19770926 TZHC Mwanza1

\ . \ '·,_,.. JUEJJTJ.:71 Cl o o O O ,O O • o O O O O O O O O <! 0 0 i:; 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 C 0 0 0 0 h.T]:ELLLNT vor::3U8 . • 000 000 00 00 0 00000 0000 0 0 0 Cl O 000 0000.0. CHLRGE:- Robbery r,,j-t;h ,Jiclcncc c/s 285 ,._nc1 2£36 of tho I1erJ0.)_ CQ·c1o .Cr-~J_)olG "7c:l.J_ of -~110 TJC..1 {f1. 1 Thu nppoJj_:'.:nt to :,Jt'FT -i,;:Lth th1"eo others ·:rnr6 jointly tried · on n ch:--:.rce _cf rob'.Jd'Y ·;.:"ith ·,j_olcneD contr:-~ry .to Ernc-tions 285 ··r;..11cl 2sq.. Tl.~o. ·L.1~-.;.r:. \l'TlJ.G·~-~1.~~~;)<J~·.:r·(J{~~· (-~.t rJccct:t(1 :-'..C-cUs.0·c1 ,·-··.t the t,rin.l w~.s- c.cg_1;tttc~ ~-·_f-:~,;:" \ 1--:-:-~nL: his :~efcricc :2L.~- on tl1.o r--J;plic:·•':7ion of the 10arr1ut rn1·u1ic proc:,;0cutor. ·.chc circu;-:iitr-1.ndc:s surrouncling the s2,j_c~ ;--~r;plj_c·-,.tio11 c..x·c r1o·t o.--:.sy--- ,+c; 'm'i·~~(;·rst~jnc}. 11.s· ·~-~· !J~·~ttcr of f.':.ct tllcy ,..,re: hichly sus:::j_cir::unr~. Howcv.:..:r, I c~o not intend to EK',ke o.,ny ft1rt!'lcr O:Js,:)rv'~ t:1.cnc ovsr the s:-~no boc:~t'.Bb, I think, . the :point "F:'..S E:mf:?ic:L,:!1 tJ_~; 'J::-'.'~:1_;, :b.-t · ho;-:.,; by r::y le'.rnecl broth(:;r, · l\/f+'n l· '\,1r:, . .t•l:.;J.:f:.. i,r.. ,,); T CJ •.- ~ ·i yj- r<.-,-; ,·n i·1~ ,.., J -~-..... , ,.,., 7 .L'J, 'G,:., • t: 5·2· o:--f 1976 (r,~,;Tc, ~.L ..!u. .. 1 ln 1 .l(-·~ Y1 -PC; _ •"i re• try) • u...:;c)--L:J ~. ·'· .....,, ...,_,_ T ,"7~ .,,.U.4'.!'

