[2012] KEHC 3309 (KLR)
The court held that the substitution of Emily Wanjiru Njoroge for her deceased husband, William Njoroge, was proper and should be allowed to ensure representation of the deceased's interest in the estate. However, the prayer to dismiss the pending summons for revocation of grant was declined, as the issues raised...
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- [2012] KEHC 3309 (KLR)
- Parties
- Applicant: Walter Mbuthia; Applicant: Michael Kuria; Applicant: Emily Wanjiru; Applicant: Leah Wanjiku Njenga; Respondent: Jeniffer Wambui
- Court
- High Court
- Court Station
- High Court at Nairobi (Milimani Law Courts)
- Jurisdiction
- Kenya
- Case Number
- Succession Cause 453 of 2001
- Procedural Posture
- Succession Cause / Ruling on Substitution and Dismissal Application
- Outcome
- Application for substitution allowed; application for dismissal of summons declined; parties to bear own costs.
- Judges
- I Lenaola
- Legal Topics
- Succession, Grant Revocation, Administrator Substitution, Estate Distribution
- Source Language
- en
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Walter Mbuthia
Applicant
Michael Kuria
Applicant
Emily Wanjiru
Applicant
Leah Wanjiku Njenga
Applicant
Jeniffer Wambui
Respondent
Procedural Posture
Succession Cause / Ruling on Substitution and Dismissal Application
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether the application for substitution of the deceased beneficiary by his widow should be allowed.
- 2 Whether the summons for revocation of grant should be dismissed for want of prosecution.
- 3 How the distribution of the disputed land parcel should be finalized.
Ratio Decidendi
The court held that the substitution of Emily Wanjiru Njoroge for her deceased husband, William Njoroge, was proper and should be allowed to ensure representation of the deceased's interest in the estate. However, the prayer to dismiss the pending summons for revocation of grant was declined, as the issues raised regarding the distribution of the estate, particularly the disputed land parcel, were substantive and required determination on their merits. The court emphasized the need for the parties to resolve the distribution expeditiously and ordered that the pending summons be set down for hearing. Each party was ordered to bear its own costs.
Court Disposition
Application for substitution allowed; application for dismissal of summons declined; parties to bear own costs.
Orders
- Emily Wanjiru Njoroge shall substitute her deceased husband, William Njoroge, as a beneficiary.
- The prayer for dismissal of the summons dated 15th February 2007 is declined.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
35 paragraphs
REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT AT NAIROBI
MILIMANI LAW COURTS
Succession Cause 453 of 2001
IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF FRANCIS MUCHIRU MBUTHIA (DECEASED)
WALTER MBUTHIA…………………………....………. 1ST OBJECTOR/APPLICANT
MICHAEL KURIA………………………………..………2ND OBJECTOR/APPLICANT
EMILY WANJIRU…………………..…………....………3RD OBJECTOR/APPLICANT
LEAH WANJIKU NJENGA………….......…..…………..4TH OBJECTOR/APPLICANT
VERSUS
JENIFFER WAMBUI………….……………………...…………….……..RESPONDENT
R U L I N G
1. This Succession Cause has been pending unresolved for ten (10) years because the Co-Administrators, Walter Mbuthia and Jeniffer Wambui cannot agree on the distribution of Land parcel No.Kabete/Lower Kabete/2065. Although the grant issued to them was confirmed on 5th February 2007, Jeniffer Wambui, by her Summons dated 15th February 2007, sought revocation of the grant for the single reason that when Rawal J. confirmed the same, she did so allegedly without taking into account the way the beneficiaries were occupying the Land and without regard to what they had previously agreed. That Summons is pending before this Court and is undetermined.
2. On 21st March 2011, Walter Mbuthia, without waiting for the prior Application by his sister and co-Administrator to be determined, filed a Summons under Section 47 of the Law of Succession Act seeking that the Summons dated 15th February 2007, “be dismissed for Want of Prosecution” and that Emily Wanjiru Njoroge be allowed to substitute her deceased husband, William Njoroge, brother of Walter Mbuthia and Jeniffer Wambui.
3. I have read the Supporting Affidavit sworn by Mbuthia on 17th March 2011 and the Replying Affidavit sworn on 22nd June 2011 by Jeniffer Wambui. Each blames the other for delay in finalizing the process of distribution but those reasons are not important to restate because there is clearly bad blood between the siblings and neither has addressed the more fundamental issue at hand; By what means should the distribution of parcel No.Kabete/Lower Kabete/2065 be finalized?
4. According to Walter Mbuthia, the distribution as ordered by Rawal, J. was proper and should be implemented. Jeniffer on the other hand, is of the view that the learned Judge made certain errors and ignored the Report of the Kiambu District Land Surveyor which had apportioned the Land in a certain manner. Further, that the learned Judge ignored the fact that Jeniffer Wambui had built a house on portion C which had instead been allocated to Michael Kuria.
5. None of the issues raised by Mbuthia and Jeniffer are idle and need to be resolved quickly and on the merits. However, the issue of the substitution of William Njoroge by his wife, Emily Wanjiru Njoroge is not an issue.
6. In the event, I will therefore order as follows;
i)The Application by Walther Mbuthia dated 17th March 2011 is allowed to the extent that Emily Wanjiru Njoroge shall substitute her deceased husband, William Njoroge. The Prayer for dismissal of the Summons dated 15th February 2007 is however declined.
ii)The Summons dated 15th February 2007 is to be listed for hearing on a date to be agreed between the parties and it should be concluded expeditiously.
iii)Each party to bear its costs thereof.
7. Orders accordingly.
DATED, DELIVERED AND SIGNED AT NAIROBI THIS 20TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2012.
20/1/2012
CORAM:
ISAAC LENAOLA – JUDGE
Miron – Court Clerk
Applicant present
Respondent present
ORDER
Ruling duly read.
FURTHER ORDER
Mention on 24/1/2012 before G.B.M. Kariuki for taking of dates in respect of the Application dated 15th February 2007.
ISAACLENAOLA
JUDGE