19951113 TZHC Tabora

IlJ THE HIGH 00T.7:2.I1 01"' ;I:/-:.lTZANIA A'I! T.b. BO TIA (EC) CRIHINAL li.PPF.J;..L i:JO • 70 OF 1995 ( Origin'll Shiny~"lgo. CrL1in!:.l CD.St: No* 204 of. 199 3 :S_efora~ J 0 L. T1Ilchum'bi 1 . R.:::sitli:::Ult j\fn,gist~t~) ZABB.GlJ f.~ /0 I'I'UZELENGI APPELLANT VE:r:?.[JUS TEE RE:?u.BLIC RESPON:OENT 10 2nrl Count: Fdrgery (;,/s 337 of tbi P,::Lno.l Cod~ Cap., 16., 3rd. Com1t: Utt<:tring o. f~ls1;; d.ocum<1nt c/s 342 of the :::,ttn!)..l Cod;,;; C~.p~ 16~. 4j;_h__ 12_o:-ig_:t: E'M.udulc}~, t f:,J.ss; o.ccounting c/s 317(b) of' tl1u Pci1-:,l Codu Cr.-.p.

16. KA TI'l1I J., ~ ·---···-~- .$..... - - Shiny'.1i."1gn. District Cou:r.t W!J.8 hos:pitr."'Jly n. judici'.tl host of ontt to b<) ca.11..:d. th.: A:p:pell'lnt, fr.,,cing multi:;,lc counts no~ely~ -1- 3t1::~linc ·:;y 2-::rvant c/s 271 of the 20 P,~:1'.).1 Cod~, -2- :iTorg1:::ry c/~1 337 of thic: ?1:c..;l.l Cotl,af k. 3-- Ut~ering ~- f'.11S-J <locurn~nt c/s 3.:J.?. of t·:11c: F;;:::.c.l CoJ.c n.;.::.tl ~4~ F:r8,udrl~nt f'.'.'.lse '1CC01..nting c/s 317(ot of tb.1:1 ?0:".lc1.l Co<l;;; C::,:P. 16, The 9-ppell!".nts :pleo. o:f not guilty to 9.11 counts '.'\ co·(l:r.•s""' ~1~ h!:l.d '1 l~gn.1 right to tt\ka, w~.s '.2,.'lrti:1gerf or prt:cusor to tlie: ·cri~l, t>·.t culmin9.ti::d in his co:,1_viction~ on ,,,11 counts, r.,,nd ~s if th~ itffenca 1 s Weights of sariousnes-s wctr.:t 0:1. tb,:,: sc':il..i 1:ven, th"' tri~.1 r-1~gis.tr:.t~ 9 P'.'.!.SSc<l 11 sentence of fiv~ yeo.rs i1:1prisonmcntt oi1 ~o.ch count 9 b:.:t ord.::ro:td th& S'!\me to run concu:cr..:11.tl;y. •• The Appallant, not 'l :tl/'.l.SOchist, wn.s ~ggrit:Ved r.,nd haa a:pp~ed, 30 ,.gn.il:st convictions througl: r-. Shinyo:,1g:i. br-..s ~d Advocate Mr. Mn.hum'.:l.. I:Ir., rb.hurne. in pros~cuting tb:.! ~:fll)uc.l, mr.J.r1t~ined thatf -1- the tri~l 1 Ho,gisi;ro,te ~rrod in lo.wf in holding th~;t the App~ll9,11t committed forg1;:r-y, utter~d f".tlse documents, o.nd th~t, there was fraudulent f~se o.ccounting• x.1d -2•-w tho.t

