20140807 TZHC Mwanza

~~ • • o• ••"- L ~•~ ,.\··~;·-.~4~::~. \..J&L. -~~;:,..._,~' /~J!:~'-- .-;J!lllt-~---~ •l I ·: .,,. . .. .. .; . ~; · ... - .... ~ ~ ..,. . ·-·- . , ., . ·- .,,: ., ·_· J • " • :'1• ..:.: ,··• . '"":~ .::~,~~--,.. ,, .. · ,::::~~ ·--. LABOUR DIVISION ... . "'.·-· k .. :,._;,,,;..·,.·~•-.· r:1; .......... __ •. ,--,... ~-. A~?A :,,.'..... . -.. ,:, -t.e-~~/-+·~::"" ..... •......... . . - . . . _.,.._. < .,. . ,~ .,:,-.. _~~ . <;-"'~l·.:MWANZA -· · - . , ~.;.,....,.~~~,.., •;•~/f'ii:e~•~ i :rn r;. '... ,_..-.-,..,._.:..,.;.,,., ;' · ~§.~-YJ.~JC>,t!JfPtt 7,SJ)f,J,OJ.~..-ry, f!. f .1 ei .';'fW , ~ ,;,,_.;;°'w :;•;, 'IOii ,: ,,t,ttc;tt: THEODOSIA RVVEYEMAHO ........................................·~·:··; ... AP~LICANT · . . VERSUS · . . ~A·\ A"" ~ :THE AGA KHAN HEALTH SERVICES ........:......: .....:...~~\tgENT (ORIG/NAU CMA!MZM!48/20~ . · '~ 25ll/2014 & 7108/2014 r ·,-;:~ I . . R.M.RWEYEMAMU, J:- "\_ · ~, . The applicant and anotheraucc~ferred a claim of unfair termination to the Commission for Mediation ~n~~t.!tion (CMA). In her claim form, she alleged to have been unfairly terrninate~~~~.,.,~nt and sought payment of Tshs . 5,531,427/= and subsistence •. allowanc\ until;~ payment of the claimed amount. The dispute was unsuccessful~imJ~~~'lg-sJt for determination framed at the CMA after parties opening statementstWer~1,r€~¥Jiwere; ;~.:.;~!.. '!,_, -~ l::.- ·a), whethenhie applicant's employment was terminated, if so, b), whether proper procedures were observed or c), whether employment was terminated by the applicant; and last, d), relief parties were entitled to. · (1] ~ ··~~<,' ~ ~i/• ,._. - ?)~~; , .".--':. • ·. . ;: :{if-_ .thereiafter that, the parties had disc~ssed retirement but th~ ·applicant had .a change of. •. ,. -~· .·., ; ·i,:, ' heart,'after rec~iving the resP.9n~ehfs letter of 5/6/2010. That letter, put benefits due td .· .; <t~1{~~- ~c~.-.~,..:; j;ffi~'··gppfi~ af fsf(;400;·oiioiif ari~hic>tJ11t· tb~~idereii•_disrnar h~- the applicanffo't'lh~_ ,onr' ,z: ,...?._, · ;,, > ·:,~-- _:~~~-'; ;~ •-ll~- ••-!1!tt•.._-._:.Af.·-•· /~ L;i" .. \:' ·;·~ ·._ . .. . '. ,.,,,.. ·: ~,·. ,.. ' . \· •..' :, .: ·. .. :ti"~.:£-... .,. .,· ... .. . . .. ,, . ' . . . . . . ·'._,,;~oil~.,;.£• ·. ··u.M, etil\;,f'•nJ.,_,,,~~..,.,,..,- •(~--,,.• .,;,_~... ;, ~,,.jles;;~--~\lll;;ot_,,fi•.~• ~~ . /., ,,;'- 'f~ '. Th_e .second undisputed fact is· that, following rnisundersta ding :~etir~ment and due benefits, the respondent wrote a letter d ng to _:/o'):: reinstate the applicant. The latter did not den recei t of tha! letter or t. ~h.:..:::e:..=.:.:==:..=:.:. the letter that she had no desire to return to work. As rightlY, ted out by e respondent, ' ·the applicants' desire of not wishing to return to work is fu~n . _ by her response to a question in cross examination, at page 22 of the . cor J (3M.A arbitration proceedings. , The applicant is recorded to have ad~d thllP'.,..._ r ~h; did not wish to return to . work was that she ~as hated. On ti~~ct, }~ i.f . e r~sptffl'ttent had initially unfairly . . ~- . terminated the applicant, she clea~l t e ~ e r employment later, when she refused opportunity to resume work. ~g~,~~, Furth~r. as rig~t1¥rt~~~1~ ~ttie respondent, the applicants' assertion that she ~( · · ... . returned to v,,.,ork •••. following \ . the':+r~i'atement \•.< letter but the respondent refused to take her back or give herJ;;i;~~'stn6? raised or supported at the CMA. For that reason, I discard ..... • •f~.'. '·•:- ~. ! 1:_::1 . the story a~ "an119ffertbought. In view of my above conclusions, I confirm the Arbitrator's finding that the(;·;~licant's employment was not terminated; leave the decision and order for +:- payment of terminal p~JrefU_.~•.. which was not contested, undisturbed. Finally, I dismiss this ": ' ·.···:'-:\";,... \'.:'. ~ ~>:·'.:_: .. application for ~\iitcf.ffem:. :{}~~\. . /.#,J;:·.•'lt. /j ~ ~ 1,.: f/.'~'\~.~·'".C:?,): •.~}~~~ \ ~ +.· \ ' . r . _... ·Jt>~~~ I :i v .\\•i= \~ . • v>.Ht)~ ';._ ·•·· .,,;1 ~ R.M. Rweyemamu JUDGE \.~ (?:. ,. ....:, . . ~··~".;,·. . . ~ . ·v;-· 07/08/2014 ·'-o'-'}'.(- ~--"•i.l' V · ~::/it; r;~ Mt,·i,~'),:;• ·~,--.·:::.-d.~--::;;:;~· (3]