Shell SA Energy (Pty) Ltd v National Bargaining Council for Chemical Industry (“NBCCI”) and Others (JA 42/10) [2012] ZALAC 39; (2013) 34 ILJ 1490 (LAC) (12 December 2012)
Court
Labour Appeal Court
Case number
JA 42/10
Judges
Tlaletsi, Molemela, Murphy
The Labour Appeal Court held that a jurisdictional dispute over the true employer could not be resolved as conciliation without viva voce evidence.
Avroy Shlain Cosmetics (Pty) Ltd v Kok and Another (J202/97) [1997] ZALC 1 (1 January 1997)
Court
Labour Court
Case number
J202/97
Judge
Jali
The Labour Court held that it does not have jurisdiction to adjudicate the unfair dismissal dispute at this stage, as the Labour Relations Act requires such disputes (other than those specifically listed in section 191(5)(b)) to be resolved through arbitration by the CCMA. The existence of an employer/employee relationship is a jurisdictional fact that the CCMA must determine in the first instance, subject to review by the Labour Court. The applicant's attempt to bypass the statutory process and seek declaratory relief directly in the Labour Court was rejected. However, given the material dis…