·' . ... Tho ,ciI.Jfcll:~.:.1+ :.n-:l -th:-: r-:s::,·.ii1L:1:~.: two othtJrs -trnre, howc"',.ror, found guilty r~f3 cfr:1-"'rgc::'.~ ,"'.net they ·w~cr,:;, en.ch, :Juntenccd to tho str:.tutory nin-il.,1u:r.1 of r~ovcn. yo·r;:, j:· . j_l. in One of' the convicts, ··who ['.,pric:::.rcd 8-Z fo1_;.rth ci.,cc:H:.wd <t ·1;L.c tri...--.1 :--,p}'.hr:·lod to the fhgh Cc1-1rt but his [.\I)l)c:·1..1. w.r-.:3 c7.isuicnci(~, sc.o Cr:W·1j_n2.l L.ppoe,l No. 45 2 of 197,6 (liw::',nzo. -- Regis cry). - TI;,o c,,:;;;:/oll .nt ,rho '1.;-;·,s third ,~~ccv.i,ed nt the· :trio.l, _is no-w cloo :~ p{~.l:Lnc. The thi:r·c~.' conv:Lct did. not Ci.~')J)0:-,.1. It 1,,~:;s o:.~t,·'..:)1ishccl :.-:t th0 tr:i'.".,l th:-:t on the nieht of 29/1/75 ,.,.l_·_•,o J_,· V . C ('•' .,.~.1:-'..J._. ·', n·•'i_,-·it ·, ,,;, ~,. _ . I.,.., 0 -'Q,-.l' u _<,_:, 0 u-~- c< 0' - ~ . ,,1~ 0 "') •.• ,·~0 ~ j; IT ' .-·'c• T --' -7' l'}V,--, -;· .--, ·1 hy . ._- ,scvlc ,., ~ ,:>'· cc- ci·~o-·Ll_LJ ~t ,;::,, •.. : 0-· c:-,r-,vr-, cros .• ( '•b who w;o~ra ~:rm.eel w:i.th, inter 2li . ~ Ci :sun,, ~Choy cr~i:r\cd 2..ccoss into the huiL~inr: ~:ftcr brcJp,kin,; the ,:oor with· r-i, h':.1go ::;tcnc. VIhile insido th.J t . ,_)j_l:•;::Ln,z they firoc~ norc:: shotEJ. So;rn of tho pellets , st_ ruck the conpl2.in~,__nt 's tdfc, Furu H0scr:.ni (r-w;2i) ,;,•rho w2..s.' them ·tt;.,,.,,..,. SJ_ _ _.i..cJ.c. .i·~ J.\ l·)nc71 J ;, .l.',.,

t:::. 1rc c; - ., (,, "'"·'- I, ·9 ~-. ·- ,"!,-.,.., TT.::,·7 ,.'-'- (.) ,_,_.,_,, l, ~·-r· cf1.1°·ll <""'lTT'"' v ·...:. J.J..'-tS 1~ \.o o. , :. Cl"l1·1a.=1·· · ~ i'n ·-'l ie-•("!~'- ...{:.'r~f')t':i.:;'V'r~ - J _ '--' 1 light, provi~~!_x: by '.'1'.. k-nr which -r,,:rC'.S on in ,-tho ro'om whoro she rlnd her husbr'..ncl, the --cor. j)l.:-:inrJ:1t wo1r·e. - It w.':'..s · cho Cf'cSO for :tho ~rosecution 1 th2.t tho r\y;pellr,nt w:_·~s o::1c cf th;__; f3'::id ro b 1Jors. Ho wc,,s identified by voice by the cm,·'.:1::in n·:; ··: ,1. sc•cn by ]:::,.,ru (Pw2) before she loot crondciousnGsf:'• ;~s :-, TCsL·J_t cf tho _';un wounds wb.ich she rccoivod in the r2.E:. ·rn 1;~.i.·s .