Sign in
Canada Source-linked decisions Coverage checked

Canada Case Law

Search judgments by proposition, citation, court, judge or legal topic, then move directly into the source-grounded case analysis.

Courts on this page
2 court collections
Last checked

Canada decisions

Decisions matching the current search

Clear filters
Tort 2023 BCSC 714

Paleshnuik v. Dulay

The plaintiff was awarded $663,270 after a rear-end collision caused persistent concussion-related, neurological, psychological and pain symptoms, plus income and future-care losses.

  • Non-pecuniary damages
  • Loss of income-earning capacity
  • Loss of housekeeping capacity
  • Cost of future care
  • Credibility assessment
  • Causation
Read case analysis
Tort 2023 BCSC 58

Langara Gardens Holdings Ltd. v. Chen

A fire in a Vancouver rental unit led to findings that the tenant was negligent and that both tenants were contractually liable for repair costs, but not lost rent under contract.

  • Negligence
  • Contributory negligence
  • Breach of tenancy agreement
  • Fire safety/sprinkler retrofit
  • Damages
  • Summary trial procedure
Read case analysis
Limitation of actions 2021 ONCA 681

Gordon Dunk Farms Limited v. HFH Inc.

The motion judge’s factual finding that the directing minds of the plaintiff knew by May 12, 2014 of the collapse, its likely causal connection to negligent design/construction/inspection by the respondents, and the need for legal action met the discoverability test (plausible inference of liability); separate pleaded particulars do not reset discoverability, so the action (commenced May 24, 2016) is statute barred; any error in citing s.14 was harmless.

  • Discoverability
  • Limitations period
  • S.14 notice of possible claim
  • Summary judgment
  • Causation
Read case analysis
Civil procedure 2020 BCSC 2048

Owners of Strata Plan EPS1699 v. Ponderosa Peachland Development Limited Partnership

The court dismissed in part an application for leave to file a third party notice, refusing the time-barred contractual debt claim against Ponderosa while allowing the notice to proceed against consenting defendants.

  • Third party notice
  • Leave to third party
  • Limitation act s.22
  • Contribution and indemnity
  • Prejudice and delay
  • Contractual debt
Read case analysis
Tort 2019 BCSC 1204

Tomas v. Sticha

The court found the collision caused the plaintiff’s TMJ disorder and trigeminal neuralgia, awarded general damages, limited future care, and rejected the earning-capacity claim.

  • Causation
  • Non-pecuniary damages
  • Loss of earning capacity
  • Subrogation
  • Mitigation
  • Cost of future care
Read case analysis
Tort 2018 BCSC 1090

Provost v. Bolton

Damages assessment after a motor-vehicle collision: the court awarded compensation for non-pecuniary loss, future earning capacity, and related heads, and allowed the AG Canada’s subrogated recovery.

  • Non-pecuniary damages
  • Loss of earning capacity
  • In-trust (caregiver) damages
  • Subrogation of employer benefits
  • Collateral benefits deduction
  • Pleadings amendment
Read case analysis
Civil procedure 2016 BCSC 1675

Carby v. Benoit

Assessment of costs and disbursements after settlement in two motor vehicle actions. Most tariff units were allowed, but several expert and MRI-related disbursements were disallowed.

  • Costs assessment
  • Disbursement allowance
  • Expert fees
  • Tariff items
  • Settlement
  • Medical causation (ehlers-danlos syndrome)
Read case analysis
Civil procedure 2016 BCSC 222

Penner International Inc. v. Basaraba Estate

The court refused the defendants’ costs application, finding the plaintiff’s rejection of a pretrial settlement offer was not unreasonable in light of liability and damages uncertainty.

  • Offers to settle
  • Apportionment of liability
  • Costs awards
  • Settlement timing
  • Offers-to-settle
  • Costs-awards
Read case analysis
Tort 2015 BCSC 1136

Penner International Inc. v. Basaraba Estate

Assessment of damages for two successive truck collisions, with the court apportioning divisible and indivisible losses, rejecting salvage credits, and awarding $223,315.92.

  • Apportionment of liability
  • Indivisible vs divisible damage
  • Assessment of actual cash value (acv)
  • Salvage and disposal
  • Vicarious liability
  • Towing and cleanup costs
Read case analysis
Civil procedure 2015 BCSC 733

Provincial Health Services Authority v. Crothall Healthcare

Master Baker dismissed Nilfisk’s application to strike amendments, holding the June 2013 step added a party under Rule 6-2, so the September 2013 pleading was the first amendment.

  • Amendment of pleadings
  • Addition of parties (rule 6-2)
  • Third party proceedings
  • Limitation act s.4(1)(b), s.4(3), s.4(4)
  • Prejudice from late amendment
  • Irregularity vs nullity
Read case analysis

About this LexChat collection

Canada decisions are organised by court, judge, legal area and indexed issue so a practitioner can move from a proposition to a citable authority with the surrounding context intact.