Deacon Trust and Another v Ngwenya (LCC114/2008) [2025] ZALCC 21 (29 May 2025)
Court
Land Claims Court
Case number
LCC114/2008
Judge
SJ Cowen
The Land Claims Court ordered compliance with an earlier land-vacation order, but declined civil contempt relief, finding wilfulness made out yet mala fides not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
Director General: Department of Employment and Labour and Another v Green Secure Group (P76/2018) [2019] ZALCPE 16; (2020) 41 ILJ 189 (LC) (23 August 2019)
Court
Labour Court Port Elizabeth
Case number
P76/2018
Judge
Van Niekerk
The Labour Court held it retained jurisdiction over a compliance-order application that was pending when section 77A(a) of the BCEA was repealed.
National Bargaining Council for the Clothing Manufacturing Industry (Cape) v J n' B Sportswear CC and Another (C489/2010) [2011] ZALCCT 4; [2011] 8 BLLR 756 (LC) (3 March 2011)
Court
Labour Court Cape Town
Case number
C489/2010
Judge
Steenkamp
The arbitrator's findings on all three points in limine were unsustainable in law. The doctrine of estoppel requires proof of misrepresentation, reliance, and prejudice, none of which were established by the employer. Compliance certificates issued by the Bargaining Council are based on information provided by the employer and do not preclude the Council from enforcing its statutory duties if subsequent investigation reveals non-compliance. The arbitrator erred in holding that the Council must withdraw a compliance certificate before instituting a claim, as the certificate is merely a prima f…
Bargaining Council of Hairdressing and Cosmetology Trade (Pretoria) v Smit t/a Hair Mistique (J 4636/01) [2002] ZALC 2; [2002] 3 BLLR 218 (LC); (2002) 23 ILJ 388 (LC) (24 January 2002)
Court
Labour Court
Case number
J 4636/01
Judge
AA Landman
The Labour Court held that a bargaining council could not, by collective agreement, confer jurisdiction on the court to enforce a compliance order as an award.