- 3·{~ 11 ce {"~t -~l~G. t:r·j_ri.l tl~o 2p1)cl.l::nt. ~1t~,tec1 tl1c~t on ' 11 30/1/75 2.t :-,b01.1-t 5.:3C ::~.-::. l-.--:~ ]~o· Y'(~ g1.m ,shots anc: cried-, fo:::a help in the vill:·.e;c. Ee ::ct o,..J_t of hj_r: houso rm: l'li'occcc~c:JC1 to the. scene 1 He foimc1 :•, lot Gi' ::,e:o~l-:~.- :Lnc:h/ir:; P.C. Mwit2, (Pw-3) ,;nd the \c... rd · l,.J0 r::;ocv, 0 t·-..,.--~v 7 l.J -L,., 1=\-.·rf: \-ii.~·.,•. ..1.._, r.-~·-'t-,,·r~ :>'·.c·,, ·'u- ·fi·~v-· t6... 1_ ..:.-..L -1-i,·1ut,,~ ..... v._, 1·1"' ,..,,..,"T t.he .!-•-- ..,,, .• l ..... .i.. ' - ' : 0 £ ..,.\'I lJ- porson Pho ;: ,--,·. ,~ r-•cl r, C! +·~ rr~+ ' CC''F' "r'1 ": t. ·i+ -:_~ ~\- 7 ;r, . ' v -l,: .'. ·~-,, -. ~\ ~ 1~. -~'· . 1 e tri·~ 1

1?'.,:-~,Jini brou.r.•·ht D:'JT ~~-- ' t,rc ·I . l-c,_J OI L--·~-',L'--0• ~~ _;~l~~~- -r ., ~;•··' ~~ ~· W ~t~; _: ~~ + -~:Tt~ CO ~ 4\ O •_ .L:V,.-.,-u .._ ..... l,y .i,11,., .l.~--L,::i,, ,J:,,-L-.,... 1..;d ,holJ t,,.b.~n to J~' ,~:~ .~~.C j •1 ~ : ~~:; '} ~· .' lr Ju-be .. c··o·"1.......··,1··,1~1:·,r,t - 1 lv 10 hOl l. , __ ,--,+ J U ;·,,·n,1,ro 1 '"''\ :..A...._:-, ~n' be'- 01'YQC,11r,,.-,;- /'_I,.··'-' 1 ,., .J ,..1...:.u, (.r,c,--01:;F)"'niod . ., _., ""-.L'·" .. ,..-L.• C.,,,.,_,A. .,. _,., .(.._,J_.,.,_._1,;_, V thera. vn1ilc tl: :):;:G he ::,J:ipcll[·.n t t o:;::;_)re•:,rwd his ,sy;JJY:thios to the · :· compl2j.i1;::;nt ·bott;rt: Y'\?turn:i.nc ho,·:10. On 1/3/75 -ho, r~)l")Gll,·nt, W:'"'.S . e,r:costc";_ while ,~~tt6~·,'::i_::1,c; tit~J c:~:·1,nif.r;thcr.- f.u:ncrz,l r~nt on 3/3/75 ,-y;::·c... -.') --- -1- ,..·) .. tr· i· "-. ~ r~t. . he' ·.,,-Vv,.,1:c,<;;., Jrc,1 .-0'l--f ..t:.·-- h'--''-'·'· -r:-• 1 I ._. , 1 ,c 0 J.l r_; !\A. lnt., .. ,_,_:_ 0 ('" 1 ,~ .J • ·- The L;' -.r•nr/ tri~·l ri r:::i..cr'.:r:' to fluii.c' th '. t the ic"..on tific2.tion of the ;:' ~ :;:. e1J:-,.ut J-:,~fl su:f':i :i.cicmtly b-:..on GSt[,.bli.shcrl i<dore procoe;C:~j_n:3 to co:1.vict hin. , .. -.•.·,-, _, .•-- con te1~cJr0 •••oee.•·•/2 2 w::-..s not trnffici•,·,n·r,ly i'.'.ontiliocl by Pwl ;·.nc7. Pw2 bee ~t·•.;-:,0 conditions fr-.vouring .'.:, cor::c\)c;f' :i:7.c.~nti:2:~c::;tionG voro