i t w~s not ::;irov;;;:tl blityond re9.sonable doubt, th'.lt the A:ppall~nt stole Sha.,1,2'24,r3i$/85, -3- that tha tri'-1 }~n.gistrat.;: err.;d in am:;rding '.'!. S(;)r:.t*nc11:, of five ye~rs imprisonment on ..;c,.ch count., On the othitr ho.nd. 1 th.:: R..:1)ublic,. w1.s re:pr.esantecl l)y ;,. 51 ~. Sonior St~t<:.! Attor::1'<:!y Mrq Ndu:.1g1.,r..1 9 wl10 for rcn.s.ons that wili ~mur~e h1::tr~m:1tler1 dE.-cli...'1.ed to· support conv:i.ctior.s, on counts ( 2) ~ ( 3) ~"1:d (.4) but su:f):._.:orte<l conviction on 1st Coul,.t, !\g;).l.11 for rea.sonst I sh~ll ~ dutifully 1nd purpos,.:fully, :Plo.shing 01.n ji.dici~l :;,i~th rucltl,;:rly 1 .-::.re th.;: fb,cts th~t 9.r~ b:~ic:\lly, not cov . . . ri,.,g so V'.).S t o. t..trri torJ. Th1;y · ').re as fol~ows.., '11he A;:11.-::ll-::--nt W'!'J.S ,.n lsnf-listCZ1t -~cco·.mte,r:.t 1 sine.,; Nay 1993, , .·. o.n<l . then As his professionnl . . .. ·. .. .~ ' '• ti tl-.:: 10·..1J.l~;- s ])t.!'J,kS, 'lCCO'Jl'"i tint5f 'b::,.;:.:.king, J.rawi~,g ch-.::q_U es .~en.dy_. for sig:.·1::-,-cure ·::~-- '!.uthor:Lz.;cl si15-1'.ltorL.:s, wi t·.10.ro.wG.l of mon1:ty from )he 10 . l ·~- , E~,.c.l~, :po,y:J,.:Y?·t of W'lf:;':.?3 .= • to t=mplo7e,.;B L.:11 within the Appelln.n:ts .·••,. br".',Ck,~t3 .of •.l-o.tie-S. On t'rla 24/5/1993 1 tha Apj,>cl1ant on· instru.ctionJ ~ (lr..,w r.-. cb.,JCfci.: for S:1aDl,00() 1 00·)/==, wi-~l: o.tt1:11d~nt•

supporting Joc:1 □ ~L ts 1 h!:>.d th"' c'.1ee11<:! si,:r.G.::d. ·,;;y ~-; // # 2 :=LRICK WASSHJK• for ,:i:1c:'1.s~ur,1,,;!::,.t 1 L1 roo.•li!1~r.rn :for_ l?~.:.ymunt ?f work,~rs. w!lges, on th~ 25?5/199:=;. It is co:1focm<ling- ch::i.11.::,G'-, d~fyi:ng controversy. • • ,,~i_..~•-.~~• 1~1i~:t,~ ., ., I ,. f. •, scox·.:l::L:~:Lng <nJ.d ,_ ¥.. :, · 1 '.:l.::-.y sus::,>1q1on~ .t:1.!).·.; tq~ Ap:pell~..nt d:1-,i on 4 24/5/1995·~1d.tL1r9,w S)1s.,1 1 000,.buo/,, __ tro;:1 ~-i:i'.Jonga 1~'.?.t·icine.l Bo.nk of Com:n.::::x-.: br'.