Search judgments by proposition, citation, court, judge or legal topic, then move directly into the source-grounded case analysis.
Results update automatically as you type.
Canada decisions
Decisions matching the current search
Registrar review of law firm accounts reduced fees and disbursements after finding ballpark estimates were not properly managed and the clients should have been advised sooner.
Registrar upheld Lindsay Kenney LLP’s bills, found good cause to withdraw, and ordered Sam Yehia to pay $25,356.02 in fees, disbursements and taxes.
Appeal from a solicitor's bill review was dismissed. The court upheld the registrar's fee assessment, finding no binding fee estimate and no error in the work done.
The Court dismissed the appeal, finding the evidence supported the Superior Court judge’s conclusion that the appellants had not established fee arrangements and had acted on a pro bono retainer, that the assessment adjournment did not bar the application, that the matter could properly be determined by application, and that there was no reasonable apprehension of bias.
Source excerpt
Lawyer’s bill assessment under the Legal Profession Act. No $25,000 fixed-fee retainer was proven; fees were assessed at $70,000, with most disbursements disallowed.
The court allowed the appeal, concluding the application judge erred by not treating the admitted 15% discount and the escrow agreement as special circumstances under Echo Energy; because the discount and escrow implicated the full sequence of accounts and there was no evidence of prejudice, leave was granted to assess all accounts.
Source excerpt
The appeal is dismissed because the motion judge correctly found that the assessment officer erred by making unsupported findings of incompetence, by substituting rates contrary to the clear retainer, by making conclusory sweeping reductions of billed time without cogent basis, and by mischaracterizing the complexity of the case; the motion judge properly undertook his own evaluation and his award stood within reason.
Source excerpt
The assessment officer applied Tariff B principles, reduced several claimed fee item units to appropriate lower amounts based on file review and practice (reducing fee item 5 units, allowing limited units for fee item 13 and 14(a), disallowing fee item 14(b) for second counsel, disallowing fee item 25 for interlocutory motions but allowing it for the substantive proceeding), adjusted disbursements to a reasonable allowance, and assessed the Respondent's bill at $6,052.55.
Source excerpt
Review of solicitor accounts in an estate matter. The Master confirmed a fixed probate fee and litigation fees, found the bills reasonable, and awarded costs to the solicitors.
Registrar Blok reviewed a solicitor’s accounts in a China business matter, found the $18,000 figure was only an estimate, and reduced the bill to $82,254.06.
Explore more