9 ~t tho tiE10 of the robbery di:'."fj_cFlt •. :Ih. lfur.;•:· ;): -c cf'-· 1:i.;,. ',}.'('_1.X"tOi"~t -'chc :"'aIJ}_)OlJ.:-,nt quotoc1 the cnse 0 1 of Llx7.::~l+J2::.,. ) Li_.l'LulitS~~ .:: ;g,__ .';'l:"_'. -::~:};..::..L_Yf_P:_l:£::-1..I::::I.~ s 20( E:-L. C.• A.166 in which it \r.· r~;: h,/L-~' ~iY' thi. c:.•l·T-:~. o:J: -;'::°'~--o- l for Ec-"st .:'.fricc, th;-,"t ·, _ ll0lt],nu:"""h ~- .'i" r.t ,.:,t -,/r ,,.,, .J- ..•.. ._,_) ---• .. -.~_'c•·:_~_-.. .... •·• ~,..- -·~• -· -'-l_,., _,_\,.;.,; +:)•"1-l-:i':,nc·,v I.,.OJ.'"' i·-~-,·1c •ri"tr1 "'S"'' V ;,JI.. _ . . ~V•-1.} 0 ►::) .l.L:_,• .,, \, 1 \..,,,._.::, lJL.lt tt1is c-:.-.-1.1J_(· ::~c . .:·:·; ll!_,·i: ~L-3:::3(..1: -:-~,_-(.] ~:.:_;. Jl~.. :.:·c1'l· tcs-Ci11.c 1t!i tl1 tb.c 1 e;·re:-~'--t c8 t; c-·-.-~u t> c- .:;v-=~- :~ .... 1::.: -·::j: . · D:L:1i:-.. .:: -.-TJ. -cri.c:2s 11"1.~ .J}~(;c-l~ i~ng jJ~~ orL tifi- cn. t ioi1 1..?f:,::•·.;c_·;~Jly 1 ,~>:..:n :·.-:; ~ ,:::· ·.::~0Fn ·:-11.·· ~~ tl1c.- co:': ,i·:~ions f:.vouring ~, cox'rc..:ct :t." -~---.-ti~'-•~::; '.-~i .:::1:.. -.:c::~-._:, ('_j_J'fi-.:\:~J_·~-~ Cl I}:l sl.,1. c~·1 circ1.,1~Js~~-'.i1ces T,T~l~·t v~ .. <. • ., ·1· ~-- q 'Tl·:--:;:,,-.--,; .,__t;..., ...... 1 -•-'- i (.~ ,..~-'- 1; circu~st~nt~~l or direct, . -·n -., !; . .... _J_ ~_;•"'1 .'": '""-""'('1, d . -'--··- .• ~._,,,, ··-:"1·7 .... ,-!_, .. ·,1"' 1- ...... \ . , l• ..

-........ 1Joj_11Jcir1~:; to :-1.-:.j-~Lt f·~cc:·; ·:-~:.._ri.c.'..!. --~ ;j 1.-1_t'..e,~e or j1n·;y c:.;n rc:--,son:-,,bly conclucl< tl1~. t · tl"~ e: : 01.:-j_;.__ .~~--- c: c · 0~ · i ~- .•:;·L. <.-. j__ ~ j_~ t·ic·11 e ---~11. c~foly 00 ~cceptod 2s 1 free fr9~ . . +;:.-.:. ·; ]_'G:.:.:f~~;_t;il:~. t:r. rJf .! . :,;:L~ror. n ,,,11,...:::: .L '-' V ,...,vi. --:;c·, .,\,; <.., c,-,·· , "" :i·r'. ....,.•--:·~·ir'· :-'-; ' . ,,. " ".·.a.··-_, 1 · \ .... _ '-'-· 0,J ..1'1~ -~-ri .LL J_~'ln·· l,,. ~ -~1-- <"'"'·~;.-.. ~11:t·· 1 .,. ,•.t.J J .... ' ~-.:...s C. ., ' C, 1-i.. C"\'lC •VC: r , we, s not of ~'. si1~,:·l::· 1::)_tn,.:c;:0 lP.'!.t of two wiJcno::::E,r)s. Lc:'.r.rl.ttoclly the robber3 took ,)1:-·.c,; in tl-:'"~ nir·ht. ·nm,rovor ·i:;he u.n,~i.s:1li.t.::d cv:ic1.enco shows th ~t ~i·h·,ro (., v 'T''~' , .... J J....:. :._J'_···1· ;' 1,-n:;-)' ('"" _. .