19911017 TZHC Tabora

Jt_)._ ~ ~6~ . T I :1 . :, ,.. . ',f . .·. -~;· ! ;.• j - .I][ TITO IIIG!i .COURT ,.,,,. ' ' •' OF : TiU:YZ.'1:ru ··:· .. \' .AT T.till011\ .lI'l21LlTE JV.R.ISDICTION (T,."J30:LJ'i. JDGISTRY) (RC) OfilMilTAL 4-I'P:1.\L lW. 153 OF 1989 :i ORIGTIT..\L CPJMIN..'iL C..\SE NO. 27 OP 1957 OF •I1j:::.J DISTRICT COUD.T OF 3TIIDY.iJ:IGl DISTP..ICT AT SIIDITllTGli, Before J';..J.l•• MSicr.r,;~, ~TJSD)Di{T HAGISTil.'~TD JIS IlTZ:l. WGUNBi e O o •. 0 0 0 o O ~ 0 o • • 0 O O O O • .:i.rr£LL.;J:;;T ( O:d.3ini1l Accused) Versus ,. TI]:; IU'J}1JJJLIC o o o o o ,e, o o o o c o o o· o o o o • • o o o O l:JS:'.. OiTDifil!T f ( Ori[:;'inal l'rosecutor) smmLE .J. JUDGnJFT The appellant Jiai~:iza Il'llt:,rruoba. togethGr with.. two .. otJ.iax-s WG.ll) j.oj,nt.J.y. .. ~ in tho District Court of Shiri;y-anga 11i th tl1e ~ollowin-3" o:f:foncos. Fh'Otl;r, do~an.d.in& proj,)0rty with mo:o.1cces, contrai-y to section 292 of th.c l 0112,l,. -'i.1il. \ 3eoondly optaind.ng C:,'Oods 1:;;y- false p1'et0ncos, oontral"\J to section 3E,2 of tho _...--- · -- ··'r'cm~.-0 odo..-- .Tbe 2nd oo~t __wls: -p..;'o£o:.:'~- iJJ: ·tho .,aj.:to::.."".t.1&ti vc to co1u1t 0110. T:10 ap:.lOl~t- ~ms t::0 1st a.ccu..sod at tl10 t::..1-al. ::i.t t!lo co11clu.sio:1 of tte t:dc.l_ t:10 apj?Cllant r:.::x1 tho l>Ol"SOi'l uto i'T8.S the 2nd u.ccusod t:c:rc convicted on th0 1st coi1.nt, that is,_ deD:lj_1clin~:; pro1,,crty with :·,.cmancos. Tho D.~1.JC).lc.nt ·,1a.s then sontc,1ccd to serve a t:n'Cc :rear tclllr.l of ir:,p:risoru.:rent. Tho 2lil. (;l,(;..Ct,'.:sod. o.t,- ~ t:;.~if_.~, it is ;roco::.."dod, becs,v.sc ho wa.s a first offm'ldor a,~.d ~.1is yot~tluiil ar._;o, · he -;r;:.s sm1tc11ccd to servo a. tern of 12 nonths i;,1~)rison:.10nt • The tl:.i:;.'C~ .::i.cc-usod. na.s acquitted. Tb.o ap,:x:llant is now a;::voa.ling-· c.c;ainst iJot1.1 co11victio11 and oo~'2tc:cco. I' T;.10 ba.ckgro1.uil of ttc cc::.sc is b;.1.cf~y tlln.t Coi~Otir.io in June 1507,. tho a:1:,,:icJ.J.::,nt :::.rid 1-:.is co.....:;,cc'l".Sec..1 vioj_ tcd t:.1:::: hor.10 o-Z ]7'.1' 1 ChJ.rlcs Iinc;i. and info:;.uod then thc::.t t:·wy h2.d been lli:rod by SOIJC pco::J.~ f::."'Oc lhndo ..h·cr,. to lo.11 I1"T1 1 s r:iotb,cr as s:10 was suspected bo bo r.., :ritol:. :lnd that -'lihoy ;J.nd n.11."'.:lac.1.y 'been paid Shs. 50,000 to ci:.:.:i:':..7 out t!1c execution. The !1ppoJ.lc..nt is said to haw 1)con the one ,;!J.o started tl1is .disc1.,2r.:ion. They then- tlo;.~c~ndod. h02.ds of cattle am ooncy fro.o. tllo fc._ :ily in o:."Cl.a:::: ;.1ot to ldll thai~ r.1otl:or. n;1 and :us 1:>rothoi- r:r2 tilon gavo out 3 heads of cattle .;,.,1~ Shs 4000/:a to those :people. Tho n.;1Xlll:J.nt and hi3 collccl.i:-~ dt:..1.;f took. o.wn.y tl:lis J?1."0:._:o:!.'1Yt 0 ••••• /2 2 nn :,.owovor lntcr 0~1r.:l1lc.inoct to tho 1oce,l CCH office 2,nd.