Sign in
Hong Kong Source-linked decisions Coverage checked

Hong Kong Case Law

Search judgments by proposition, citation, court, judge or legal topic, then move directly into the source-grounded case analysis.

Courts on this page
2 court collections
Last checked

Hong Kong decisions

Decisions matching the current search

Clear filters
Bankruptcy law [2020] HKCFI 1720

RE FORMERLY KNOWN AS SHUM WAN MAN

The court held that a creditor’s objection to automatic discharge was filed late under s 30A(6) of the Bankruptcy Ordinance and declined to extend time, dismissing the objection and related applications.

  • Automatic discharge
  • Objection to discharge
  • Time limits and extension
  • Interim orders
  • Amendment of proceedings
  • Service of documents
Read case analysis
Bankruptcy law RE LI NGAI

RE LI NGAI

The court dismissed a creditor’s objection to a bankrupt’s automatic discharge, finding no proved grounds under s.30A and treating the debt misstatement as an inadvertent error.

  • Discharge from bankruptcy
  • Objection to discharge
  • Automatic discharge under s.30a
  • Failure to disclose assets
  • Trading while insolvent
  • Accounting offences
Read case analysis
Bankruptcy law FRED LEE v. LEUNG SUI SUM

FRED LEE v. LEUNG SUI SUM

Court of Appeal dismissed a trustee’s bankruptcy appeals, upholding remittal to the Master and holding that costs of objecting to discharge cannot be a condition under s 30A(9).

  • Automatic discharge
  • Section 30a bankruptcy ordinance
  • Objection to discharge
  • Conditional discharge
  • Remission to master
  • Trustee conduct and duties
Read case analysis
Bankruptcy law

Fred Lee, trustee of the property of Leung Chin Yeung, a bankrupt v Leung Chin Yeung; Fred Lee, trustee of the property of Leung Sui Sum, a bankrupt v Leung Sui Sum; Fred Lee, trustee of the property of Lee Yuk Man, a bankrupt v Lee Yuk Man

The Court of Appeal dismissed three bankruptcy appeals by a trustee against orders remitting discharge objections and conditional discharge issues to the master.

  • Automatic discharge from bankruptcy
  • Objection to discharge
  • Conditional discharge
  • Trustee costs
  • Case management order
  • Appeal competence
Read case analysis
Bankruptcy law

Fred Lee, trustee of the property of Leung Chin Yeung, a bankrupt v Leung Chin Yeung; Fred Lee, trustee of the property of Leung Sui Sum, a bankrupt v Leung Sui Sum; Fred Lee, trustee of the property of Lee Yuk Man, a bankrupt v Lee Yuk Man

The Court of Appeal dismissed three bankruptcy appeals, upheld remittal to the master, and said objections to automatic discharge and conditional discharge must be exercised cautiously.

  • Automatic discharge
  • Objection to discharge
  • Conditional discharge
  • Costs
  • Case management orders
  • Bankruptcy
Read case analysis
Bankruptcy law

Fred Lee, trustee of the property of Leung Chin Yeung, a bankrupt v Leung Chin Yeung; Fred Lee, trustee of the property of Leung Sui Sum, a bankrupt v Leung Sui Sum; Fred Lee, trustee of the property of Lee Yuk Man, a bankrupt v Lee Yuk Man

Appeals concerning bankruptcy automatic discharge and consent conditions were dismissed. The court held the trustee’s approach was flawed and costs could not be treated as a discharge condition.

  • Automatic discharge
  • Objection to discharge
  • Conditional discharge
  • Costs
  • Case management / remission to master
  • Bankruptcy
Read case analysis
Bankruptcy law FRED LEE, TRUSTEE OF THE PROPERTY OF PANG LAI FAI WILLY, A BANKRUPT v. PANG LAI FAI WILLY

FRED LEE, TRUSTEE OF THE PROPERTY OF PANG LAI FAI WILLY, A BANKRUPT v. PANG LAI FAI WILLY

The court disallowed the trustee’s costs from the bankrupt’s estate after finding the trustee had not made proper investigations before objecting to discharge.

  • Automatic discharge under section 30a
  • Objection to discharge
  • Trustee duties and investigatory obligations
  • Misrepresentation to creditors and official receiver
  • Payment of trustee's costs from the estate
  • Section 84 complaints against trustee
Read case analysis
Bankruptcy law FRED LEE v. LEE YUK MAN

FRED LEE v. LEE YUK MAN

The court held that section 30A(9) can apply to automatic-discharge cases under section 30A(3) or (7), but refused the proposed consent conditional discharges and remitted the cases for further consideration.

  • Automatic discharge
  • Section 30a(9)
  • Conditional discharge
  • Objection to discharge
  • Trustee conflict of interest
  • Remuneration and taxation of costs
Read case analysis
Bankruptcy FRED LEE v. LEUNG SUI SUM

FRED LEE v. LEUNG SUI SUM

The High Court held that section 30A(9) can apply to automatic discharge cases, but the trustee’s consent applications were not granted and were remitted for reconsideration.

  • Automatic discharge
  • Section 30a(9)
  • Conditional discharge
  • Objection to discharge
  • Trustee duties and conflicts
  • Costs and taxation
Read case analysis
Bankruptcy RE LEUNG YAT TUNG

RE LEUNG YAT TUNG

The court held that the petitioning creditor could rely on its affirmation in the Official Receiver’s summons only on the Official Receiver’s two grounds, not its own late additional grounds.

  • Automatic discharge
  • Objection to discharge
  • Locus standi of creditors
  • Statutory procedure s.30a bo
  • Bankruptcy rules r.88
  • Bankruptcy
Read case analysis

About this LexChat collection

Hong Kong decisions are organised by court, judge, legal area and indexed issue so a practitioner can move from a proposition to a citable authority with the surrounding context intact.