•.·n·,.,··.,,,001--1 .L - · •,r'·: l.. ) 0 l"'e V,J_\:.,.... J..1]·,o /:()"•'-'J:'- ,; . .L, 1 ;·,1,~i·11·•·~t ,_.,_. · .11 ·J,; ·,ncl_ ......1-l..:S ... ..1.. 1./ ..... ~ J-.J.., .J wife, Pw2, w:]r,3 ,. t the tt,,c of tk, robbery. Tho- COD}:;1.·· j_>J/-.nt hinGclf s2.ic1. Jd'.l.~~t hu ~-lid ~1ot sco tho :·:t•~,:;11·:,nt whj_lo tho l:-:'.ttcr w::-•.s in tho roof::l ·but. hc~'.T(.l n.im outsiclc; · urc,-' hio com::,;\nions not Jo light their torchos. He, i.o. tho co:;1,J.:·.i1F'Jit, thcrofore ic''.ontii'icd him,

ti~~ 2,--ppell~.nt, by. -hio voico. Lccc:;:--;:.in,-; to 1:w2, however, tho .sr..w ~n rccoe:;niL(:rl the ,.p1)0J.1-·.rt ~.rt,.cn: the; l,~ttcr ;,w: .-,bou.t :four oth:..:rs . el'.1.tcrod tho -roon-, w:- er:; sh9,:_i:,r.".s, :-·,s '.".forc)s:·•.ii: 9 si tU.n 0 in bGd bre""st-foec:1.j_nfs Lur child. It !J.-,,s beef.. -h,··i:~ .,.;_\. 'Jv·-:~hi.<-· , v . C(' 11l't ~-l,.1._.1·1~,+ ·1·i''t''Y'() l.r' ''l"+i·fi'c"tl·ons i·n ..... v \ .•.v .. ,.. 1.J -,_,,,..,..,, !...,.4- ... 7 __ .._, tho sc,J.o. bc~s:Ls of r~ ccx:vj_ctj_on i~ 1-·.cn j_ t I'.11..:ot be W:'..tor ticht. The rnc'..tor:i_. J_ .quor:;tion in tl~·.o. i!'.)Et,·nt :-~:. ·hx;l is, tl:1.:s, Hhethor the evidence of idontifj_c··:ti<in in tLii:.: c"r.::o vrr;s i:-r·.tort:~c;ht. On the evidG)''.CC on :r-cccr:~ ~: ·(~O ::1.ot J1 ·:sit~·.t() to r~ns,;:rcr tJ'.'is cp,1.r3stion in the ,·,fJ.n;_:,r1·. ·'tl·v·,., t... \,:;, 0 _:..H ·.s· -'.·hd 1· -·,,·-r.-~ ·r: .-·~,~J·::-1. )""1rr-isJ~-,,;-·te .. ......._. .J... iJ L ..... , \.., \.,; qui·+o c·or~r '>ct1,T •. -.LJ.\_,-:_ ..Y 0 D"'C'- •J .-1...- ... ................. - u 11 \.,, 1 rvc.::~ ·t1::i:c. :-.:)1:E::J.lc.:~~i; w·· . 1.: ;:10t -··, ,:tr·.1,:;::r· i1'l thu eyGs of both the compL-:~:1· nt, ·~1.-~:: l2.'i'::: ;·.,::.:L, 9 l'"\,r2 ~ I t :U:1. in evLlonce th~.t the f'"ppell- :nt ,n·l t\~<2 cr:-,:1i··l.':.j_11 .;::,_·'.; r.re .nc,ic-;l11Jouro. · Furth0r, t...ccording to Pw2