\Y:ic'.1, on i;.;:'(1 ~,lf of ::1io :,mployurs office.. And it· is no-c J,;:r.Li...:.:l di tl:t::r- th'.).t~ 0 ~ th;.; 25/5/19931 'iih1: A:ppdllant could 20 naithax: t~ tr3,c,:d 9,t ".101Jr::• :10:c o.t :,1is office~, o.rd worr.ied ~bout the 110:c"'y i th0 office: S').f r:: kays w•~r.: fir:c.ily surr~:adereJ by the Appelln.nts wife ::,/ ,- • ~~ R:JS~S F'.ARY i•1UZEL;i;;_,fGI, ·l111n,t thu saf~ W'.l.S opened in th~ pr~S-:Ji1C-c of .i?.,W.,1 ?..C~U-1.T.iJ J'LOO?c .. P.W.2 T!RICK \IA.Ssnm: 9.11:l P,,W. 6 nr:r.::~:::~ou. J'}Jl:L:2-;!'·:c,:.:;· T.f..G-.,:'.,,J,Af is unci::.".\.11,::Eg'e::J~ .~s truthful it iS9 th!:l.t '· ~a·-+ t L~.0 ~ ..,~.:.. ... .:. vcL~ 0 1.1.:.1 o.,...!... +·, • ..ii.~t: .:.>,.,.._ - ~,.o '""f·\::"f t,.•,,.,">",_., \" - - ;...l. \JJ..:.._.:...•1· Q·n~· ,,.o,·•.~ +i,,. .J..- '··' ~ . t-:(r.;/.- ~ 1 horr..,,_·.,.,,·lousl,· 1 ./, ··-9 .... J

J.~ the not· p.o.:i.l th/it d~y..,. i ':.111 sue:: ffil?r.io,1s indic·tirienta pref.=:rreJ. ' . conc~J-J.\ C:oll-::ctin'g shs,1,000~ 000/== from r:~ n.J.l,!d. thtt.t .Wh<.:;!n he c!).me b~ck to th~ offic~,. ~1~ n.n.J :?-.~·11,2~ rci,,·Ycn1tcd thu mo1::..::y,; cii.,<l th:i.tf 'lS P,W~2 h:\d givon bio. lca.y;.:::Jo go to j',Iw:i.:C'Z'.:, to s~~ his. sick chil':!,~ ·ha (A,:ppcll9nt) Th t:. trial ...·' 1119.gis t ro.:t.:: · ,_ ii: ~ ~1L_rnt,al:;r C0;."1Si-'.ldr~~1 j1.1,,lg;n~::.t, r0tj.,c·:~J,i the Defence 9 found the _i?ros,.:.,cution 1,,rovi1:1r5 th~ ch"l.rg1:1s ·ou~·o:d r,::~sonn.'bl-: ldo-ubt, n.ntl henctt 40 th~ cor:victions 9 '.lXl-:1 sent,::,;,1c,,,s 9 t~1-..::s 1)r0'Vo:cL,g tl1.is 'lj)pc)~l. In ti-le lir.:ction for .J.is:i)o·s~J. of t::is App~n.lt I sh'.tll first d.~~ ,;,d th co1Jnts ( 2 ), ( 3) ~nu (4) t~1-..:.: coP. Victions on which fo;2;_1J no support from the §tote Attor1:.py. In is not<;J. with res:pr~ct, th3.t the 9-ll ...,gc:l cc,.sh f~.ls 1::fL:.l voucl:llr 1 ~ Joc'..:LH,li1 t forged. 1 rel evn.n t in th<# _S!'.l.i:l cour1ts, w~s nd-:-cr t~:;.1J~r,d i::'.'. uvi.i~r:.c-.: 1 nor ~ny credible: ~viJuncE f~uduL.:nt 11tt.::red.J remcd:1.e.l tht: sacr..;t· of the prosecution 1 a.11.J the tri•.-.l :-bgis-tr::.te tr,J'.:l.·s.:::l t:,.d S~'..m0 · ''.'.8 ~ S!;l.:,.cturr-y, 9,nd 9,;Jftic.,,teu from the d'J.tJt of .:h,cii:i.h-::ring tl:.,: s::ua,,:. :'"3ut with ro::sp~ctJ.