- tho :-:12,t·lior Has followed. t.!p ZU'ld t:10 t:;.rac ::or.v1s of cattle he l1z.1_,:-:_ ;given out were soizocl fror:1 tl1e np:)ellan-1; and fro,;1. ·tl:.o pcroon wh.o wn.s tJ.10 2n:·l accused nt tho t:rinl. Lccor<ling to the 'folico 0-1ficor (Fil3) who invGstig.:i,tod t!19 case, . .t;.,.e appcllr.nt ·:,~s fou.11.. 1:L ;1i t:,. ono of those l1oacls of c::-:t~lc._ poro,:,n w:,,o 9aid. baclc sho 4000/=,, Tho pc1°son wl10 wo..s ·:;:·. o 2nd accused wns f,mn}.. with tho Ji;wo l:;.cinr.Ls of ce.ttlc, The nppollcnt in :1i □ ;1..ofonco clid not r.;_J/)OG:i:' JGo ob.3,llr.ngc ~-:n :-:i.nd r,T' s oontontion -~:,.at :C.o ( c-,J:1pc_lL,nt) a.i."ld ::.iis colloc.:,gLlG ·bole so~c ~-~-cr,ds of c2ttlc 8l1..: 1:;,)noy fr,JL: r:n Is '..1.ono 0 . . ' ' ·thic2.,1;s :)v.t ro.thor it 1-ir,s f;:i.vcn ·t;o l1im as f oos for hr:vin~ cn.rriod. nLtJli aomc loon.l mo'.lioel trcatncn·:; ~-t. ·l;L.1:~ homo!) Ho wo.s n r.io::lioinomr.11~ ·- Tho person w:.10 WW,J ·b>o J.s·b acc1..1.scd. on hj,s pe.rt t ·OOl'lplotoly don.i.0d oven Jtlo h2.vc gono to tho l:o;·.10 of nn. in t~i,:; cor.1~')~ of the appollarrb ·bo praotioo local modicino ·.~!:,,,re. I h~vc cr.ro:f'ully 1-,ort-:.no::~ ~nc'. oonsidorod ·t!:lo ovidoncc on rcco:rc.".. n.c woll as t>c ·appi:,llant I o gro1..u1cls of t>ppo:11 ~s oot 01..1.t. in his potiJt1ion of appcnl !~\i was n,-y~ r'.. f o,o ~s :1::: oo~Y;;onclo:l ii.l l:.io rlof'cnco. ;<:. r ,1 { • • '.: , ' I ":• ' ~ > • •' ! 1 'I • • >. ~,' .;,_ \ .. : '_ Tho ~v\c1-Jncd5, of 'rt-r l ·r,nct 'r-ri2 t9 ,JG).1~ of:i;'~c:-ii· -Gi::at ,t:10 ;.~ppcllcfft. · :·., fl' ." • , t . r '.t • , ,,,,: ', ,,, ·..,f f ' • ·• · .,_. tb.c ·p,ropcJ?.t.&-· -;,y;"~J:¢:'cfts "1:ta: •tJupp9,rtecl ir.( Jiho•. cvic:.01i<?o. of J '.-T4~ ,jonqi'..: :i:Jkuluii:i., ~ /{ • ~ 1 ~ 1 . •, :•·• : ' ,. I ' ( j ;- . • •' ' , • ,:t~l.0 Sm1gt. .Si,1..l1.gi1. .CO!~ll!:d,~1c:or t.;.o, was. ori.9 6(;,".tl.:.-o l;,o,.1soi1s· who :~ollow~cl up tLc natter. 1 : ~ ; • • • 4 • , ., I TJ.:c appelb:cts conv:!.q:ti,H1 W~S ~:iorof~)};'C wcU, :f()t.1.114cc.l f'.:11':i. i>i is ~1c::rq,by up;::el,cl.,, ):!.\c·, scntcnc6 of t:'.'.I'eo yonrs i::1prisonr.,cnt t~12.t wns ir.1pcscc". 0:.1 ·:;ho appollaxr\; was in t:J.Q cir- 01..1L1str.11cos of tho cnso 1,rO}:JOl'" let wc:.s alno n,::,-t; o::oossivq to r:.tt:i:r.ct in1;or.,.. fGl'OllCO b.:; ·f1io court. In i;hc on,l rosal t t::is apper,l f:'.ils '.'J1d i ·t :i.s d;i.sraisscd in its cn-:;ir,3ty. , I ·-'" \ 17/1~/91 _ . Dclivcrc,l il1 the ·p:::oscfr1co L'lf !ir. Oswn.l:l, loc'.rno.l 3'vr>.to 1..ttorney on ., t:.!c 171;:i. '1,-:_y of Ooto bar :T. H. S:l{"'-'."'LJ: : . J1::JG.3 17/10791