:--.nr.:'. her ov::./Lnc,: cm <:b..; l)Ofr:.t .w:·.s nc•i thcr ch:--.. lle:).1 6 ed. nor C·o·n·tr'"'r ir>tr,.' c•J•1n ;,s.·,c, ~-l·,-,c,r,,v T,r1·1,..,,~ t-hr, t1,·upc-• ~r.-11)<:rlrnd 7 , __ .. __ :··1.,7- ·-,·:-1,':> 1 \_._......_ __ . ., .,_.,_,_,...c.,~· V-~ .•. ...:;.\...,lrn ... v. . . . ,::, . c .. i . • . J.I.J- J t.,; - (..")D VL. ~~v on thoir. 8",v:·,.co :-'..tt'.:ck·. S;·.J ·\-r ·,s net i"',S it wor,:) 1 f'..11:::'.J::cnod fron sleep by tho invr.-.s:i.0:..1. j_:i,1 wlli(;~1 C,'.3C 0112 ·trn-uld :)cr}1.r-..j_:;s .h.'":.VC thought th::-.. t l. 't ,-.,..., ,, 1-i".,,v_v L.~c~,,J -rr,-, +··'. l ~ ,-", ·1-1./-J-v . .J. ..... i ···1 ,., ·i''r~ ' 1·1 · ·r to · ,a,,,t ,, CJ, ,v, r . "'\ri r, ·i on I· .... "-.-~ V·•• ... - .... l.- 1 :.- J• .,v t_"J\.:; ~t-~ _._,,,, • _.Q_ _c...i,_ 1 r,. . ··r··,rV ',ot lJ"-\T.'-i 1-,r:, 'Il )< 1f'ns·•c- ·}-k-• s1·n)" ll\.i "'na. ·· ·tt,;·,-,. -u _d, .t,. .i., 'lr-c,r CO"'R<'"OU>'nG·:"'"'' ,v . yv\... _,.J... ..._ .. ~.. 1 ~ ....- _, .,_ .. 0 v,':'-'"- ,_, J..1.t _ U)J • Far 'frrn2 .it. In, "',<:c~:i.tion to t:1is both the conplr.:i.n:-:.nt ·'.~nd. Pw2 d · - ·. ·c·1·os·"'c' ·1-1',.,J. +h~·,y 1··•·r'L ...L,.ll...L_ ~ .. , ,1 .; ' .. ·1·h-f·ier _,..,I., ,__,_ - 7 ·+!Jo '-:1~~""ol',1'''.,,...,_ .,.,,._-..,: .,.LJ.!.., • . __ .._._.,_1.J .. J.o h'"'"TO" ')eon· on•" o·J.. -L • V--· (. \J .. -. .. \ J V · tho ·ro~,;.Jors :~·t -!~h<..:

o:-'.rlio;:;-t; possi;Jlo o 1Yocrti..µ'1i ty t n··,;-10ly :whon et '.:! rol~q·o 'offfuccr 9 -· P. (;. Ilwltr., (?vr3 )'. '."'..rrj_vcd. ,-:-,,t thG scone.· · 'I10 ny Bind . tl\is fc,c-t lorids G:rodi t to :··tho ,Jvir.l0t!CO of thc~o t"i'ro wi tnesscs o,n, this t:'aSl)CCJC of t.hc ,C:::'a$C. . ... In bis p(d;i ticn of :·· ~i;:·c2.l tho t:'../'IJCll;--J:i.t cl!.t:,lJ.,,;N(OG ,tl":!.o evidenc1 of Pwl· r:nd }~,2 th:c·;t tl:cy idOlltifiod hiw ;J8C..,1..1.:J8 j_t fr~;s Tiot' until ::'..ftcr ono full noDth whon he, n~1pcllt-.,nt, wr··.::-J ;·,r:rostcd. ~-J:1rl Clr.rcoll. Lccorti.n,:;. to the ::'.rJ:cll'":Lt_ o_n 3~/1/7~5. h~ to?k 1.J•.rt i:n ·d::.o c..rrosting of tno first c..ccur:;ecl ,. t t~1c trJ_ ".l ~x1cl .!10 h:i.:·1::.wlf w· .s ,'..rrcisted orr 1/3/75. \ ':1'.:'..rt·: frou tbcfr,c, ho.. '.:-t c;t,-., tcr::cntrJ in fuis poti tion of- npponl theos :'..lL:c;:· tions r)y · tho z~-;:::;_.