Trustco Insurance t/a Legal Shield Namibia and Another v Deed Registries Regulation Board and Others (SA 14 of 2010)
Trustco Insurance t/a Legal Shield Namibia and Another v Deed Registries Regulation Board and Others (SA 14 of 2010) [2011] NASC 10 (15 July 2011)
The first appellant had standing as its legal obligations under the contract with the second appellant depended on the validity of the tariffs. The tariffs did not infringe Article 21(1)(j) because they were rational regulation and not a material barrier to practice. The tariffs did not constitute unreasonable administrative action under Article 18, as the fixed sliding scale was a reasonable policy choice by a specialist board. The Deeds Registries’ Tariff was not ultra vires section 10(1)(c), as the Board was empowered to prescribe fixed tariffs, including ad valorem fees.
Source excerpt
- Standing (locus standi)
- Freedom to practice a profession
- Regulation of legal fees
- Reasonableness of administrative action
- Ultra vires challenge