The Court of Appeal dismissed Ms. Anderson’s sentence appeal, upholding a 4.5-year custodial sentence, fines, and a DNA order for tax evasion and counselling fraud.
The Court concluded the trial judge made no legal errors and his factual and credibility findings were supported by the record: the appellant was proven to have directed and benefited from the forgery business by admissible direct evidence and corroborated indicia (control of equipment, orders of supplies, banking evidence), the co-conspirators exception was applied lawfully after establishing a conspiracy and the appellant’s participation on admissible evidence, the affidavits were not used for their truth but to test an expert and did not form the basis of findings, the trial judge did not…
The judge found beyond a reasonable doubt that Ralston MacDonnell was the directing mind who knowingly and dishonestly diverted funds subject to statutory deemed trust (HST and payroll deductions) into undisclosed/private accounts and for personal use, evaded RTPs and trust examinations, issued NSF cheques and made misleading proposals to CRA; those acts constituted both fraud under s.380(1)(a) and willful evasion under s.327(1)(c) of the Excise Tax Act, and the defence explanations and testimony lacked credibility and did not raise a reasonable doubt.
Sentencing for fraud and tax offences: the court imposed a conditional sentence order of two years less one day for Counts 1 and 3, plus a $121,179 fine for Count 2.
British Columbia Supreme Court appeal upholding tax convictions against Willi Isaak for false statements and tax evasion arising from management fees and a BC Hydro refund.
Post-trial ruling on sentencing facts after jury convictions for fraud and tax offences. The court fixed only the facts necessarily proven or proven beyond a reasonable doubt.
The British Columbia Court of Appeal dismissed Keith David Lawson’s appeal from convictions for tax-related offences, upholding the jury charge and refusal to leave a mistake-of-law defence.