The appeal against Sauer’s murder conviction failed, but the Supreme Court reduced her sentence from ten years to five years after finding the original term too severe.
S v Cele (497/1984) [1985] ZASCA 84 (16 September 1985)
Court
Supreme Court of Appeal
Case number
497/1984
Judges
Jansen, Van Heerden, Grosskopf
The court held that the trial judge was correct in admitting only the relevant portions of the documents and excluding irrelevant and potentially prejudicial material from the assessors. The appellant's explanation of accidental discharge was rejected as implausible, given the position of the firearm and the evidence that the appellant cocked the pistol, indicating intent to fire. The trial court's finding that there were no extenuating circumstances was upheld, and the appeal against conviction and sentence was dismissed.