Niehaus and Another v ABSA Bank Ltd and Another (NCT/69/2009/138(l)(P)) [2009] ZANCT 10 (5 September 2009)
- Citation
- [2009] ZANCT 10
- Status
- Order
- Jurisdiction
- South Africa
- Court
- National Consumer Tribunal
- Panel
- EM Mphahlele
- Case number
- NCT/69/2009/138(l)(P)
More details
- Court
- National Consumer Tribunal
- Panel
- EM Mphahlele
- Case number
- NCT/69/2009/138(l)(P)
On this page
Professional case brief
Research organized from the available case record
01
Holding and result
The Tribunal is satisfied that the parties have entered into valid debt rearrangement agreements facilitated by a debt counsellor in terms of section 86(7) of the National Credit Act. The agreements specify amended terms for the applicants' credit agreements with ABSA Bank Limited and Standard Bank of South Africa Limited, including reduced and fixed interest rates, capitalization of arrears, reduced monthly instalments, and extended repayment periods. The Tribunal confirms these arrangements as a consent order under section 138(1) of the National Credit Act. The parties are warned that non-compliance with the order constitutes an offence under section 160(1) of the Act.
Court disposition
Consent order granted confirming the amended credit agreements between the parties.
Orders
- The credit agreement with ABSA Bank Limited for vehicle finance account number 68045377 is amended: interest rate reduced to 17%, arrears of R1569.33 capitalized, monthly instalment reduced to R820.00, instalments increased to 24.
- The mortgage loan account with ABSA Bank Limited, account number 805322693, is amended: interest rate fixed at 12.9%, arrears of R2079.21 capitalized, monthly instalment reduced to R2783.30, instalments increased to 98.
- The Blue Bean Credit Card account with Standard Bank of South Africa Limited, account number 5120570201086671, is amended: interest rate reduced to 18.5%, arrears of R2327.74 capitalized, monthly instalment reduced to R700.00 for 23 months, R722.98 for 1 month, R864.79 for 24 months, and R644 for 1 month, instalments increased to 46.
- The agreements reached between the parties are confirmed as a consent order in terms of section 138(1) of the National Credit Act.
- Failure to comply with the consent order constitutes an offence under section 160(1) of the National Credit Act.
02
Material facts
Parties
Charles Johannes Niehaus
ApplicantJacoba Johanna Niehaus
ApplicantABSA Bank Limited
RespondentStandard Bank of South Africa Limited
RespondentAmounts and remedies
- Vehicle Finance Arrears Capitalized: ZAR 1,569.33
- Vehicle Finance New Monthly Instalment: ZAR 820
- Vehicle Finance Instalments Increased: ZAR 24
- Mortgage Loan Arrears Capitalized: ZAR 2,079.21
- Mortgage Loan New Monthly Instalment: ZAR 2,783.3
- Mortgage Loan Instalments Increased: ZAR 98
- Credit Card Arrears Capitalized: ZAR 2,327.74
- Credit Card New Monthly Instalment (first 23 Months): ZAR 700
- Credit Card New Monthly Instalment (1 Month): ZAR 722.98
- Credit Card New Monthly Instalment (next 24 Months): ZAR 864.79
- Credit Card New Monthly Instalment (final 1 Month): ZAR 644
- Credit Card Instalments Increased: ZAR 46
03
Procedural history
Posture
Consent Order Application / Final Order
04
Questions and positions
Legal issues
- 01
Whether the parties have reached a valid debt rearrangement agreement under section 86(7) of the National Credit Act.
- 02
Whether the Tribunal should confirm the agreements as a consent order under section 138(1) of the National Credit Act.
- 03
What are the operative terms for the amended credit agreements regarding interest rates, arrears, instalments, and duration.
Party arguments
- Applicant
- The applicants, Charles Johannes Niehaus and Jacoba Johanna Niehaus, seek confirmation of debt rearrangement agreements negotiated with ABSA Bank Limited and Standard Bank of South Africa Limited. They submit that the agreements comply with section 86(7) of the National Credit Act and request the Tribunal to confirm the arrangements as a consent order, amending the terms of their credit agreements to facilitate repayment.
- Respondent
- ABSA Bank Limited and Standard Bank of South Africa Limited consent to the proposed amendments to the credit agreements, including reductions and fixation of interest rates, capitalization of arrears, and extension of repayment periods. The respondents agree that the arrangements are in accordance with the National Credit Act and support the confirmation of the consent order.
05
Court’s reasoning
Legal principles
- 01
National Credit Act (No. 34 of 2005)
A debt rearrangement agreement negotiated under section 86(7) of the National Credit Act may be confirmed as a consent order by the Tribunal under section 138(1).
- 02
National Credit Act (No. 34 of 2005)
Failure to comply with a consent order constitutes an offence under section 160(1) of the National Credit Act.