>.:J.1·--,!1t do net c'..P:J)O~.r to b0 s_upportcd :;-.,r;iywhcrcL Ls ::. :::1,,,•;~tt:I' oi' :f:--.ct, in ::is :1.ofcncu ~:t the tric"l the 1 nppolJ,cr1.t did not. :J:',.V J:::E"'t ;1.c took 1Y',rt ir.t tho [',J-:rost of the first .,.,CCll~O,. · ~-~CCCr d.].1-1·,.,. '..> .\.vC' ..'~,...:.,;, ~"' ., •..; ,.h ..l,.3,,., ;, l, ., f1' r-="G. ~ C,..U '"'C~.l b-~-"lll. r.r . ~ ..... ,., J.l,., 1 '1 C< ( . ,· I ' ,..,..... . 1 " .... ',; .L\., -- •CJ 1 , • ,,_; 0 '·''-' 0 l) brol.;l_ght to the scone by

J+C.'•V.Ji c:f · pco:r,lo. l~o dc;uJYt the first , ['..Ccusoc1 ~.111cd; thoro:fore s r -.vc . . .~lro· ~:.Y 1)ocn ~'--:iprehunc1..ct when· the '\'\nJ?poll::.nt sf'..w hin, j_f .., t :.11. Se:conc'"!.ly 9 the rocm:-d of proceedings in the lower court cl~~:~.i l:r ;,~>cYis tlr.t the C'..l)pcl1~-:.nt Wr'.S brought 1 boforo it for the ::j_rst tine cm 2712/75 :--.nc1 not in Hr~rch, 1975 ns nllccoc1 by hj.r:1 ~ r..':)t·•, 1:rrol: ·.:~-, ·'c '(;() juoticc G~'.):'licr them II,,::;_·~g (Tvr3) -:}:o ::-"c},_;j_tt,.:r.1 th:-t I'wl c1..nd · •· .~c~l -::_:..·:~ \}·~ic:t:;:: :·r.-~cu · · .:r!::~. ho1...1s0 he 9 .• .... /3 Nwi tn, know· wr',r.J o:c,:: nf the, rc•l")1)crs. I'i,·r1-t;-,, t,_;r:;t:Lfj_ccl 2t the tri0.,l to tho ef'f cct th ·.t h,: t:c.Lcc~ 'cc) fcillcn~ tho c,11:::-e:lJ.::nt :,, t his houso 0 on SCNOrr:,l OCCt'.c::jr'r•;J 1.t c,c: to trrr__;,~ hi;J. Accow:in:'_'; to P.C. r.'.lti-ri tc. f.\ftc1~ t}1c :to1J-bc~~?- ~=--t r\~)~_-,o.-:'.I'~;( tl°~'l t ·tl·.i...:: ~.:.·i11eJ_J_:--.::1t l1r,:J. sl1ifted from Jij_s hc 1 :c o in th c v-i1:L:· o. JYin.~~l_J_;·/ 1 it =L;._-_: j_j:1_ c_;vj_(:c.~·~cc; tY-1.·t PoC. l~l~ritr.;, 2,:~si.:Jtocl l.Jy tl1c :JJ: rd Socr,Jt·r•r (:;'·w6) trr·:? 1 :_. n:c ,;)10 -~c-h.:.,11:y ;--:.J::Tc8t~·(l the first ~:ccu.sc:Cl r,Jftcl",, t1 10 lI<)rt~i11.-.--~ 1 t;::; )1 tc ·::ic :L'i_::-~o(_ r:.s tl1.n first ctccu. scc1 -.:: . ~·le :-:.. iJi.J} tc

