[2011] KEHC 1595 (KLR)
The court found that the applicant, as next of kin of the deceased, had standing to seek exhumation and reburial. The application was supported by the clan and the current landowner, with no objection raised. The statutory requirements under section 146 of the Public Health Act were satisfied, as the applicant was a...
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- [2011] KEHC 1595 (KLR)
- Parties
- Applicant: Machua Mbugua; Respondent: The Hon Attorney General; Interested Party: Daniel Muli Kimuli
- Court
- High Court
- Court Station
- High Court at Nairobi (Milimani Law Courts)
- Jurisdiction
- Kenya
- Case Number
- ? 356 of 2010
- Procedural Posture
- Miscellaneous Application / Ruling on Exhumation Application
- Outcome
- application allowed
- Legal Topics
- Exhumation Orders, Burial Rights, Clan Land Disputes
- Source Language
- en
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Machua Mbugua
Applicant
The Hon Attorney General
Respondent
Daniel Muli Kimuli
Interested Party
Procedural Posture
Miscellaneous Application / Ruling on Exhumation Application
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether the applicant, as next of kin, is entitled to seek exhumation and reburial of the deceased's remains.
- 2 Whether the statutory requirements under section 146 of the Public Health Act for exhumation have been satisfied.
- 3 Whether the consent of the current landowner and clan members is sufficient for the order sought.
Ratio Decidendi
The court found that the applicant, as next of kin of the deceased, had standing to seek exhumation and reburial. The application was supported by the clan and the current landowner, with no objection raised. The statutory requirements under section 146 of the Public Health Act were satisfied, as the applicant was a legal representative and the interested party consented. There was no opposition from the respondent. The court therefore allowed the application, directing the relevant Minister or permitting authority to issue the required permit for exhumation and reburial as soon as possible.
Court Disposition
application allowed
Orders
- The relevant Minister or permitting authority may issue the required permit for exhumation and reburial of the deceased's remains as soon as possible.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
31 paragraphs
REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT NAIROBI
MISCNO. 356 OF 2010
MACHUA MBUGUA.…………….……………………………APPLICANT
VERSUS
THE HON ATTORNEY GENERAL …………………………… RESPONDENT
AND
DANIEL MULI KIMULI…………………………………… INTERESTED PARTY
RULING
Coram:Mwera J.
Mutinda for Applicant
No appearance for Respondent
Court clerk Njoroge
The motion herein dated 24. 6.10 was brought under section 146 of the Public Health Act (Cap 242) and section 3A Civil Procedure Act, for an order
i)that the body of Machua wa Muchugia be exhumed from plot No. DAGORETTI/MUTU-INI 840 and be buried on plot No. DAGORETTI/MUTU-INI 725.
The reasons advanced were that the applicant was the grandson of the deceased Machua wa Muchugia who died in 1968 and was buried on Plot No. 840. It was the deceased property but after he died that plot was inherited by one of his sons. Later the interested party herein, Daniel Muli Kimuli, bought that plot. He does not belong to the clan of the deceased. The clan now wishes to exhume the deceased’s body and rebury it on its land Plot LR 725. This was a unanimous clan decision which it discussed with the interested party. He has no objection – hence this application.
Machua Mbugua, the grandson of the deceased and the applicant herein, swore a supporting affidavit more or less restating what is in the grounds. The deceased died on 10. 1.68 and was on 14. 1.68 buried on Plot No. 840. This was his property. But following his death one son inherited it. It later changed hands and now it is the property of the interested party.
On 18. 04. 10 the Muchugia clan resolved that they wanted the deceased’s remains exhumed and reburied on Plot No. LR 725. The interested party had no objection. Five (5) members of the Muchugia clan filed a consent for the order of exhumation. There were no copies of title for plots No. 840 or 725.
On or about 28. 7.10 the interested party, Daniel Kimuli was served with this motion. He acknowledged service but did not file any papers in opposition.
When the cause was listed for hearing the Hon the AG was served. Miss Maina, a state counsel appeared and sought time to take instructions. On two occasions for mention Miss Maina did not appear before court and so it decided to determine the motion.
Section 146 cited herein says:
“146. Subject to the provisions of section 147, it shall not be lawful to exhume any body or the remains of any body which may have been interred in any authorised cemetery or in any other cemetery, burial ground or other place without a permit granted in a manner hereinafter provided.
(2) Such permit shall be granted to the legal personal representative or next of kin of the person buried, or to his or their duly authorized agent.
(3) Such permit may be granted by the Minister in respect of any body or the remains of any body interred in any cemetery or burial ground or any other place.”
Then subsection 4, with a proviso thereto, goes on to state that the permitting authority may append conditions to the permit as it deems fit, which ought to be complied with. And that such permit shall not be necessary where a magistrate orders exhumation of a body when holding an inquiry in the cause of death of any person.
The applicant, kin of the deceased, has sworn an affidavit in that regard and stated that the deceased was buried on plot 840 which later became the property of the interested party. That party did not object to the wishes of the clan to exhume the remains of the deceased for reburial on the clan land – plot LR 725.
From the foregoing this application succeeds. The relevant Minister and/or also called the permitting authority, may issue the required permit as soon as possible to facilitate the desired exercise by the kin of the deceased herein.
Orders accordingly.
Delivered on 6. 7.11
J. W. MWERA
JUDGE