[2024] KEHC 13450 (KLR)
The court found that since the appeal was recently filed and little had transpired, it would not be appropriate to award costs. Furthermore, as the dispute was between family members over succession, the court applied the principle that each party should bear their own costs to foster reconciliation. The court...
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- [2024] KEHC 13450 (KLR)
- Parties
- Appellant: Francis Kiarie Manyara; Respondent: Elizabeth Muthoni Manyara
- Court
- High Court
- Court Station
- High Court at Kiambu
- Jurisdiction
- Kenya
- Case Number
- Civil Appeal E143 of 2024
- Procedural Posture
- Civil Appeal / Ruling on Withdrawal and Costs
- Outcome
- Appeal withdrawn with no order as to costs; file marked as closed.
- Judges
- DO Chepkwony
- Legal Topics
- Succession Disputes, Withdrawal of Appeal, Costs in Family Matters
- Source Language
- en
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Francis Kiarie Manyara
Appellant
Elizabeth Muthoni Manyara
Respondent
Procedural Posture
Civil Appeal / Ruling on Withdrawal and Costs
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether the withdrawal of the appeal should be allowed without an order for costs.
- 2 Whether costs should be awarded in a family succession dispute upon withdrawal of appeal.
Ratio Decidendi
The court found that since the appeal was recently filed and little had transpired, it would not be appropriate to award costs. Furthermore, as the dispute was between family members over succession, the court applied the principle that each party should bear their own costs to foster reconciliation. The court relied on precedent that discourages awarding costs in family disputes where the appeal is withdrawn before substantive prosecution, unless there is evidence of bad faith or malice. Consequently, the withdrawal of the appeal was allowed with no order as to costs, and the file was marked as closed.
Court Disposition
Appeal withdrawn with no order as to costs; file marked as closed.
Orders
- The withdrawal of the Memorandum of Appeal dated 12th August, 2024 is allowed.
- There shall be no order as to costs.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
22 paragraphs
In re Estate of Manyara Kamau (Deceased) (Civil Appeal E143 of 2024) [2024] KEHC 13450 (KLR) (17 October 2024) (Ruling)
Neutral citation: [2024] KEHC 13450 (KLR)
Republic of Kenya
In the High Court at Kiambu
Civil Appeal E143 of 2024
DO Chepkwony, J
October 17, 2024
IN THE MATTER OF ESTATE OF MANYARA KAMAU (DECEASED)
Between
Francis Kiarie Manyara
Appellant
and
Elizabeth Muthoni Manyara
Respondent
Ruling
1. The Appellant moved the court through a Memorandum of Appeal dated 12th August, 2024 in which he sought to appeal against a ruling delivered by Hon. P. M. Mugure in Limuru Sucession Cause No.104 of 2017, In the Matter of the Estate of Manyara Kamau on 11th June, 2021. Additionally filed a Notice of Motion application dated 12th August, 2024 under Certificate of Urgency seeking the revocation or annulment of the Certificate of Confirmation of grant and or staying the execution of the said Certificate of Confirmation of Grant issued on 1st July, 2024.
2. In response, the Respondent filed Notice of preliminary Objection dated 16th October, 2024, in which she raised a Preliminary Objection to the appeal for being incompetent, bad in law and fatally defective for having been filed out of time without leave of court contrary to the provisions of Section 79G of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010.
3. When the matter came up on 17th October, 2024, it was brought to court’s attention that there was a Notice of Withdrawal dated 17th October, 2024, seeking to have the Memorandum of Appeal withdrawn with no orders as to costs. The Respondent’s Counsel indicated that it did not have any objection save for payment of costs since his clients were in court. The Appellant’s Counsel then indicated that the matter was coming up for Mention for purposes of compliance and therefore there was no need for the Respondents to have travelled to court. He was however willing to pay their travel expenses.
4. In rejoinder, the Respondent stated that he was not seeking the travel expenses but the costs of defending the appeal. He further indicated that the matter relates to family members who have disputed the distribution of their father’s property and therefore the court should make an order for costs.
5. Having heard both parties, this Court finds that, firstly, this is a matter whichwas recently filed in court in August, 2024 and thus not much has taken place. It would therefore not be appropriate to issue an order for costs. Secondly, the court notes that the appeal relates to family members and therefore the court is inclined to abide by the principle that each party should bear their own costs. On this finding, the court relies on the case of Akram & Another –vs- Akram & 5 Others (Family Appeal E004 of 2023) [2024] KEHC 4887 (KLR) (7 May 2024) (Ruling), where it was held:-“In my view, costs would not be appropriate in the circumstances of this matter. This is so because this is a dispute between family members. An award of costs will not promote reconciliation between parties. In any case, the appeal was withdrawn before there was substantive prosecution so that the Succession matter could be heard and determined. Withdrawal of this matter saved precious judicial time and enabled the Court to focus on determining the dispute regarding the confirmation of the grant. I am not convinced that the appeal was filed in faith or was actuated by malice or ill will.”
6. Based on the foregoing, the court proceeds to allow the withdrawal of the Memorandum of the Appeal dated 12th August, 2024 with no orders as to costs. The file be and is hereby marked as closed.It is so ordered.
RULING DELIVERED VIRTUALLY, DATED AND SIGNED AT KIAMBU THIS 17TH DAY OFOCTOBER , 2024. D. O. CHEPKWONYJUDGEIn the presence of:-Mr. Stephen Muhia counsel for AppellantMr. Masaviru counsel for RespondentCourt Assistant - Martin