CfJr:~~:._.:.,;__;" ;_-~;-:~~- ·--.t~-~~:o U]~ .·:·l~,:-)-t 11e:j_t1'. _::.;J~ of· tb.eso 1 1• 1 1 two wi tncc::.:,:::-; ~ ::\O -. ; c.1 :;~\r6 9 r--· f: cc.•:, >::t:Lc:;_rncL '."Jy the r:.p;:,:;ll~~n t on the C'.,l1egc' tic:n tl·,_,._.;~ ,_ c ~ :,,: ell::'.11·!; ~ -:--.lr:.e; tcok r::,ri:; in :.:he c~TTcst of the fi1,,st n.cc·:J_;-:32,(_ I11 D~_,..LOJ~t, l:l.J.:::. :.: th.o ~-.L-:. · ·.rrJ.ccI trj_;~J_ r1····.;sirs-'.~1~r,,te ~ I ctr.a 0 s [~tis f j_ 8 ::.~ t JJ.r· ~ s - ;:~ (·· J..,.\/ Gi ~_.,. r_:11 ;) ~~l ,--~ J?r: -~--1 J_ :-, .}:l t in t1. t 8 (1- •:) f C:n. Ce is n El8I'8 cocl;:-r\:'._1d_-.. 7:",1u_J_J_ _ t;;tc-1"'~; jJ:-.1.c.:~::~::~·· ·lt:: c:f ~.cr\i:JirL:~:~~ r'...n~r rc--~.sor)_;:_.1)10 doul:Jt in ,:·y LiL ·•. S~LllCG thor(: w~~f3 suf:ficL.:n t li3ht in thu I'OOI:1 :::.nd Pw2 itT~oS wic1o a1--r~~lco fl.t tt1.0 ~-:;_~~t01~i~---~1 ti~-~c -~~T.!.~.l, i~1.1_r. tl.1cr 9 tb_,-, t t:J.10 rtr):c>.:::l.lnnt was 11ot c~ str2-,r.1.c.;01~ to l.:otl1 I'vll ~-~ncI I¾-J2 I ~~r1 s.('_ ttsf'j_c(J. 9 ~'~1J \r:'. S tl10 trial D,~gistr~::, tc, th~t tho ic.1cnt:dic:·:.·'don of tho C'-J1IJCll: ·.?1t as one, of tho 0 robbers hc,d sufficjcmtly boon c;_:·Gc-.,blir::l10d. Tb.0 '.':',ppo11.~11t 's conv:ictj_c;n w.·..s 9 th,:,:i_,oforo, ;juctifiod. Thu e:1c11to.L1co it11Josccl in tl1.o Llin.i~·_JU.J.7. J~l''oserifJcc1 ~JY ln.1'1. If 8..nything tho r.p~:::cll::-'..nt ·• ·,,1;3t corn:iLlor

hi:.1r3elf v,-:.;Ty lucky to havo f;ot n,1.-rr·:.:~r 1"1j_th the T~1j__ y~_:jJ lll f:i,JiYtcr1cc. lT. . cc1-loss to r;r·.Jr, tf1cro woro i::cgf~rc.,vr--; tt~1c fn,ctors ire thL, c ·.sc ~ Th,.: :::,p) ._,11,,,nt W~",f:J in 2, group which wr-:,s :c-.r:.wd 'i,ri th L1tL~'.1 •;, 1 ;.:::·,;ons c,uch :--:,s :·,, ftJ.n, in tho nieh t c,ncl r:, pcr'f.3011 suff i:n.jm:,j.__ ;::: in t\-_,,) rr·'.id. E:,,..-;d. tho :tppoll::1.nt boon sorve:d wi.th ,.,_ ncticc of cnht.JJco::;cnt I would not h'·,vo hosi tn.tod to onhic;nco tllc 2:ontc::nco ··,:-,_,sr:;~.:d by tho trj_,:.l court. Howuvcr, ns ho WllS ru~t I -t:ril.l tt\c 2<.,,J_:.tc.n.cc ;_:.,s i.t :L:3. in its cntj_ •.:'cty. D<.;J._:~_ \·--01~c(t :Lr1. o~~~(:11 Ccn1rJc :\t rh<J"r.t11zD. tl1is 26th C:t2_.y of Soptcnbcr, 1977. Ff}!JtlTZL 26'11H 8T!:?'.l1I;L-,~:R,1977 JUDGD ------...--~. .,,..-.-