The court found the accused unfit to plead after a psychiatric report showed mental illness, postponed the trial, and ordered treatment and a pre-bail report.
The trial court's order committing the applicant to a mental institution for a fixed period of six years after he had been certified as having recovered from his mental infirmity was illegal and improper. Based on the applicant's recovery, as certified by a psychiatrist, and in line with current legal principles and sentencing guidelines for individuals found guilty but insane, the appropriate action is unconditional discharge.
Mwangi v Director of Public Prosecutions [2024] KEHC 12381 (KLR)
Court
High Court
Case number
Miscellaneous Criminal Application E020 of 2022
Judge
DKN Magare
The High Court at Nyeri released the applicant to his family after a mental assessment confirmed normal mental status, and ordered a five-year probation and reintegration program.
MNK v AOK & (A minor, suing through RTMK) RTNMK [2022] KEHC 1484 (KLR)
Court
High Court
Case number
Petition E022 of 2021
Judge
M Thande
The High Court found that the Children’s Court, under Section 76 of the Children Act, has jurisdiction to consider all circumstances relevant to the welfare of the child, including the mental health of the parents. The Mental Health Act’s reference to 'court' as the High Court applies to matters concerning the custody and estate of persons suffering from mental disorder, not to child custody disputes. The issues raised by the Petitioners regarding the Respondent’s mental fitness are already before the Children’s Court, which is competent to call for expert evidence and make determinations in…
High Court dismissed a criminal appeal application for mental assessment, admission of additional evidence, and bail pending appeal, finding no supporting evidence or exceptional circumstances.
Republic v Onesmus Nthale Mutua [2020] KEHC 742 (KLR)
Court
High Court
Case number
Criminal Case 81 of 2017
After a finding of guilty but insane in a murder case, the High Court placed the accused on three years’ probation under probation officer supervision.
Republic v Onesmus Nthale Mutua [2020] KEHC 1583 (KLR)
Court
High Court
Case number
Criminal Case 81 of 2011
The High Court at Makueni deferred sentencing and ordered a mental re-assessment of the accused before sentence is passed, with a report due within 21 days.
The High Court at Bomet found the accused unfit to stand trial for murder, postponed the trial, denied bond, and set the matter for further directions.
The High Court sentenced the accused to two years’ probation for manslaughter, after over eight years in custody, treatment compliance, and reintegration support.
High Court allowed a criminal appeal in part, upheld the conviction, but set aside life imprisonment and entered a special finding of guilty but insane.