The court held that the plaintiff’s pleadings and affidavit put his mental state in issue, so solicitor-client privilege was impliedly waived for the relevant retainer period.
Court found Duguid mentally competent in 1990 and on December 15, 1994; relationships with Dorothy LeDrew and Marlene Bird were of the type to trigger a presumption of undue influence but that presumption was rebutted by contemporaneous lawyer evidence, witness testimony, medical and institutional records and Duguid's demonstrated understanding and consent; therefore the wills and deeds were not set aside and the action was dismissed.
The court approved a gratuitous joint-trustee arrangement for a disputed bequest, declined to award costs, and barred payment of counsel fees absent further order.