Due to inconsistent opinions and the importance of the legal question, the matter concerning the right to die with dignity and provisions for living wills is referred to a Constitution Bench for authoritative decision.
Petition dismissed; the Court held that passive euthanasia can be permitted in India under strict safeguards: decisions to discontinue life support for an incompetent person may be taken by parents, spouse, other close relatives, treating doctors or a next friend but such decisions require prior approval of the appropriate High Court under Article 226, which must follow the prescribed procedure (two-Judge Bench, independent three-doctor committee, notice to State and relatives/next friend, reasoned decision based on the patient's best interest). The Court found the petitioner (Aruna Shanbaug)…
Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code is unconstitutional as it violates Article 21; it is void. Attempted suicide is not against public policy, religion or morality; it has no baneful effect on society and causes no harm to others. State interference with personal liberty is unjustified in cases of attempted suicide.