ev..:m more 9 sorro•,.;f\,l is t 1 .~" f,...._ct thnt~ t·:1,::, tri~il ::'~~gi.str.:i.ta in his minds, h~d 10 ,:;ill.o·.:ig:~ e7iJl:!nCe,~ not r0co~c2~J o_f cours.:, to convic.:t wholeso.l,.::: on tr~o:: sr-•.td. counts. Ai1·..:. still_, n:;:i~.zL:,,?; 1 is th,:f·.: fo.ct 9 thn.t, th~ tri~l l\10.,1is tro_'t,: ignoJ_\-;-14 I ho_j_).;: ::--,ot -l"l.::-1h:rc. t~ly ~ ti1c f'.1ct 1 th!l.t. if th,;i ·ce.sl::. vouc~7..-!:::'f W':.S pr..::p'-n·r.::::1 1 :::,.:for1::1 th~ wi thJr~w::-.1 of money fror:i th~ sp1.:c·'.::2.o;tion h,ts it~, tl:i-:i.t th.a :.,,rosclc,1tio:1_, w:1s referring to Cc.sh Vouc:10r1 tht:: origi;,'.11 of }I)7 hitit ;in,F1 , it could. onl3r h~v~ D<=¢'1 wri tt~:'.l 1 aft.::ir 2·~/5/199 31 ~ft . ff to£::rDi::i.o.tion of a~rv-Li~ 1 when the !lbov-:.,t i.t j_ □ w.i th :c.=sp~ct.:..-'." .; 1 n.buncb:i.1tly cl,---=c.r, th~t~ the thr~::e co.unta 20 _ S)"I-OV9 :;l wur(j not b~yond. · r.;io.soE'.lbli:l .iouct 1 /..•;i:f diJ submi fa both th;;, dr::fc:nce :1,.'1tl St').tu Counsels~ corat:covi'.:!rsy th-:,,t,, "l,_pan OJ,•i:!i1L1,3' t'::~ ~J~1.fe:, o:..-.:J.y i:.'.hs .. G65/==r w~s foun:l th ..n·uin~ }Jct it is ~1:1-:-,ll~~ un:lis:put:::::il-..: th:::.t, tl:.r:: ,.:pp.:::lla.nt diJ wi thlr.~.w Shs. 1,000, 000/= from ti"-•--= ::3~\:.1k 1 ~-1-l th~t Shs ~ 1~ 224, r3£/85 w~s hol ..k:;:-~ th"' S:".fe- in which l1~ \Tb.:J o:.~p:_,os"':..1- to hiwe kert the mon..;y 9 Ht noi; i£V-.:tr,

lenLd ')Y th~ A;,i_.l"'ll:::;;,t. :Sut~ th..:= Appellant mn.int:uned, 30 This 1-s 9,1"". L:t;:.:rt!sting J.,ift1Ecet which th"' tri~:t !·i-:.gistratc, o.ftr:=r due consilero.tion~ rGject~J~ (h,. ny p~rt,., I :.-:,.?,V\:.! g:i. V.)j.1 ou.u:ii:p:...·~ ,.ut opportunity of scrutiny' to tht: .:vLler.!Cf.: g,,nctrn.lly, !).:..1,l I '.1IY'. :i::.:l.r::ly 1;.L1us1:ed 1;y the deft:11Ccl~ oncu th-:.: :/:.r.:os.,;:cution h~.::i ·bro·ught th,,f ,:vL!_..,,nc<.l ;_-10::ie, the..t thi! app.ell~1.j.1"t had th'3 ;:io:1-::y,. I h,vd .;:xaminul J)-.::fu:1c-..t }Jlz}1i1.)it :i}) .. li,. vil-c: which th~ A:p:p-..:ll1:?.:.1t clo.i.::a,.d, to ·1:w.v0 gi Vtfl t':i,:.: no::.--1,q -:;o :i? ,.U ..