06
Ratio, limits and disposition
Ratio decidendi
The Tribunal is satisfied that the parties have entered into valid debt rearrangement agreements facilitated by a debt counsellor in terms of section 86(7) of the National Credit Act. The agreements specify amended terms for the applicants' credit agreements with ABSA Bank Limited and Standard Bank of South Africa Limited, including reduced and fixed interest rates, capitalization of arrears, reduced monthly instalments, and extended repayment periods. The Tribunal confirms these arrangements as a consent order under section 138(1) of the National Credit Act. The parties are warned that non-compliance with the order constitutes an offence under section 160(1) of the Act.
Obiter and limits
- The Tribunal emphasizes the importance of compliance with consent orders issued under the National Credit Act.
- Parties should note that the effective dates for the amended agreements are specified and must be adhered to.
Court disposition
Consent order granted confirming the amended credit agreements between the parties.
- The credit agreement with ABSA Bank Limited for vehicle finance account number 68045377 is amended: interest rate reduced to 17%, arrears of R1569.33 capitalized, monthly instalment reduced to R820.00, instalments increased to 24.
- The mortgage loan account with ABSA Bank Limited, account number 805322693, is amended: interest rate fixed at 12.9%, arrears of R2079.21 capitalized, monthly instalment reduced to R2783.30, instalments increased to 98.
- The Blue Bean Credit Card account with Standard Bank of South Africa Limited, account number 5120570201086671, is amended: interest rate reduced to 18.5%, arrears of R2327.74 capitalized, monthly instalment reduced to R700.00 for 23 months, R722.98 for 1 month, R864.79 for 24 months, and R644 for 1 month, instalments increased to 46.
- The agreements reached between the parties are confirmed as a consent order in terms of section 138(1) of the National Credit Act.
- Failure to comply with the consent order constitutes an offence under section 160(1) of the National Credit Act.
Source and reliance status
National Consumer Tribunal
This page organises the available record for research. Confirm quotations, current status, and subsequent treatment against the official source before relying on the case.
Judgment reading view
Judgment text
The complete available source text.
National Consumer Tribunal
Order
IN THE NATIONAL CONSUMER TRIBUNAL,
HELD
AT CENTURION
Case No: NCT/69/2009/138(l)(P)
Date:05/09/2009
In the matter between
CHARLES
JOHANNES NIEHAUS
And
JACOBA
JOHANNA NIEHAUS...............................................................................Applicants
ABSA
BANK LIMITED............................................................................................. Respondent
STANDARD
BANK OF SOUTH AFRICA...............................................................Respondent
LIMITED
CONSENT
ORDER
The Tribunal, being satisfied that the Applicant and the Respondents are parties to a debt rearrangement facilitated by a debt counsellor
under section 86 (7) of the National Credit Act, hereby orders, by consent of the parties:
RE:
ABSA BANK LIMITED
(1) That the credit agreement between Charles Johannes and Jacoba Johanna Niehaus in respect of a vehicle finance account number 68045377, is hereby amended;
(2) The original terms and conditions remain in full force and effect;
(3) That the variable interest rate of 19 percent be reduced to and fixed at 17.00 percent;
(4) That the arrear amount of R1569.33 be capitalized and included in the principal debt outstanding;
(5) That the monthly instalment be reduced from R1569.33 to R820.00;
(6) That the number of instalments remaining to be paid until the conclusion of the agreement be increased from 10 to 24; and
(7) That the effective date of this order is 05 August 2009.
(1) That the credit agreement between Charles Johannes and Jacoba Johanna Niehaus and ABSABank Limted in respect of a Mortgage Loan Account, account number 805322693, is herebyamended;
(2) The original terms and conditions remain in full force and effect;
(3) That the variable interest rate of 12.9 percent be fixed at 12.9 percent;
(4) That the arrear amount of R2079.21 be capitalized and included in the principal debt Outstanding;
(5) That the monthly instalment be reduced from R3079.21 to R2783.30;
(6) That the number of instalments remaining to be paid until the conclusion of the agreement be increased from 69 to 98; and
RE:
STANDARD BANK OF SOUTH AFRICA LIMITED
1) That the agreement between Charles Johannes and Jacoba Johanna Niehaus and Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd in respect of a Blue Bean Credit Card Account, account number 5120570201086671, is hereby amended;
2)The original terms and conditions remain in full force and effect;
3) That the variable interest rate of 20.50 percent be reduced and be fixed at 18.5 percent;
4) That the arrear amount of R2327.74 be capitalized and included in the principal debt outstanding;
5) That the monthly instalment be reduced from R1198.39 to R700.00 for 23 months, R722.98 for 1 month, R864.79 for 24 months and R644 for 1 month;
6) That the number of instalments remaining to be paid until the conclusion of the agreement be increased from 20 to 46; and
7) That the effective date of this order is 05 August 2009.
ORDER
1) The agreements reached between the parties are hereby confirmed as a consent order in terms of section (138)(1) of the National Credit Act (No. 34 of 2005).
2) The Parties are warned that failure to comply with the consent order constitutes an offence in terms of section 160(1) of the National Credit Act (No. 34 of 2005).
DATED ON THIS 05 DAY OF AUGUST 2009.
EM
MPHAHLELE
PRESIDING
MEMBER
Case-aware research
Ask AI about this case
The judgment and available research above are public. New questions open in a separate private conversation grounded in this case.