Search judgments by proposition, citation, court, judge or legal topic, then move directly into the source-grounded case analysis.
Results update automatically as you type.
England and Wales decisions
Decisions matching the current search
The Tribunal dismissed John Parker’s information rights appeal, holding that the withheld documents were personal data exempt under FOIA section 40(2), and that the alleged document fabrication point was outside its jurisdiction.
The Trust did not hold the information requested as reasonably interpreted; the Decision Notice was not wrong in law or discretion and the appeal must be dismissed.
Source excerpt
On the balance of probabilities, the Trust had conducted adequate searches and provided all information held within the scope of Mr Mitchell's request; discrepancies between NHS Digital and Trust data did not establish that the Trust held additional undisclosed information.
Source excerpt
The requested information, being a manager’s internal review about a request for information, is too far removed from substantive environmental information to be considered environmental information under EIR. FOIA is the correct regime to apply.
Source excerpt
The Tribunal dismissed Womenswold Parish Council’s appeal and upheld the Information Commissioner’s decision notice requiring disclosure or a valid refusal notice under the EIRs.
The Tribunal allowed an FOI appeal, holding the council could not rely on vexatious-request or manifestly unreasonable exceptions to refuse the information request.
Regulation 12(5)(e) was engaged as the withheld information was commercial, confidential, and disclosure would prejudice the Council's legitimate economic interests in ongoing tendering; the public interest in maintaining the exception outweighed the public interest in disclosure.
Source excerpt
The Council held the underlying data necessary to compile the requested map or list of roads subject to the 20mph speed limit; providing the information in the requested format does not constitute creation of new information but disclosure of information already held; therefore, the Council held the requested information at the time of the request.
Source excerpt
The Tribunal allowed this FOIA appeal in part, finding inadequate searches for some requested information and directing the Council to reconsider Questions 5, 9 and 15.
The First-tier Tribunal dismissed an information rights appeal, finding Fladbury Parish Council held no further relevant environmental information and the Commissioner’s decision was lawful.
Explore more
