[2016] KEHC 5333 (KLR)
The court found that, despite the grave charge of murder and the absence of the victim's family's views in the pre-bail report, the prosecution failed to present any compelling reasons to deny the accused bail. The pre-bail report was favourable, indicating the accused had a fixed abode, a conducive home...
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- [2016] KEHC 5333 (KLR)
- Parties
- Respondent: Republic; Applicant: Josiah Keitany Chelimo
- Court
- High Court
- Court Station
- High Court at Eldoret
- Jurisdiction
- Kenya
- Case Number
- Criminal Case 24 of 2015
- Procedural Posture
- Criminal Case / Bail Application Pending Trial
- Outcome
- bail_granted_with_conditions
- Judges
- K Kimondo
- Legal Topics
- Bail Pending Trial, Compelling Reasons, Murder Charge, Victims Rights
- Source Language
- en
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Republic
Respondent
Josiah Keitany Chelimo
Applicant
Procedural Posture
Criminal Case / Bail Application Pending Trial
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether the accused is entitled to bail pending trial for a charge of murder under Article 49(1)(h) of the Constitution.
- 2 Whether there are compelling reasons to deny the accused bail.
- 3 Whether the absence of the victim's family's views in the pre-bail report is fatal to the bail application.
Ratio Decidendi
The court found that, despite the grave charge of murder and the absence of the victim's family's views in the pre-bail report, the prosecution failed to present any compelling reasons to deny the accused bail. The pre-bail report was favourable, indicating the accused had a fixed abode, a conducive home environment, and no objection from the local administration. The court noted that the accused and deceased were cousins and that there was no hostility at the locus in quo. The court exercised its discretion to grant bail, subject to strict conditions to ensure the accused's attendance at trial and to prevent interference with witnesses or evidence. The absence of the victim's family's...
Court Disposition
bail_granted_with_conditions
Orders
- The accused shall be released upon execution of a bond in the sum of Kshs 500,000 together with one surety of a similar amount.
- The surety shall be examined and approved by the Deputy Registrar of the Court.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
24 paragraphs
REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT ELDORET
CRIMINAL CASE NO. 24 OF 2015
REPUBLIC…………………………………….……………PROSECUTOR
VERSUS
JOSIAH KEITANY CHELIMO..…….…………………….……..ACCUSED
RULING
The accused prays to be admitted to bail pending trial. On 23rd November 2015, the court directed that a pre-bail report be furnished by the Probation Service. The report was filed on 14th December 2015.
The State opposes the application. The learned Prosecution Counsel submitted that the report does not capture the views of the victim’s family. On 23rd March 2016, I called for a further report covering those aspects. It was not forthcoming. At the next hearing on 19th April 2016, and in the interests of justice, I asked both counsel to make submissions on the application for bail. The Republic maintained its earlier position. Learned counsel for the accused submitted that the report was favourable to the accused; and, that there were no compelling reasons to deny the accused bail.
I have considered the pre-bail report and the rival submissions. The accused faces a grave charge of murder; but he is still deemed to be innocent until proved guilty. The sentence for murder is death. Under Article 49 (1) (h) of the Constitution, he is entitled to bail pending trial unless there are compelling reasons. See Republic v Daniel Musyoka Muasya and others, Mombasa, High Court Criminal Case 42 of 2009 [2010] eKLR, Republic v Elias Kipkemoi, Eldoret High Court Criminal Case 42 of 2014 (unreported), Republic v John Mwenya Chumbe, Eldoret, High Court Criminal Case 47 of 2014 (unreported), Republic v Evans Kiprono Yegon, Kericho, High Court Criminal Cases 38 & 40 of 2014 [2015] eKLR, Republic v Prosper Mutua Nzilani, Nairobi, High Court Criminal Case 15 of 2013 [2014] eKLR,Republic v Caleb Oluoch Were & 2 others, Eldoret High Court Criminal Case 36 of 2008 [2011] eKLR, Republic v Ali Mcheni Ali Mombasa High Court Criminal Case 7 of 2011 [2011] eKLR.
The overarching objective of bail is to ensure the accused attends his trial. Relevant matters to be considered by the court include the nature of the charge; the likely sentence; previous criminal records, the possibility of interference with witnesses; the temptation to abscond; and, the safety of the accused.
The accused is charged for the unlawful killing of Isaac Kipyekomen Chirchir. I cannot prejudge the matter. But I note that the Republic has not filed any replying affidavit contesting the release of the accused; or, showing any compelling ground for denial of bail. In the opinion of the Probation Service the accused has a fixed abode; the home environment is conducive; and, the local administration has no objection to his release.
True, the report is silent on the views of the family of the victim. The Victims Protection Act 2014 requires the views of victim’s family to be taken into account. But the social report states that “the accused and deceased are cousins”. It can only mean that the community members interviewed by the probation officer were speaking about the same family and home environment. Like I have stated, the social report states there is no hostility at the locus in quo. I will accordingly exercise my discretion in favour of the accused.
I am however minded to grant bail under strict conditions to ensure that the accused attends to his trial; and, that he does not interfere with witnesses or evidence. The accused shall be released upon execution of a bond in the sum of Kshs 500,000 together with one surety of a similar amount. The surety shall be examined and approved by the Deputy Registrar of this Court. As a condition for bail, the accused shall not have any direct or indirect contact with the eleven witnesses named on the reverse of the information charging him with murder. As a further condition, the accused shall, upon his release on bail, report once every month to the investigating officer of this case until the conclusion of the trial or further orders of this Court.
In default of any of the conditions above, the bond shall stand cancelled and the surety called to account.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNEDandDELIVEREDatELDORETthis 12th day of May 2016.
GEORGE KANYI KIMONDO
JUDGE
Ruling read at in open court in the presence of:-
Accused.
Mr. Tarus for the accused.
Ms. B. Oduor for the Republic.
Mr. J. Kemboi, Court Clerk.