2. Ard one~ - the All~'c:11!:U':l. t ho.a ,,;oncl this f~r, whv"t~1,_ff it w0.s i:rregu1nr. for P. \-!. 1, ? , W;, 2 !).nu P~ 1tT,.C 1 to o_J?.m tht! o.ppell:~.nt-s s.<;.:L::t i11 Li::1 9."ba,:.,nce,, is imm~tcri~.. 40 J) ti f cllC<:i: ·-:,,,,., ·t ·•D :.:.r.l...t11.,DJ. ., _ .. 1•·'9 VI. ,,11 ·1--\;! -,.1.0·,,..,__,J.t_; ~•'A ... .;.,,... '-''A<• 1 l?'7 000 i 1-· ,_,Lo,.;> • ..L, ~- ... :~ ........ o .pa1·-1 - ,".,,.... ~ to ... El1IC1C \I.L.GSII-JI{: it neither shows 1 th<= sLf.t:'.3.t·.1rc of nor th..-: giv1::r. It is str,lng~s- thc.t t::::;.:i ;._:_:,}.:;;ll~.ntt an Acco11::.1ti"t1t o·f tl1irty Y-=!\rs <:!X:periencc, woul.J 1.)~ so c1:.:r-1.tfr:l ~s to ~,.-.1ve :1 vo-:..1ch~r pra11'.:'.rs::J., · th~ w-:1y it was;, -uut forgt,it to (sfJ!.Vu tte rec\;i'ITer to sign for it. I n..m in !).g'rai:l;)lant uith the trin.l :i-i~-:.g.i:dnt<:! 9 th'1.t :J2fe10C& Exhibit :1D_,1::, was -lefensiv0 JrOduct of -~ft.:!l.' t::1oue'lt~ '). runny i.-ris lon aft~r 1 cr.yJr::ili ty ~s:c::,)s·s;,,,:~nt 9 wo·.1lJ. Sc:tlDl j_n my vi,;W, to J?urth1::1r, scorn t:a,:,; Ap:p1.::ll::mt. 2 ,,''.1., 2 1~::i.i1e.:d b""iYlG :.--~c:;~.;,.:d OV!:!r 'JX!.Y mon-.::y 1 'Jy 10 th,:;; L:i,>1)-.,:llnn.t~ (.1?i'.l vr:-.s- ~ss._,,ss ...d h.::.:.,;·::ly cr~li°:)lc:. He wn.s the sola · signo;;;or-f of th2 chaqu2s 1 n..'1.l :15.d ,.1ot :1.uuJ. to go through th~ A:i,ilJ.-;llQ.l.1t 1 to stt':cl.. And if P .W. 2 h:.d

:i.llow"'J. th.:.: Apl)..Jllo,nt to go to Mwo.n~C4 9 to a,:;:e n. sick <;hilcl, tha s~,:: J? ,'\! .. 2 would not ·,10.vtt. O(;:en -1- supris~d to S-.;u work;:ll."S not bclir.g :p~itl th..:iir ~~l~.ri"'s 9 •-2- ha would not have hurriuclly r-,tported to .!? • H ~l, tc1;.; ~DS-8nc.., of th.: appelll),.i"'lt~ :-};- hu would not s~nd Jh1oplt! to th~ Ll,)pol~t to chv,.t-k his where~bouts, --4- he would not :i,1.,.rson,'.:'.11:y cont':l.llt t;-~'-= A:pp.£:1.1::,;c,ts i•lif<! 9 o.bout the o.ppelln,nts whe~ e.bouts" -5- h,:,: wonl.;l ·not to...1{~ tD.~ troubl.::.i 1 of having the sa.fe-:'co:penud 9 as wi tr!t:tS-Sadt- which h.:: would not do,, if ~10 kn-=w he had bean hn.nd.,;1d the 20 mon..:y, The persoi1 showing such conc~rn, wo·c1ld not be th~ pt:irson~ we n.r..: -:J...:ing p,:;rsno..ded to ·b~li.av1:: 1 \'TOuld rclct:i ve the mon~y from the Lpp~lb..,."'lt 9 st~~l th~ r:J.On1:;y 1 but m~k..: o. u-h1rn 1 ~.nd plant th-i:t th<:#ft upor.