[2019] KEHC 9463 (KLR)
The court held that it is legally untenable to charge an accused with both aiding and abetting the commission of a crime and, at the same time, failing to report the commission of the same crime. Such charges are mutually exclusive and cannot stand together unless one is framed in the alternative. The charge sheet...
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- [2019] KEHC 9463 (KLR)
- Parties
- Respondent: Republic; Appellant: Esther Rioba Makori
- Court
- High Court
- Court Station
- High Court at Migori
- Jurisdiction
- Kenya
- Case Number
- Criminal Revision 4 of 2019
- Procedural Posture
- Criminal Revision / Ruling on Review of Sentence and Conviction
- Outcome
- conviction quashed and sentence set aside
- Judges
- AC Mrima
- Legal Topics
- Female Genital Mutilation, Defective Charge Sheet, Plea of Guilty, Sentencing Review
- Source Language
- en
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Republic
Respondent
Esther Rioba Makori
Appellant
Procedural Posture
Criminal Revision / Ruling on Review of Sentence and Conviction
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether an accused can be charged with both aiding and abetting a crime and failing to report the same crime.
- 2 Whether the charge sheet was incurably defective for containing both counts without alternatives.
- 3 Whether the proceedings, conviction, and sentence based on such a charge sheet are a nullity.
Ratio Decidendi
The court held that it is legally untenable to charge an accused with both aiding and abetting the commission of a crime and, at the same time, failing to report the commission of the same crime. Such charges are mutually exclusive and cannot stand together unless one is framed in the alternative. The charge sheet in this case was therefore incurably defective. As a result, all proceedings based on the defective charge sheet, including the plea, conviction, and sentence, were declared a nullity and set aside. The accused was ordered to be released forthwith, and any fine paid was to be refunded.
Court Disposition
conviction quashed and sentence set aside
Orders
- Proceedings, conviction, and sentence are set aside as a nullity.
- The charge sheet is dismissed for being fatally defective.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
26 paragraphs
REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MIGORI
CRIMINAL REVISION NO. 4 OF 2019
REPUBLIC.....................................................................PROSECUTOR
-VERSUS-
ESTHER RIOBA MAKORI..................................................ACCUSED
RULING ON REVIEW
1. The Learned Resident Magistrate at Kehancha Law Courts forwarded this matter to this Court requesting for review of the orders on sentencing as the court had inadvertently not sentenced the accused person on the second count.
2. The accused, Esther Rioba Makori,was charged with two counts under the Prohibition of Female Genital Mutilation No. 32 of 2011(hereinafter referred to as‘the Act’). The charges were tailored as follows: -
Count 1: Aiding and Abetting Female Genital Mutilation contrary to Section 20 (a) as read with Section 29 of the Prohibition of Female Genital Mutilation No. 32 of 2011.
On the 21st November 2018 in Kuria West Sub-County within Migori County, aided the commission of Female Genital Mutilation on her daughter namely SNM a girl aged 16 years.
Count 2: Failing to Report Commission of Female Genital Mutilation Contrary to Section 24 as read with Section 29 of the Prohibition of Female Genital Mutilation No. 32 of 2011.
On the 21st November, 2018 in Kuria West Sub County within Migori County, was found having not reported the Commission of Female Genital Mutilation on her daughter namely SNM a girl aged 16 years.
3. The accused pleaded guilty to both counts and the court rightly entered pleas of guilty. Facts were immediately read out and the accused person admitted them. She was subsequently convicted on her own plea of guilty and tendered mitigations. The sentence followed a week later where the court sentenced the accused person to pay a fine of Kshs. 200,000/= and in default to serve one year in prison.
4. It is that sentence which prompted this review. The accused person faced two counts under the Act. On the first count she was charged with aiding and abetting her daughter to undergo genital mutilation on 21/11/2018. On the second count, the accused person was charged with failing to report that her daughter had undergone genital mutilation on the same 21/11/2018.
5. I have carefully considered the twin charges and I am of the considered position that an accused person cannot be rightly charged with such both counts. That is because one cannot be accused of aiding and abetting the commission of a crime and at the same time be charged with failing to report the commission of the very crime he/she is accused of taking part in. If the investigator was intent on preferring both charges, then at least one of them must have been in the alternative.
6. The Charge Sheet was therefore incurably defective and the plea court ought to have declined to admit it. I therefore find that proceedings on the plea up to the sentence were a nullity. The same are hereby set-aside. It then follows that the convictions are quashed and the sentence set-aside accordingly. The Charge Sheet is equally dismissed for being fatally defective.
7. The upshot is that the accused person, Esther Rioba Makori,shall forthwith be released from prison unless otherwise lawfully held and in the event the fine was paid, the same shall be refunded to the depositor forthwith.
8. Those are the orders of this Court.
DELIVERED, DATEDandSIGNED at MIGORI this 08th day of March 2019.
A. C. MRIMA
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in open Court and in the presence of: -
Esther Rioba Makori the Accused person.
Mr. Kimanthi, Learned Senior Principal Prosecution Counsel instructed by the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the State.
Evelyne Nyauke– Court Assistant.