[2021] KECA 989 (KLR)
The court found that, considering the advanced age of most of the appellants and the potential negative impact on their health from continued delay, there were sufficient grounds to certify the Notice of Motion dated 28th October, 2020 as urgent. The court exercised its discretion under Rule 47 of the Court of...
Source-derived case information.
- Citation
- [2021] KECA 989 (KLR)
- Parties
- Appellant: Winnie Mukolwe (sued as the administrator of the estate of David Nyambu Jonathan Kituri - deceased); Appellant: Julia Kirira (sued as the administrator of the estate of David Nyambu Jonathan Kituri – deceased); Appellant: Hope Mutua (sued as the administrator of the estate of David Nyambu Jonathan Kituri - deceased); Appellant: Clara Kitao; Appellant: Delina Nasibu; Appellant: Flora Nyange; Appellant: Emily Mwaro; Appellant: Irene Kituri; Appellant: Damaris Kituri; Appellant: Henry Kituri; Appellant: Aswani Nzee; Appellant: Mercy Nzee; Appellant: Cicilia Nzee; Respondent: Lucy Wanjiku Muchai t/a Bellavin Investments
- Court
- Court of Appeal
- Court Station
- Court of Appeal at Nairobi
- Jurisdiction
- Kenya
- Case Number
- Civil Appeal E335 of 2020
- Procedural Posture
- Stay Application / Application for Certification of Urgency in Stay of Execution Pending Appeal
- Outcome
- Notice of Motion certified as urgent; to be given a priority hearing date.
- Judges
- FI Koome
- Legal Topics
- Stay of Execution, Certification of Urgency, Appeals Process, Environment and Land Court Orders
- Source Language
- en
Source-derived case record
Summary, issues, holding and outcome
More case intelligence is available
Unlock the full research layer for this judgment.
Parties
Winnie Mukolwe (sued as the administrator of the estate of David Nyambu Jonathan Kituri - deceased)
Appellant
Julia Kirira (sued as the administrator of the estate of David Nyambu Jonathan Kituri – deceased)
Appellant
Hope Mutua (sued as the administrator of the estate of David Nyambu Jonathan Kituri - deceased)
Appellant
Clara Kitao
Appellant
Delina Nasibu
Appellant
Flora Nyange
Appellant
Emily Mwaro
Appellant
Irene Kituri
Appellant
Damaris Kituri
Appellant
Henry Kituri
Appellant
Aswani Nzee
Appellant
Mercy Nzee
Appellant
Cicilia Nzee
Appellant
Lucy Wanjiku Muchai t/a Bellavin Investments
Respondent
Procedural Posture
Stay Application / Application for Certification of Urgency in Stay of Execution Pending Appeal
Legal Issues
- 1 Whether the Notice of Motion dated 28th October, 2020 should be certified as urgent.
- 2 Whether the age and health of the appellants justify prioritizing the hearing of the application for stay of execution.
Ratio Decidendi
The court found that, considering the advanced age of most of the appellants and the potential negative impact on their health from continued delay, there were sufficient grounds to certify the Notice of Motion dated 28th October, 2020 as urgent. The court exercised its discretion under Rule 47 of the Court of Appeal Rules to prioritize the hearing of the application for stay of execution. The decision was based on the need to prevent possible prejudice to the appellants due to their age and health conditions, outweighing the respondent's objections to urgency.
Court Disposition
Notice of Motion certified as urgent; to be given a priority hearing date.
Orders
- The Notice of Motion dated 28th October, 2020 is certified as urgent.
- The application is to be given a priority hearing date.
Full Case Text
Judgment text and source record
40 paragraphs
IN TH COURT OF APPEAL
AT NAIROBI
(CORAM: KOOME, J.A (IN CHAMBERS)
CIVIL APPEAL (APPLICATION) NO. E335 OF 2020
BETWEEN
WINNIE MUKOLWE (sued as the administrator of the estate of
DAVID NYAMBU JONATHAN KITURI -
deceased)...............................................1ST APPELLANT/APPLICANT
JULIA KIRIRA (sued as the administrator of the estate of
DAVID NYAMBU JONATHAN KITURI –
deceased).............................................2ND APPELLANT/APPLICANT
HOPE MUTUA (sued as the administrator of the estate of
DAVID NYAMBU JONATHAN KITURI
deceased)............................................3RD APPELLANT/APPLICANT
CLARA KITAO................................4TH APPELLANT/APPLICANT
DELINA NASIBU............................5TH APPELLANT/APPLICANT
FLORA NYANGE...........................6THAPPELLANT/APPLICANT
EMILY MWARO.............................7TH APPELLANT/APPLICANT
IRENE KITURI...............................8TH APPELALNT/APPLICANT
DAMARIS KITURI....................... 9THAPPELLANT/APPLICANT
HENRY KITURI............................10TH APPELLANT/APPLICANT
ASWANI NZEE...............................11TH APPELLANT/APPLICANT
MERCY NZEE...............................12TH APPELLANT/APPLICANT
CICILIA NZEE..............................13TH APPELLANT/APPLICANT
AND
LUCY WANJIKU MUCHAI t/a
BELLAVIN INVESTMENTS........................................RESPONDENT
(Being an application for stay of execution of the order by the Environment
and Land Court of Kenya (Gacheru, J.) dated 15th October, 2020in ELC CASE No. 175 OF 2019)
*******************
RULING
On 4th November, 2020 I declined to certify the Notice of Motion dated 28th October, 2020 as urgent. Counsel for the applicant requested for an inter partes hearing on the issue of urgency as provided under Rule 47 of the Court of Appeal Rules. Upon considering the matters raised in the letter by counsel for the applicant dated 12th November, 2020, his submissions on the issue of urgency as well as the submissions by counsel for the respondents who are opposed to the matter being certified as urgent. I am persuaded that most of the appellants are advanced in age and a continued delay in finalizing the issues raised therein may impact on their health negatively. I accordingly certify the Notice of Motion dated 28th October, 2020 as urgent to be given a priority hearing date
Dated and delivered at Nairobi this 5thof February, 2021.
M. K. KOOME
...................................
JUDGE OF APPEAL
I certify that this is a true
copy of the original.
Signed
DEPUTY REGISTRAR