•. tr.o Ap:pal 19.n t¢ I co.1::0.ot:, but ::,,11.d Si'/t'.11 ow, this 2ro pars i tio:n~. in th,; circunsto.uccn_ I ')J;1 th-:rofo:r.,, f.i.:Hi.1ly to conclude n.s did the tri!:l.l :,Ic.gistr-:.td~ tb.o.t th1:.: A:pp-..:llc.:,.:t c.licl o-.f'ficit>,lly hav~~ in o·ffj_cil).l ~ustotl:y-, :!b.s ., 1:f'?,2/~~ B0J./85f t~1c:c!' t:.--..,~ 1:1011.cq W:'.\S on 25/5/1993 su bsuqu~ntly found Dissing- 1 ::i.,d thn.t tL~ £J!?1.:llo.,1t 011 t·:ic:t v-:ry d9.j,- could

not b1;; tr::i.c-~d,, t:1~t :-1e ·:!:-:.d n<:1itl1,:;r ol:to.LiuJ. J.(.:~V•J cJ~ ,::jsence from !1-'1:,"bo<ly, nor ~--~1x1cl,:;cl tLL: D0~:J7 to P/:i~2 'lS h~, cJ.~.i:,,1-:::,,l~ Tht: Apl-)ell!:nt th~refo-rc 30 tolJ. li,as~ on two ~S}J,:-cts~ -1- th,:--,t .L..: wo.s given lcn.ve of a.1Js~nce from duty 1 :.cntl -2- th·:1.t h~ h~1d.~:l thu !.il.0;.-11.:iy to 2/ifl,2., But lies. re::mo.in l i ~ , o,r1cl ,;J.or;:; often th'.lll not~ ths: Lccun..,,1 t1:;1lls. li~st whi=re h.::: kn~w hi&: io guilty~ :i.r..cl h.: j_s trying to b.itl.; t;1is f'.'}.ct froi::1 the Courtt .9.S the truthf'ul ~l tclrn'1 t i ve 1 is n.c tu :,,11:? to 1,1 fr!::.d gv.il t:r. From t:te '.J.bove, I ~m c!.~1.tisfi,.:;Q o,s w~13 th_,,. tri~l L~,:;istet~, tht:-.t tha :pros.ecution evid.:mc<:!? ditl -=Stl.'.l.·01isl-'>. i),:qor:..d o. sl1'.!.d.Ow of dPubt, thc.t, it was th~ n,pp..:llo.;1t 1 '.lnd nobody als.: 1 who stol-.1 th-.: c:harl.3'1::d money~ Tha co;:1victio11, was o.s d'7!B0rved t:i,::i .it w2.s 9. :m.:ist 1 ~:id. it is u1>held., Ls o.fort:s1.id 9 the tri'.:l.l Ifo.g-istr".!.ist, :,,!).Ss-.,d a s,.;,ntenc~ of five yaa.rs 40 im tilii"'ri:itonmtm x- t on •~en' "''... · co·,·, t ... -~ ,, '-"-u~.s;u. ,, •. 9 ..... n~,, r- , 1;_1Q8 "} t o ?Un concurrently_ ,.,L 54 Th"' tr.ic.l :fa.gis tr'l t,;. ho.vL::g gi v~r_ ?llous.,11c-::: t.<?. ::tha,,f"!;l.c-J.;, tho.t th~ . . . '.· . Appclioi1 t '\o,'11~ C, lirst off

;.;1:.il6r, ,.D...:.:V'<.:rtl:s::L;;SS proc~cdad to. giv~ the . ·. .of tl:.r. f'.'.'.ct, th::.t tri..,~ .;.ccusud l1o.s not deprived. hie co-wo-;-k«rs .6f r~'7.iving ti1..;ir sr.2b.riea on tim,;;. 1.:·.it. ?,lso h-...s c.'.).us.,,d o.. grur.t loss of non~y, tho:: Gov~r::.,:.:i.ant ~19,d r~i'HV;lcl fro::i n. do;:ior Countryp 10 jo.il tern in respect or' 0e,c:! ooun-:~ h.: h~ been convicted .if~ :rn.ch s .... ~1t<£'.:.cas c.r-: to run concurre:ntly.,·· 1 . . ~d set n.sidt:: tht:e s,.::nt-:::'lco;;as 1 ny. obs.::r:~tions c:m_-s£::ntencing ,'t ... Ha.gistro.te to tr,:;e.t ~ l the c~J.'