and confirmed on 28th March, 1996.
5. A Ruling was made on 28th March, 1996 by Justice Githinji (as he was then) which identified five survivors after the Court heard oral submissions. The Court ordered that the estate be distributed equally amongst the five survivors who were as follows:
(i) Hannah Wairimu Kibui
(ii) Christopher Ruringe Kibui
(iii) Paul Njoroge Kibui
(iv) Alice Nyakarura Kibui
(v) Alice Njeri Ruringe
6. The five beneficiaries were to share the following properties equally (each one fifth Share)
(i) Dagoretti/Waithaka/154
(ii) Dagoretti/Waithaka/T96
(iii) Dagoretti/Waithaka/T94
7. On 17. 6.1997 Justice Kuloba made a ruling allowing Jane Njanja Kibue to be included as a beneficiary of the estate.
8. The Court also ruled that two plots be carved out of Dagoretti/Waithaka/154.
9. Another Application was made by Veronica Njeri Kibue on 4. 9.2011 and it was allowed by Justice Njagi on 3. 12. 2011 and the Court ordered that veronica Njeri Kibue be included on the list of the beneficiaries.
10. On 20. 6.2016, Justice W. Musyoka revoked the grant of letters of administration intestate made on 23. 5.1995 and confirmed on 28. 3.1996 on 23. 9.2016.
11. Justice Musyoka ordered that Letters of Administration be issued to the following:
(i) Alice Nyakaruru Kibue
(ii) Veronica Njeri Kibue
(iii) Paul Njoroge Kibue
(iv) Alice Njeri Ruringe (Now deceased)
12. On 23. 9.016 Justice Musyoka also ordered that the Certificate of Confirmation issued on 28. 3.1996 be rectified to comply with the orders made on 17. 6.1997 and 8. 12. 2011.
13. This Court issued letters of administration to Alice Nyakarura Kibue, Veronicah Njeri Kibue and Paul Njoroge Kibue on 5. 4.2019.
14. I now direct that the three administrators apply for rectification of the Certificate of Confirmation issued on 28. 3.1996 to comply with the ordes of 28. 3.1996, 17. 6.1997 and 8. 12. 2011.
15. For avoidance of doubt, the said orders were as follows:
(i) On 28th March 1996, Justice Githinji ordered that the Estate be shared equally amongst the five beneficiaries.
(ii) Since Hannah Wambui Kibue (Deceased) has since passed away, I direct that her share to be distributed equally amongst the surviving beneficiaries
(iii) On 17. 6.1997 Justice Kuloba ordered that Jane Njanja be added as a beneficiary of the estate and further that two plots be curved out of Dagoretti/Waithaka/154
(iv) On 8. 12. 2011 Justice Njagi ordered that Veronica Njeri Kibue be included as a beneficiary.
(v) Since Jane Njanja is now deceased, her share to go to Veronicah Njeri Kibue.
(vi) I further direct that the three administrators namely Alice Nyakaruru Kibue, Veronica Njeri Kibue and Paul Njunge Kibue apply for rectification of the Certificate of Confirmation issued on 28. 3.1996 to comply with the above stated orders within 30 days of this date.
DELIVERED, SIGNED AND DATED IN OPEN COURT THIS 20THDAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2019
ASENATH ONGERI
JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA, NAIROBI.