.l:::·g-.l,:: off~:r1C,;:!S·,. ~s being. of. equa.1 g~,d. ty of S<::riouaness· 9 aho11ra h·::>H ::lu 1:t1.::-V~r both,;:rad to read· eo.ch . . o.ffcnc~ sectionJ. to se~ h()W: th,<: L0ginl~.tuJ~a in iis leg·islative . . wis<lomt ge.v~ ~~ch offtmce its ow.c! w.)igb::;, j_n ·soc.i0ty $ -~;y pr;;;scri bing 20 o. tl.i.ffl!.tr'51Y.:.t 1n.misl:1me.nt., I shD.11 !?.<lviss: the i,;:~.gistr'.ltc :.lntl I D.D doing it now 1 th-~t he sho.11 ncv.;.ir ~•~s ~"-Y a ..xGt::)nc~ without . . t u r o f t'·11~ 1 0.w. .:,c, 0co:,:1u, r<:11 .:.;vc;n t • 1~pr1;;1!'). 1 .i f·. th I • '.1.l . t: ·cri - '-~ . • t !ro,\, !'i~gis ' ~ e:, h~d recollected th".l,t t·i:1a Shi.nyo.r~g,:-. :C rO{J:C'.l.'.:J:::.~, 'J'lS Gov,~rr.::1c:n-b :p-roj._~ct~ it would ht:we d.O'\!rne-d on l::in thc.t t.:-._,, Yiinhr:.m :-~:e:ntc:::nc1:<s Act

1972 1 ~s L.ncr1:.d.e0, fro,:1 tis~s W'3S D.'.?i'lic'.).1:1:·:1 .".',:::d :ce.nc.:; tha f::inimm S~1tei1.ce of fiv~ f..:o,rs i::1Jris01::::i"':1t o:.i.-fi:rst co:.::,1~,r co::.sirh:r:i.ng th"' c.rao1.mt in vol v~tlf 9.{!,!l,in showing~ th,'.1-t th;; L.1gisl ~.hl r0 w~s tre.::i.ting tb.&ft of Publi<:: pro1,1s:rty, :::ior.:: :Lgn0rni11Y;;islyt ·th!:'.71 otb.;,;r cho.rged offenc<;J~ 9 so, that, ira:posL1g .9, ninim,1,.1 s .:.:r:t.::nce of f.i:v~ J'e~.rs. on first count 1 c.nd 30 le-s~o.r Ele,:1t,::nc&s on· other countsr th0 trio.l rno.gistro.te would ha.ve mor,i ho~our9,bly: n.chi.ev~cl a fiv,;: yeD.rs conc·c1rre...,t sentr,mce, i f he b.o.s ap~inJ. c.tsnchnent to it, if order1:.±:l so to run~ Third, the tri:9,l Mc.gistrn.t.~ nn:rst r'3o.lis'=!f th9.tt s.e..>1tencing en Accu·s1:t<l person~ is a s=..11si tiv<:! ax.:;rcis'-$ of discretion. ~'1d not Th~ trin.l Court s:houl<l ~12,ve coll-:ctt?d ao.ti.!r.t~ls, to h~lp him to o.wo.rd o. just IJUnishm~,t, in tl'le circu;:ista,.,c<ds.- In tl1is co.se, the trial Mn.gis-t:r::i.tef denonstrn.tetl uoru of trio.I f~_tiguc. 9 thm1 desire to. s.e.e, th!"'.t ..:,o.oh s:antcnce, met -tbe ju1;1tic,! of th-=l co.se, on 1::'1Ch count .. I, ' I ' 55 ~JJ ; ). I JJ~t 1 for tl-1~:: :i.:JoVt:: obs~1.,v~,ltior1s, e.n.d. ~llow.in.g t~ha O.lJlJe"tJ or1 counts (2)! (3) r21d (4\ th~ !).i.JJ..lcl".';. .:in ,first count, is dismis-s<t<l in 1995 .. .IUDGE ·Nr .. ~;:::,.cluri 9 Se1:dor Stat"' Att:.1r.·,ay.:for t:c10:: J.&public A _,_.)Je'o;l.Ln:n t; Za broo s / o ~,foz ':i!l vi1gi is :Cti:Qr,lfH::n t &d by Mr. I1o,huran. who is 10 n.bser/t, ~rd. inst.::o.cl I-1:r:, l'-'It!).ki; is. holding A. brief 09.sa .. Court Cl(:,;rk~ :Lr.., Julius 1995,. ..,.. '